You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 8.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 50 of 71 < 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 >
kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 21 Nov 18 8.43pm

I dont get the crying over the f***ing seat.

if the stand was being pulled down you go.
& sod the HF too, they & you are short term.
HF are current, you or them may decide in a year or two not to go.


its not yours or their seat, its temp.
the club want to change things, that's it.
move.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Laths Flag West of Selhurst. 21 Nov 18 8.59pm

Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall

I dont get the crying over the f***ing seat.

if the stand was being pulled down you go.
& sod the HF too, they & you are short term.
HF are current, you or them may decide in a year or two not to go.


its not yours or their seat, its temp.
the club want to change things, that's it.
move.

Idiot ! I’ll leave it at that.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Nov 18 9.54pm

Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall

I dont get the crying over the f***ing seat.

if the stand was being pulled down you go.
& sod the HF too, they & you are short term.
HF are current, you or them may decide in a year or two not to go.


its not yours or their seat, its temp.
the club want to change things, that's it.
move.

Fair enough, you don't get it

For those that do, a lot of it is about respect. And about fairness. It feels like those that have been around a long time are now past their sell by date, the club just doesn't care about them any more.

That is not, in general, how social clubs work. In essence that is what a football club is for most of us, IMHO. Otherwise we'd watch whatever team is playing the best football, rather than 'supporting'.

Generally you show respect for those that have helped establish, grow and nurture the club - making it better for those that come next. Hence we clap when the old players come back to visit. Recently some of the most loyal fans have been shown clear disrespect

And also, many of them will just not come any more as their social groups are broken up, the seats are harder to get to, old people have to sit in the rain and the more infirm lose their helpers etc.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Nov 18 10.11pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

Fair enough, you don't get it

For those that do, a lot of it is about respect. And about fairness. It feels like those that have been around a long time are now past their sell by date, the club just doesn't care about them any more.

That is not, in general, how social clubs work. In essence that is what a football club is for most of us, IMHO. Otherwise we'd watch whatever team is playing the best football, rather than 'supporting'.

Generally you show respect for those that have helped establish, grow and nurture the club - making it better for those that come next. Hence we clap when the old players come back to visit. Recently some of the most loyal fans have been shown clear disrespect

And also, many of them will just not come any more as their social groups are broken up, the seats are harder to get to, old people have to sit in the rain and the more infirm lose their helpers etc.

I understand what you’re saying and the HF are bringing a new ‘nurture’ to Selhurst Park. This whole issue has really highlighted what we all knew about generally two types of supporters that Parish doesn’t really get, but certainly gets the HF constantly singing, although he doesn’t get that not that many will sing for 96 minutes. By that I mean when Parish said on hol radio ‘why can’t everyone be like the HF?’ after Frank was sacked and the sun don’t shine tomorrow lads tweet. I knew from that he’d probably u-turn but doesn’t really understand the fan base. The handling and compensation has been shambolic and insulting, but Parish is in love and probably knackered and sex drunk, what with Susannah’s alarm clock going off at 3am, so maybe one of several reasons why, and several innings every night, along with it’s Palace, what do we expect?

‘Many of them will just not come any more as their social groups are broken up, the seats are harder to get to, old people have to sit in the rain and the more infirm lose their helpers etc.’ Is all of that you say really true?


Edited by Rudi Hedman (21 Nov 2018 10.25pm)

 


COYP

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 21 Nov 18 10.27pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I understand what you’re saying and the HF are bringing a new ‘nurture’ to Selhurst Park. This whole issue has really highlighted what we all knew about generally two types of supporters that Parish doesn’t really get, but certainly gets the HF constantly singing, although he doesn’t get that not that many will sing for 96 minutes.

‘Many of them will just not come any more as their social groups are broken up, the seats are harder to get to, old people have to sit in the rain and the more infirm lose their helpers etc.’ Is all of that you say really true?

Edited by reading the BBS thred on this I counted a total of eight who can't get seats tofether who have said stuff it and won't be coming again.Another said the same "Stuff Parish I won't go where I;m not wanted". There was a feeling running though all the pages I read that the HF are becoming hated for their actions this season
Great business Steve NOT.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Nov 18 10.36pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Edited by reading the BBS thred on this I counted a total of eight who can't get seats tofether who have said stuff it and won't be coming again.Another said the same "Stuff Parish I won't go where I;m not wanted". There was a feeling running though all the pages I read that the HF are becoming hated for their actions this season
Great business Steve NOT.

You said many won’t be coming, listing loads of physical disabilities and hardship with the elderly sitting in the rain (very tabloid headline) and then you’ve said you counted 8. Eight. Parish has handled this very badly, but 8? Have these 8 said they’re going to contact the club with their specific case?

Edited by Rudi Hedman (21 Nov 2018 10.38pm)

 


COYP

Mapletree Flag Croydon 21 Nov 18 11.01pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You said many won’t be coming, listing loads of physical disabilities and hardship with the elderly sitting in the rain (very tabloid headline) and then you’ve said you counted 8. Eight. Parish has handled this very badly, but 8? Have these 8 said they’re going to contact the club with their specific case?

Edited by Rudi Hedman (21 Nov 2018 10.38pm)

I know of 8 in my row. One lady who came with her now deceased friend as kind of a ritual homage won’t come next season. The guy with the stick at the end. The group of four old boys. And a couple who aren’t well enough to sit in the rain. Just one row. The demographics are mostly older people who have been in the row for 23 years

 

timbob Flag 22 Nov 18 4.30am

You are all missing some big points here because as usual some of you got personal and ‘emotional’.......!

IMHO The formula used to work because ;

. On scoring and celebrating a goal The players were ‘conditioned’ to ‘connect’ and run to a safe part of the stadium where fans were waiting for that special mutual exchange of energy


. The corner section galvanised another great section of fans in the ‘Arthur’ and encouraged backwards forwards ‘singing and banter momentum ‘

. The corner ‘configuration meant fans standing were less threatening to views of their colleagues the diaphragm could generate more energy and noise / vibration which reverberated to their neighbours and the players on the pitch

. The media / commentary box is just above and the noise and visual scenes of the palace faithful below spread a ‘message’ to other teams and fans globally that ‘palace fans’ are noises and passionate


The timing of the HF debacle and departure was ludicrous.We needed a good start and momentum at a tough timetable period I don’t think people thought the whole thing through from a common sense point of view

I personally challenge the HF to come out of hiding and show if they actually still exist or if in fact as I suspect have run out of energy and frittered away

Time will tell

R.i.p Staffie

Coyp

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Nov 18 8.23am

Originally posted by Willo

In the Championship we tended to do far better at home than we have done in the PL of late.

In our last season in the Championship we only lost 2 Home league games out of 23 matches,the season before that we lost 5 at Home and the season before that we lost 6 at home.The team haven't given us too much to get excited about at home of late !

Due to chronic mismanagement on and off the pitch at this level. Pulis, Pardew, De Boer, scouting, the HF debacle. There's one common denominator...

 

Glazed Over Flag Sevenoaks 22 Nov 18 10.18am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Respectfully I have to disagree

There will be a 200 person waiting list once they've filled the 400. Probably many people not really suited to it but this is the new sexy.

And I reckon this will be the future for many copycat clubs. Watch Huddersfield and Watford. Leicester has been desperate to do this for ages. Whoever shows the way, there will be many on their tails.

Edited by Mapletree (21 Nov 2018 6.26pm)

We'll see.

What you're forgetting is the demographics of the HF who would want to fill the 400 seats in Block E.

If all these seats are for ST holders only, then the cost of a ST has to be considered - and a large number of the 16 - 24 age group who can afford a one off game at Wembley, may not want to or be able to afford or commit to a full priced ST in E Block.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Nov 18 10.27am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Due to chronic mismanagement on and off the pitch at this level. Pulis, Pardew, De Boer, scouting, the HF debacle. There's one common denominator...

I appreciate that they are 'Persona non grata' on HOL, however when Pardew joined we were 18th and he kept us up, as well as getting the team to an FA Cup Final.When Pulis joined we were 19th and he also saved us from the dreaded drop.

Whilst I appreciate the negatives surrounding both Pardew and Pulis, one could argue that they were both managerial appointments when we were in the mire and as such their primary objective was to avoid the drop - in this respect they delivered.

Edited by Willo (22 Nov 2018 10.27am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Nov 18 10.35am

Originally posted by Glazed Over

We'll see.

What you're forgetting is the demographics of the HF who would want to fill the 400 seats in Block E.

If all these seats are for ST holders only, then the cost of a ST has to be considered - and a large number of the 16 - 24 age group who can afford a one off game at Wembley, may not want to or be able to afford or commit to a full priced ST in E Block.

Oh come on those 400 ST’s will be gone as soon as they’re available. In a few pages time you’ll be saying how it’s going to be dangerous with 2 to a seat etc. You’ve probably already said it. The singing section is too small because there’ll be loads in B and C disconnected from it. The whole Holmesdale we aren’t ready for but 3, or at least the halves of 3 blocks with the other halves joining in is very much possible.

 


COYP

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Nov 18 11.31am

Originally posted by Willo

I appreciate that they are 'Persona non grata' on HOL, however when Pardew joined we were 18th and he kept us up, as well as getting the team to an FA Cup Final.When Pulis joined we were 19th and he also saved us from the dreaded drop.

Whilst I appreciate the negatives surrounding both Pardew and Pulis, one could argue that they were both managerial appointments when we were in the mire and as such their primary objective was to avoid the drop - in this respect they delivered.

Edited by Willo (22 Nov 2018 10.27am)

Briefly Willo. Short term appointments, both ready to take the cash and run

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Nov 18 11.54am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Briefly Willo. Short term appointments, both ready to take the cash and run

I don't know the thinking of these managers in terms of longevity.

In terms of Pardew he was in charge for nearly 2 years and the mood music was that Parish should have 'wielded the axe' long before he did.

Anyway the debate is moving away from the subject of this thread !

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 22 Nov 18 12.05pm

Originally posted by Glazed Over

We'll see.

What you're forgetting is the demographics of the HF who would want to fill the 400 seats in Block E.

If all these seats are for ST holders only, then the cost of a ST has to be considered - and a large number of the 16 - 24 age group who can afford a one off game at Wembley, may not want to or be able to afford or commit to a full priced ST in E Block.

There will also be current non ST holders who will be attracted to return, like myself and a few of my mates. I don't expect to be lucky enough to get one though.

Demand will be very high. I'm certain of that.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Nov 18 12.12pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

There will also be current non ST holders who will be attracted to return, like myself and a few of my mates. I don't expect to be lucky enough to get one though.

Demand will be very high. I'm certain of that.

My concern is for those NOT in the so called 'Singing section' who will have their view obscured by all these supporters standing throughout the game.

Persistent standing is against the ground regulations but clearly the club will choose to turn a blind eye as they have done before.

Edited by Willo (22 Nov 2018 12.14pm)

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 22 Nov 18 12.43pm

Originally posted by Willo

My concern is for those NOT in the so called 'Singing section' who will have their view obscured by all these supporters standing throughout the game.

Persistent standing is against the ground regulations but clearly the club will choose to turn a blind eye as they have done before.

Edited by Willo (22 Nov 2018 12.14pm)

Let's not start this debate again. Whether you agree or not, the reality is that a lot of fans prefer to stand and that it's impossible to police.

Standing at the back of the block will have minimal impact anyway as there is no one behind them. If they were standing at the front of the block, you'd have a good point.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Nov 18 1.03pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Let's not start this debate again. Whether you agree or not, the reality is that a lot of fans prefer to stand and that it's impossible to police.

Standing at the back of the block will have minimal impact anyway as there is no one behind them. If they were standing at the front of the block, you'd have a good point.

And a lot of supporters wish to sit and watch the game without having their view obstructed by persistant standers.

Anyhow I have made by view on this patently clear, resulting in a plethora of fiesty exchanges on HOL, so I believe you are sensible in advocating that this debate should not be re-introduced as it will only result in the same old arguments being aired probably much to the chagrin of many.

 

turbohorsebox Flag Coulsdon 22 Nov 18 1.11pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Let's not start this debate again. Whether you agree or not, the reality is that a lot of fans prefer to stand and that it's impossible to police.

Standing at the back of the block will have minimal impact anyway as there is no one behind them. If they were standing at the front of the block, you'd have a good point.

Ah, the "I'm right, you're wrong so shut up" brigade strike again.

 


All good. Nothing bad.

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 22 Nov 18 1.22pm

Originally posted by turbohorsebox

Ah, the "I'm right, you're wrong so shut up" brigade strike again.

Excuse me? Where have I said I was right and he was wrong and asked him to 'shut up'?

I've merely stated the fact that rightfully or wrongfully, that there are a lot of people prefer to stand. Willo has correctly stated that there are also a lot of people that prefer to sit.

If the people who prefer to stand are at the back, it will have little to no effect on those in front or to the side who prefer to sit.

Thank you for your contribution.

 

Page 50 of 71 < 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic