You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy's comments
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy's comments


Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 31 Oct 23 7.54am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Ex Wolves manager Julian Lopetegui been in stands at Palace for last 2 home games. Just saying


Well he left Wolves as he was unhappy with the club's recruitment strategy. So based on that I think it's probably better for all parties not to get involved!

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

southnorwoodhill Flag 31 Oct 23 7.58am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Roy always plays safe - he knows no other way.
He has his favourites and even if they play badly week after week he will not drop them.
Ward is now beyond the pale and it is sad to see such a good and loyal player so out of his depth.
Hughes is no more a centre forward than I am and seeing his ponderous snail like run on Friday was embarrassing.
Replace Ward and start playing players in position and give youth more of a chance.
His team and tactics worked for a while but then didn't and so he blamed the subs - really Roy?

A fine post. Can anyone honestly dispute the points made therein?

 

beak Flag croydon 31 Oct 23 8.15am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

A fine post. Can anyone honestly dispute the points made therein?

Look at the long list of failed managers (and I mean badly) that we have had and Roy is the best we've had for years. o.k.you may have forgotten the Dutchman, superstar (only as a player)Vieira etc.We have paid over the odds to save our souls on Fireman Sam and Pulis neither are progressives and dig trenches in front of our goal,no way would we improve league position under them.Roy suits us and we suit him we are not Manchester City and would not want to be.

Edited by beak (31 Oct 2023 8.15am)

 

PatrickA Flag London 31 Oct 23 8.15am

I think Roy's comments after Spurs can't be taken in isolation.
After the Newcastle defeat he was asked about the positive contribution of the younger players when they came on as subs.
He was dismissive and said the game was already gone, that their contribution wasn't relevant and that if the press reported positively on their efforts, he would advise the young players concerned not to read the articles.
He seems to be going out of the way not to praise them.
Now this could be way of managing expectations and keeping their feet on the ground and making sure they know they have to earn their place.
It leaves a negative taste in the mouth, but in fairness he usually gets it right on young players.
During his last stint there was a clamour for him to use the likes of Brandon Pierrock and Sam Woods when we were struggling.
I recall him saying there was only one player amongst the young players who was a first team candidate and that was Mitchell.
The others disappeared without trace.

It seems trite and obvious to say Roy knows the game inside out.
You'd like him to be more positive when they do get minutes, but he's unlikely to change now. He believes in his methods and will only play youngsters if he's convinced they will be better than their experienced alternatives (e.g AWB over Ward).

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 31 Oct 23 8.47am

Originally posted by beak

Look at the long list of failed managers (and I mean badly) that we have had and Roy is the best we've had for years. o.k.you may have forgotten the Dutchman, superstar (only as a player)Vieira etc.We have paid over the odds to save our souls on Fireman Sam and Pulis neither are progressives and dig trenches in front of our goal,no way would we improve league position under them.Roy suits us and we suit him we are not Manchester City and would not want to be.

Edited by beak (31 Oct 2023 8.15am)

You have neatly sidestepped acknowledging the points made and engaged in a bit of whataboutery. Fair play.
Being a thread about Roy's comments, it reminded me of a game during his first stint where Wickham made his comeback after a lengthy injury, and did well. From memory it was a cup game.
The interviewer suggested that Wickham had had a good game on his return, Roy's answer was basically "No".
Looks like Roy can't change.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 31 Oct 23 8.56am

Originally posted by Painter

Vieira told Eze he wasn’t good enough to play in his team behind closed doors, did it make Eze want to prove a point when Roy joined, just maybe. Telling people hard truths, when they are being very well paid to perform, isn’t a crime.

I'd 100% agree that hard truths are needed, I'd expect that every Monday morning there is a video debrief sessions where Roy and the coaching staff are going through the good and bad points of the game. Warts and all.

Just not sure its useful doing it in public.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 31 Oct 23 8.56am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

A fine post. Can anyone honestly dispute the points made therein?

Yes, I can.

1. Roys '' favourites ''. Every manager at every club has them, and gets questioned by the fans at to why. Hodgson plays the players he trusts to implement his tactics. Results suggest that these players do not perform badly '' week after week ''.

2. Joel Ward. Definitely needs replacing. If you believe the rumours, Palace were hoping to get AWB back at a reduced fee. That never happened. We all know how the summer transfer budget was used, but if you are using Ward's continued selection to critisise Hodgson then I think you need to look elsewhere. Nobody knows, but I find it difficult to think that Hodgson would have signed the players we did if he had total control of transfers.

3. Of course Hughes is not a centre forward, nor was he asked to be. His selection in that area was a tactical one, and until we went behind, it worked. I acknowledge that Roy focussed more on stopping Spurs rather than us trying to force the issue, but how do we do that given the players currently available ?

4. His post match comments did not blame the subs. We were losing the game and their introduction made no difference was the main thrust. But you can choose to use your own interpretation to suit your agenda.

5. Give youth a chance - well didn't he do just that ? How many U21 and U18 games do you watch ? As teams, the club are competing well in their respective leagues. Looking at individual players though and it's a different story. Ozoh apart, I can't think of one player that I think could add value to the first team squad. I would be interested to hear of other people's views on that.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

taylors lovechild Flag 31 Oct 23 9.06am

To be fair, we're not talking about youth in general, we're talking about three specific young players. JRS was a standout performer in League One and has showed recently he may be able to step up. Ahamada was one of the top performing players for his team in the Bundesliga and we paid 10 million for him. Franca was not signed to play in the U21s. These are players Roy needs to find a way of introducing to the first team. They might not work out but so far none of them have been given enough time to be heaped with praise or damned with criticism. Patience will be needed, but personally I just don't see how Roy's comments are particularly helpful.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 31 Oct 23 9.07am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

A fine post. Can anyone honestly dispute the points made therein?

No, I can only say I'm not sure on Hughes being a 'centre forward'. I guessed that Roy played him in an advanced midfield position (not CF) as he did look to congest the midfield and stop Spurs playing out from the back. That worked first half as Hughes was like a defensive midfielder playing as an attacking one, meaning they had to move the ball forward quickly with few chances to catch us out as our defence was ready. This is the problem however as Spurs did get a goal, which all started with Johnstone f-ing about and ended with an entirely avoidable and unnecessary hammer of a volley from the once again calamitous Joel Ward.

A here lies the huge problem for us. Roy plays for the 0-0 and sets the team up to try and negate the other side when playing any team deemed to be superior to ours, as opposed to seeing what we can do. I think what most fans would like to see is us being a bit more 'positive', 'attacking' or showing intent. The issue with the pragmatic or pessimistic stance is that it does work occasionally however the inevitability when a team get a goal is that we look entirely uncompetitive in yet another match, sinking to yet another narrow loss. There is no 'plan B', as has been referenced ad infinitum so we painfully draw out the narrow loss as opposed to looking to do anything ourselves.

The argument probably will and should be that this means over the course of the season we should finish somewhere reasonable, we shouldn't take too many 'hammerings' and that Roy does not have the resource available to do anything but be pragmatic and responsive. Therefore it's the old conundrum: We don't like what we are seeing but do we blame the manager, suggesting someone else can do better? Do we blame the ownership, bemoan the lack of players and thank the manager for steering us safely albeit sometimes downright depressingly due to our situation? Or... or, do we learn to have a grumble about our narrow losses, move on, wait for the next game, appreciate the holistic picture and just hope for better on the horizon?

I'll settle for the last of those options for now. I fear there will be a time for a 'real moan' but it isn't now or yet.

COYP

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

The Dolphin Flag 31 Oct 23 9.27am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Yes, I can.

1. Roys '' favourites ''. Every manager at every club has them, and gets questioned by the fans at to why. Hodgson plays the players he trusts to implement his tactics. Results suggest that these players do not perform badly '' week after week ''.

2. Joel Ward. Definitely needs replacing. If you believe the rumours, Palace were hoping to get AWB back at a reduced fee. That never happened. We all know how the summer transfer budget was used, but if you are using Ward's continued selection to critisise Hodgson then I think you need to look elsewhere. Nobody knows, but I find it difficult to think that Hodgson would have signed the players we did if he had total control of transfers.

3. Of course Hughes is not a centre forward, nor was he asked to be. His selection in that area was a tactical one, and until we went behind, it worked. I acknowledge that Roy focussed more on stopping Spurs rather than us trying to force the issue, but how do we do that given the players currently available ?

4. His post match comments did not blame the subs. We were losing the game and their introduction made no difference was the main thrust. But you can choose to use your own interpretation to suit your agenda.

5. Give youth a chance - well didn't he do just that ? How many U21 and U18 games do you watch ? As teams, the club are competing well in their respective leagues. Looking at individual players though and it's a different story. Ozoh apart, I can't think of one player that I think could add value to the first team squad. I would be interested to hear of other people's views on that.

I don't care about other clubs - only ours.
Badly performing for us regularly is only Ward to be fair and it isn't his fault - he tries his hardest every week but age catches up with everybody.
Hughes - this is more about square pegs in round holes - something that Roy is excellent at when there is no need to be.
His post match comments absolutely blamed the subs for not turning things around when the ship had long sailed into the distance!
Youth - play them from the start or give them longer on the filed - certainly don't just bring them on when the game is lost.
Neillo - Roy has been brilliant for us and he is a true Gentleman of the game but I just do not agree with his tactics currently and it is now fair to say that the entertainment has gone out of our game - albeit I accept that Eze and Olise are not available.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 31 Oct 23 9.44am

I think it might also be pertinent to point out we conceded just as meekly at the end of last season under Roy when we lost 0-1 to Spuds and Eze and Olise were both in the team. It isn't just about personnel. It's these kind of performances that everyone (including Parish it seemed) got fed up with in the end of Roy's last reign.

I think the next three games will be far more telling. Roy has a very good record against lower placed teams and hopefully we'll see a bit more positivity.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 31 Oct 23 9.47am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I don't care about other clubs - only ours.
Badly performing for us regularly is only Ward to be fair and it isn't his fault - he tries his hardest every week but age catches up with everybody.
Hughes - this is more about square pegs in round holes - something that Roy is excellent at when there is no need to be.
His post match comments absolutely blamed the subs for not turning things around when the ship had long sailed into the distance!
Youth - play them from the start or give them longer on the filed - certainly don't just bring them on when the game is lost.
Neillo - Roy has been brilliant for us and he is a true Gentleman of the game but I just do not agree with his tactics currently and it is now fair to say that the entertainment has gone out of our game - albeit I accept that Eze and Olise are not available.

Hi Dolphin,

I don't care about other clubs either, but I hope you got the point I was making.

I think we agree on Joel. It hurts to critisise him but he should be no more than a squad player now.

Hughes...as I and others have said, it was a tactical selection which worked for more than half of the game. If we had Mateta up front with Edouard we would have played straight into Tottenham's hands. Square pegs in round holes sometimes make sense !

You now seem to have shifted your position on Roy's post match comments more into line with mine, which was critising the subs for not making a difference when they came on - which they didn't.

It's the old argument about young players. If they merit selection then they should get their chance. I don't think that Jes or Franca look starting material yet. Do you ?

As for Roy's tactics, last season we saw what he can do when he has the players available to him. As you acknowledge, he doesn't have them at the moment. And so he is reverting to being the pragmatist that he is.

I don't think we should lose sight of the fact that Roy is here for the short term. And despite the '' Top 10 '' comment in pre season, his primary objective will not have been changed - to stay in the Premier League.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Putitout Flag Oxford 31 Oct 23 9.50am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I think it might also be pertinent to point out we conceded just as meekly at the end of last season under Roy when we lost 0-1 to Spuds and Eze and Olise were both in the team. It isn't just about personnel. It's these kind of performances that everyone (including Parish it seemed) got fed up with in the end of Roy's last reign.

I think the next three games will be far more telling. Roy has a very good record against lower placed teams and hopefully we'll see a bit more positivity.

The club have a very good record against lower placed teams under any manager. Hodgson has as good or better record for beating the giants than any other manager manager we ever had from way back.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 31 Oct 23 10.05am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

To be fair, we're not talking about youth in general, we're talking about three specific young players. JRS was a standout performer in League One and has showed recently he may be able to step up. Ahamada was one of the top performing players for his team in the Bundesliga and we paid 10 million for him. Franca was not signed to play in the U21s. These are players Roy needs to find a way of introducing to the first team. They might not work out but so far none of them have been given enough time to be heaped with praise or damned with criticism. Patience will be needed, but personally I just don't see how Roy's comments are particularly helpful.

You’re right to point out the fees paid for these so called young players, it really is a part of what is the whole crux of this situation. Public or otherwise, right or wrong, Hodgson says they are not good enough, he says get them back on the training pitch and let’s see if we can get them there. What does that say about his present relationship with those in recruitment,? Those comments don’t just hit us, or the individuals, they hit recruitment, they hit his bosses, and this moderate man , after a life time of diplomatic response ,knows that and couldn’t give a toss. It’s hard not to think there is a tight rope being walked on in the club right now.

Edited by Putitout (31 Oct 2023 11.30am)

 

beak Flag croydon 31 Oct 23 10.05am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

You have neatly sidestepped acknowledging the points made and engaged in a bit of whataboutery. Fair play.
Being a thread about Roy's comments, it reminded me of a game during his first stint where Wickham made his comeback after a lengthy injury, and did well. From memory it was a cup game.
The interviewer suggested that Wickham had had a good game on his return, Roy's answer was basically "No".
Looks like Roy can't change.

I remember that game well wickham scored and had a decent game, I can only imagine that Roy's view might have been that "One swallow does not a summer make". Also Roy didn't want Parish saying well you've got Wickham you don't need another striker,Roy like most people realised that you couldn't depend on Wickham to stay injury free and so it proved.

 

Croydon Sunset Flag London 31 Oct 23 1.24pm

I didn't like reading them, not exactly inspiring man management from Roy there. But it feels like Roy code for 'give me some effing money to spend in January'

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

After Roy's comments should SP have a rethink and send him to a retirement home?

Simple Yes or No?

Potential replacement Kieran McKenna?

 

Painter Flag Croydon 31 Oct 23 1.41pm

Originally posted by Croydon Sunset

I didn't like reading them, not exactly inspiring man management from Roy there. But it feels like Roy code for 'give me some effing money to spend in January'

Roy doesn’t buy players, it’s the same in all Premier clubs. Why can’t Roy say what he thinks, to many bland post match interviews with media sound bites. His comments were correct, they didn’t improve the team. To me they may have potential, but they looked very lightweight and were easily brushed aside by experienced pros.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 31 Oct 23 2.32pm

Originally posted by Painter

Roy doesn’t buy players, it’s the same in all Premier clubs. Why can’t Roy say what he thinks, to many bland post match interviews with media sound bites. His comments were correct, they didn’t improve the team. To me they may have potential, but they looked very lightweight and were easily brushed aside by experienced pros.

In not to many words that makes some very relevant points. The young players , are they up to the job? Most people in the game would say no, and Hodgson has handled players of all age groups in his long career , I’m one glad to agree with him.
It is almost laughable that all managers have to give extended interviews week in week out with no one apparently wanting to hear the truth on everything relevant to a teams performances. He didn’t say they lost us the game , he said in so many words they are not good enough to be his subs. By referring to them as kids, people are talking about the young players involved as if they are children, they are young men, already earning exceptional money, and based on ability the potential to earn a whole lot more.
We know it’s been the trend for some time to not hurt the feelings of the young, but come on, they are not 17 years old on National Service are they, getting told a few home truths most days. Being told you are not doing well enough is always going to happen in football, you move on positively. Eze, didn’t get to us unscathed.
Added to that JRS, in. Particular , whom I have time for , is finding it very hard to cope with big international quality full backs , they just overwhelm him , mature man against young man. He can develop ,but to much of this will hurt his confidence far more than Roy saying your not ready, you need more time, public or otherwise.

Edited by Putitout (31 Oct 2023 2.46pm)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 31 Oct 23 2.49pm

Originally posted by Putitout

In not to many words that makes some very relevant points. The young players , are they up to the job? Most people in the game would say no, and Hodgson has handled players of all age groups in his long career , I’m one glad to agree with him.
It is almost laughable that all managers have to give extended interviews week in week out with no one apparently wanting to hear the truth on everything relevant to a teams performances. He didn’t say they lost us the game , he said in so many words they are not good enough to be his subs. By referring to them as kids, people are talking about the young players involved as if they are children, they are young men, already earning exceptional money, and based on ability the potential to earn a whole lot more.
We know it’s been the trend for some time to not hurt the feelings of the young, but come on, they are not 17 years old on National Service are they, getting told a few home truths most days. Being told you are not doing well enough is always going to happen in football, you move on positively. Eze, didn’t get to us unscathed.

My only caveat to this is, you can’t realistically expect inexperienced players to come on and change the entire way we were playing (which is what we had to do against Spurs) and then take the game by the scruff of the neck. Lerma, Doucoure are supposed to provide the solidity to the team. Provided they are fit they should play full games every week, so if you are going to change the game it has to come from the players in front of those two and then JRS, Franca, Ahamada must get the support from behind to allow them to do that.

Hughes should be our back up player for one of the Doucoure/Lerma spots and nothing else. He does not have the pace to influence the game anywhere else.

To be honest I couldn’t work out what we were trying to do in the last 20 mins, so to blame the subs is harsh unless of course they didn’t do what they were instructed to do, which is quite possible.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 31 Oct 23 3.17pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

My only caveat to this is, you can’t realistically expect inexperienced players to come on and change the entire way we were playing (which is what we had to do against Spurs) and then take the game by the scruff of the neck. Lerma, Doucoure are supposed to provide the solidity to the team. Provided they are fit they should play full games every week, so if you are going to change the game it has to come from the players in front of those two and then JRS, Franca, Ahamada must get the support from behind to allow them to do that.

Hughes should be our back up player for one of the Doucoure/Lerma spots and nothing else. He does not have the pace to influence the game anywhere else.

To be honest I couldn’t work out what we were trying to do in the last 20 mins, so to blame the subs is harsh unless of course they didn’t do what they were instructed to do, which is quite possible.

I don’t think Hodgson expected them to improve the situation , let alone win the game.
I think the point everyone seems to miss is. He hasn’t just found out they are not good enough. What you saw is all he has, and he hopes you know it ,
As ever in these games players had run themselves out, and needed subbing , so he had to get someone on, the lads are on the bench because there is no one else. People have questioned the line up and how it was used anyway , I would like to know who these improvements he could have changed the game with are? Personally I agree with Hodgson , for me JRS, was bullied out of the game,, Franca, was erratic , and a mistake away from disaster, and the French guy didn’t let us know he was there.

 

Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy's comments