You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Widow review
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Widow review


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
PatrickA Flag London 02 Sep 23 5.36am

Now it’s passed , how do people evaluate the window?
I’ve looked back at the early posts on the topic and nobody was asking for a centre half, but everybody was looking for a wide forward and/or a striker.

Negatives
- the squad remains unbalanced, top heavy in central defenders and light in attacking quality
- we lack pace and quality in wide areas
- if we struggle in games the weakness of forward options on the bench won’t help
- we’ve not exploited the loan market

Positives
- we’ve retained our quality players other than Zaha
- Lerma looks like a good signing

Longer term Henderson and Holding may turn about to be shrewd purchases as we don’t appear to have overpaid and Guiata has to be replaced and eventually Tomkins too will need replacing.
It is difficult to understand why we haven’t strengthened in wider areas as there were plenty of options available either via purchase or loan and we’ve seen these options move to the likes of Bournemouth, Forest, Fulham and Brighton .
If it’s true that we were hanging our hat on the young forward with PSG by agreeing terms with the player, but as of last night not contacting PSG formally, it all seems a bit bizarre.
It doesn’t sound a serious proposition with no plan B or time left for alternatives in the very likely scenario of the deal not happening.

The club has a lot of credit in the bank for purchases in recent seasons, but if you analyse this last window in isolation it would be difficult to score it higher than a charitable 6 out of 10.
If the so far unproven Franca turns out well there is potential for that score to be higher.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 02 Sep 23 6.46am

Originally posted by PatrickA


If the so far unproven Franca turns out well there is potential for that score to be higher.

And if he turns out to be another donkey?

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 02 Sep 23 7.01am

To not get another striker is a massive problem, Edouard and Mateta do not give us enough of a cutting edge at this level. If the likes of Forest and Bournemouth can do It, why on earth can’t we?

SP tells us we are an “established Premiership side” then it’s about time we started acting like one!

 

YT Flag Oxford 02 Sep 23 7.02am

Well losing Wilf felt like a bereavement.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 02 Sep 23 7.06am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

To not get another striker is a massive problem, Edouard and Mateta do not give us enough of a cutting edge at this level. If the likes of Forest and Bournemouth can do It, why on earth can’t we?

SP tells us we are an “established Premiership side” then it’s about time we started acting like one!

Some might say Forrest are a ‘bigger’ team

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Simber Flag Rustington 02 Sep 23 7.07am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

To not get another striker is a massive problem, Edouard and Mateta do not give us enough of a cutting edge at this level. If the likes of Forest and Bournemouth can do It, why on earth can’t we?

SP tells us we are an “established Premiership side” then it’s about time we started acting like one!

^this

 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 02 Sep 23 7.19am

Originally posted by YT

Well losing Wilf felt like a bereavement.

losing Wilf brought no money in so we couldnt spend on another player in large amounts , brighton got lucky with players selling at inflated prices so had money to spend , we should have sold wilf 2 seasons ago and strengthen the squad with the money but all those on here kept saying no it would mean relegation , you didnt know , no one did , all people want is spend spend spend at all cost because they know how to run a football club NOT , so we are doing the best job with the tools we have ,

 

Oddball2021 Flag Adelaide 02 Sep 23 7.22am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Now it’s passed , how do people evaluate the window?
I’ve looked back at the early posts on the topic and nobody was asking for a centre half, but everybody was looking for a wide forward and/or a striker.

Negatives
- the squad remains unbalanced, top heavy in central defenders and light in attacking quality
- we lack pace and quality in wide areas
- if we struggle in games the weakness of forward options on the bench won’t help
- we’ve not exploited the loan market

Positives
- we’ve retained our quality players other than Zaha
- Lerma looks like a good signing

Longer term Henderson and Holding may turn about to be shrewd purchases as we don’t appear to have overpaid and Guiata has to be replaced and eventually Tomkins too will need replacing.
It is difficult to understand why we haven’t strengthened in wider areas as there were plenty of options available either via purchase or loan and we’ve seen these options move to the likes of Bournemouth, Forest, Fulham and Brighton .
If it’s true that we were hanging our hat on the young forward with PSG by agreeing terms with the player, but as of last night not contacting PSG formally, it all seems a bit bizarre.
It doesn’t sound a serious proposition with no plan B or time left for alternatives in the very likely scenario of the deal not happening.

The club has a lot of credit in the bank for purchases in recent seasons, but if you analyse this last window in isolation it would be difficult to score it higher than a charitable 6 out of 10.
If the so far unproven Franca turns out well there is potential for that score to be higher.


For the fans it’s 5/10, if Parish it’s 10/10 because we don’t have the strike power to get into Europe (which he doesn’t want because it forces him to spend) and we have enough mids and defenders to avoid relegation.

 

BM Flag 02 Sep 23 7.22am

This window was always about who we sold rather than who we bought, so to have lost only Wilf must been seen as a great result. We have, with the exception of right back, a brilliant first 11 if and when everyone is fit, but therein lies the problem. With Olise and Franca out we are insisting on using Schlupp as a wide attacker, which just shouldn’t still be happening. All in all, though, happy enough. I can’t see us going down and we should have a decent war chest for next summer’s inevitable big-name departures.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 02 Sep 23 7.26am

I agree with the OP.

Feels like sensible signings of DH, RH and JL.

Franca is obviously an exciting talent.

 

YT Flag Oxford 02 Sep 23 7.47am

Originally posted by mtp1958

losing Wilf brought no money in so we couldnt spend on another player in large amounts , brighton got lucky with players selling at inflated prices so had money to spend , we should have sold wilf 2 seasons ago and strengthen the squad with the money but all those on here kept saying no it would mean relegation , you didnt know , no one did , all people want is spend spend spend at all cost because they know how to run a football club NOT , so we are doing the best job with the tools we have ,

I totally agree with you. Incidentally, my reference to bereavement was a cheeky dig at the thread title (transfer WIDOW).

However, Wilf's departure did free up a large amount of expenditure, and we used a chunk of that saving to improve Olisé's contract

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 02 Sep 23 7.51am

Another stereotypical Palace window really. Failing yet again to bring in players in areas where they are most needed.
I still find it odd that we have paid £20m on a back up goalkeeper.
We are seriously short in forward options and now have to rely pretty much on Mateta and Edouard as our only strikers. Very frustrating when you see clubs like Forest bring in somebody like Origi on loan. I'm not saying Origi would of been the answer but he certainly would of provided us with another quality option.

Yet another season of enduring Joel Ward at right back as well.. We complain about our lack of creativity yet we insist on playing a right back and left back who are poor going forward and can only ever seem to be able to pass backwards.

Don't get me wrong we will stay up. Luton and Sheffield United are so poor that 2 of the 3 relegation places are taken already really which will just leave one place to fight over. I do fear if we carry on with this lack of ambition and doing everything on the cheap then it will catch up with us in the end.

As great as it is to of kept our big players we also have to be realistic and accept that this will most probably be Eze, Doucoure and Guehi's last season at the club. That will leave massive gaps next season.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 02 Sep 23 7.56am

Originally posted by YT

I totally agree with you. Incidentally, my reference to bereavement was a cheeky dig at the thread title (transfer WIDOW).

However, Wilf's departure did free up a large amount of expenditure, and we used a chunk of that saving to improve Olisé's contract

I didnt see that

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 02 Sep 23 8.08am

ANother window which shows us again what is the point of this club we have no ambition but to survive every year so why bother?

If we was doing this and generating lots of money to store or go towards things I could understand but now over a decade in the Prem and we are still happy to operate like this.

This again show we need new people in to control the club.

Spending 25m on a youngster who has done 0 in professional career and is injured already is not good business (It shows we do have some money and wasted like this)

Next spending 20m on a GK when we already have another 3 with it looking like none have them even left the club in the window either.

Buying yet another CB an area we have so many people that can play in madness.

For years we have needed cover on each side yet still nothing.

The most annoying thing is when you look at the other transfers a lot of those names we could have gone for and not cost a lot of money either.

2 out of 10

Amateur club everyone else has no issues with multi signings but we take forever and do not even use loan system.

The only way things will change is if the likes of SP goes he has done well but we need to move on and are stuck with him being in charge its a business not a family gathering.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Jefroc Flag Crete 02 Sep 23 8.30am

At the end of the season Palace had FIVE players who could easily have been bought by Chelsea, Arsenal, Liverpool Spurs and who knows who else. Olise, Ebs, Decoure Guehi and Anderssen have all stayed even though up to yesterday there was talk of Ebs going to Spurs. That they didn't is all praise to Parish and Freedman. They kept a really good squad together. Plus Palace have another top class goalkeeper, a proven EPL defender, a potentially excellent attacking striker/midfielder and another really fine midfielder. Further Palace have three players in the England squad.

Running a football club is not the same as playing a video game - it's real RESPONSIBLE life! Yet all I read on these pages are pitiful bleatings from the same NEGATIVE MOANERS!!!

 


Always remembering walking from the Holmesdale to the Whitehorse end at half time!

Wright stuff Flag Bexley 02 Sep 23 8.34am

Biggest plus keeping Eze, Olise, Guehi, Andersen & Doucoure.
Lerma seems to be great business.
The Jury is out on Henderson, Holding & Franca, the latter has a back problem that sounds like it will keep him out for months.
Front line is extremely weak & needed reinforcing.I would like to dream this is the season Eduoard & Mateta step up & score goals but I will not hold my breath.
The lack of pace in the team is a worry as especially against the better teams it’s how we competed.
The positive is teams like Luton, Sheffield U , Burnley, Everton, Wolves have not really strengthened.
Let’s see how we fair against Wolves, this will be a good barometer for the season going forward.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 02 Sep 23 8.40am

Once again waking up the day after transfer deadline day expecting no late deals, and Palace didn't disappoint.

After a promising start signing Lerma on a free transfer, it has once again been somewhat of a disappointment.

I realise we needed another Keeper after Guiata's tantrum, but did we really need to go so big on another keeper ? It must have taken a massive chunk of our budget.

I cannot figure out why on earth we have signed Rob Holding, who Arsenal could not get rid of quick enough. After coming in for an injured Saliba last season, their defending went to pieces.

Now for Franca. It's not only concerning he arrives injured but there is no expected return date.

I said in a post recently that we can't even complete with Forest or Bournemouth now, let alone the likes of West Ham. Forest sign Sangare from PSV on deadline day (terrific signing), and Bournemouth get Sinisterra on loan (the left sided player we needed, so why could we not get him on loan ?,).

Looking at the expenditure table, we are 4th off bottom with only Luton, Burnley and Everton below is. I said this recently, in terms of finances we near the bottom of the table.

 

Aray Flag South London 02 Sep 23 8.42am

We somehow kept all our key players apart from Wilf who we’ve replaced with Franca. The jury is out on that one obviously.

We have replaced Luca with Lerma. I think that’s a proper upgrade.

We replaced Guita with Henderson, another upgrade, and one that was forced upon us- probably blowing up our plans to finally replace Benteke.

And yes we had to do it given how important that position is and the fact that Johnston is injury prone.

We still need full backs

A solid 6 out of 10

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 02 Sep 23 8.45am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Another stereotypical Palace window really. Failing yet again to bring in players in areas where they are most needed.
I still find it odd that we have paid £20m on a back up goalkeeper.
We are seriously short in forward options and now have to rely pretty much on Mateta and Edouard as our only strikers. Very frustrating when you see clubs like Forest bring in somebody like Origi on loan. I'm not saying Origi would of been the answer but he certainly would of provided us with another quality option.

Yet another season of enduring Joel Ward at right back as well.. We complain about our lack of creativity yet we insist on playing a right back and left back who are poor going forward and can only ever seem to be able to pass backwards.

Don't get me wrong we will stay up. Luton and Sheffield United are so poor that 2 of the 3 relegation places are taken already really which will just leave one place to fight over. I do fear if we carry on with this lack of ambition and doing everything on the cheap then it will catch up with us in the end.

As great as it is to of kept our big players we also have to be realistic and accept that this will most probably be Eze, Doucoure and Guehi's last season at the club. That will leave massive gaps next season.

I couldn’t agree more!

The whole “well we tried but it’s a really difficult window to get deals over the line” messaging that we will inevitably get is undermined by the Bournemouth, Everton and Forest signings.
I am massively disappointed that our main weaknesses (RB, and striker positions) yet again haven’t been resolved.

But it’s okay……..we signed Rob Holding.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 02 Sep 23 8.48am

Originally posted by Oddball2021


For the fans it’s 5/10, if Parish it’s 10/10 because we don’t have the strike power to get into Europe (which he doesn’t want because it forces him to spend) and we have enough mids and defenders to avoid relegation.

Agreed with your fans assessment.

The Parish assessment laughable.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Widow review