Quote legaleagle at 25 May 2014 9.35pm
Quote davenotamonkey at 25 May 2014 9.27pm
As just a simple racist and fascist having voted UKIP, I'm keen for the enlightened on here to explain something that has eluded me.
In the 90s, post-recession, the economy was growing (driven by debt) strongly and net migration into the UK was about 20-30k average per year.
Why is it, 20 years later, we suddenly require a migrationary level 10X that, for an economy that is very much not booming?
What has changed? Why do we suddenly need so many more people coming into the country for work purposes? Why does this level of immigration demonstrate that the economy is "on the up" (as has been claimed by many espousing the virtues of the influx, including Vince Cable).
The UK population increased by about 6.5 million from 1991 to 2012, considerably from the Labour flood. But does that require 10X higher level of immigration?
I'm looking at graphs such as this, for example:
[Link]
When did EU freedom of movement come into effect anyway, out of interest?
"It is a core principle, enshrined in the EU treaties, which works in parallel with the other three basic freedoms in the single market: freedom of goods, capital and services.
The European Commission says it is the right most closely associated with EU citizenship. An EU survey suggests it is seen as the EU's most positive achievement, ahead of peace in Europe, the euro and student exchanges.
More than 14 million EU citizens are resident in another member state - 2.8% of the total EU population.
Before the EU's big eastward expansion in 2004, citizens of the former communist bloc countries had less freedom to travel than western Europeans. That was a legacy of the Cold War.
The EU's Justice Commissioner Viviane Reding told students in Belgium recently: "Today, as European citizens... you can travel 3,000km (1,860 miles) across Europe - from Vilnius in Lithuania to Valencia in Spain - without once stopping at a border."
Freedom of movement helps to fill job vacancies in many EU countries and gives employers a wider talent pool, the Commission argues. Germany, resilient in the euro crisis, is proving a magnet for jobseekers from recession-hit countries like Spain, Italy and Greece.
Europe's football clubs are among those who have benefited from the freedom of professionals to move".
Well, I'm glad for these EU surveys. They are well known not to be loaded with bias or taxpayer propaganda mouthpieces designed to keep the plebs subservient. I'm very grateful for the EU keeping the peace - otherwise we'd have Greek grandfathers blowing their brains out in front of their parliament, the installation of unelected governments in Italy, and popular votes for far-right parties across Europe.
I think giving all poor countries the right to join Europe and move where they want is a great idea. I can't wait for all of Africa to join us. Because it's only fair you see, and we in the UK have the infrastructure and capacity to accommodate loads more than 200,000 a year.
It's also great that we can fill all those job vacancies from a pool of 200,000 extra people per year, because there just aren't enough people currently out of work in this country to fill them. Phew.
My point remains. Why do we need this level of immigration when we have 10X less 2 decades ago. What has changed in this country that requires it? I'm not asking if it's legally allowed (it clearly is - isn't the EU wonderful?), I'm asking why we need it? What is the skills shortage in the labour market that desperately needs to be plugged by this level of immigration? Are all these 200,000 people heart surgeons and professional footballers? Will I be able to get to see the doctor within 24 hours thanks to all those extra Polish doctors moving to the UK?
Why can't we operate a supply-and-demand skill-driven migration policy? Why should we have no say in what type of people come into our own country to settle? Is that really racist? Fascist?