You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rak-Sakyi
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rak-Sakyi


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 08 Feb 23 7.58pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I stand corrected!

I think the point still stands - Olise was playing and impressing in the premier league at the age JRS is doing the same in league one.

Absolutely, but players do develop at different rates. The important question is:
Is JRS still developing?

Given the way he has taken to League 1 football and the esteem with which he seems to be held by Clown fans, it seems that he is.

There is a genuine possibility IMO that Championship clubs will be wanting his services next season and if he performs in that league he will have a good chance of becoming a PL player. A long way to go, I know but not impossible. Let's not forget that Gallagher's first loan spell was with the Clowns in League 1 before moving up to Swansea in the Championship etc.

 

lush1076 Flag leatherhead 08 Feb 23 8.10pm

He might be playing with us in the championship next season.

 

PJEagle Flag London 08 Feb 23 9.01pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Age isn't an issue at all. Simply making the point that we can afford to take our time with him. Outside of 2 appearances for the first team, he's only got 25 professional games under his belt.

Kane had a couple of Championship and a Prem loan before playing for Spurs.

Personally I'd want JEs to start next season at a Champ club, and recall him in Jan if he's flying.

League 1 - Prem is one hell of a step up.

Ideally we'd want him involved in the first team squad 23/24

 

djcpfc Flag Within a 5 minute walk 08 Feb 23 9.02pm

I’m quite glad JRS has stayed at Charlton for the rest of the season.

Clearly it’s important just like any other young player he gets games, and it allowed to make mistakes, and learn without fear of losing his place in the side. Charlton are mid-table L1 might have a squeak of the play-offs, like to try and play a bit, and therefore you couldn’t really hope for a better situation for him.

Let him learn his trade and see where he is across the remainder of his contract. There are quite a few players ahead of him in the pecking order, and I’m sure a few behind him too. I think you can see he has an eye for goal, hopefully he’ll get a chance in red and blue again let us see what he does with it.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Feb 23 9.12pm

Originally posted by doombear

Absolutely, but players do develop at different rates. The important question is:
Is JRS still developing?

Given the way he has taken to League 1 football and the esteem with which he seems to be held by Clown fans, it seems that he is.

There is a genuine possibility IMO that Championship clubs will be wanting his services next season and if he performs in that league he will have a good chance of becoming a PL player. A long way to go, I know but not impossible. Let's not forget that Gallagher's first loan spell was with the Clowns in League 1 before moving up to Swansea in the Championship etc.

I think an even bigger point is that we already have an abundance of luxury players who throw in the occasional bit of fancy skill but fail to contribute much to the goals tally. Is he an out an out goal scorer or just another wide player to add to Ebiowei and Banks on loan, Olise, Ayew, Zaha, Eze? Albeit if he scored as many as Wilf no one would ever complain.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 08 Feb 23 9.48pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I think an even bigger point is that we already have an abundance of luxury players who throw in the occasional bit of fancy skill but fail to contribute much to the goals tally. Is he an out an out goal scorer or just another wide player to add to Ebiowei and Banks on loan, Olise, Ayew, Zaha, Eze? Albeit if he scored as many as Wilf no one would ever complain.


A good question Eaglecoops.

I saw him as yet another luxury player in the Olise/Ebiowei mould. It will be interesting to see how he has developed at Charlton.

Having said that, regarding the others you mention:
- Eze's not a wide player IMO
- Wilf may well not be with us next season
- Ayew will probably be on annual contracts
- Banks didn't do a great deal at League 2 Bradford before his lengthy injury. Also apart from his free kicks, I don't see him as a PL player.
- Ebiowei is unproven and looked lost in a recent appearance before his loan to Hull
- As for Olise, I can well see him being snapped up by a bigger club in the summer for a fee the club will find difficult to refuse.

On the general point of luxury players, that's been a major part of our problem in recent weeks with neither Olise nor Eze doing enough, especially out of possession.

I'm hoping to see both Lokonga and Ahamada in play as proper midfielders who will let the opposition know they are in a scrap. It would mean Eze being on the bench.


Edited by doombear (08 Feb 2023 9.50pm)

 

mileend Flag East London 12 Feb 23 9.40am

Really great goal from him yesterday

[Link]

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 12 Feb 23 9.52am

Originally posted by mileend

Really great goal from him yesterday

[Link]

It was indeed, perfect result JRS scores but Charlton lose.

 


One more point

silvertop Flag Portishead 12 Feb 23 10.59am

Originally posted by Badger11

It was indeed, perfect result JRS scores but Charlton lose.

That could be us in a few years. Lower tier, half filled stadium losing at home to a team you didn't realise was fully professional.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 12 Feb 23 11.12am

Originally posted by mileend

Really great goal from him yesterday

[Link]

Good on the fella. Whether he can do this in the PL we don't know, but he is whole heartedly taking his opportunity at Charlton.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 12 Feb 23 11.38am

Originally posted by silvertop

That could be us in a few years. Lower tier, half filled stadium losing at home to a team you didn't realise was fully professional.

Agreed. They hate their owner who just scuppered a bid for the club which the fans wanted. From what I read I'm not sure the new owners would have been any better but yes how the mighty have fallen.

I used to know a prominent Charlton Fan who worked for the club and ran the official supporters club. He took great glee when Jordan was in financial trouble bragging how well run a club Charlton was Jordan begging Charlton to buy some of our players.

Whilst a little bit of me has a s n i g g e r I agree that this could be us all it needs is for the Americans to oust Parish and sell out to some dodgy consortium.

Their fans are grasping at straws the latest failed bid was lauded because it was based on the Bolton model. Well I looked at that and wondered what the Bolton model is, apparently it is based on getting a good CEO who knows how to run a club. That's not a model it's an aspiration like saying we will achieve success by appointing good managers and buying good cheap players.

Edited by Badger11 (12 Feb 2023 11.40am)

 


One more point

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 12 Feb 23 12.16pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Agreed. They hate their owner who just scuppered a bid for the club which the fans wanted. From what I read I'm not sure the new owners would have been any better but yes how the mighty have fallen.

I used to know a prominent Charlton Fan who worked for the club and ran the official supporters club. He took great glee when Jordan was in financial trouble bragging how well run a club Charlton was Jordan begging Charlton to buy some of our players.

Whilst a little bit of me has a s n i g g e r I agree that this could be us all it needs is for the Americans to oust Parish and sell out to some dodgy consortium.

Their fans are grasping at straws the latest failed bid was lauded because it was based on the Bolton model. Well I looked at that and wondered what the Bolton model is, apparently it is based on getting a good CEO who knows how to run a club. That's not a model it's an aspiration like saying we will achieve success by appointing good managers and buying good cheap players.

Edited by Badger11 (12 Feb 2023 11.40am)

What are the prospective buyers actually buying ? There was mention of a £10m purchase price quoted to the Methven bid.

The stadium and training ground are owned by Duchatelet. I understood ( it may have changed ) that any deal included the commitment to purchase those from him. And he wanted something like £50m for them.

It's like the Goldberg / Noades situation.

A far cry from the Richard Murray days. A mate of mine was on the Charlton Board then and I used to envy the way that club was run.

As for Jes, he's having a good season in a very average team. Hopefully he can use it as a springboard to progress with Palace next season

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 12 Feb 23 12.51pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

What are the prospective buyers actually buying ? There was mention of a £10m purchase price quoted to the Methven bid.

The stadium and training ground are owned by Duchatelet. I understood ( it may have changed ) that any deal included the commitment to purchase those from him. And he wanted something like £50m for them.

It's like the Goldberg / Noades situation.

A far cry from the Richard Murray days. A mate of mine was on the Charlton Board then and I used to envy the way that club was run.

As for Jes, he's having a good season in a very average team. Hopefully he can use it as a springboard to progress with Palace next season

Apparently there is some form of agreement that the club rent the ground from Duchalet with an option to buy so any new owners would inherit this option. However I take your point what do you actually get for £10m a load of under performing players with little transfer value.

As for Methven he is the clown that Sunderland supporters loath for ruining their club.

Edited by Badger11 (12 Feb 2023 12.52pm)

 


One more point

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 12 Feb 23 1.25pm

I think he's ready, bring him in next season

 

mileend Flag East London 12 Feb 23 1.40pm

Originally posted by Pete53

Good on the fella. Whether he can do this in the PL we don't know, but he is whole heartedly taking his opportunity at Charlton.

Top scorer for them with 9

There must be doubts but I am confident maybe he and others will come through and get their chance in the first team as our Academy is among the best teams in country at both U21 and U18. If other clubs can find a few players that way why not us? In time they should be given the chance to prove themselves at Palace.

However, throwing a young talent into our totally dysfunctional team and type of non football we are playing right now could prematurely end a few promising careers!

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 12 Feb 23 3.33pm

Originally posted by mileend

However, throwing a young talent into our totally dysfunctional team and type of non football we are playing right now could prematurely end a few promising careers!

Originally I thought sending him out to clowntown could end his career, but I think you’re probably right with this statement, we’ve got enough headless chickens up front at the moment without creating another one

 

waddy Flag Highton,Melbourne 18 Feb 23 3.55pm

From what I hear at half time he is having another cracking game !!

We need players who are creating around him & him in our team

 


Forever Palace Proud

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 21 Feb 23 9.34am

If zaha goes or even if he dosent bring this man in next season

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 21 Feb 23 10.40am

Originally posted by Pete53

Good on the fella. Whether he can do this in the PL we don't know, but he is whole heartedly taking his opportunity at Charlton.

Send him to the Championship might be the best bet. Remember Gallagher, had a good spell at Charlton, and then really showed his full potential at Swansea.
If Rak Saki, can do something similar , we really could be on to something, and of course so could he.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 21 Feb 23 10.50am

Originally posted by Putitout

Send him to the Championship might be the best bet. Remember Gallagher, had a good spell at Charlton, and then really showed his full potential at Swansea.
If Rak Saki, can do something similar , we really could be on to something, and of course so could he.

This.

Its a BIG step up. I'd assess him in pre-season but assume he needs 6months/a season in the Champs

He's done nothing yet, but hopefully Ebiowei can have a good end to the season for Hull and may be ready for hte step up.

 

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rak-Sakyi