cpfc-rjd Beckenham and the BBS 14 Jan 05 3.06pm |
|
|
If he actually received any money from the civil list you might have an argument... but he doesn't.
He and his family live on the money that ordinary people pay them in their taxes. He is a public figure by virtue of the fact that he wants all of the perks of royalty, he has to accept the downside as well as the upside of public life.
"Her very Lowness with her head in a sling I'm truly sorry but it sounds like a wonderful thing"
NEITHER LEFT OR RIGHT BUT OUT IN FRONT
[Link]
|
kav The Helicopter View 14 Jan 05 3.07pm |
|
|
Where would you rather live? Quote cpfc-rjd at 14 Jan 2005 2:36pm
Quote Petealiator at 14 Jan 2005 2:29pm
Quote cpfc-rjd at 14 Jan 2005 1:17pm
I do not have to leave this country just because I don't like the way it is organised, governed and run. I want to stay in this country but turn it into a republic, as is my right.
Why bother? You obviously feel the place is a screw-up and totaly beneath you!
I'm sure that there is a lot of things that you would like to see change in this country. Or do you think that it's perfect?
Everytime I get high I lay my head on my baby's breasts
|
Petealiator 1066 Country! 14 Jan 05 3.09pm |
|
Quote cpfc-rjd at 14 Jan 2005 3:06pm
he has to accept the downside as well as the upside of public life.
I'm sure he does!
My Rocksteady band... [Link] [Link] IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!
|
cpfc-rjd Beckenham and the BBS 14 Jan 05 3.10pm |
|
|
Quote redacted There are countless systems of governance throughout the world that work equally as well that do not rely on the idea that someone is born to be the head of state, no matter how useless, talentless or worthless. Surely the idea that should be promoted is that of a meritocracy? The idea of a monarchy is completely out of date in the 21st century.
"Her very Lowness with her head in a sling I'm truly sorry but it sounds like a wonderful thing"
NEITHER LEFT OR RIGHT BUT OUT IN FRONT
[Link]
|
tome Inner Tantalus Time. 14 Jan 05 3.14pm |
|
Quote Petealiator at 14 Jan 2005 3:02pm
Quote cpfc-rjd at 14 Jan 2005 2:55pm
Scrapping the monarchy isn't the answer to all our problems but it is a start.
Bollocks is it! How is the monarchy a problem? Politicians, lawyers and the hordes of scumbags they protect are the problem!
The monarchy is adored by millions of people in Britain.
But what is the point of the monarchy? Their role is now purely ceremonial, and to bring in the tourists. Yes, they have a place in the constitution, but they aren't going to use it unless they lose their collective or individual marbles. Just becuase we've lived in a monarchy for hundreds of years doesn't mean we should continue.
A one and a two...
|
Legal Eagle A town where fog lights shine, eve... 14 Jan 05 3.17pm |
|
Quote yellabubs at 14 Jan 2005 2:28pm
Quote Legal Eagle at 14 Jan 2005 2:04pm
Quote yellabubs at 14 Jan 2005 10:00am
Quote Legal Eagle at 14 Jan 2005 1:59am
Regardless of the "fun" in dressing up as a Nazi (please do enlighten me), Harry was a complete t*** to have made such a choice. I personally think he's out there to wind up as many people as he can, which makes me think he's even more of a s***.
How old are you? Sorry, just noticed you're a leagal student. My condolences, it must be difficult being born with a mental age of 54.
Tell us, if you were a prince, what fun rib-tickling costume would you have worn?
Sorry, didn't realise I'd made a personal dig at you?
I'm not his advisor, but if he insists on a little satire, why not go as a royal butler. It fits the colonials theme just as well as a Nazi.
So it's OK for you to say someone's a "tw*t" and a "sh*t" because of his choice of fancy dress costume but it's an unwarranted dig for me to imply that you views are that of someone who is old before their time?
I like the butler costume idea though. He could have eaten kangaroo testicles for extra comic effect!
If he wants to come and call me that, let him, I'm sure he can fight his own battles . But I will apologise for my choice of language then, I was under a little stress last night.
Back on topic, I'm all for the monarchy, just not a fan of Harry.
It's just a matter of crossing the i's and dotting the t's
|
tome Inner Tantalus Time. 14 Jan 05 3.18pm |
|
|
Quote redacted And what's the good of that?We don't need someone to replace the monarchy, Blair is the head of state in practice because he is elected to that position, why would we need anything else?
A one and a two...
|
Petealiator 1066 Country! 14 Jan 05 3.18pm |
|
Quote cpfc-rjd at 14 Jan 2005 3:10pm
There are countless systems of governance throughout the world that work equally as well that do not rely on the idea that someone is born to be the head of state, no matter how useless, talentless or worthless. Surely the idea that should be promoted is that of a meritocracy?
The idea of a monarchy is completely out of date in the 21st century.
Where are these systems then? Name them.
So you think only the intellectual elite should be at the top of the pile then do you? You don't consider bravery, loyalty, decency of any merit at all? You think us thickies should know our limits in life and know our place then do ya? f***ing meritocracy my arse, what a complete load of pseudo-intellectual snobby bollocks!
It's the so-called great thinkers of the world that have caused the most f***ing problems throughout history!
Edited by Petealiator (14 Jan 2005 3:19pm)
My Rocksteady band... [Link] [Link] IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!
|
tome Inner Tantalus Time. 14 Jan 05 3.22pm |
|
Quote Petealiator at 14 Jan 2005 3:18pm
So you think only the intellectual elite should be at the top of the pile then do you? You don't consider bravery, loyalty, decency of any merit at all? You think us thickies should know our limits in life and know our place then do ya? f***ing meritocracy my arse, what a complete load of pseudo-intellectual snobby bollocks!
It's the so-called great thinkers of the world that have caused the most f***ing problems throughout history!
Edited by Petealiator (14 Jan 2005 3:19pm)
And you think these qualities are inherited? That someone who is nice but dumb should be in charge of our country?
A one and a two...
|
Petealiator 1066 Country! 14 Jan 05 3.22pm |
|
Quote tome at 14 Jan 2005 3:14pm
But what is the point of the monarchy? Their role is now purely ceremonial, and to bring in the tourists. Yes, they have a place in the constitution, but they aren't going to use it unless they lose their collective or individual marbles. Just becuase we've lived in a monarchy for hundreds of years doesn't mean we should continue.
What's the point of you? What's the point of Warwick Castle? What's the point of anything? What's YOUR point?
My Rocksteady band... [Link] [Link] IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!
|
tome Inner Tantalus Time. 14 Jan 05 3.23pm |
|
|
Quote redacted No it doesn't - that is sorted by the parlaimentarey system, not by the monarchy.
A one and a two...
|
Petealiator 1066 Country! 14 Jan 05 3.25pm |
|
Quote tome at 14 Jan 2005 3:22pm
And you think these qualities are inherited? That someone who is nice but dumb should be in charge of our country?
1) I wasn't talking about the royal family, I was talking about this 'meritocracy' bollocks and the snooty attitude that only intellectuals are of any merit!
2) The monarchy don't run our country!
My Rocksteady band... [Link] [Link] IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!
|
yellabubs Sheffield 14 Jan 05 3.26pm |
|
Quote cpfc-rjd at 14 Jan 2005 3:06pm
If he actually received any money from the civil list you might have an argument... but he doesn't.
He and his family live on the money that ordinary people pay them in their taxes. He is a public figure by virtue of the fact that he wants all of the perks of royalty, he has to accept the downside as well as the upside of public life.
Some members of his family receive money from the civil list but he doesn't. Besides the money they receive from the civil list is only a fraction of their total income - you may be surprised to know they are actually indepenently wealthy. Therefore any claim for Harry's pocket money to be stopped for poor fancy dress selection (on the grounds it comes from the public purse) may be unfair.
I'm not a bit fan of the royals either but I still don't understand why you begrudge paying them for what you yourself called "a job for life, 24 hours a day"?
|
tome Inner Tantalus Time. 14 Jan 05 3.31pm |
|
Quote Petealiator at 14 Jan 2005 3:25pm
Quote tome at 14 Jan 2005 3:22pm
And you think these qualities are inherited? That someone who is nice but dumb should be in charge of our country?
1) I wasn't talking about the royal family, I was talking about this 'meritocracy' bollocks and the snooty attitude that only intellectuals are of any merit!
2) The monarchy don't run our country!
Point 2 is invalidated if we say that my comments can be attributed to both the Royal Family and the government - are you suggesting therefore that loyal, decent people should be in charge of the country regardless of their intellect?
A one and a two...
|
cpfc-rjd Beckenham and the BBS 14 Jan 05 3.31pm |
|
Quote Petealiator at 14 Jan 2005 3:18pm
Quote cpfc-rjd at 14 Jan 2005 3:10pm
There are countless systems of governance throughout the world that work equally as well that do not rely on the idea that someone is born to be the head of state, no matter how useless, talentless or worthless. Surely the idea that should be promoted is that of a meritocracy?
The idea of a monarchy is completely out of date in the 21st century.
Where are these systems then? Name them.
So you think only the intellectual elite should be at the top of the pile then do you? You don't consider bravery, loyalty, decency of any merit at all? You think us thickies should know our limits in life and know our place then do ya? f***ing meritocracy my arse, what a complete load of pseudo-intellectual snobby bollocks!
It's the so-called great thinkers of the world that have caused the most f***ing problems throughout history!
Edited by Petealiator (14 Jan 2005 3:19pm)
As someone who is arguing for the existence of the monarchy, it is a bit much to call my idea of a meritocracy 'snobby.' I simply think that people should be appointed to positions on merit, not because of who their mummy or daddy was. The Royals are the ones who want to keep the whole idea of class and privilege going, that's snobby.
"Her very Lowness with her head in a sling I'm truly sorry but it sounds like a wonderful thing"
NEITHER LEFT OR RIGHT BUT OUT IN FRONT
[Link]
|