You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > VAT on school fees
November 21 2026 9.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

VAT on school fees


Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 17 Jun 24 7.34pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

It's absolute fact.

You don't need to pay for private school. You can find a good quality state school and send your kids there. It's a luxury item, a lifestyle choice.

'Luxury – a state of great comfort or elegance, especially when involving great expense.' Bang on the money. No pun intended.

Also 'lefties'... 'probably don't vote labour' etc. then goes on to say Labourites send their kids to private schools. Well the first part is observably wrong, the second is right – A large swathe of the left wing set send their kids to private school. Pretty much the entirety of the middle class Guardian set you so despise either send them there or aspire to do so. I'm afraid you're sorely mistaken if you think only right wingers and Tories send their kids to private schools. Perhaps Eton, Westminster and the elite schools, but the private system is extensive, diverse and more than just about the stereotypes that stem from the big names.

Private healthcare in the UK is a luxury expense, yes. As is private education. Americans don't have a choice. We do.

As already pointed out, I don't think the way the policy is being implemented will make as much difference as Labour are claiming (shock horror). However I think that it will make some difference, and that's better than no difference at all. A lot of private schools should also not be charities, and it's about time someone closed this loophole.

You need to look up 'fact' while you are at it.

But you might be right about some Labour types sending their kids to private schools. After this, they might vote Reform.

Luxury is not defined by having a choice. People have private health care provided or subsidised by their employers. It is a question of availability or being able to afford it. The latter is a big factor in private schooling.

Are you suggesting that luxury is defined by what one can afford and another can't?

In that case, it is all relative.

Fact my arse.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 17 Jun 24 7.56pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

'Less privileged' encompasses anyone who can't afford to pay fees. Are you suggesting that kids from 'working families' don't go to private school? Because they absolutely do, along with the 'less privileged'.

Obviously not in vast numbers - yes quotas - private schools can only afford a certain number of full or part bursary kids each year, otherwise they'd go under. Family straightforward.

This is the point of the bursary system – to encourage households that earn under a certain level with bright kids to apply.

Above that level you need to get scholarships to get discounts. Further, if a child demonstrates scholarship level aptitude at the higher end schools will often make fee concessions to ensure they get them in. Why? Competition.

Also it's helpful to think broader than just intelligence when considering if a kid is a good fit to a private school. There's behavioural, cultural and other areas that need considering. Not everyone is right for it, wealthy, working or otherwise.

Finally... 6k a year? You mean 6k a term. Minimum. Try 20k a year at the cheaper end for the private secondary system.

You cannot defend that line about earning under a certain amount alongside 20 k a year for private education. What % of kids fit this bursary choice and what is the cut off on earnings to qualify? From my pov 1000s of bright kids miss out because mum and dad earn a few quid. The irony is that it isn’t the brightest who get the chance is it ?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 17 Jun 24 8.10pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

You need to look up 'fact' while you are at it.

But you might be right about some Labour types sending their kids to private schools. After this, they might vote Reform.

Luxury is not defined by having a choice. People have private health care provided or subsidised by their employers. It is a question of availability or being able to afford it. The latter is a big factor in private schooling.

Are you suggesting that luxury is defined by what one can afford and another can't?

In that case, it is all relative.

Fact my arse.

It is not a necessity, it is not an essential, it is not a requirement.

Not everyone that has private healthcare gets it via employment - and also, it is classed as a benefit. A nice to have. A little pearl to entice you to join said company. A luxury item.

You can have free healthcare via the NHS, and free education via the state system. To a good level if you’re actually bothered about where you send your kids or if you care about your health.

You do not need private education or healthcare, much like you don’t need all manner of ‘life’s little luxuries’.

I’m not sure how well you know the private system, if at all beyond cliches and stereotypes, but believe me in a lot of cases the word luxury is a perfect description for what you get for the money.

‘Luxury item’
‘A non-essential item that is deemed highly desirable within a culture or society’.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 17 Jun 24 8.21pm

Originally posted by cryrst

You cannot defend that line about earning under a certain amount alongside 20 k a year for private education. What % of kids fit this bursary choice and what is the cut off on earnings to qualify? From my pov 1000s of bright kids miss out because mum and dad earn a few quid. The irony is that it isn’t the brightest who get the chance is it ?

Hang on. Before I get further into this, was your 6k per year figure your estimate of cost post bursary, or a typo that meant to say per term. The way it’s written it comes across as 6k per year no bursary, which obviously is 14k short of reality.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (17 Jun 2024 8.45pm)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 17 Jun 24 8.47pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Hang on. Before I get further into this, was your 6k per year figure your estimate of cost post bursary, or a typo that meant to say per month. The way it’s written it comes across as 6k per year no bursary, which obviously is 14k short of reality.

No I was guessing at the cost per year for a parent to pay at a basic private school.
Clearly I’m way off the mark which proves my point that the cleverest kids don’t get the offer of state help if the family can’t afford it. If your figure of 20 k is the low ball figure then many won’t find an extra 4 k for vat so will be sending their kids to a state school. Or have I misread your figures. I’m all confused

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 17 Jun 24 10.03pm

Originally posted by cryrst

No I was guessing at the cost per year for a parent to pay at a basic private school.
Clearly I’m way off the mark which proves my point that the cleverest kids don’t get the offer of state help if the family can’t afford it. If your figure of 20 k is the low ball figure then many won’t find an extra 4 k for vat so will be sending their kids to a state school. Or have I misread your figures. I’m all confused

OK.

Yes. An entry level private these days is about 20k a year. So probably 23k if the VAT increase comes in, as it's likely most schools will look to absorb some of the cost as it will get competitive fast.

Bursaries are means tested and the size of them (anything up to 100% discount) varies usually depending on both household earnings, family situation (eg. single parent household, finances diverted due to elderly dependents etc) and various other factors. Private schools also offer fee assistance in some cases, again to make sure they are competitive and get the best kids no matter the background.

But ultimately it's for families that are 'less privileged' 'working' or otherwise with bright kids to get access to the private system.

It is up to the parents to apply of course, but if you have one of the 'cleverest kids' and don't earn enough to pay ~1650 a month then providing the child passes the entry exam and you apply they'll be offered a bursary place.

It's designed to work for low income households with bright kids not middle class families who can afford it but would rather not sacrifice the SUV and the February skiing getaway.

Yes there will be edge cases where people will lose out from the VAT increase but IMO if a family can afford 1650 a month they can afford the extra 250 on top p/m to pay for the VAT.

Not sure what you mean about the state subsidising private school entry though. Private schools offer these bursaries themselves to allow the brightest kids from low income families that would otherwise miss out to attend. Not sure state funding of private school places would ever be a thing...

And sure there will be loads of bright kids from low income families that don't get in to private schools – there are only, and can be only a finite number of bursary and fee discounted places otherwise the school would fold. Those places will only go to the brightest as well – it's a competitive system, the school doesn't want dross as it will fall down the table and attract less interest.

But to suggest that the brightest kids from working family backgrounds don't go to private school is inaccurate.

And just because you have money doesn't mean your kid gets in – they have to pass entrance and maintain levels year on year, otherwise they're out.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (17 Jun 2024 10.04pm)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

RubinsCube Flag Wimbledon 17 Jun 24 10.28pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

OK.

Yes. An entry level private these days is about 20k a year. So probably 23k if the VAT increase comes in, as it's likely most schools will look to absorb some of the cost as it will get competitive fast.

Bursaries are means tested and the size of them (anything up to 100% discount) varies usually depending on both household earnings, family situation (eg. single parent household, finances diverted due to elderly dependents etc) and various other factors. Private schools also offer fee assistance in some cases, again to make sure they are competitive and get the best kids no matter the background.

But ultimately it's for families that are 'less privileged' 'working' or otherwise with bright kids to get access to the private system.

It is up to the parents to apply of course, but if you have one of the 'cleverest kids' and don't earn enough to pay ~1650 a month then providing the child passes the entry exam and you apply they'll be offered a bursary place.

It's designed to work for low income households with bright kids not middle class families who can afford it but would rather not sacrifice the SUV and the February skiing getaway.

Yes there will be edge cases where people will lose out from the VAT increase but IMO if a family can afford 1650 a month they can afford the extra 250 on top p/m to pay for the VAT.

Not sure what you mean about the state subsidising private school entry though. Private schools offer these bursaries themselves to allow the brightest kids from low income families that would otherwise miss out to attend. Not sure state funding of private school places would ever be a thing...

And sure there will be loads of bright kids from low income families that don't get in to private schools – there are only, and can be only a finite number of bursary and fee discounted places otherwise the school would fold. Those places will only go to the brightest as well – it's a competitive system, the school doesn't want dross as it will fall down the table and attract less interest.

But to suggest that the brightest kids from working family backgrounds don't go to private school is inaccurate.

And just because you have money doesn't mean your kid gets in – they have to pass entrance and maintain levels year on year, otherwise they're out.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (17 Jun 2024 10.04pm)

I haven't read all the posts in this thread so apologies for any duplication. I am state educated myself. But as a former teacher for around a decade working in two of the sorts of private boarding schools which levy fees in the regions quoted, I wanted to bring some practical context to the financial realities of what is being proposed.

There seems to be an assumption that most private schools which charge comparable fees operate similar business models with similar margins. This is not the case.

Some schools thrive on an international pupil base with recruitment drives. In many cases these institutions operate networks of partner or feeder schools stretching around the world. Others are largely domestic and standalone.

Additionally, many of the schools which this legislation would affect are financially solvent only because they operate on large numbers (headcount; fees) and thin margins (net profit).

Why is all this relevant? Should the legislation come in, many private schools would go the the wall and a higher number than anticipated would fold. They can't simply absorb the cost in many cases because of the wafer thin margins, irrespective of whether demand would suffer from increased prices.

Nor could they simply bump up the prices: doing that would increase the VAT liability. There are then practical considerations like how to grandfather in pupils where the family have already paid for education in advance, bursaries etc.

I would expect a situation where many schools close and there is a resultant influx of pupils into an already stretched state system.

If we want to homogenise schooling and ensure all our young people are state educated, then that is a different argument and a really valid one to have.

But to imagine that materially transformational sums of money can be gained by adding VAT to school fees is fanciful at best.


Edited by RubinsCube (17 Jun 2024 10.28pm)

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 17 Jun 24 10.50pm

What is being ignored in the rich vs poor argument here is the thousands of children in private SEN schools. They are just being sacrificed at the altar of socialist dogma

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Dubai Eagle Flag 18 Jun 24 6.39am

My Kids were born & raised in the UAE, so basically I paid for their education (Nursery / primary / secondary) for the primary & secondary parts my employer kicked in a contribution towards the cost (but it was still a bucket load of money)

When my 2 kids reached around 13 / 14 we took the decision to relocate them back to the UK with my wife & I followed on a year or 2 later.

Part of the reason for getting them back to the UK at that age was that if they attended University (despite them holding UK passports) if they had not physically been back in the UK for 3 years they would have been charged as international students & international students at Universities pay double the rate of local students.

Getting a place in a UK Secondary school was also a bit tricky - our choices were- Turn up at Tabener house in Croydon in the August & wait to be allocated a place in a Croydon school of the councils choosing with no guarantee that both kids would go to the same school, or find a school that handles their own admission policy & procedure, we did after loads of overseas phone calls manage to find a school ourselves.

Maybe Rubins knows whether international students pay increased rates at fee paying secondary schools ?

Originally posted by RubinsCube


Some schools thrive on an international pupil base with recruitment drives. In many cases these institutions operate networks of partner or feeder schools stretching around the world. Others are largely domestic and standalone.

Edited by RubinsCube (17 Jun 2024 10.28pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 Jun 24 7.37am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

It is not a necessity, it is not an essential, it is not a requirement.

Not everyone that has private healthcare gets it via employment - and also, it is classed as a benefit. A nice to have. A little pearl to entice you to join said company. A luxury item.

You can have free healthcare via the NHS, and free education via the state system. To a good level if you’re actually bothered about where you send your kids or if you care about your health.

You do not need private education or healthcare, much like you don’t need all manner of ‘life’s little luxuries’.

I’m not sure how well you know the private system, if at all beyond cliches and stereotypes, but believe me in a lot of cases the word luxury is a perfect description for what you get for the money.

‘Luxury item’
‘A non-essential item that is deemed highly desirable within a culture or society’.

So by that definition, only food and water are not luxuries.

Are you sure?

Your idea of luxury is not someone else's.

Ultimately, very little is necessary. A TV is not necessary.
Your definition is too broad.

The whole idea of taxing education is backward.
The EU won't allow it. Remember the EU? Your lot wanted to stay in it.
Now you suddenly like the idea of retrograde, ideologically driven social engineering.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 18 Jun 24 8.39am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

My Kids were born & raised in the UAE, so basically I paid for their education (Nursery / primary / secondary) for the primary & secondary parts my employer kicked in a contribution towards the cost (but it was still a bucket load of money)

When my 2 kids reached around 13 / 14 we took the decision to relocate them back to the UK with my wife & I followed on a year or 2 later.

Part of the reason for getting them back to the UK at that age was that if they attended University (despite them holding UK passports) if they had not physically been back in the UK for 3 years they would have been charged as international students & international students at Universities pay double the rate of local students.

Getting a place in a UK Secondary school was also a bit tricky - our choices were- Turn up at Tabener house in Croydon in the August & wait to be allocated a place in a Croydon school of the councils choosing with no guarantee that both kids would go to the same school, or find a school that handles their own admission policy & procedure, we did after loads of overseas phone calls manage to find a school ourselves.

Maybe Rubins knows whether international students pay increased rates at fee paying secondary schools ?

That is why I get so angry with the Scots getting free uni and giving cheaper to EU students than non Scottish British funded by the UK taxpayer

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 18 Jun 24 8.40am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Because we don’t calculate tax bills based on individual usage of services - why should that uniquely be the case when it comes to education?

I didn't say it should. I was just pointing out that this "subsidising" currently works in both directions.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 18 Jun 24 9.59am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

So by that definition, only food and water are not luxuries.

Are you sure?

Your idea of luxury is not someone else's.

Ultimately, very little is necessary. A TV is not necessary.
Your definition is too broad.

The whole idea of taxing education is backward.
The EU won't allow it. Remember the EU? Your lot wanted to stay in it.
Now you suddenly like the idea of retrograde, ideologically driven social engineering.

'Your idea' – Actual definition, the shoe fits, it's not too broad. Private education in this country is not a necessity. It is a luxury.

Taxing education... it's adding VAT onto a service provided by profitable, private businesses (not charities) that should have been added decades ago.

So dramatic

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 18 Jun 24 10.04am

Originally posted by HKOwen

What is being ignored in the rich vs poor argument here is the thousands of children in private SEN schools. They are just being sacrificed at the altar of socialist dogma

This is an example of why the policy hasn't been properly though through. Although it does open up the system for abuse, SEN kids/schools should be exempt.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 18 Jun 24 10.37am

Originally posted by RubinsCube

I haven't read all the posts in this thread so apologies for any duplication. I am state educated myself. But as a former teacher for around a decade working in two of the sorts of private boarding schools which levy fees in the regions quoted, I wanted to bring some practical context to the financial realities of what is being proposed.

There seems to be an assumption that most private schools which charge comparable fees operate similar business models with similar margins. This is not the case.

Some schools thrive on an international pupil base with recruitment drives. In many cases these institutions operate networks of partner or feeder schools stretching around the world. Others are largely domestic and standalone.

Additionally, many of the schools which this legislation would affect are financially solvent only because they operate on large numbers (headcount; fees) and thin margins (net profit).

Why is all this relevant? Should the legislation come in, many private schools would go the the wall and a higher number than anticipated would fold. They can't simply absorb the cost in many cases because of the wafer thin margins, irrespective of whether demand would suffer from increased prices.

Nor could they simply bump up the prices: doing that would increase the VAT liability. There are then practical considerations like how to grandfather in pupils where the family have already paid for education in advance, bursaries etc.

I would expect a situation where many schools close and there is a resultant influx of pupils into an already stretched state system.

If we want to homogenise schooling and ensure all our young people are state educated, then that is a different argument and a really valid one to have.

But to imagine that materially transformational sums of money can be gained by adding VAT to school fees is fanciful at best.


Edited by RubinsCube (17 Jun 2024 10.28pm)

As I've said, I think it's high time private schools charity status was put under the microscope and charging VAT is something that probably should have come in decades ago.

It will not create transformational sums of money, that's for sure. But I doubt this will force a significant majority of private schools to close. It will certainly impact some, though.

Some costs can be absorbed due to the ability to claim back expenses elsewhere. It will get competitive and I'll be surprised if the govt don't include a couple of taxback related sweeteners as part of the change.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

dreamwaverider Flag London 18 Jun 24 10.44am

One thing is for sure, whatever the detail, the private school system is in for a hell of a kicking if Labour get in.

 

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 18 Jun 24 11.02am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

As I've said, I think it's high time private schools charity status was put under the microscope and charging VAT is something that probably should have come in decades ago.

It will not create transformational sums of money, that's for sure. But I doubt this will force a significant majority of private schools to close. It will certainly impact some, though.

Some costs can be absorbed due to the ability to claim back expenses elsewhere. It will get competitive and I'll be surprised if the govt don't include a couple of taxback related sweeteners as part of the change.

Sorry to be a bit thick on this topic but when we talk about private schools are we referring to the likes of Eton etc. or does the potential VAT charging also apply to private religious orientated schools. Will they get an exemption?

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 18 Jun 24 11.06am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

As I've said, I think it's high time private schools charity status was put under the microscope and charging VAT is something that probably should have come in decades ago.

It will not create transformational sums of money, that's for sure. But I doubt this will force a significant majority of private schools to close. It will certainly impact some, though.

Some costs can be absorbed due to the ability to claim back expenses elsewhere. It will get competitive and I'll be surprised if the govt don't include a couple of taxback related sweeteners as part of the change.

I am in agreement with this however it should be part of a wider review. There are far too many organizations which are abusing the charitable system, we need a complete review and a tightening of the rules.

 


One more point

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 Jun 24 11.09am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

'Your idea' – Actual definition, the shoe fits, it's not too broad. Private education in this country is not a necessity. It is a luxury.

Taxing education... it's adding VAT onto a service provided by profitable, private businesses (not charities) that should have been added decades ago.

So dramatic

Education is not a gold watch or a hot tub.

People are paying for the quality of education. Luxury is the wrong definition.

What ever you call it, taxing education is retrograde. It is anti productive, anti wealth, anti aspirational, anti achievement.

It is typical Labour.

Next they will after your pensions and inheritance. All the things that people work for.

Vote Reform.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 18 Jun 24 11.55am

Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines

Sorry to be a bit thick on this topic but when we talk about private schools are we referring to the likes of Eton etc. or does the potential VAT charging also apply to private religious orientated schools. Will they get an exemption?

It applies to many schools that offer special needs education in areas where it is not available, this may force parents to move to get the SEN services their children need, who could support this or is it acceptable level of collateral damage.

The more famous public schools like Eton and Harrow are the exception and will not lose any students as the parents are wealthy and often not in the UK.

Could you name say twenty private primary or secondary schools?

The left is obsessed with education being a class struggle and always wheel out Eton and Harrow.

Remember Baroness Clean slate who gave Corbyn's Labour a big tick in the anti semitism box in return for a peerage, She then got all bitter cos Eton wouldn't take her son and he had to slum it at Dulwich College.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > VAT on school fees