You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer policy
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer policy


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
PatrickA Flag London 29 Oct 23 7.16pm

I've noted from many comments on these forums there is a lot of discontent about our transfer policy e.g no Zaha replacement, no new full backs, no new striker, no loans brought in.
Furthermore, players brought in at goalkeeper and at centre back where we already have good players.
This is seen as misallocation of our scarce resources where we have glaring gaps elsewhere.
I can only assume the club are looking at the medium term as opposed to the immediate need.
It's likely to be Tomkins' last season and rumours continue around the future of Guehi and Anderson, so Holding may be viewed with the medium term in mind, particularly if the fee was reasonable.
The Henderson deal is a head scratcher for a number of reasons.
His injury record isn't great and Johnstone has done well.
It was generally thought we'd go for a talented and experienced back up instead.
Franca may well turn out to be a bargain, but it's a risk for a club of our stature
For £25 million we should be getting an immediate first team player.
I suppose the above highlights the discrepancy in approach between the fans and the club.
The fans want to see squad shortcomings dealt with now, whereas the club take a longer term view taking into account the terms of players' contracts which we are unfamiliar with.
Ideally you'd want to be able to do both, but this is evidently defeating us at present.

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 29 Oct 23 9.34pm

Roy on the other hand is very definitely short term and is wanting immediate assistance, not players for the future , to help his cause for success. We are witnessing medium term planning by the club with a short term manager hence the disjointed post match comments. I think we all know that Roy was employed to buy time for the club’s medium term recruitment to come to fruition. The key for the future now is not so much the rate of development for the youngsters but the selection of the correct manager to utilise them. Time will tell. COYP

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 30 Oct 23 11.45am

i think there is an African club in Jan /Feb 2024.

Not sure if they've all qualified but Schlupp, Ayew and Doucoure could all be missing for over 1 month.

Makes the lack of transfer activity in the front 3 positions this summer even more bizarre, especially as we already knew the Olise injury was going to keep him out for 3 or 4 months.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 30 Oct 23 11.58am

Franca was presumably Textor, whilst so was the sale of O'Brien - which I didn't think either were good value for us. Henderson: sounds like we had him as a target for a while but I don't see the point of two first team goalies in today's football. One will inevitably be unhappy. There were rumours of Johnstone leaving, however. Could have been that. Holding now looks rubbish but we didn't exactly pay much and he wasn't bad for Arsenal.
Looking at it all - it does not look like a joined up policy. Looks like individual actions that were unconnected.
The lack of right back is starting to show. It really is where we needed cover. Always remember too - if Mitchell is injured cover is so poor that Ward or Clyne go to left back. Says a lot about Reidewald and Schlupp there.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 30 Oct 23 12.03pm

I think our policy has been effective in recent seasons but is also clearly flawed and muddled in some aspects.

Signing Henderson for £20m may be seen as good value by the club but the problem is that the longer he doesn't play (ignoring the fact that he's now injured), that value will depreciate.

In order for the value to maintain or increase, he's got to play and play well. Johnstone has been very good for us since joining and it would have been harsh to drop him regardless when he hasn't done a lot wrong so far.

Someone like Holding joining for £5m makes more sense as, even if he doesn't play until one of the other CBs leave, that's a relatively small fee. £20m, for us, isn't,

Franca is a curious one. Roy started on after the game on Friday about how 'some people' are expecting unrealistic things from him.

Not sure if he was referencing the fans by that, who I actually think have been very patient and haven't overhyped him too much, but Roy needs to consider the significance of us paying £25m for the lad.

How many times have we ever paid more than that for a player? Once or twice maybe? By the fact that he is one of our biggest signings or all time, he is automatically going to have pressure on him to deliver.

If he'd gone into Chelsea's squad or similar, where £25m is really just a throwaway fee and there's so much competition that he could take his time, the pressure in some ways would be less. For us, a £25m player has to do well and reasonably quickly.

It's all well and good us looking for bargains when they appear but that will all be for nothing if we get relegated and, although I am confident that won't happen this season, we do have some glaring holes in our squad that we can't keep ignoring forever or it will eventually cost us.

Ultimately we need a new starting right back with Ward dropping to reserve and Clyne / Ferguson off the wage bill.

We need left back competition for Mitchell who I remain unconvinced by.

We need a specialist left winger.

And we need a striker to replace Mateta and give Eduoard competition.

Currently the core of our side, the central players, are being let down by the wide players in defence and midfield being of a lower standard and as soon as the likes of Olise get injured and Zaha leaves, you see the level drop.

The last two games we've seen Mitchell and then Ward targeted and have shockers while Ayew, who a year or so ago nobody wanted in the side, is currently trying to do the job of about 3 men.

I completely support the club being shrewd and picking up bargains but it has to be balanced with filling glaring holes too and the latter needs to take priority.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Putitout Flag Oxford 30 Oct 23 1.15pm

Money is and has been a problem for Palace, and getting a right balance out of our circumstance will never be easy, or possibly good enough to be much more than we have been.
But having said that the recruitment in the last three windows has not only been short of what was needed but puzzling in what’s was done.. Yes the full back situation doesn’t go away, mid field is stronger, but after two immense signings in Eze, And Olize, no other forwards are better than just squad fillers. And the club knew it could well lose Wilf.
The important issue really is the game has moved on with 5 subs 100minute games common place. Regardless of any addressing actual positions the squad has got smaller certainly in experience, and is really not anywhere near the numbers needed for where the game is going. Considering money was spent the puzzle is , why spend it on a goal keeper , injury prone? When a cheaper option would have done. Why a kid from Brazil, , that Hodgson says clearly is a beginner in the sense of doing Premier league, £25 mill don’t forget , what would that have picked up in Europe? Put the two together and by some reckoning £50 mill. No visible attempt to get a forward to ,not replace but fill the Wilf gap , no chance it seems of even a loan to getup and cover our two fairly ineffectual strikers. As far as squad size is concerned possibly we could have remained a bit short if we had ,as it is we are woefully short. And the business done didn’t begin to address that.

Edited by Putitout (30 Oct 2023 1.16pm)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 30 Oct 23 1.21pm

I read that it was Freedman pushing for Franca and the club claimed they had been tracking him for a while. It's one of those deals where in a few years time we could be tucking away £70+ million in the bank as he heads off to Barcelona/Real, or we could be shipping him out on loan to the Portuguese second division. For the first team we've seen a cameo against Newcastle where he looked highly promising, and one on Friday where he didn't. The only way he is going to settle is to play so we may all just need to be patient and let him make mistakes and find his feet.

Henderson is the weird one. If he's fit then £20m is actually a good price for a keeper yet to hit his prime, an England international and with possibly another decade of football ahead of him. But rumours are Forest shied away due to fitness concerns, so what does that say about us?

Although cheap the Holding deal made no sense to me. It almost felt like a token gesture for Roy. Here you go buddy, a solid pro. We know you like those.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 30 Oct 23 3.38pm

There were rumours of Johnstone having a release clause, so I can only imagine the board thought he'd be off. And ending the window with no first team keeper wasn't an option.

Johnstone didnt end up leaving and then we end up with 2.

I'm fine with the Franca gamble, but I don't see why we couldn't have got a loan in as well e.g. Jack Harrison

Would have given us an immediate Wilf replacement, and some time for Franca to get used to England.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 30 Oct 23 4.57pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

I think our policy has been effective in recent seasons but is also clearly flawed and muddled in some aspects.

Signing Henderson for £20m may be seen as good value by the club but the problem is that the longer he doesn't play (ignoring the fact that he's now injured), that value will depreciate.

In order for the value to maintain or increase, he's got to play and play well. Johnstone has been very good for us since joining and it would have been harsh to drop him regardless when he hasn't done a lot wrong so far.

Someone like Holding joining for £5m makes more sense as, even if he doesn't play until one of the other CBs leave, that's a relatively small fee. £20m, for us, isn't,

Franca is a curious one. Roy started on after the game on Friday about how 'some people' are expecting unrealistic things from him.

Not sure if he was referencing the fans by that, who I actually think have been very patient and haven't overhyped him too much, but Roy needs to consider the significance of us paying £25m for the lad.

How many times have we ever paid more than that for a player? Once or twice maybe? By the fact that he is one of our biggest signings or all time, he is automatically going to have pressure on him to deliver.

If he'd gone into Chelsea's squad or similar, where £25m is really just a throwaway fee and there's so much competition that he could take his time, the pressure in some ways would be less. For us, a £25m player has to do well and reasonably quickly.

It's all well and good us looking for bargains when they appear but that will all be for nothing if we get relegated and, although I am confident that won't happen this season, we do have some glaring holes in our squad that we can't keep ignoring forever or it will eventually cost us.

Ultimately we need a new starting right back with Ward dropping to reserve and Clyne / Ferguson off the wage bill.

We need left back competition for Mitchell who I remain unconvinced by.

We need a specialist left winger.

And we need a striker to replace Mateta and give Eduoard competition.

Currently the core of our side, the central players, are being let down by the wide players in defence and midfield being of a lower standard and as soon as the likes of Olise get injured and Zaha leaves, you see the level drop.

The last two games we've seen Mitchell and then Ward targeted and have shockers while Ayew, who a year or so ago nobody wanted in the side, is currently trying to do the job of about 3 men.

I completely support the club being shrewd and picking up bargains but it has to be balanced with filling glaring holes too and the latter needs to take priority.

We payed 17m not 25m, the add ons are never going to happen.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

eritheagle Flag Erith 30 Oct 23 5.02pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

There were rumours of Johnstone having a release clause, so I can only imagine the board thought he'd be off. And ending the window with no first team keeper wasn't an option.

Johnstone didnt end up leaving and then we end up with 2.

I'm fine with the Franca gamble, but I don't see why we couldn't have got a loan in as well e.g. Jack Harrison

Would have given us an immediate Wilf replacement, and some time for Franca to get used to England.

According to Johnstone Roy reassured him that he was he’s no.1

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 30 Oct 23 5.04pm

The transfer policy (if we can call it that) is vexing.

For two years we have been crying out for new players to fill 3 main positions:
1. A full back (or two)
2. A creative midfield general
3. A striker (by which I mean somebody who can actually score)

No.2 is a most difficult position to fill, decent candidates are like gold dust. But for Nos 1 and 3 there is a wider choice.

But what happens? We pay up to £20 million for an injury prone keeper. We renew Ferguson's contract, seemingly out of pity for a
talented but permanently injured youngster and we spent years trying to get Conor Wickham fit. A lesson not learned. Edouard has talent but gets little provision and Mateta is £14 million down the drain. Even Gerry Queen in the 70's ran valiantly for a lost cause.

I guess the extravagances of the Sahko and Benteke transfers have to some extent been learned but then they buy an injury stricken keeper for circa £20 million who lasted all of 20 minutes on his only appearance.

We are one of the lowest goal scorers and leak goals down both wings yet nothing so far has been done to address these problems.

There is no substitute for talent but all we offer is spirit and endeavour. Buying players is fraught with difficulty and disappointment but that is no excuse for the failure to get the players in the positions we desperately need.

Roy is holding the fort until the cavalry (Olise and Eze) eventually arrive. In the meantime our chances of a result against Burnley don't look great.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 30 Oct 23 5.05pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

We payed 17m not 25m, the add ons are never going to happen.

He has to be nominated for the Ballon D'Or was one add on that was reported originally. I can just about remember Ronaldo and Messi playing at a similar age and can say they were a bit raw, but undoubtedly much better than Franca. I wonder what the others are, I believe something about The Champions League (I honestly think winning it) was one. There are two we look relatively unlikely to pay. However, should we have to pay them, I'm pretty sure we'd only be too happy to do it.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 30 Oct 23 5.15pm

It certainly seems we are all in agreement with the position the club is in and the lack of action to fill the glaring holes in the team.

The biggest conundrum I keep banging my head against the wall with is why, when you have £50m+available (in addition to the money for Lerma and also apparently money was there for a striker), that we bought a goalkeeper, a youngster and an old hand none of which are oven ready first team players. This just smacks of poor planning to me as there were plenty of players for both cash or loan out there to:

1) replace Wilf
2) replace Clyne and make Ward back up
3) replace Guaita with a an experienced no 2 keeper
4) replace Mateta (can’t believe we had a decent bid in for him too).

We knew Guaita wanted to leave, we knew Wilf wanted to leave, we’ve known for two years that a RB upgrade was required along with LB cover and everyone knows Mateta is not cut out for PL football. He is a Sorloth MkII and will probably do ok in less demanding leagues.

It all points to Dougie not being quite as agile in the market place as some would have us believe.

My mate normally spends about £24k a year on corporate tickets for Palace. He hasn’t this year for first time in a while and when asked why not he simply said, “when you put your hand in your pockets to buy some decent players to watch, so will I”. He’s kind of got a point.

 

PatrickA Flag London 30 Oct 23 7.29pm

If I go back to the summer a confused picture emerges.
Roy has said we were close to bringing in two new players, a left back/ midfield (Hall) and a striker (Etiteke).

The assumption must be that these were two positions that had been identified as needing to be strengthened and I doubt too may on here would disagree with that.

It was also known there was a problem with Guiata in the summer when he didn’t go on tour or join pre season training so we would need a second keeper.

We have ended up not strengthening the two two identified positions and instead opted to add where we are arguably strongest (centre back) and also bought a potential first choice keeper when we have a perfectly good one in Johnstone ( I know there are rumours on concerns re a release clause for him).

It may be there has been reasons for switching of targets that we are not privy to, but on the face of it, and having observed performances recently, it is difficult to understand.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 30 Oct 23 8.34pm

Question - which is most likely?

1. A finished new main stand
2. Buying a 15 goal a season striker

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 31 Oct 23 6.49am

New Main stand.

Originally posted by Davepalace707

Question - which is most likely?

1. A finished new main stand
2. Buying a 15 goal a season striker

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 31 Oct 23 9.07am

Originally posted by PatrickA

If I go back to the summer a confused picture emerges.
Roy has said we were close to bringing in two new players, a left back/ midfield (Hall) and a striker (Etiteke).

The assumption must be that these were two positions that had been identified as needing to be strengthened and I doubt too may on here would disagree with that.

It was also known there was a problem with Guiata in the summer when he didn’t go on tour or join pre season training so we would need a second keeper.

We have ended up not strengthening the two two identified positions and instead opted to add where we are arguably strongest (centre back) and also bought a potential first choice keeper when we have a perfectly good one in Johnstone ( I know there are rumours on concerns re a release clause for him).

It may be there has been reasons for switching of targets that we are not privy to, but on the face of it, and having observed performances recently, it is difficult to understand.

Its very difficult to understand. Especially given how much in budget movement there was in the market.

The level of cover in some positions is pretty woeful, and a few injuries have shown the implications.

I still cant really believe that we didnt sign a ready made replacement for Wilf. I don't know if its disrespectful or ignorance given his contributions to the team over the last decade.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 31 Oct 23 9.19am

Thought this might 'cheer' people up, it's supposed to be the 15 worst signings we've made incl a current squad player. 15 players: 12 goals: 249 apps.

[Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 31 Oct 23 9.59am

We fans aren't privvy to what's going on behind the scenes at Palace.

You would like to think that the Henderson and Franca signings make sense to Freedman and Parish even if they don't to us at this moment in time.

It's hard to accept though, when you see glaring gaps that need to be filled in other positions.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

rikz Flag Croydon 31 Oct 23 10.07am

I just don't understand our transfer buisness at all, I understand we don't have money but to use 20 million on a goalkeeper makes no sense. Also over 20 million on a 19 year old, great prospect yes, replacement for wilf, no, unless you're a generational great then any 19 year old clearly needs to develop. Probably not the best window to spend that money on one.

Also what's frustrating is there were players available. Traore, Hudson odi, gray etc would any have made us into world beaters, no, do they all have prem experience, yes, would they have improved our squad, yes.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer policy