You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Everton match thread
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Everton match thread


Page 5 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 11 Nov 23 5.22pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Ward does a lot of ball watching and two of the goals was part his fault not tracking the man watching the ball.

We desperately need left and right backs both are not good enough at this level as first team starters squad players yes.

Correct no Plan B

He does have options but how is bringing a player on at 89min good one the same with a striker who has scored 1 in 35 prem games with only 10min left.

20m+ Brazilian getting 0 min

We are hardly a relegation team stop being drama queen we are mid table team who has history of games like this messing up.

Edited by grumpymort (11 Nov 2023 5.16pm)

Sorry when did I say we were a relegation team??.. I said we will tread water between 17th and 13th.. Stop being a drama queen and read the posts properly.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

palace chick Flag South Croydon 11 Nov 23 5.22pm

Entertaining game today, but sadly we defended badly unlike Everton. Lots of mistakes by us at the back. We also desperately need a centre forward.

 

PatrickA Flag London 11 Nov 23 5.25pm

Many on this thread, including me, were hoping for a point foreseeing it as a difficult game which we could easily lose.
Everton are not the clueless team of recent seasons and have a good manager in Dyche and solid , experienced players like Pickford, Tarkowski, Doucoure, Guehi, McNeil and Calvert Lewin.
They are no mugs.
That being said, it could have gone either way and if we had a decent striker we’d probably be looking at a different result as we did create chances.
As it is, we can forget the myth of ‘Fortress Selhurst’ this season and have conceded 3 goals again.
Roy will not he content with that defensive performance, but sadly many players will now be on international duty which will disrupt work on the training field.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 11 Nov 23 5.27pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Ward does a lot of ball watching and two of the goals was part his fault not tracking the man watching the ball.

We desperately need left and right backs both are not good enough at this level as first team starters squad players yes.

Correct no Plan B

He does have options but how is bringing a player on at 89min good one the same with a striker who has scored 1 in 35 prem games with only 10min left.

20m+ Brazilian getting 0 min

We are hardly a relegation team stop being drama queen we are mid table team who has history of games like this messing up.

Edited by grumpymort (11 Nov 2023 5.16pm)

Olise came on in 69th minute. Franca isnt ready for the first team, whats the point of throwing him in. Olise was given little game time initially.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 11 Nov 23 5.28pm

Originally posted by mtp1958

oh sorry thought we was Man city reading posts , most of you havent kicked the ball outside your garden , because you can watch it all from off the pitch doesnt mean you are experts , play the game at pitch level its a different game COYP

WTF Are you going on about ?

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 11 Nov 23 5.31pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Was a lazy, lackadaisical performance against a team we knew could only try to outwork us and swing balls into the box.

It seemed as though no preparation was done for this nor was it amended at half time or during the match.

Absolutely sh!t and ridiculous.

Yep that was b awful. And watching Edouarde getting caught offside time and time again when we were on top in the first half. What’s the point of getting Elize back & putting in crosses and passing to that muppet.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 11 Nov 23 5.32pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

Nonsense.


Well, Edouard was a liability first half, all the good work we did fell apart around him. We desperately need to get rid of both him and Mateta, bring in a decent striker and hope that Franca can turn into a goal scorer at PL level.

 

Hannes Flag Vienna 11 Nov 23 5.37pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Many on this thread, including me, were hoping for a point foreseeing it as a difficult game which we could easily lose.
Everton are not the clueless team of recent seasons and have a good manager in Dyche and solid , experienced players like Pickford, Tarkowski, Doucoure, Guehi, McNeil and Calvert Lewin.

Don`t jinx it!

 

rikz Flag Croydon 11 Nov 23 5.47pm

I feel sorry for Roy, do you think he wants a squad with Edouard and mateta as his strikers, ward and Mitchell as full backs he has no choice but to start, no replacement for our best player, lerma as a replacement for macarthur and luka. Great spine but we all know where we're lacking and its the boards fault.

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 11 Nov 23 5.54pm

Originally posted by G O Eagle

To me Edouard follows in the footsteps of Gabbiadini, Taylor, Akinbiyi .... but is a poorer players than any of those

We give Marco Gabbiadini stick, but look at the stats.

He was a one-goal-in-three striker at Sunderland when we paid £1.2m for him and guess what?............He was a one-goal-in-three striker at CPFC.

His greatest offence was that he was not Ian Wright........not even close.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 11 Nov 23 5.55pm

Frustrating result. No idea why Hughes started over Doucoure, did he have a knock or something? If not made no sense.

We all know where the weaknesses in this team are at this point and it's boring typing it out repeatedly.

It is insane that we haven't bought better full backs to compliment our centre backs and I think it's a crying shame that we'll probably lose at least one of Anderson and Guehi in the summer without ever seeing what we could have done without those weak links in defence.

The difference in quality in our team from having Ayew and Schlupp as our wingers to Ayew and Olise as our wingers is absolutely absurd and, again, it's baffling that we didn't get anyone to replace Zaha. Unless you count Franca, who Roy said we basically all need to back off from.

I dunno. We're so close to being a really good team, like 2/3 players away, but we never quite get there and will always just fall slightly short.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

WJK1960 Flag 11 Nov 23 5.59pm

Originally posted by New Forest Eagle

Funny because I thought we looked pretty good and cant believe we came away without 3pts let alone 1

Just back from the game. Sometimes the performance and the result don't match. I thought in general we played well, Eze was great, but they took all of their chances and we didn't. Compare tbis performance with that agaibst Forest and its chalk abd cheese.It's painful, but it happens.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 11 Nov 23 6.03pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

Yep that was b awful. And watching Edouarde getting caught offside time and time again when we were on top in the first half. What’s the point of getting Elize back & putting in crosses and passing to that muppet.

Eddie scored a good goal but his overall play is simply not good enough. He doesn't work the defence hard enough nor does he score enough goals albeit he has 5 this season which is a good start. If he ends up with around 20 PL goals then I shall have to revise my opinion.


 


One more point

eritheagle Flag Erith 11 Nov 23 6.07pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

Frustrating result. No idea why Hughes started over Doucoure, did he have a knock or something? If not made no sense.

We all know where the weaknesses in this team are at this point and it's boring typing it out repeatedly.

It is insane that we haven't bought better full backs to compliment our centre backs and I think it's a crying shame that we'll probably lose at least one of Anderson and Guehi in the summer without ever seeing what we could have done without those weak links in defence.

The difference in quality in our team from having Ayew and Schlupp as our wingers to Ayew and Olise as our wingers is absolutely absurd and, again, it's baffling that we didn't get anyone to replace Zaha. Unless you count Franca, who Roy said we basically all need to back off from.

I dunno. We're so close to being a really good team, like 2/3 players away, but we never quite get there and will always just fall slightly short.

Doucoure didn't train all week until yesterday Roy said in his pre match press conference. I don't know why though.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 11 Nov 23 6.14pm

Originally posted by rikz

I feel sorry for Roy, do you think he wants a squad with Edouard and mateta as his strikers, ward and Mitchell as full backs he has no choice but to start, no replacement for our best player, lerma as a replacement for macarthur and luka. Great spine but we all know where we're lacking and its the boards fault.

Why are you feeling sorry for Roy..??

He has resources at his disposal - but continues to play his favourites - irrespective of how badly they perform..!!

Ward is just a liability, Hughes too lightweight for the Prem - Schlupp - not even sure what he does - the list goes on..!!

Look Olise was clearly fit - so why not start him, why Richards is not given a go at right back is beyond me when Ward is so poor. When is he ever going to give Franca a go - where was Ozoh today - not even on the bench..!!

So no I don’t feel sorry for Roy - just fed up with him playing his favourites and it’s costing us..!!

As I said raging..!!

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 11 Nov 23 6.15pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Eddie scored a good goal but his overall play is simply not good enough. He doesn't work the defence hard enough nor does he score enough goals albeit he has 5 this season which is a good start. If he ends up with around 20 PL goals then I shall have to revise my opinion.


He can't trap a ball, can't manage 2 yard passes, doesn't win headers, can't stay onside and doesn't bother running.

His one saving grace is that he has a few goals this season.
But it's catch 22. Does Roy pick this lazy striker or his replacement, Headless Chicken?

 

taylors lovechild Flag 11 Nov 23 6.20pm

Personally I really enjoyed the game bar the result, certainly more than many of our performances of late (including the win last week). Ward switched off for the first goal, Lerma for the second and Hughes for the third, but in terms of our overall play the team looked like they knew how to pass a football again. Eze seemed to instil that confidence in the team that they could play football and if he had a top striker in front of him we win that game. I feel harsh saying that as I thought Eduoard worked really hard (by his standards) but he is waaaaay too slow to make decisions. Two weeks to get Eze and Olise more fitness and match ready before what will be a tough game against a resilient looking Luton.

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 11 Nov 23 6.35pm

Another home game against another ordinary team where the goals and points were gifted and one again showing that under the current ownership, we will not be any better than a middle/lower third premiership team.
Sadly our two classy centre halves cannot compensate for a captain who is past it at this level and a left back who needs to work on his defensive game and positional sense.
Another game where the need for a proper centre forward was glaring.
Roy is clearly a very decent man, but why expose yourself to a barrage of criticism, working for a bloke like Parish who is not prepared to properly improve the starting eleven over his beloved academy ?
In January, Mr Freedman will probably go and get us another goalkeeper.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 11 Nov 23 6.42pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

He can't trap a ball, can't manage 2 yard passes, doesn't win headers, can't stay onside and doesn't bother running.

His one saving grace is that he has a few goals this season.
But it's catch 22. Does Roy pick this lazy striker or his replacement, Headless Chicken?

Completely agree, surely we can play without either of those two in a starting 11 even if it’s Ayew at centre forward? Even with Edouard today there was to many mistakes by individuals which cost us 3 goals. Edouard playing or not wasn’t the biggest problem in my opinion but it would have helped with a CF who can hold onto a ball as well as pass it and have some pace :-(

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 11 Nov 23 6.43pm

We gave away easy goals and didn't make the right choices in the final third. Our build up play, passing and moving were good. We'll win more often than not attacking like that but we'll lose, more often than not, defending like that. Roy won't be happy but there are positives. Olise and Eze look a class above the rest of the players. With them two, we're going to score more but Olise is going to have to do more dirty work with Ward behind him. We're a wing back or so away from a half decent side with everyone fit.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 5 of 11 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Everton match thread