Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 5.19pm
Quote luckybuck at 25 May 2014 4.55pm
You shouldn't claim to know what a person has been through. In fact I've been subjected to experiences in my time that I could quite easily call racist attacks. They haven't dented my values though. I don't carry it with me or attribute it in any shape of form to individuals I don't know and haven't met. That would be my idea of hell.
It sounds like you lived a 'minority experience' in Stockwell, being white where many non whites lived around you. Instead of using that to gain an insight into the kinds of experiences people have when they are placed on the fringes of society it appears that you're perpetually trying to get out of being in that situation again. You're viewing people in the situation you yourself were placed in with suspicion and dislike. Difference isn't disease.
Edited by luckybuck (25 May 2014 4.58pm)
Quote
Why shouldn't I? I said your views were typical of a certain type of person. I'm not claiming I know your personal experiences.
You very obviously meant to suggest that I was likely part of that group that was typical, else why even say it? I'm just telling you that I'm not.
Quote
It's quite amusing that you tell me to not claim to know your experiences when in your next paragraph you give an opinion about how I reacted to situations you didn't experience......Hypocritical.
I suggested that you didn't know of my experience on account that I'd told you absolutely nothing about it. You based your view of me on nothing. You told me that you were a 10% minority and that you suffered racism. Having an opinion on information presented is very, very different from assuming that person hasn't had a bad experience and is 'typical', when none of that applies to them.
Quote
I do object to being within a cultural minority within my own country. If I moved to another country that would be a situation I'd willingly placed myself within.....But I haven't. This is where I was born.....So my expectations of wishing to live within a majority of my own culture aren't unreasonable at all.
Many move here by complete choice, just as many Brits do abroad. Plenty of people here haven't wished to place themselves in that position though. The wives, the children and so on. There are of course many reasons people end up here.
There are pockets in countless countries that are minority centric. As you say, it's not really the fault of those moving there that you are unhappy with their presense. People have to be somewhere now don't they, and it can't always be in a configuration that suits you personally.
Quote
Your analogy of Wisbech with Stockwell doesn't make sense. As I said, if I had moved to a place where I knew I was going to be in that situation I wouldn't really have cause to moan about it. Instead immigrants moved to where I lived....Not the other way around.
I didn't say you moved to Wisbech because of the immigrants there. I said it looks like you perpetually want to get away from environments that go down that path, as it appears Wisbech has. That's fine. If and when you have the means, you can move somewhere else. That's your perfect right.
Quote
Regardless, racism isn't something I support.....No one should be physically attacking or verbally abusing foreigners.....It isn't them I blame.
I'm glad you hold that view. That's something.
Quote
It's people in power with views like yours that create these situations by supporting 'open door' immigration levels.
Those 'typical' views of mine again no doubt, even though I don't support open door immigration at all. I wouldn't much care if the borders were tightened today. I do though care about how people already here are talked about and treated regardless of their background.
Edited by luckybuck (25 May 2014 6.08pm)