This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by oldyank
I agree with Oddball. Roy is doing the best job with what was given him by the owners. Did you know that Josh Harris an owner in Palace recently purchased the Washington Commander American Football Team for upwards of 3 billion USD. Hard to believe. Why not hit him up for some scratch to purchase better players. When it comes to matters on the pitch and training the buck stops with Roy. One of the reasons Parish is not spending huge amounts of money on players for him is his frequent refusals to play them complaining that they are not what he wanted. He took this attitude with Eze dropping him to the bench saying that “he has to learn how to defend”! It’s all very well trying to blame Parish, Freedman, Harris, Blitzer and Texter but if the manager is not up to scratch then all the money in the world is not going to improve the team. Roy was in charge of Liverpool and the England Football Team and failed miserably. We are now playing at the level of a relegation team (9 points out of 45) and unless he improves his performance he won’t last till the end of the season.
|
|
|
W Originally posted by DenTyler
Just watching a programme on TNT ‘Laura (woods) meets Roy. Blimey forgot how much experience Roy has and some of the players he has managed. Actually makes me understand a bit as to why he won’t play the kids. When you’ve worked with who he has, I guess it’s hard to look at the untested and less talented when he can see the established players in front of you. I’m not saying he is right and I still can’t wait until we have (hopefully) or more forward thinking manager. But it does make you think. Sorry - didn’t see this earlier in the thread - you watched the same programme as me. Did you come to the same conclusions..??
|
|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
W Sorry - didn’t see this earlier in the thread - you watched the same programme as me. Did you come to the same conclusions..?? I came away thinking about the talent he had at his disposal but never really did anything with. He also definitely said he was stubborn and saw the world very black and white. The bit where he said he cleaned up in the early 80’s was interesting and how teams sussed out his style of play… that was 1985.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
I don't want to be labelled as an '' apologist '', I prefer to think of myself as someone that tries, not always successfully, to see the bigger picture. In this instance, given that things went so well at the end of last season was, I think , a big factor in both Parish giving Hodgson the job and him accepting it. Of course Roy didn't have to accept the job. But for you to accuse him of greed and arrogance is typical of your inability to do anything other than critisise him. I know of ' driven ' people that carry on working when they don't need to. It's not for me but I respect their desire even if it doesn't suit me. It's regrettable that Zaha didn't stay or was replaced. That the transfer budget was used the way it was. That the season has been disrupted by injuries. Because those issues are not directly under Hodgson's control. Things may have been very different. And just to re-iterate, I didn't want Roy appointed this season either. So with these points in mind, imo the worst that could happen if Roy used some youngsters or god forbid tries different systems and ways of playing, would be that we are where we are. His actual point would be proven about youngsters and a lack of depth and us lot would have to suck it up and make him correct. He’s not chosen that option though , as though it’s a brain game where you say things so many times and eventually hope people believe you. In politics that appears to work; a 90 odd minute game x about 7 would show you are either right or wrong. The last line of the guardian article. He seems more put out having to explain himself than if he was sacked.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I wonder what this message board will look like after 10pm on Tuesday. ********************************************* I think it’s gone beyond bed wetting now Patrick, we have s***e the mattress both sides!
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I wonder what this message board will look like after 10pm on Tuesday. I’m in my 30’s Pat and worry about what it’s doing to me…
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I’m in my 30’s Pat and worry about what it’s doing to me…
|
|
|
Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews
Let’s face it his style has literally gone by its sell by date. The game has moved on and the younger managers are faster thinking and anticipate what the opposing manager does next. Unfortunately for us Roy is stubborn and not trusting of our younger stars of tomorrow. I wrote this season off long ago literally after that last transfer window, but I thought we would still stay up. For Roy Tuesday will truly see what he is made of and like I said before “this is truly a 6 pointer for us” win it and it finishes Sheffield off, a defeat Christ then we really are in it up to our necks. He needs to get on the front foot straight away and get a goal or two to get the crowd buzzing, defend like he has been doing and expect a right slagging off and fireworks! This is how I see Roy. Never been a fan of his tactics but understand how he has enabled a modicum of success through use of a system. That system is no longer working and even the defensive side that was once so solid, looks fragile. Basically I think his time at the top level is up. An analogy of how Roy must look at old vs young players can be described with classic vs modern cars. The old cars look great on paper and there is a lot of nostalgia about their previous performance back in the day, how easy they are to carry out day to day maintenance on and knowing how they will likely perform, but the simple fact is that compared to modern cars the overall performance is poor. He likes to play three Triumphs, a couple of Morris and an MGB, when we have a BMW, Porsche, Lexus and several other up and coming brands on the bench. Sometimes you just need to accept that modern is better in many ways and needs to be given a chance to prove its reliability. The old cars only run on super unleaded and additives and break down frequently. The analogy can go on and on. Right, I must take the Triumph for a spin this morning.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
This is how I see Roy. Never been a fan of his tactics but understand how he has enabled a modicum of success through use of a system. That system is no longer working and even the defensive side that was once so solid, looks fragile. Basically I think his time at the top level is up. An analogy of how Roy must look at old vs young players can be described with classic vs modern cars. The old cars look great on paper and there is a lot of nostalgia about their previous performance back in the day, how easy they are to carry out day to day maintenance on and knowing how they will likely perform, but the simple fact is that compared to modern cars the overall performance is poor. He likes to play three Triumphs, a couple of Morris and an MGB, when we have a BMW, Porsche, Lexus and several other up and coming brands on the bench. Sometimes you just need to accept that modern is better in many ways and needs to be given a chance to prove its reliability. The old cars only run on super unleaded and additives and break down frequently. The analogy can go on and on. Someone once described me as a 'Reliant Robin' smoking down the slow lane of life ! Apropos the Sheff Utd game,if we do not secure a victory the animus against Mr Hodgson will continue unabated.
|
|
|
I think you’re being a bit kind there’s a few Ladas in that squad
|
|
|
Originally posted by oldyank
Yesterday I commented on Roy not being given the players to avoid relegation and suggested Palace hit up one of their investors, Josh Harris, who the lead investor and purchased the Washington Commanders US football team not for 3 billion USD but upwards of 6 billion USD. Harris also owns the National Basketball team the Philadelphia 76'ers. (I love that name). Why don't Parrish et. al go to Harris for the money. He seems to have lots of it. Simple - for whatever reason Harris seems reluctant to invest in Palace in the same way..!! Why..?? There’s hundreds of posts on here asking the same question - conclusion you would only really know if you were in the Palace boardroom..!! There’s clearly a problem - what that problem is - is open to conjecture - but all very frustrating..!! COYP
|
|
|
If Josh Harris went out and purchased Kylian Mbappe for Palace Hodgson would refuse to play him until he has learned how to defend.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
Simple - for whatever reason Harris seems reluctant to invest in Palace in the same way..!! Why..?? There’s hundreds of posts on here asking the same question - conclusion you would only really know if you were in the Palace boardroom..!! There’s clearly a problem - what that problem is - is open to conjecture - but all very frustrating..!! COYP
Unanimous (Parish, Harris, Textor) agreement on player And with majority owner Textor eager (to say the least) for greater control, we are left with a decision making stasis.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Originally posted by Norbury Old Git
When it comes to matters on the pitch and training the buck stops with Roy. One of the reasons Parish is not spending huge amounts of money on players for him is his frequent refusals to play them complaining that they are not what he wanted. He took this attitude with Eze dropping him to the bench saying that “he has to learn how to defend”! It’s all very well trying to blame Parish, Freedman, Harris, Blitzer and Texter but if the manager is not up to scratch then all the money in the world is not going to improve the team. Roy was in charge of Liverpool and the England Football Team and failed miserably. We are now playing at the level of a relegation team (9 points out of 45) and unless he improves his performance he won’t last till the end of the season. Sorry Roy's record says otherwise, he selections are limited by the quality available. If the youngsters were that good, why are other EPL not chasing for their signatures. sorry but Parish is the problem at this club, his time is up, he is holding us back ably demonstrated by his estranged relationships with the other investors and that will hold us back as no successor to Roy who has a reputation will want to put it on the line under the current circumstances.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Norbury Old Git
When it comes to matters on the pitch and training the buck stops with Roy. One of the reasons Parish is not spending huge amounts of money on players for him is his frequent refusals to play them complaining that they are not what he wanted. He took this attitude with Eze dropping him to the bench saying that “he has to learn how to defend”! It’s all very well trying to blame Parish, Freedman, Harris, Blitzer and Texter but if the manager is not up to scratch then all the money in the world is not going to improve the team. Roy was in charge of Liverpool and the England Football Team and failed miserably. We are now playing at the level of a relegation team (9 points out of 45) and unless he improves his performance he won’t last till the end of the season. I largely agree with your opening sentence, but after that not so much. You do not know anything about Parish's spending - unless of course you have inside info ? I suspect you are confusing your assumptions with fact. Now consider these because they are facts ; Parish re-appointed Hodgson. He also endorsed the £17m spend on Franca. In other words half of the transfer budget gone on an unproven teenager to work under a manager that prefers working with experienced players. Convince me that there is anyone responsible for that situation other than Steve Parish. And harping on about Hodgson's time with Liverpool and England is hardly relevant when it's proven that he is best suited to smaller outfits such as Fulham and West Brom. Oh and Palace.
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.