You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Plymouth Argyle vs. Crystal Palace match thread
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Plymouth Argyle vs. Crystal Palace match thread


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 30 Aug 23 1.01pm

For those worrying about Andersen - felt he needed a rest. I also think Doucoure has been carrying a slight knock. Both could have played if we'd needed it but better to rest.
However, on the flip side, if someone has offered 65+ for Doucoure or 45+ mil for Andersen - we'll probably be taking it. We also will not replace Doucoure, as we have Lerma and Hughes, possible Reidewald or Schlupp at a push, but if we sell Andersen, then I'm expecting a replacement. Holding presumably.
I'm not saying definitely happening but just the noise on the wind of ifs and buts.

 


Red and Blue Army!

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 30 Aug 23 2.24pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I was at the game at the end were scored. I can confirm many of the comments. We started well and for 5 mins knocked it around as if it was training. They didn’t have a touch until they broke away got in a cross and we were behind. We couldn’t handle crosses all evening. Tomkins was misjudging them, Johnson missing them, Mitchell allowing them.

The team then looked as though they had not met one another, let alone not played together. Individually there are some ok players there who could plug a gap from time to time but together would not stand a chance in the PL.

I hoped that halftime would sort it out but within a minute we were 2 down to a great strike. Then we made the changes and everything was different. Eze has rightly been credited but Ayew also deserves praise. They could not cope with him either. The Plymouth defence crumbled as Eze, Ayew and Schlupp ran at them they backed off. All 4 goals were assists by those 3. Mateta looked awful up to then, unable to hold up the ball and passing to no one. When fed balls into channels to run on to, he was totally different.

What looked like being a painful night turned into a fun one. It’s not often you see 4 second half goals smashed in under your nose at an away ground! But the need to strengthen was clear.

The thing that concerned me most was the absence of Doucoure and Andersen.

Nice summary. Always 100x better to understand when are you are at a game, highlights show nothing.

To be fair I think we have all seen what we probably all know.

Our squad isnt great, and Roy start who he starts because of that.

Eze is instrumental to us

Our strikers (despite a lot of people hating on them) can score given the opportunity. 2 of JPMs strikes were corkers. That's not a guy who cant score

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 30 Aug 23 3.29pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Nice summary. Always 100x better to understand when are you are at a game, highlights show nothing.

To be fair I think we have all seen what we probably all know.

Our squad isnt great, and Roy start who he starts because of that.

Eze is instrumental to us

Our strikers (despite a lot of people hating on them) can score given the opportunity. 2 of JPMs strikes were corkers. That's not a guy who cant score

It’s a guy who can score against Plymouth reserves. He was given space and time which you don’t get in the Prem. Have a look at the Brentford Highlights and his total lack of movement when the Ayew cross /shot comes in near the end of the game. That’s the Mateta I wouldn’t miss if he went.

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 30 Aug 23 3.40pm

Originally posted by palace99

great summary thanks.

Agree squad is paper thin, but we have to remember that Plymouth made 9 changes so it was not as if we were facing a top championship team.

With Schlupp struggling on the left how did OE perform in that position?

Has done ok there previously - so wonder if that might be an option for Sunday.

Also Richards at CB. Thoughts? Haven't been convinced by Tomkins for a couple of seasons now, so was surprised he got a new deal.


I think this is why we are looking at Holding and Tomkins may go out on loan or move into a more coaching capacity

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 30 Aug 23 3.50pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

It’s a guy who can score against Plymouth reserves. He was given space and time which you don’t get in the Prem. Have a look at the Brentford Highlights and his total lack of movement when the Ayew cross /shot comes in near the end of the game. That’s the Mateta I wouldn’t miss if he went.


Whether Mateta, can score regularly in the premier is still an open book, but he could only do what he did last night, and all of his efforts were decent strikes.
One thing about Plymouth reserves , is that until we introduced four class premier level players they were to good for our reserves, and would have won that game if we didn’t change the dynamic with the changes, Mateta, who knows ,he still could. For many in the reserve squad they might not get in Plymouths reserve team.

 

YT Flag Oxford 30 Aug 23 5.20pm

I had to be at work at 4am today, so up at 3am. Being of 'advanced years' I stayed with last night's commentary as long as I dared, before deciding enough was enough and turning in with Palace 0-2 down, thinking "ah well; at least we can concentrate on the league.

Imagine my surprise and delight at 3:01am!!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 30 Aug 23 5.34pm

I had an ex-co-worker who left to catch a train with the Knicks up 6 points in a playoff game against the Pacers. There was about 10 seconds remaining when he left.

With 9 seconds left Reggie Miller single handedly scored 8 points and the Knicks lost. To be fair, those 9 seconds took about 2-3 minutes to play (foul on the Knicks and Pacers in there).

This was pre-smart phone days. He was on the Long Island Railroad home and thought the Knicks had won... until he got home and watched the news.


Originally posted by YT

I had to be at work at 4am today, so up at 3am. Being of 'advanced years' I stayed with last night's commentary as long as I dared, before deciding enough was enough and turning in with Palace 0-2 down, thinking "ah well; at least we can concentrate on the league.

Imagine my surprise and delight at 3:01am!!

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 30 Aug 23 5.41pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Hardly you cant expect players to perform without run of games.

Swapping out the whole team as well doesn't help.

Roy is stubborn and has favorites it's that simple the same when he was in charge of England.

Edited by grumpymort (30 Aug 2023 8.35am)

They've literally all just had a run of games - pre-season. Rak-Sakyi and Ahamada in particular were used extensively. Ahamada has played in 3 of our 4 games so far.

Even if they hadn't had games, Plymouth made 9 changes - more than us. Their back ups performed perfectly well.

If Lerma were to get injured tomorrow, how many PL games is it acceptable for the replacement to play at below Plymouth reserves level before they get a 'lack of games' out of the system?

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

pafcprogs Flag 31 Aug 23 5.03pm

And here is the post mortem

Gutted that you made the changes but it shows what a difference in standard there is between the divisions.


Eze was just unplayable......only for a few minutes but we should have made some changes earlier...tired minds couldn't keep up .

Good luck and hope you win it .....good noise from your fans too...second half of the second half at least


[Link]

 

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Plymouth Argyle vs. Crystal Palace match thread