You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Due to no game on Saturday...
November 19 2026 5.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Due to no game on Saturday...


Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Bexter Flag By the Sea 18 Feb 03 12.38pm

The civilians who are killed by the US and her allies every day? and are about to be bombed to smithereens? i'm sure they are!

 

Eddie_Hitler Flag Sussex 18 Feb 03 12.56pm

Lets be honest, the civilian casulties caused by US and her allies are going to be minimal, compared to the hundreds of thousands that have already perished under Saddam's leadership, and the hundreds of thousends more that will perish all the time he is in power.

I cannot understand why people are supporting a man that has killed members of his own family, because he felt they were destroying his image. A man who kidknapped the leader of another country, set his beard alight and hammered nails into his head until he died.

 

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 18 Feb 03 12.57pm

Quote saxoneagle at 18 Feb 2003 11:21am

For every person (of the estimated 1m that were there) there were 58 who either:

a - could not be bothered
b - felt differently

Maybe we should have a pro-war march and see who turns up for that

All this crap on TV about it being *obvious* that most of the country don't want a war, how do they know? I think any kind of referendum on this would produce a VERY close result.

It would be fantastic if we had a referendum on it --- actually being asked about it would be a stupendous step on the road to real freedom and democracy. Which is exactly why it would never ever happen, not in a million years mate.

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 18 Feb 03 1.45pm

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 18 Feb 2003 12:57pm

It would be fantastic if we had a referendum on it --- actually being asked about it would be a stupendous step on the road to real freedom and democracy. Which is exactly why it would never ever happen, not in a million years mate.

But how could there ever be a fair referendum on this? The government can't disclose it's intelligence on Iraq, we can't therefore make an informed decision.

At the end of the day a democracy only gives you the power to elect a government, from then on you have to trust them to get on with the job. If we had a referendum on every important decision nothing would ever get done and the tabloids would be running the country. Not to mention the cost and logistics of organising it all.

 

Glad All Over Flag Bath 18 Feb 03 2.04pm

Quote Meerkat 2 at 18 Feb 2003 1:45pm
... and the tabloids would be running the country.

They do already don't they? After all, it's them who decide who gets elected.


Edited by Glad All Over (18 Feb 2003 2:05pm)

 


Hard work pays off in the future, laziness pays off now.

Bexter Flag By the Sea 18 Feb 03 2.14pm

eddie - it was an anti war march - not a pro saddam march. if we bombed every country we have sold arms too to kill one lot of people, then they later on use them on other people which we then disagree on then where would it end? and thats if you believe this war is going to be on moral grounds and nothing to do with oil or anything....
as for a referendum, its true we give a mandate to a government when we elect them to run our country, but when it comes to a war that no one wants which will cost lives - our troops and iraqi citizens, when there is no evidence of any threat - then democracy has failed - it veers on dictatorship when one man makes such a decision with no backing from his people..

 

Eddie_Hitler Flag Sussex 18 Feb 03 2.42pm

Bexter - You seem more than happy to help the victims of people like Saddam when they turn up on our doorstep seeking asylum. Yet when it comes to helping them on there own turf, where they are powerless to do anything, you turn a blind eye.

 

Bexter Flag By the Sea 18 Feb 03 2.57pm

maybe i don't think bombing their homes is the answer? do you think we should bomb every country who has an unsavoury leader just out of interest?

Edited by Bexter (18 Feb 2003 2:57pm)

 

matt_the_eagle Flag Tulse Thrill 18 Feb 03 3.03pm

Quote Bexter at 18 Feb 2003 2:57pm

maybe i don't think bombing their homes is the answer? do you think we should bomb every country who has an unsavoury leader just out of interest?

Edited by Bexter (18 Feb 2003 2:57pm)

Yes, starting with America.

(joke)


 


I think Keith Murray said it best when he rapped
"If you aint fly you cant play with my yo-yo".

I'm sure you'll agree.

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 18 Feb 03 3.08pm

Quote Bexter at 18 Feb 2003 2:14pm

as for a referendum, its true we give a mandate to a government when we elect them to run our country, but when it comes to a war that no one wants which will cost lives - our troops and iraqi citizens, when there is no evidence of any threat - then democracy has failed - it veers on dictatorship when one man makes such a decision with no backing from his people..


No evidence that YOU have seen.

If we were living under a dictatorship you would not have had the freedom to march on Saturday. It's great that we do live under a system where people are free to express their opinions openly, and I believe that the government ARE listening, after all Tony Blair's political future hangs on what he does next. But at the end of the day leadership is about making decisions based on all the evidence in front of you and clearly he (and Ian Duncan Smith) believe that there is a strong case for military action.

 

Bexter Flag By the Sea 18 Feb 03 3.16pm

How come only they've got this evidence then? what about France and Germany? and of course I know I am lucky I could march - still don't understand what that has to do with bombing another country that doesn't allow its citizens too - we'd be bombing the hell out of alot of countries! and while we are on the lack of informing us about what is going on - how about all these security threats? if they can see a threat then i would like to see it too as i work in central london thanks! I mean, they must have evidence else they wouldn't be deploying tanks at heathrow would they? I understand that they have to be careful with intelligence etc but by saying there is no specific threat they are either lying or deploying tanks for no good reason, or to make a stronger case for war.... who knows? a bit of honesty wouldn't go a miss at this stage.

 

Eddie_Hitler Flag Sussex 18 Feb 03 3.21pm

Quote Bexter at 18 Feb 2003 2:57pm

maybe i don't think bombing their homes is the answer? do you think we should bomb every country who has an unsavoury leader just out of interest?

Edited by Bexter (18 Feb 2003 2:57pm)

Of course not that would be insane.

Out of interest do you think Saddam should be aloud to carry on in the manor he does? If not what would you do to solve the problem? I don't think weapons inspectors is really working. Do you?

He clearly poses a serious threat to not only his own people but his neighbouring countries aswell.

 

Bexter Flag By the Sea 18 Feb 03 3.24pm

what is he doing that makes him so much worse than say, sharron? he clearly poses a serious threat to whom?

 

Bexter Flag By the Sea 18 Feb 03 3.26pm

and how can the weapons inspectors do their job when they are not being given the time they need and want? they have produced absolutely no evidence of any 'threat' but i am all for them having more time to find out before we go wading in.

 

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 18 Feb 03 3.32pm

I'm glad to see it's finally being admitted on here that there is no credible evidence to back up the US claims... which makes me wonder why so many of you are convinced war is the right move?

Is there some evidence you've seen that I haven't?

Or is it just that you don't really understand just how horrific war is, and have bought into the sanitised version presented to us by the US?

Just curious.

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 18 Feb 03 4.09pm

Surely if MI5 and MI6 publish all their intelligence it kind of stops being intelligence doesn't it? I'm sure Saddam would welcome that, not sure about those working under cover in the region though.

Yes war is a nasty business, so is being taken from your home and tortured, so is being attacked with mustard gas, so is seeing your kids pistol whipped, I'm told Anthrax can give you a nasty cough too.

As for Israel, the USA needs to get it's head out of it's arse, stop funding those f***ers and treat them with the condemnation they deserve.

 

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 18 Feb 03 4.18pm

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 18 Feb 2003 3:32pm

Is there some evidence you've seen that I haven't?

Just curious.


No, I've seen the same intelligence that you have, aerial footage, intercepted radio communication, lists of unacounted for nerve agents and biological contaminents. The sort of stuff you can make public without compromising your field agents and informants.

 

Bexter Flag By the Sea 18 Feb 03 4.54pm

in your absolutely honest opinion - do you think we are waging this war because we care about the treatment of the iraqis by saddam? why dont we sort out other nasty regimes - because there is no ££ gain - like how late did we finally go into yugoslavia? way too late to save millions. the un evidence is still not evidence enough for a bloody war. no way. i'm with the cheese and sausage eaters on that one - and nelson mandela, and even the darn pope i hate to say!

 

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 18 Feb 03 5.11pm

Indeed. I wonder if we would have stood aside and done nothing if there was oil in Rwanda, for example.

With the USA's history of meddling in other countries, causing military coups and civil wars, bombing civilian targets and so forth, don't you think we're entitled to be sceptical?

Edited by halfmanhalfslug (18 Feb 2003 5:15pm)

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 18 Feb 03 5.18pm

Bexter, no I don't think it is the Iraqi people's suffering which is the main reason for the UN to go after Saddam. Neither do I think it is purely oil rights. Yet the richest oil producing country in the world has one of the highest infant mortality rates, mostly through treatable diseases and malnutrition. And no that's not because of that sanctions, it's down to Saddam's way of dealing with the sanctions.

The key reason for this 'war' is that Saddam is developing VX, anthrax, ricin, saran etc and sooner or later he WILL sell these substances to the highest bidder, and sooner or later they WILL be used by terrorists somewhere in the world, possibly here. This, to my mind, sets Iraq apart from North Korea, Syria, Israel, Saudi etc.

So if Saddam isn't developing these agents then why is he openly obstructing UN weapons inspectors? Why are his goons following them around in radio cars? Why won't he say what happened to the missing Anthrax and VX gas from a decade ago? Why does he need mobile laboratories? Why won't he let his scientists be openly questioned by the inspectors?

How long do you give him to put his house in order? a month? two? 5 years? 10 years?

Too many questions left unanswered.

Edited by Meerkat 2 (18 Feb 2003 5:29pm)

 

Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Due to no game on Saturday...