This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Clearly, it is difficult to retain a commemoration to a man who was found guilty of child abuse during our lifetime. If he had been around 300 years ago and his sins only came to light now, then time might have allowed us to balance his crimes against his good deeds. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (04 Apr 2022 9.11am) Technically, he wasn't found guilty, as he died before this all came to light. So you think that the passage of time can diminish the scale of the crimes and enhance the value of the good deeds? That may be the reality, but isn't it just a tad hypocritical? If people are being posthumously pardoned for things they did which were illegal in their day, but legal today (see "Turing's" law), should not the reverse attitude also be acceptable?
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Technically, he wasn't found guilty, as he died before this all came to light. So you think that the passage of time can diminish the scale of the crimes and enhance the value of the good deeds? That may be the reality, but isn't it just a tad hypocritical? If people are being posthumously pardoned for things they did which were illegal in their day, but legal today (see "Turing's" law), should not the reverse attitude also be acceptable? As someone or other will object to absolutely any statue, we might as well take them all down to avoid the civil disturbances.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
So you think that the passage of time can diminish the scale of the crimes and enhance the value of the good deeds? That may be the reality, but isn't it just a tad hypocritical? If people are being posthumously pardoned for things they did which were illegal in their day, but legal today (see "Turing's" law), should not the reverse attitude also be acceptable? True. And no, it is not a reversible attitude. The battle has already been won. Slavery was abolished. Before that, it was legal. One day, someone with an attitude like yours might want to retrospectively vilify someone for eating meat or using a petrol car. It is ridiculous and you know it. All discussion about it now is entirely about political and social power. It is in some cases a feeble minded attempt to get compensation. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (04 Apr 2022 11.02am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
True. And no, it is not a reversible attitude. The battle has already been won. Slavery was abolished. Before that, it was legal. One day, someone with an attitude like yours might want to retrospectively vilify someone for eating meat or using a petrol car. It is ridiculous and you know it. All discussion about it now is entirely about political and social power. It is in some cases a feeble minded attempt to get compensation. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (04 Apr 2022 11.02am) That's the whole point! Homosexuality was illegal, now it isn't. That battle was won and those previously convicted have been pardoned. Thus, history has been revisited. If it can be done in one direction, why not the other? I am not arguing it should be. I am only pointing out the hypocrisy involved. It would only be relevant to meat eating, or driving a petrol car, if they became illegal. None of this discussion is about politics, social power or compensation. It's about the possible hypocrisy involved in accepting the removal of some historical artefacts, but not others.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That's the whole point! Homosexuality was illegal, now it isn't. That battle was won and those previously convicted have been pardoned. Thus, history has been revisited. If it can be done in one direction, why not the other? I am not arguing it should be. I am only pointing out the hypocrisy involved. It would only be relevant to meat eating, or driving a petrol car, if they became illegal. None of this discussion is about politics, social power or compensation. It's about the possible hypocrisy involved in accepting the removal of some historical artefacts, but not others. If you can't see why then you must be incapable of reason. Retrospective pardoning is an act that undoes an ill conceived law or poor conviction. It works because the 'victim' is the That is completely different to demonising a dead person who abided by the law as it was in his day. Do stop trying to argue idiotic ideas. You are no better than the people who dug up Oliver Cromwell and put his head on a spike or any other historical descecrstion you care to use which was based on irrational emotionalism.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That's the whole point! Homosexuality was illegal, now it isn't. That battle was won and those previously convicted have been pardoned. Thus, history has been revisited. If it can be done in one direction, why not the other? I am not arguing it should be. I am only pointing out the hypocrisy involved. It would only be relevant to meat eating, or driving a petrol car, if they became illegal. None of this discussion is about politics, social power or compensation. It's about the possible hypocrisy involved in accepting the removal of some historical artefacts, but not others. Homosexuality was not illegal, homosexual sex activities were. Edited by georgenorman (04 Apr 2022 1.11pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
That's the whole point! Homosexuality was illegal, now it isn't. That battle was won and those previously convicted have been pardoned. Thus, history has been revisited. If it can be done in one direction, why not the other? I am not arguing it should be. I am only pointing out the hypocrisy involved. It would only be relevant to meat eating, or driving a petrol car, if they became illegal. None of this discussion is about politics, social power or compensation. It's about the possible hypocrisy involved in accepting the removal of some historical artefacts, but not others. Why not have statutes of limitations? Anyone convicted, accused or suspected of anything gets pardoned after 100 years and replaced on the naughty step by those deemed guilty of transgressing modern standards of behaviour.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
But it's not, so why introduce that into the conversation? If you wander about town being bothered by statues looking down at you, then I would suggest that it is you that have the problem You know full well that statue bashing is just a symptom of a bigger issue. Its name is mass immigration and the erosion of British culture. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (04 Apr 2022 8.57am) In Mauretania and Sudan chattel slavery is legal, apparently none of the owners enjoy white privilege
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
If you can't see why then you must be incapable of reason. Retrospective pardoning is an act that undoes an ill conceived law or poor conviction. It works because the 'victim' is the That is completely different to demonising a dead person who abided by the law as it was in his day. Do stop trying to argue idiotic ideas. You are no better than the people who dug up Oliver Cromwell and put his head on a spike or any other historical descecrstion you care to use which was based on irrational emotionalism.
All I am trying to do is to get this "woke" idea put in its rightful context. It isn't quite as simple as some seem to want it to be. Slavery wasn't just illegal, or simply immoral, by any standards. A strong argument could be made that it was even worse than paedophilia, though both are horrible. Slavers regarded their captives as less than human. Thousands died being transported, including many children. Savile was an evil man, but, so far as I know, he didn't kill anyone. Using the passage of time to ameliorate this behaviour is not acceptable. It should be remembered, but in the right way, so that we never forget.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
All I am trying to do is to get this "woke" idea put in its rightful context. It isn't quite as simple as some seem to want it to be. Slavery wasn't just illegal, or simply immoral, by any standards. A strong argument could be made that it was even worse than paedophilia, though both are horrible. Slavers regarded their captives as less than human. Thousands died being transported, including many children. Savile was an evil man, but, so far as I know, he didn't kill anyone. Using the passage of time to ameliorate this behaviour is not acceptable. It should be remembered, but in the right way, so that we never forget. I came across this in an article, sums it up well I think: Read more at:
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
You think they were being identified for a clean ? If you need to see the word removal then here you are. I have a nice life thanks A spokesperson from the Glasgow City Council said that despite the council leader's apology on behalf of the local authority, that they are not proposing to remove any statues as a result of the audit yet. I suspect the ‘yet’ was inserted by The Daily Mail I also expect that if any statue were removed it would be someone other than livingstone. There is no sign at all that any statue is targeted for removal. This is nonsense written by two media sources that just love to enrage people that enjoy getting enraged So get a life, not mindlessly angry. Edited by Mapletree (04 Apr 2022 4.43pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
A spokesperson from the Glasgow City Council said that despite the council leader's apology on behalf of the local authority, that they are not proposing to remove any statues as a result of the audit yet. I suspect the ‘yet’ was inserted by The Daily Mail I also expect that if any statue were removed it would be someone other than livingstone. There is no sign at all that any statue is targeted for removal. This is nonsense written by two media sources that just love to enrage people that enjoy getting enraged So get a life, not mindlessly angry. Edited by Mapletree (04 Apr 2022 4.43pm) But it was right and good to get angry about a statue in Bristol and pull it down.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
A spokesperson from the Glasgow City Council said that despite the council leader's apology on behalf of the local authority, that they are not proposing to remove any statues as a result of the audit yet. I suspect the ‘yet’ was inserted by The Daily Mail I also expect that if any statue were removed it would be someone other than livingstone. There is no sign at all that any statue is targeted for removal. This is nonsense written by two media sources that just love to enrage people that enjoy getting enraged So get a life, not mindlessly angry. Edited by Mapletree (04 Apr 2022 4.43pm) What apart from them commissioning a report to identify statues. street names, buildings etc that have some vague connection to slavery? Looks like quite a large sign to me.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
We should be reaching out and re-educating slave traders in order to integrate them into today's diverse society, rather than tearing things down. We can’t even do that with market traders.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
All I am trying to do is to get this "woke" idea put in its rightful context. It isn't quite as simple as some seem to want it to be. Slavery wasn't just illegal, or simply immoral, by any standards. A strong argument could be made that it was even worse than paedophilia, though both are horrible. Slavers regarded their captives as less than human. Thousands died being transported, including many children. Savile was an evil man, but, so far as I know, he didn't kill anyone. Using the passage of time to ameliorate this behaviour is not acceptable. It should be remembered, but in the right way, so that we never forget. I don't think anyone has forgotten how bad slavery was. Let's not try and kid anyone that the current BLM related noise or statue bashing has anything to do with remembering slavery. However bad it was, it will have to be left in the past, just like all the other enslavement that many races have endured over the centuries. No one has a monopoly on enslavement. You don't hear anyone asking to knock down the Colosseum in Rome.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I don't think anyone has forgotten how bad slavery was. Let's not try and kid anyone that the current BLM related noise or statue bashing has anything to do with remembering slavery. However bad it was, it will have to be left in the past, just like all the other enslavement that many races have endured over the centuries. No one has a monopoly on enslavement. You don't hear anyone asking to knock down the Colosseum in Rome. Why does everything have to be laid at the door of "BLM"? From all I can tell, and it's not something I follow or have much interest in, it's mostly young local activists involved who have no connection to "BLM". For the record, I don't think they should be destroyed either. If the local people want them removed and placed in a museum, with explanations to set them in their historical context, or even left in place with new inscriptions, that ought to satisfy everyone. The Colosseum's history is a big part of any visit to Rome.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mapletree
A spokesperson from the Glasgow City Council said that despite the council leader's apology on behalf of the local authority, that they are not proposing to remove any statues as a result of the audit yet. I suspect the ‘yet’ was inserted by The Daily Mail I also expect that if any statue were removed it would be someone other than livingstone. There is no sign at all that any statue is targeted for removal. This is nonsense written by two media sources that just love to enrage people that enjoy getting enraged So get a life, not mindlessly angry. Edited by Mapletree (04 Apr 2022 4.43pm) " yet " LMFAO
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.