You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why are Brighton so much better than us right now?
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why are Brighton so much better than us right now?


Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 25 Sep 23 3.19pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Completely agree with sentiment Robbo but just as an attempt:

We sort of remind me of myself at school now - there's potential there for so much more and a good foundation but TBH we're almost guaranteed to be fine even with the most minimal of effort and coasting off that. The difference here is that Palace's position is due to finances whereas my own was down to the want for chasing tail and the lack of inclination to devote a large proportion of my time to academics. I'd suggest this is why we have seen very little investment of late and as a result, a paper thin squad.

A positive spin on this is perhaps that we have a manager who is willing to call this out whilst still soldiering on, doing his job. I would also suggest a lot of teams 'throw' the Carabao Cup and/or are equally unable to compete yet do not voice this. I'd rather have a manager who's honest with both fans and the board than one who seemingly bobbles their head and goes along. We may, may see some investment in January, especially if we are still ravaged by injuries and results fall off a cliff but also perhaps more favourable draws in the FA Cup, the proper one.

United away is hardly a banker, although perhaps very winnable, and Roy's comments may also be aimed to lighten the burden on the players, put the onus on an already under fire United, and perhaps create the conditions for a very mild 'shock'.

COYP, in Roy we trust.

Good try!

And to be fair I do like the fact that Roy has come out and said it.

Given we've got a solid 2nd string back 5. I really hope we get to see some of the attacking kids have a go.


 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 25 Sep 23 4.10pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Completely agree with sentiment Robbo but just as an attempt:

We sort of remind me of myself at school now - there's potential there for so much more and a good foundation but TBH we're almost guaranteed to be fine even with the most minimal of effort and coasting off that. The difference here is that Palace's position is due to finances whereas my own was down to the want for chasing tail and the lack of inclination to devote a large proportion of my time to academics. I'd suggest this is why we have seen very little investment of late and as a result, a paper thin squad.

A positive spin on this is perhaps that we have a manager who is willing to call this out whilst still soldiering on, doing his job. I would also suggest a lot of teams 'throw' the Carabao Cup and/or are equally unable to compete yet do not voice this. I'd rather have a manager who's honest with both fans and the board than one who seemingly bobbles their head and goes along. We may, may see some investment in January, especially if we are still ravaged by injuries and results fall off a cliff but also perhaps more favourable draws in the FA Cup, the proper one.

United away is hardly a banker, although perhaps very winnable, and Roy's comments may also be aimed to lighten the burden on the players, put the onus on an already under fire United, and perhaps create the conditions for a very mild 'shock'.

COYP, in Roy we trust.

Utd have also been dealt with an injury blow.

Maguire has recovered from his.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

dreamwaverider Flag London 25 Sep 23 6.14pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Utd have also been dealt with an injury blow.

Maguire has recovered from his.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 25 Sep 23 10.17pm

Haha!

P****d meself. Ha!

Originally posted by Spiderman

Ferguson?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 25 Sep 23 10.34pm

Originally posted by silvertop

A deal of naivety as to how things are done. You have serious money bag clubs who will pay whatever is required to get their new ground and a considerably smaller club trying (more or less successfully) to run it sustainably in the most expensive league on earth. Thus, for arsenal an extortionate ransom strip - pay em off. The authority impose outrageous 106 conditions - whatever. We lack the financial clout but have the corporate principles not to tolerate what others accept. You must decide whether you support a club that is bound to its convictions or one so rich they can afford not to have them.

I’d be interested to know in our case how much the extortionate ransom strip was and also the cost of the outrageous section 106 conditions because for those barriers alone, I would be very surprised if they came to more than the cost of one extremely average player.

Under old build (pre covid) prices we could probably have built a new stand with the money we have just spent on an untried youngster, an Arsenal reject and a goalkeeper that we didn’t really need along with the supposed £50m that was already ring fenced. Unfortunately, I reckon that ship has sailed and if the new stand doesn’t get built it’s because the original budget cost has probably more than doubled and it may now be unaffordable.

So, in my opinion we have shot ourselves in the foot by delaying and delaying. I don’t believe the negotiations with Sainsburys and the Council were as difficult as they have been portrayed. They were after all just property deals and there is always a work around. If the new stand (as was being mooted at the time), was going to be the real impetus to the club moving forward then it appears on the face of it that Parish has failed, although we continue to be told it’s going ahead at the end of the season, so for now it’s a case of wait and see.

If it doesn’t go ahead we will be in a poor position as the main stand and the Arthur are truly awful and I’m not sure how the works required are going to be funded in the future.

 

MFW94 Flag Sutton 26 Sep 23 9.05am

It most also be said that Brighton are 500/600 million pound in debt to bloom.

He offsets must of the losses they have make. Now some would say this is a good owner but football must be the only business in the world were operating this way is deemed 'best run club etc' - any other industry operates this would be horrendous and a car crash.

Fair play to them, still cant stand them though.

Edited by MFW94 (26 Sep 2023 9.10am)

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 26 Sep 23 10.14am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Utd have also been dealt with an injury blow.

Maguire has recovered from his.


Now a certainty he'll head in the winner for them!


 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 30 Sep 23 12.05am

Originally posted by MFW94

It most also be said that Brighton are 500/600 million pound in debt to bloom.

He offsets must of the losses they have make. Now some would say this is a good owner but football must be the only business in the world were operating this way is deemed 'best run club etc' - any other industry operates this would be horrendous and a car crash.

Fair play to them, still cant stand them though.

Edited by MFW94 (26 Sep 2023 9.10am)

Not sure how Brighton can be in debt to Bloom. He owns the club therefore any debt is his own which actually puts them in a good position because he basically owes himself money, so all the time he doesn’t care about the club owing him money they are in a decent position. If someone wants to buy them out then they will have to pay his debt.

They are in many ways better off than many other so called debt laden clubs.

To take your later point I would imagine that his losses here are more than offset by gains elsewhere in his business empire.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 30 Sep 23 6.23am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Not sure how Brighton can be in debt to Bloom. He owns the club therefore any debt is his own which actually puts them in a good position because he basically owes himself money, so all the time he doesn’t care about the club owing him money they are in a decent position. If someone wants to buy them out then they will have to pay his debt.

They are in many ways better off than many other so called debt laden clubs.

To take your later point I would imagine that his losses here are more than offset by gains elsewhere in his business empire.

All heavy lifting tax avoidance.

 

YT Flag Oxford 30 Sep 23 7.57am

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Along with Luton, they’re probably the biggest overachievers in the country currently.

Well run operation, excellent recruitment strategy with a seeming conveyor belt of good players meaning they are not reluctant to sell their best players as they already have a replacement.

Annoyingly they are our rivals. Best to focus on ourselves, we’re also punching above our weight by gradually becoming a competitive and established PL club. Let them have their day. It’s taken them about 50 years to get ahead of us.

Sorry but how do you measure overachievement? Do you have a list of where every club should be placed and then compare it to their actual status? In your opinion, where should Brighton be placed ie what should be their current level of achievement, and how do you reach that conclusion? While you are at it, where do you think we should be compared to where we are, and why?

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

stateside Flag Norfolk 30 Sep 23 1.55pm

Aston Villa are kicking them all around the park at the moment they are 3-1 down. sorry now 4-1 @ 65mins

Edited by stateside (30 Sep 2023 1.56pm)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 30 Sep 23 2.00pm

Originally posted by stateside

Aston Villa are kicking them all around the park at the moment they are 3-1 down. sorry now 4-1 @ 65mins

Edited by stateside (30 Sep 2023 1.56pm)

Villa are playing very well at the moment, I fully expect them to fill one of the lower Euro spots this season.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 30 Sep 23 2.05pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Not sure how Brighton can be in debt to Bloom. He owns the club therefore any debt is his own which actually puts them in a good position because he basically owes himself money, so all the time he doesn’t care about the club owing him money they are in a decent position. If someone wants to buy them out then they will have to pay his debt.

They are in many ways better off than many other so called debt laden clubs.

To take your later point I would imagine that his losses here are more than offset by gains elsewhere in his business empire.

Quite simply, the club is a company. One of Bloom's other companies loans them money. The club is then in debt for the loans. Not much money, if any, is given freely by any owners. They recoup when they sell enough players or sell up altogether, Or when the loan is paid off.
Our finances are similar. The directors or companies have loaned money. Last I looked we owed around 70 mil in loans. Presumably more now.

Edited by ASCPFC (30 Sep 2023 2.06pm)

 


Red and Blue Army!

eritheagle Flag Erith 30 Sep 23 2.32pm

They’re not based on today’s performance at Villa!!!

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 30 Sep 23 2.39pm

Ermmmm. They're not!!! ))

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 30 Sep 23 2.42pm

Close thread , , its bollocks

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 30 Sep 23 2.59pm

Maybe the sweaty tight Villa shirts put the weed players off

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Oct 23 8.28am

Well this morning they are not!

 

djcpfc Flag Within a 5 minute walk 01 Oct 23 9.37am

To answer the question, I'm not sure they are.

I think we have turned a corner with recruitment. They had the best Director of Football in the country in Dan Ashworth, who put in place a recruitment strategy that has now been emulated at every club. From 2013-2018 we allowed managers to dictate the signings and they proved costly.

Sakho, Benteke, Van Aarnholt, Cabaye and others came in with big price tags and big wages without being moved on for a return. I can't see this being a strategy that we'll ever pursue again. We keep our heads above water but little else.

Brighton are now due to fail, but are also likely to start hitting FFP rules if they ever intend to keep hold of players. Sooner or later the players they sign wont hit the heights they have so far and with the additional games they will struggle to get their best players on the pitch.

I can't see them finishing much higher in the league this season.

They play a high energy game. Lets see if they can maintain that this season with 50+ games to play.

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 01 Oct 23 10.06am

Originally posted by djcpfc

To answer the question, I'm not sure they are.

I think we have turned a corner with recruitment. They had the best Director of Football in the country in Dan Ashworth, who put in place a recruitment strategy that has now been emulated at every club. From 2013-2018 we allowed managers to dictate the signings and they proved costly.

Sakho, Benteke, Van Aarnholt, Cabaye and others came in with big price tags and big wages without being moved on for a return. I can't see this being a strategy that we'll ever pursue again. We keep our heads above water but little else.

Brighton are now due to fail, but are also likely to start hitting FFP rules if they ever intend to keep hold of players. Sooner or later the players they sign wont hit the heights they have so far and with the additional games they will struggle to get their best players on the pitch.

I can't see them finishing much higher in the league this season.

They play a high energy game. Lets see if they can maintain that this season with 50+ games to play.

I haven't been keeping track of the numbers closely, but at a glance their net transfer spend would seem to be massively in the black. I would struggle to see how they would be troubled by FFP any time soon?

 

Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why are Brighton so much better than us right now?