johnfirewall 19 Aug 15 1.53pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Aug 2015 10.20pm
Quote legaleagle at 18 Aug 2015 10.07pm
And now loads of Brits want to live in multi-cultural Australia...but unlike the old days loads can't go ..because they have points-based immigration rules that no longer are biased towards those from one particular background (Brits).It seems you are opposed to a society which has pretty strong immigration rules but practices multi culturalism overwhelmingly successfully for those who live there.
Edited by legaleagle (18 Aug 2015 10.11pm)
I'm don't believe in multiculturalism. I was forced to live within it growing up and I exactly what I'm talking about.
If others are happy with that lifestyle then I'm happy for them. Though I'm not sure I buy your rosy picture about Australia....But I haven't researched it.
I believe in a points based system but rather than encouraging an acceptance of multiple cultures I'm far more a supporter of integration into a host culture.
The left have lost this argument in Britain....The whole reasons that UKIP started up is because of people with views like yourself Legal.
I've no idea when the word entered common parlance but I associate 'multiculturalism' more with the Blair era than any other period in our history where for example we've accepted numbers of much needed overseas workers.
It's got fcuk all to do with scoring points and integrating as a valuable forgeign asset. That's what Australia are practising and that's why they all get along. I'm confused as to how anyone on the left would cite this as an example of a multicultural utopia while endorsing a less discriminate model for the UK.
Edited by johnfirewall (19 Aug 2015 1.55pm)
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 19 Aug 15 2.25pm |
|
Quote johnfirewall at 19 Aug 2015 1.53pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Aug 2015 10.20pm
Quote legaleagle at 18 Aug 2015 10.07pm
And now loads of Brits want to live in multi-cultural Australia...but unlike the old days loads can't go ..because they have points-based immigration rules that no longer are biased towards those from one particular background (Brits).It seems you are opposed to a society which has pretty strong immigration rules but practices multi culturalism overwhelmingly successfully for those who live there.
Edited by legaleagle (18 Aug 2015 10.11pm)
I'm don't believe in multiculturalism. I was forced to live within it growing up and I exactly what I'm talking about.
If others are happy with that lifestyle then I'm happy for them. Though I'm not sure I buy your rosy picture about Australia....But I haven't researched it.
I believe in a points based system but rather than encouraging an acceptance of multiple cultures I'm far more a supporter of integration into a host culture.
The left have lost this argument in Britain....The whole reasons that UKIP started up is because of people with views like yourself Legal.
I've no idea when the word entered common parlance but I associate 'multiculturalism' more with the Blair era than any other period in our history where for example we've accepted numbers of much needed overseas workers.
It's got fcuk all to do with scoring points and integrating as a valuable forgeign asset. That's what Australia are practising and that's why they all get along. I'm confused as to how anyone on the left would cite this as an example of a multicultural utopia while endorsing a less discriminate model for the UK.
Edited by johnfirewall (19 Aug 2015 1.55pm)
I think you're more or less right, that multiculturalism entered the general lexicon with Blairites, but its been in use since the 60s in a less 'driven' manner. Its certainly not a new thing either, just the annoying one.
In theory it doesn't apply just to overseas workers, but to pre-existing and adopted cultures as well - it would be eronous to presume that cultural diversity in the UK is solely along ethnic lines of influence, that tends to suggest that cultural diversity in the UK is a product of migration, which isn't true (Cultural diversity in the UK is diverse within ethnicities, as between them).
On reading up a bit, I think the problem of multiculturalism, is a lack of interculturalist philosophy 
Edited by jamiemartin721 (19 Aug 2015 2.28pm)
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
nickgusset Shizzlehurst 19 Aug 15 2.34pm |
|
|
Well I'm on a ferry to Calais now. Some posters will be pleased to know that plenty of pesky foreigners have left the country.
|
TheJudge 19 Aug 15 4.43pm |
|
Quote nickgusset at 19 Aug 2015 2.34pm
Well I'm on a ferry to Calais now. Some posters will be pleased to know that plenty of pesky foreigners have left the country.
I hope the border police will be checking your boot on the way back.
|
Stirlingsays 19 Aug 15 5.39pm |
|
Quote TheJudge at 19 Aug 2015 4.43pm
Quote nickgusset at 19 Aug 2015 2.34pm
Well I'm on a ferry to Calais now. Some posters will be pleased to know that plenty of pesky foreigners have left the country.
I hope the border police will be checking your boot on the way back.

'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
Stirlingsays 19 Aug 15 5.48pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Aug 2015 2.25pm
Cultural diversity in the UK is diverse within ethnicities, as between them.
Edited by jamiemartin721 (19 Aug 2015 2.28pm)
Sorry Jamie but that is fundamentally inaccurate.
A massive divide is between alligence to a nationality and historical background.
This is a bit different to the fact that your neighour may be a bit of a prick. If this country had to conscript again for a war your neighbour is getting called up like you are (Mmmmm). Economic migrants aren't.
I know that state alligence isn't big for you but it is a major deal for many others......Including those from external cultural communities themselves.
Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Aug 2015 5.49pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|
johnfirewall 19 Aug 15 10.25pm |
|
|
Another silly posh tart
[Link]
The article acknowledges that some of them are looking to work but it also mentions that they don't like France, failing to add any detail.
She also goes on to argue on Facebook with a Brit (I spotted this on there via a friend who I imagine was sharing to highlight her efforts) who points out that he'd found lots of opportunities in France and that it was safe place for migrants again without any detailed objection.
Edited by johnfirewall (19 Aug 2015 10.27pm)
|
legaleagle 19 Aug 15 10.32pm |
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 19 Aug 2015 5.48pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Aug 2015 2.25pm
Cultural diversity in the UK is diverse within ethnicities, as between them.
Edited by jamiemartin721 (19 Aug 2015 2.28pm)
Sorry Jamie but that is fundamentally inaccurate.
A massive divide is between alligence to a nationality and historical background.
This is a bit different to the fact that your neighour may be a bit of a prick. If this country had to conscript again for a war your neighbour is getting called up like you are (Mmmmm). Economic migrants aren't.
I know that state alligence isn't big for you but it is a major deal for many others......Including those from external cultural communities themselves.
Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Aug 2015 5.49pm)
Not sure you understood his point.I think his point (he'll no doubt correct me if I'm wrong) was simply that there can be and are significant cultural differences within an wider "ethnic group" in the UK.Take "former Yugoslavs";certainly the case there.Take WASPS in the UK.Significant cultural differences between say the "upper classes" and "working class culture".Same might apply say to people who came here from different parts of the Carribbean.
Edited by legaleagle (19 Aug 2015 10.32pm)
|
legaleagle 19 Aug 15 11.02pm |
|
Quote leggedstruggle at 19 Aug 2015 9.56am
Quote legaleagle at 19 Aug 2015 9.34am
Quote leggedstruggle at 19 Aug 2015 8.00am
Quote legaleagle at 18 Aug 2015 7.59pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 18 Aug 2015 7.49pm
Quote leggedstruggle at 18 Aug 2015 5.50pm
Australia.. is now experiencing the usual problems of mass immigration of people of different race, religion, language and culture.
Nail on head.....I was just too lazy and busy today to go through the counter argument.
Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Aug 2015 7.49pm)
Interesting Stirling.Why is it "nail on head" to suggest Australia has not generally been a stunning example of successful migration of people from all over the world,under a policy of multiculturalism,ie 2006 census (top nine foreign born groups other than those born in UK or New Zealand),206,000 born in China,199,000 born in Italy,159,000 Vietnam, 147,000 India,120,000 Philippines,109,000 Greece,106,00 Germany.
Edited by legaleagle (18 Aug 2015 8.00pm)
"stunning example of successful migration" - struth mate: [Link]
Yes,it is indeed most unfortunate that any country should contain amongst its inhabitants such people as those who support "Reclaim" in Australia.See the link.
[Link]
But you just told us it was a stunning example of a multi-cultural paradise.
I said multi culturalism has generally been very successful and beneficial to the country in a way that might be described as stunning.
Alas,like any country,that does not preclude it having some jerks living there.
|
legaleagle 19 Aug 15 11.11pm |
|
Quote Kermit8 at 19 Aug 2015 8.14am
Quote Stirlingsays at 19 Aug 2015 8.04am
Legal thinks that if you're not fond of multiculturalism that it's doubtful that you should be in favour of curry.
One of the more amusing points made in the argument around multiculturalism.
It's a fair point. We should be putting our own herbs and vegetables first before other culinary incomers.
But even then,you can never be too careful about resisting the insidious advance of "foreign" foodstuffs.Even what some might think of as a quintessential "British" vegetable like the carrot is thought to have originated in Persia/Asia Minor and only came here as an immigrant in the middle ages.no doubt gaining acceptance in a misguided attempt at middle ages multi-culturalism.
Edited by legaleagle (19 Aug 2015 11.12pm)
|
leggedstruggle Croydon 20 Aug 15 6.31am |
|
Quote legaleagle at 19 Aug 2015 11.11pm
Quote Kermit8 at 19 Aug 2015 8.14am
Quote Stirlingsays at 19 Aug 2015 8.04am
Legal thinks that if you're not fond of multiculturalism that it's doubtful that you should be in favour of curry.
One of the more amusing points made in the argument around multiculturalism.
It's a fair point. We should be putting our own herbs and vegetables first before other culinary incomers.
But even then,you can never be too careful about resisting the insidious advance of "foreign" foodstuffs.Even what some might think of as a quintessential "British" vegetable like the carrot is thought to have originated in Persia/Asia Minor and only came here as an immigrant in the middle ages.no doubt gaining acceptance in a misguided attempt at middle ages multi-culturalism.
Edited by legaleagle (19 Aug 2015 11.12pm)
The modern orange carrot originated in the Netherlands in the 17th century. The Eastern variety was purple and was inferior to the orange carrots which were sweeter and more fleshy than their purple counterparts, thus providing more food per plant and being better tasting.
mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler
|
legaleagle 20 Aug 15 9.08am |
|
Quote leggedstruggle at 20 Aug 2015 6.31am
Quote legaleagle at 19 Aug 2015 11.11pm
Quote Kermit8 at 19 Aug 2015 8.14am
Quote Stirlingsays at 19 Aug 2015 8.04am
Legal thinks that if you're not fond of multiculturalism that it's doubtful that you should be in favour of curry.
One of the more amusing points made in the argument around multiculturalism.
It's a fair point. We should be putting our own herbs and vegetables first before other culinary incomers.
But even then,you can never be too careful about resisting the insidious advance of "foreign" foodstuffs.Even what some might think of as a quintessential "British" vegetable like the carrot is thought to have originated in Persia/Asia Minor and only came here as an immigrant in the middle ages.no doubt gaining acceptance in a misguided attempt at middle ages multi-culturalism.
Edited by legaleagle (19 Aug 2015 11.12pm)
The modern orange carrot originated in the Netherlands in the 17th century. The Eastern variety was purple and was inferior to the orange carrots which were sweeter and more fleshy than their purple counterparts, thus providing more food per plant and being better tasting.
Interesting,since the ones grown here from the 15th century onwards. were red and white coloured.Orange hybrids were thought have have been developed in Europe from the 16th century.You are right that the orange "carrot" hybrid on which our cultivated carrots are based today were developed by Dutch horticulturalists in the 18th century.
A truly multi-cultural vegetable,originating anywhere but within the Uk.
|
johnfirewall 20 Aug 15 10.05am |
|
|
This reminds me of that meme doing the rounds on Facebook, along the lines of "Drives a German car, eats Indian food, drinks Italian coffee but hates foreigners"
I don't know who's more stupid. The fictional racist portrayed or the sort of people who share such rubbish in the belief that it's actually relevant to anything.
|
legaleagle 20 Aug 15 10.30am |
|
|
Or perhaps a third option for the most stupid? Those who are so blind they can't see the wood from the trees and say in relation to a discussion about benefits/negatives of multi culturalism, things like that the benefits of living in a more multi-cultural society as shown by our cuisine,such as "indian" food becoming one of our "national dishes",as an example are of no relevance whatsoever
Edited by legaleagle (20 Aug 2015 10.31am)
|
leggedstruggle Croydon 20 Aug 15 10.33am |
|
Quote legaleagle at 20 Aug 2015 10.30am
Or perhaps a third option for the most stupid? Those who are so blind they can't see the wood from the trees and say in relation to a discussion about benefits/negatives of multi culturalism, things like that the benefits of living in a more multi-cultural society as shown by our cuisine,such as "indian" food becoming one of our "national dishes",as an example are of no relevance whatsoever
Edited by legaleagle (20 Aug 2015 10.31am)
Right, lowered wages, competition for jobs, housing crisis and occasional terrorism - all worth it if we can buy a Chinesse takeaway or pitza.
mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler
|
johnfirewall 20 Aug 15 10.33am |
|
|
We invented the Tikka Masala...
Other holes in such a specious notion being anyone that indiscriminate in their dislike of foreigners is a rarity. Is anyone that stupid to not consider the external cultural influences on food? (ignoring the ridiculousness of where a car might come from)
By pointing out the ignorance of a fictional character we've agreed on a couple of additional benefits of migration but I didn't see you crying out for the enrichment that Romanian cuisine might bring.
Edited by johnfirewall (20 Aug 2015 10.48am)
|
legaleagle 20 Aug 15 10.40am |
|
Quote leggedstruggle at 20 Aug 2015 10.33am
Quote legaleagle at 20 Aug 2015 10.30am
Or perhaps a third option for the most stupid? Those who are so blind they can't see the wood from the trees and say in relation to a discussion about benefits/negatives of multi culturalism, things like that the benefits of living in a more multi-cultural society as shown by our cuisine,such as "indian" food becoming one of our "national dishes",as an example are of no relevance whatsoever
Edited by legaleagle (20 Aug 2015 10.31am)
Right, lowered wages, competition for jobs, housing crisis and occasional terrorism - all worth it if we can buy a Chinesse takeaway or pitza.
Your overview of the overall benefits of a multi cultural society to the UK since say the 1950's might seem to some to be as skewed as your spelling of pizza
|
leggedstruggle Croydon 20 Aug 15 10.45am |
|
Quote legaleagle at 20 Aug 2015 10.40am
Quote leggedstruggle at 20 Aug 2015 10.33am
Quote legaleagle at 20 Aug 2015 10.30am
Or perhaps a third option for the most stupid? Those who are so blind they can't see the wood from the trees and say in relation to a discussion about benefits/negatives of multi culturalism, things like that the benefits of living in a more multi-cultural society as shown by our cuisine,such as "indian" food becoming one of our "national dishes",as an example are of no relevance whatsoever
Edited by legaleagle (20 Aug 2015 10.31am)
Right, lowered wages, competition for jobs, housing crisis and occasional terrorism - all worth it if we can buy a Chinesse takeaway or pitza.
Your overview of the overall benefits of a multi cultural society to the UK since say the 1950's might seem to some to be as skewed as your spelling of pizza
South African spelling - in honour of Jacob Zuma
mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler
|
legaleagle 20 Aug 15 10.46am |
|
Quote johnfirewall at 20 Aug 2015 10.33am
We invented the Tikka Masala...
"We" did indeed."we" being Brits.The Brits in question being of Bengali origin.Pleased to see they count as "we" for you rather than non Brits.
Though some say chicken tikka massala was basically an evolution of "butter chicken", "invented" in India.
|
legaleagle 20 Aug 15 10.50am |
|
Quote leggedstruggle at 20 Aug 2015 10.45am
Quote legaleagle at 20 Aug 2015 10.40am
Quote leggedstruggle at 20 Aug 2015 10.33am
Quote legaleagle at 20 Aug 2015 10.30am
Or perhaps a third option for the most stupid? Those who are so blind they can't see the wood from the trees and say in relation to a discussion about benefits/negatives of multi culturalism, things like that the benefits of living in a more multi-cultural society as shown by our cuisine,such as "indian" food becoming one of our "national dishes",as an example are of no relevance whatsoever
Edited by legaleagle (20 Aug 2015 10.31am)
Right, lowered wages, competition for jobs, housing crisis and occasional terrorism - all worth it if we can buy a Chinesse takeaway or pitza.
Your overview of the overall benefits of a multi cultural society to the UK since say the 1950's might seem to some to be as skewed as your spelling of pizza
South African spelling - in honour of Jacob Zuma
You mean the thoroughly unsavoury (no pun intended)President of S Africa?
Little known fact: Unbelievable I know,but some suggest that because Zuma is an thoroughly unsavoury character ,this means all of a different race here or abroad are to be regarded as unsavoury.
|