This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Hudsoneagle
My initial thoughts about CG was that he was desperate to make an impact at Chelsea this year, and because of that he’d not be interested in coming back to Palace on loan again. Now, after only making it on to the pitch in the 99th minute, which is a shame for the lad, I wonder if he will be wondering how he makes the World Cup team with those sort of appearances. I do think he may leave on loan, but to another club, and not Palace. Am I right in thinking if we loan him again, it has to be with a view to signing him permanently? If that is the case, I can see him choosing a more straight forward loan somewhere else, with a view to having another crack at playing for Chelsea next season. On a side note, I think this rule of having to go for a loan/buy in a second year loan deal is wrong. If a player has developed well at a loan club, and the parent club want to extend that development experience for the players welfare, then why put such an obstacle in the way? Perhaps, anything over two seasons should have such rules come into play. But one season is rarely long enough. I think that rule applies to full season long loans and the season has already started so wouldnt apply in this case . Having said that i personally would love it if we signed him permanently.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hudsoneagle
I must admit, I’ve never seen the rule in writing, it’s only what I’ve picked up from posters on this site. If we can offer a straight forward loan, I can see CG choosing us over anyone else. He knows have valued he was, and he knows he will play in a system that suits him. I think if it was a straight forward loan I would probably steer clear unless we really haven't identified some form of alternative. With an option to buy or permanently from the off then I would love to. I just worry with a loan and nothing else, we just end up back here again next season
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hudsoneagle
I must admit, I’ve never seen the rule in writing, it’s only what I’ve picked up from posters on this site. If we can offer a straight forward loan, I can see CG choosing us over anyone else. He knows have valued he was, and he knows he will play in a system that suits him. Yes i know what you mean, he absolutley loved it at SP and we loved him , and his enthusiasm was so infectious . I cant see him going to sandcastle or neverton . I hope!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hudsoneagle
I must admit, I’ve never seen the rule in writing, it’s only what I’ve picked up from posters on this site. If we can offer a straight forward loan, I can see CG choosing us over anyone else. He knows have valued he was, and he knows he will play in a system that suits him. So just read that it stops 2 year loan agreements. I.e continuous, like Moises Kean to juve.
|
|
|
Originally posted by rossboss29
So just read that it stops 2 year loan agreements. I.e continuous, like Moises Kean to juve. But it wouldn’t be a 2 year loan, as he has played for Chelsea this season. Maybe that’s why he came on for a few minutes in the last game?
|
|
|
Originally posted by AshfordEagle94
I think if it was a straight forward loan I would probably steer clear unless we really haven't identified some form of alternative. With an option to buy or permanently from the off then I would love to. I just worry with a loan and nothing else, we just end up back here again next season I understand your sentiment, but loaning a player we know will perform is not a negative. If the club have the money to buy a permanent player that can or will eventually perform to the same level, then I’d say that is the better option…but have we found such a player? Can we even afford that type of player? With Wolves asking for 35m for Gibbs-White, I’d imagine we can’t afford a player as good as CG. I’d really prefer the club don’t spend that sort of money on a single player for the foreseeable future. We over spent on Benteke and Sakho…it’s no wonder a few years down the line we didn’t have a penny left to spend on younger players. We have just again started signing proper players again and I’m more comfortable with the 15-20m fees we have been seeing. Saying that…I’d take a punt on Watkins if he was available for around 26m.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
But it wouldn’t be a 2 year loan, as he has played for Chelsea this season. Maybe that’s why he came on for a few minutes in the last game? Ah i didnt cop that! Very calculated move by Chelsea .
|
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
The irish lad Kofi Balmer has signed, Official. I logged on to see what everyone thinks of this. The silence answers that one!
|
|
|
Originally posted by maddog
I logged on to see what everyone thinks of this. The silence answers that one! Well im in Ireland and follow the Northern Ireland league very loosley and, not trying to insult the guy but ive never heard of him . If he was outstanding in the league he would be heard of . Maybe the scouting team see something special in him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker
Well im in Ireland and follow the Northern Ireland league very loosley and, not trying to insult the guy but ive never heard of him . If he was outstanding in the league he would be heard of . Maybe the scouting team see something special in him. glens or blues?
Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents? |
|
|
Originally posted by kingdowieonthewall
glens or blues? Cliftonville for me
|
|
|
Originally posted by mark_cpal785
Is no 2nd loan a new rule as not heard that one before? We had Batshuayi on 2 loans only. This is FIFA new rules [Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker
Well im in Ireland and follow the Northern Ireland league very loosley and, not trying to insult the guy but ive never heard of him . If he was outstanding in the league he would be heard of . Maybe the scouting team see something special in him. Feels like we've brought him in to make the U23 team competitive (and maybe allow Jake O'Brien a League 1 loan at the same time) with a view to turning a profit on him. Both of those players feel too old to make it with our first team.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
But it wouldn’t be a 2 year loan, as he has played for Chelsea this season. Maybe that’s why he came on for a few minutes in the last game? Yh, even if he didn’t play for Chelsea in between if we signed him again it would be two seperate year long transfers- 2 deals. Moises Kean went to Juve on a 2 year loan deal in one transaction. These are now banned.
|
|
|
Forest signing Maupay for £15m and a Korean forward How many more are they go8ng to sign?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Spiderman
Forest signing Maupay for £15m and a Korean forward How many more are they go8ng to sign? I think that makes 15 signings this window,the only snag is how long will it take to integrate those players with the current squad? Their transfer policy may well be their undoing.
|
|
|
Originally posted by beak
I think that makes 15 signings this window,the only snag is how long will it take to integrate those players with the current squad? Their transfer policy may well be their undoing. Like all things in this world it’s not volume it’s quality that counts and delivers results…!! COYP
|
|
|
I really want them to go down now, hate it when teams just completely disregards the guys that got them promoted.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.