You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
November 22 2026 2.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ukip (LOCKED)


Page 51 of 187 < 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 >
Stirlingsays Flag 25 May 14 2.29pm

Quote legaleagle at 25 May 2014 1.50pm

True, massive generalisation. But,even given that, its true in the sense that the Jewish community was near-monolithically Labour voting 50/60 years ago, same in USA with the Democratic party.

As the community (which had generally been poor)moved to (largely) 2nd/3rd generation in the UK and dispersed into various general income groups, that shattered and people began voting more along income lines in keeping with the general population.....Not so different to immigrant communities from, for example, Asia in the 1960's/70's.

100 years ago, Jewish immigrants faced precisely the same kind of scaremongering prejudice immigrants from Eastern Europe encounter today (ie not people you'd want as neighbours). So, as well as economic grounds, it is scarcely surprising the community generally shied away from voting for those on the right who were the main anti-immigrant force in those days.

but my point was re the difference between what Ken said and the UKIP line..


The income group and who you vote for is a stereotype. So like many stereotypes it has some truth to it but its a caricature of the real picture.....So him stating this without caveats just winds people up.

I would have thought that Livingstone would have kept away from talking about this particular group but.....Then again he's retired now so he probably cares even less than before.....Which while I rarely agree with him is at least refreshing.

As for Ukip.....Well Ukip believe what the Tories and Labour believe. Indeed the benefits system has been changed by both of those parties to make it difficult for immigrants to avail themselves of our systems.

The figures banded about by pro-immigration 'open door' idealogs who use them to often claim that immigration doesn't harm the UK are partly down to our system having in-built protections....Which still aren't perfect.....It isn't down to some nonsensical romantic view of immigrants.

What Ukip believe in this area isn't really all that different to the main parties.....But they are more honest in their statements about it.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The White Horse Flag 25 May 14 2.46pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 2.29pm

The income group and who you vote for is a stereotype. So like many stereotypes it has some truth to it but its a caricature of the real picture.....So him stating this without caveats just winds people up.

It's the most reliable stereotype there is politically, I'd say. Was it Marx who said it originally? Something like "a man's politics is the best reflection of his material circumstances".

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 2.29pm

I would have thought that Livingstone would have kept away from talking about this particular group but.....Then again he's retired now so he probably cares even less than before.....Which while I rarely agree with him is at least refreshing.

He made the comments mentioned during his last mayoral campaign over 2 years ago.


 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

legaleagle Flag 25 May 14 3.01pm

Yes, you are right. The Tories (unsurprisingly, since UKIP stem originally from disaffected Tories) and Labour (shame on them, so as to not appear left wing and sacrifice principles to chase votes) have both pandered to populist anti-immigrant sentiment.

Sentiment based upon thinking immigrants are a key causal factor for the mess we're in...in league with the other hardy perennial that all would be hunky dory were it not for "benefit scroungers".

In fact, "savings" from denying health care to some groups of immigrants are miniscule compared to the defecit reduction/savings that would result from shutting down the many tax avoidance routes available to the big companies and high net worth individuals. For some reason, that's not high on the media and right-wing agenda.

Its worth remembering that "the end of British civilisation as we know it" was predicted by those opposing Jewish immigration 100 years ago and those opposing migration from the Commonwealth in the 1960's/1970's.THe reality was our economic woes were based on end of empire and continuing economic decline that was already setting in 100 years ago. If we hadn't joined the EU, our economy might well and truly have sunk completely by now.

There are massive numbers of Australian and New Zealand immigrants living here, but the press and political parties seeking the populist vote never seem to mention them...wonder why?

Not to mention the vast number of Brits taking advantage of the EU to live overseas (and claim benefits like health care)...

Its not about all immigrants being great...or our immigration policies being perfect. Neither are.

What it is about is the utter nonsense of suggesting our economic and social woes are largely due to our EU membership and the migration within the EU that has resulted.....

That is just the latest manifestation of the same old prejudice and scaremongering that's been going on for over 100 years...

 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 May 14 3.05pm

Quote The White Horse at 25 May 2014 2.46pm

It's the most reliable stereotype there is politically, I'd say. Was it Marx who said it originally? Something like "a man's politics is the best reflection of his material circumstances".


I personally know plenty of low income people who vote Tory. I grew up on a council estate and you'd be surprised.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 25 May 14 3.10pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 3.05pm

Quote The White Horse at 25 May 2014 2.46pm

It's the most reliable stereotype there is politically, I'd say. Was it Marx who said it originally? Something like "a man's politics is the best reflection of his material circumstances".


I personally know plenty of low income people who vote Tory. I grew up on a council estate and you'd be surprised.


Fair point, but not necessarily meaning the general principle is completely wrong.


 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 May 14 3.20pm

Quote legaleagle at 25 May 2014 3.01pm

Yes, you are right. The Tories (unsurprisingly, since UKIP stem originally from disaffected Tories) and Labour (shame on them, so as to not appear left wing and sacrifice principles to chase votes) have both pandered to populist anti-immigrant sentiment.

Sentiment based upon thinking immigrants are a key causal factor for the mess we're in...in league with the other hardy perennial that all would be hunky dory were it not for "benefit scroungers".

In fact, "savings" from denying health care to some groups of immigrants are miniscule compared to the defecit reduction/savings that would result from shutting down the many tax avoidance routes available to the big companies and high net worth individuals. For some reason, that's not high on the media and right-wing agenda.

Its worth remembering that "the end of British civilisation as we know it" was predicted by those opposing Jewish immigration 100 years ago and those opposing migration from the Commonwealth in the 1960's/1970's.THe reality was our economic woes were based on end of empire and continuing economic decline that was already setting in 100 years ago. If we hadn't joined the EU, our economy might well and truly have sunk completely by now.

There are massive numbers of Australian and New Zealand immigrants living here, but the press and political parties seeking the populist vote never seem to mention them...wonder why?

Not to mention the vast number of Brits taking advantage of the EU to live overseas (and claim benefits like health care)...

Its not about all immigrants being great...or our immigration policies being perfect. Neither are.

What it is about is the utter nonsense of suggesting our economic and social woes are largely due to our EU membership and the migration within the EU that has resulted.....

That is just the latest manifestation of the same old prejudice and scaremongering that's been going on for over 100 years...


I can't say I share many of your expressed beliefs here.....I don't feel your parallels with immigration history are at all relevant to today's numbers and scale and hence validity of complaint.

Your views are typical of why Ukip continue to gain support. It's denial and though your views aren't rude at all....Contained within them is a form of patronization.

Antipodean immigrants? Their numbers can be controlled being outside the EU and their culture isn't that different to my own.....So as long as the numbers are reasonable I don't mind them.....This can't be said of Eastern European immigrants.

The EU is party responsible for our economic woes though by no means all of it. The creation of the euro led to a system that the banking crises easily destroyed (though I'm talking degrees here as any system would have been damaged)....I'm more critical of how this EU has created an almost slave like system....Being out of the Euro (which Blair and the liberals would have put us in) saved us from the same level of damage.....As despite having a large financial sector and being hit hard we can devalue and hence react and respond.

While I'm not a fan of what this EU has done economically to its people compared to what a looser more trade based system would done it is not my main issue with it.

The total free movement of peoples is my biggest issue personally.....And all those British to have moved abroad don't exactly come high up on my list of concerns....Anyone who knows my views knows how I regard those 'cake and eat it' stop outs.

Edited by Stirlingsays (25 May 2014 3.28pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 25 May 14 3.24pm

Quote legaleagle at 25 May 2014 3.10pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 3.05pm

I personally know plenty of low income people who vote Tory. I grew up on a council estate and you'd be surprised.

Fair point, but not necessarily meaning the general principle is completely wrong.

As a general principle I'd agree.....Less right wing voters amongst low income people than left wing would be true....Yup....Though possibly more even amongst the aspirational.....Though that's just my opinion.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

luckybuck Flag 25 May 14 3.29pm

----


Edited by luckybuck (25 May 2014 3.48pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 25 May 14 3.31pm

The beauty is that in a democracy we can debate and disagree. So, I can respect we think differently, without needing to suggest you are patronising me or others.

Your post is helpful. You lay it on the line. It is not so much immigration and its economic effects per se you object to, but immigrants who are not culturally "like us".


 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 May 14 3.45pm

Quote legaleagle at 25 May 2014 3.31pm

The beauty is that in a democracy we can debate and disagree. So, I can respect we think differently, without needing to suggest you are patronising me or others.

Your post is helpful. You lay it on the line. It is not so much immigration and its economic effects per se you object to, but immigrants who are not culturally "like us".

My first objection is to the scale of the immigration and how it has affected the working classes personally in respect to housing, the required supporting infrastructure and system and perhaps more importantly job competition amongst the working class....The powerless within British society.

I don't mind immigration....We as an island are built upon it....It's about numbers and what swamping does to unsuspecting communities.

My loyalty is firstly to the vulnerable in the British community....Not people from overseas. I'm not an egalitarian outside of helping where it doesn't adversely my own.

I grew up in a council estate in Stockwell in the eighties surrounded by culturally foreign influences....I hated it. As an adult in his late twenties I moved to Wisbech....Only to find the buggers moved there in such numbers in the last ten years that now the town is nicknamed, Wisbekistan.

I'll move out when I can....Probably when I finally leave teaching.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

luckybuck Flag 25 May 14 3.57pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 3.45pm

Quote legaleagle at 25 May 2014 3.31pm

The beauty is that in a democracy we can debate and disagree. So, I can respect we think differently, without needing to suggest you are patronising me or others.

Your post is helpful. You lay it on the line. It is not so much immigration and its economic effects per se you object to, but immigrants who are not culturally "like us".

My first objection is to the scale of the immigration and how it has affected the working classes personally in respect to housing, the required supporting infrastructure and system and perhaps more importantly job competition amongst the working class....The powerless within British society.

I don't mind immigration....We as an island are built upon it....It's about numbers and what swamping does to unsuspecting communities.

My loyalty is firstly to the vulnerable in the British community....Not people from overseas. I'm not an egalitarian outside of helping where it doesn't adversely my own.

I grew up in a council estate in Stockwell in the eighties surrounded by culturally foreign influences....I hated it. As an adult in his late twenties I moved to Wisbech....Only to find the buggers moved there in such numbers in the last ten years that now the town is nicknamed, Wisbekistan.

I'll move out when I can....Probably when I finally leave teaching.

Of course 'no blacks' signs back in the day were in part born out of the nottion that people had come from an alien culture. Now many have integrated and it would be odd to differentiate based on race alone. I wonder what you'd have represented and stood for had you have been a grown man back then?


Edited by luckybuck (25 May 2014 4.00pm)

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 25 May 14 3.58pm

Quote The White Horse at 25 May 2014 2.46pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 2.29pm

The income group and who you vote for is a stereotype. So like many stereotypes it has some truth to it but its a caricature of the real picture.....So him stating this without caveats just winds people up.

It's the most reliable stereotype there is politically, I'd say. Was it Marx who said it originally? Something like "a man's politics is the best reflection of his material circumstances".

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 2.29pm

I would have thought that Livingstone would have kept away from talking about this particular group but.....Then again he's retired now so he probably cares even less than before.....Which while I rarely agree with him is at least refreshing.

He made the comments mentioned during his last mayoral campaign over 2 years ago.


He made more comments a few weeks ago!

[Link]

Oh dear!

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

legaleagle Flag 25 May 14 4.03pm

In the 80's I lived in Kennington....there were some great foreign influences...not least a good Greek Cypriot-run café!

Fear of "swamping" due to numbers is exactly what the anti-immigration lobby said about Jews 100 years ago and Commonwealth immigrants in the 1960's/70's...

Housing is a big problem. But, I suspect maybe more to do with the long-term effects of the mass sell off of local authority housing in the 1980's,our banks' approach to lending since financial deregulation in the 1980's/90's ,the capital gains tax free house price bonanza since the 1970's,rather than arrivals from E Europe, particularly given the large numbers of Brits who have left the country, EU bound and otherwise (freeing up housing stock)in the past 2 decades

 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 May 14 4.05pm

Quote luckybuck at 25 May 2014 3.57pm

Of course 'no blacks' signs were in part born out of the fact that people had come from a different culture and were deemed to have nothing in common with us. Now many have integrated and it would be odd to differentiate based on race alone. I wonder what you'd have represented and stood for had you have been a grown man back then?

Who knows? We are all products of our influences.

I don't object to people based upon their skin colour and never have.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 25 May 14 4.09pm

Quote legaleagle at 25 May 2014 4.03pm

In the 80's I lived in Kennington....there were some great foreign influences...not least a good Greek Cypriot-run café!

Fear of "swamping" due to numbers is exactly what the anti-immigration lobby said about Jews 100 years ago and Commonwealth immigrants in the 1960's/70's...

Housing is a big problem. But, I suspect maybe more to do with the long-term effects of the mass sell off of local authority housing in the 1980's,our banks' approach to lending since financial deregulation in the 1980's/90's ,the capital gains tax free house price bonanza since the 1970's,rather than arrivals from E Europe, particularly given the large numbers of Brits who have left the country, EU bound and otherwise (freeing up housing stock)in the past 2 decades

I've already answered most of the points you've written here but you've repeated them. Never mind, as you say, we aren't going to agree.

We will see how the chips fall.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

luckybuck Flag 25 May 14 4.09pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 4.05pm

Quote luckybuck at 25 May 2014 3.57pm

Of course 'no blacks' signs were in part born out of the fact that people had come from a different culture and were deemed to have nothing in common with us. Now many have integrated and it would be odd to differentiate based on race alone. I wonder what you'd have represented and stood for had you have been a grown man back then?

Who knows? We are all products of our influences.

I don't object to people based upon their skin colour and never have.


For many black people to become part of our culture to begin with, they would've gone through the phase you declare as people you hate living near and want to get away from. It will have been a combination of attempting to intregrate and of commonality with those who decide they aren't some alien species that changed that. Just a thought.

Edited by luckybuck (25 May 2014 4.28pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 May 14 4.36pm

Quote luckybuck at 25 May 2014 4.09pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 4.05pm

Quote luckybuck at 25 May 2014 3.57pm

Of course 'no blacks' signs were in part born out of the fact that people had come from a different culture and were deemed to have nothing in common with us. Now many have integrated and it would be odd to differentiate based on race alone. I wonder what you'd have represented and stood for had you have been a grown man back then?

Who knows? We are all products of our influences.

I don't object to people based upon their skin colour and never have.


For black people to become part of our culture to begin with, they would've gone through the phase you declare as people you hate living near and people you want to get away from. It will have been a combination of attempting to intregrate and of commonality with those who decide they aren't some alien species that changed that. Just a thought.


Attempting to integrate? Not many first generation immigrants do that....Maybe half do to some degree....Many look to hold on (to their culture). It's the second generation who usually have far less problems and cause less social issues because of it.

Your views are typical of someone who hasn't had bad experiences. I lived upon Stockwell Park Estate in the eighties....That's the same area and time of the Brixton riots....Some of which I observed from looking out of my mother's high rise council estate window.

Being a 'white British' family on that estate we were about ten percent of the breakdown.....The 'nutty' Labour council wouldn't let us move off even though we experienced racism and attacks living there. I still bear the scars of that time physically.

Racism from a minority mind....But that's all it takes. Personally I believe you should treat as you find and it's about culture with me.

Regardless, what you say would be fine if it reflected reasonable numbers. Being surrounded by first generation immigrants in your own country isn't particularly fun if you don't enjoy widely different cultures.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

luckybuck Flag 25 May 14 4.55pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 4.36pm

Quote luckybuck at 25 May 2014 4.09pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 4.05pm

Quote luckybuck at 25 May 2014 3.57pm

Of course 'no blacks' signs were in part born out of the fact that people had come from a different culture and were deemed to have nothing in common with us. Now many have integrated and it would be odd to differentiate based on race alone. I wonder what you'd have represented and stood for had you have been a grown man back then?

Who knows? We are all products of our influences.

I don't object to people based upon their skin colour and never have.


For black people to become part of our culture to begin with, they would've gone through the phase you declare as people you hate living near and people you want to get away from. It will have been a combination of attempting to intregrate and of commonality with those who decide they aren't some alien species that changed that. Just a thought.



Attempting to integrate? Not many first generation immigrants do that....Maybe half do to some degree....Many look to hold on (to their culture). It's the second generation who usually have far less problems and cause less social issues because of it.

Your views are typical of someone who hasn't had bad experiences. I lived upon Stockwell Park Estate in the eighties....That's the same area and time of the Brixton riots....Some of which I observed from looking out of my mother's high rise council estate window.

Being a 'white British' family on that estate we were about ten percent of the breakdown.....The 'nutty' Labour council wouldn't let us move off even though we experienced racism and attacks living there. I still bear the scars of that time physically.

Racism from a minority mind....But that's all it takes. Personally I believe you should treat as you find and it's about culture with me.

Regardless, what you say would be fine if it reflected reasonable numbers. Being surrounded by first generation immigrants in your own country isn't particularly fun if you don't enjoy widely different cultures.

You shouldn't claim to know what a person has been through. In fact I've been subjected to experiences in my time that I could quite easily call racist attacks. They haven't dented my values though. I don't carry it with me or attribute it in any shape of form to individuals I don't know and haven't met. That would be my idea of hell.

It sounds like you lived a 'minority experience' in Stockwell, being white where many non whites lived around you. Instead of using that to gain an insight into the kinds of experiences people have when they are placed on the fringes of society it appears that you're perpetually trying to get out of being in that situation again. You're viewing people in the situation you yourself were in with suspicion and dislike.

Edited by luckybuck (25 May 2014 5.00pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 May 14 5.19pm

Quote luckybuck at 25 May 2014 4.55pm

You shouldn't claim to know what a person has been through. In fact I've been subjected to experiences in my time that I could quite easily call racist attacks. They haven't dented my values though. I don't carry it with me or attribute it in any shape of form to individuals I don't know and haven't met. That would be my idea of hell.

It sounds like you lived a 'minority experience' in Stockwell, being white where many non whites lived around you. Instead of using that to gain an insight into the kinds of experiences people have when they are placed on the fringes of society it appears that you're perpetually trying to get out of being in that situation again. You're viewing people in the situation you yourself were placed in with suspicion and dislike. Difference isn't disease.

Edited by luckybuck (25 May 2014 4.58pm)

Why shouldn't I? I said your views were typical of a certain type of person. I'm not claiming I know your personal experiences.

It's quite amusing that you tell me to not claim to know your experiences when in your next paragraph you give an opinion about how I reacted to situations you didn't experience......Hypocritical.

I do object to being within a cultural minority within my own country. If I moved to another country that would be a situation I'd willingly placed myself within.....But I haven't. This is where I was born.....So my expectations of wishing to live within a majority of my own culture aren't unreasonable at all.

Your analogy of Wisbech with Stockwell doesn't make sense. As I said, if I had moved to a place where I knew I was going to be in that situation I wouldn't really have cause to moan about it.
Regardless, racism isn't something I support.....No one should be physically attacking or verbally abusing foreigners.....It isn't them I blame.

It's people in power with views like yours that create these situations by supporting 'open door' immigration levels.

Edited by Stirlingsays (25 May 2014 5.26pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

luckybuck Flag 25 May 14 5.50pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 May 2014 5.19pm

Quote luckybuck at 25 May 2014 4.55pm

You shouldn't claim to know what a person has been through. In fact I've been subjected to experiences in my time that I could quite easily call racist attacks. They haven't dented my values though. I don't carry it with me or attribute it in any shape of form to individuals I don't know and haven't met. That would be my idea of hell.

It sounds like you lived a 'minority experience' in Stockwell, being white where many non whites lived around you. Instead of using that to gain an insight into the kinds of experiences people have when they are placed on the fringes of society it appears that you're perpetually trying to get out of being in that situation again. You're viewing people in the situation you yourself were placed in with suspicion and dislike. Difference isn't disease.

Edited by luckybuck (25 May 2014 4.58pm)


Quote
Why shouldn't I? I said your views were typical of a certain type of person. I'm not claiming I know your personal experiences.

You very obviously meant to suggest that I was likely part of that group that was typical, else why even say it? I'm just telling you that I'm not.

Quote

It's quite amusing that you tell me to not claim to know your experiences when in your next paragraph you give an opinion about how I reacted to situations you didn't experience......Hypocritical.

I suggested that you didn't know of my experience on account that I'd told you absolutely nothing about it. You based your view of me on nothing. You told me that you were a 10% minority and that you suffered racism. Having an opinion on information presented is very, very different from assuming that person hasn't had a bad experience and is 'typical', when none of that applies to them.

Quote

I do object to being within a cultural minority within my own country. If I moved to another country that would be a situation I'd willingly placed myself within.....But I haven't. This is where I was born.....So my expectations of wishing to live within a majority of my own culture aren't unreasonable at all.

Many move here by complete choice, just as many Brits do abroad. Plenty of people here haven't wished to place themselves in that position though. The wives, the children and so on. There are of course many reasons people end up here.

There are pockets in countless countries that are minority centric. As you say, it's not really the fault of those moving there that you are unhappy with their presense. People have to be somewhere now don't they, and it can't always be in a configuration that suits you personally.

Quote
Your analogy of Wisbech with Stockwell doesn't make sense. As I said, if I had moved to a place where I knew I was going to be in that situation I wouldn't really have cause to moan about it. Instead immigrants moved to where I lived....Not the other way around.

I didn't say you moved to Wisbech because of the immigrants there. I said it looks like you perpetually want to get away from environments that go down that path, as it appears Wisbech has. That's fine. If and when you have the means, you can move somewhere else. That's your perfect right.

Quote
Regardless, racism isn't something I support.....No one should be physically attacking or verbally abusing foreigners.....It isn't them I blame.


I'm glad you hold that view. That's something.

Quote
It's people in power with views like yours that create these situations by supporting 'open door' immigration levels.

Those 'typical' views of mine again no doubt, even though I don't support open door immigration at all. I wouldn't much care if the borders were tightened today. I do though care about how people already here are talked about and treated regardless of their background.

Edited by luckybuck (25 May 2014 6.08pm)

 

Page 51 of 187 < 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic