You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Relegation 22/23
November 16 2026 4.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Relegation 22/23


Page 57 of 85 < 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 >
PJEagle Flag London 20 Mar 23 9.01am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

And of course if we found a more prolific striker how long could we hold on to him?
A few years ago 30 goals was a target to aim for!

I wonder if Andy Johnson has still got it? Probably more than Edouard or Mateta , sadly

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 20 Mar 23 9.12am

Originally posted by Davepalace707

Agreed. I wonder if we’d just had a 15 goal striker instead of two no goal strikers, we wouldn’t be in this mess now. But that’s probably the most expensive investment.

That's not the answer to the problem. Brighton don't have a 15 a goal a season striker and they are doing ok.

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 20 Mar 23 9.13am

As much as we moaned about Benteke, he was better than the two we have been left with.

Why he was never replaced and we were left with only two recognised strikers is another massive issued that wasn't addressed. We have not have the funds to spend loads on a striker, but at least taking a gamble on someone cheaper would have been better than leaving us with just 2.

Originally posted by PJEagle

I wonder if Andy Johnson has still got it? Probably more than Edouard or Mateta , sadly

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 20 Mar 23 9.22am

Originally posted by PJEagle

I wonder if Andy Johnson has still got it? Probably more than Edouard or Mateta , sadly

He's only 42 - he'd still be good for a few penalties at least.
Quite a thought that in 2003/4 he scored 32 while so far this season the whole squad have managed 24.

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 20 Mar 23 9.25am

Originally posted by fish mitten

As much as we moaned about Benteke, he was better than the two we have been left with.

Why he was never replaced and we were left with only two recognised strikers is another massive issued that wasn't addressed. We have not have the funds to spend loads on a striker, but at least taking a gamble on someone cheaper would have been better than leaving us with just 2.

The real problem up front is not the strikers but the feed. Ever since "we" decided to go with the inverted wingers the feed has dried up for the strikers. Start with the wingers in their (correct) positions and see if that works for a few games and if it doesn't then go back to the inverted wingers again. If it's working then the inverted wingers can switch during the game.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 20 Mar 23 9.32am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Let's look at it from another angle. Imagine we beat the drop will the board have learned anything from this season?
Perhaps the realisation will come that the PL is a giant sponge that sucks up investor's money, the twist being if you don't contribute you will inevitably drop.
I have little faith that the set of investors will invest the amounts necessary to rebuild the side after all the dead wood, fly by night, sick note players have departed. I have much doubt about the academy providing the players to cover those positions.
After 10 seasons and £1bn revenue, constant managerial change, what do we have? Does Parish think that by employing FdB and PV our players are suddenly going to run round like Henry, Bergkamp, and Zidane? He wants a nice crisp modern passing game but without paying for it.
What goes round comes round, it explains why the tactical approach employed by Pulis and Hodgson was successful, within the parameters set. They understood the limitations and capabilities of the players.
The board needs a serious reality check: without proper investment there will no advance, on the contrary, as we have seen this season backward steps have been taken and we are no better off than 10 seasons ago. Relegation looks likely sooner rather than later and at least we can have but learned from this failed experiment, clear the decks, and start again.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (20 Mar 2023 8.22am)

You can only hope so, but I'm not entirely sure.

The club is in a tricky period because of close to a decade of poor recruitment. And given our finances we cant afford to make mistakes, or not many. But we are at a point after, as you said, £1bn revenue with a squad that leaves a lot to be desired. 2 sub par full backs, 1 young left back, gaps in midfield, no current senior GK's. Quite laughable given the £1bn figure.

Other teams around us, have shown that over time you can build a good squad on modest spend, and build a new progressive footballing philosophy.

The board need to hold a mirror up to themselves....

Is there a long term plan?
Is there a recruitment strategy?
Are personnel good enough? Scouts? Coaches? Dougie?

Is Parish surrounding himself with the right people vs friendly faces (Bright, Dougie etc?) What credentials do these people have?

Parish has put himself in a tricky position now. Regardless of your thoughts on Vieira, we were navigating a nightmare run of fixtures, tightly, if not excitingly. We now have no manager, and are not an attractive proposition.

If we end up with Roy, it completely undermines any sense of long term vision or philosophy. If we get in another 'firefighter' what do we do if they keep us up, offer it to them perm? Again undermining any long termism.

I can only hope, and with Palace it is a big hope, that Lucien Favre, (having been an option before) has been sounded out about this. He'd offer a new face, but still inline with a potential long term plan.

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 20 Mar 23 9.36am

Yes you are right and that has been a problem for years. We had possibly the striker who was best at heading the ball in the Premier League in Benteke and two wingers in Zaha and Townsend, who would cut inside and shoot or try and dribble past ever last defender before putting a ball across on the floor.

Most teams seem to play with inverted wingers these days. The days of getting close to the goal line and then crossing seem gone. Even my 14 year old son, who is relatively rapid and right footed plays left wing for his team.

I'd prefer it if wingers were swapped over 2-3 times each game, gives the full backs a different problem.

Of course strikers are only good if they get chances. If Edouard knows he is only likely to get two in a game it puts a hell of a pressure on him to score.

Originally posted by crystal-purley

The real problem up front is not the strikers but the feed. Ever since "we" decided to go with the inverted wingers the feed has dried up for the strikers. Start with the wingers in their (correct) positions and see if that works for a few games and if it doesn't then go back to the inverted wingers again. If it's working then the inverted wingers can switch during the game.

 

Zaha127 Flag 20 Mar 23 9.45am

Relegation is so hard to call this year. From 12th to 20th can go down. I think it will be between Southampton, Bournemouth, West Ham, Leeds and Forest. I see Dyche getting results at Everton.

2 wins and 6 draws should be enough for Palace to stay up. But a lot of games are against teams fighting for their life which may make it the worst time to play them: Leicester, Leeds, Southampton, Everton, Wolves, West Ham, Bournemouth, Forest.

Hopefully Palace do enough maybe formational change can also help something like a 3-4-2-1 or 3-5-2. Relegation would be the worst thing for Palace.

 

Jacey Flag 20 Mar 23 10.24am

Originally posted by Zaha127

Relegation is so hard to call this year. From 12th to 20th can go down. I think it will be between Southampton, Bournemouth, West Ham, Leeds and Forest. I see Dyche getting results at Everton.

2 wins and 6 draws should be enough for Palace to stay up. But a lot of games are against teams fighting for their life which may make it the worst time to play them: Leicester, Leeds, Southampton, Everton, Wolves, West Ham, Bournemouth, Forest.

Hopefully Palace do enough maybe formational change can also help something like a 3-4-2-1 or 3-5-2. Relegation would be the worst thing for Palace.

Relegation??
Better get used to it as it is coming our way IF a decent Manager is not appointed very soon.

Edited by Jacey (20 Mar 2023 12.35pm)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Mar 23 10.31am

Workrate of our entire team not good enough. Add to that some sketchy technical skills, some pretty weak players and this is what you get. The manager had to be seeing our running stats too. As others have said, most teams don't have a brilliant striker.
The guarantee is they work harder than us, and probably smarter.
This points to a failure in coaching and management.
I agree the squad is average, even quite poor, but better than how we've played for a few months now.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 20 Mar 23 10.41am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Workrate of our entire team not good enough. Add to that some sketchy technical skills, some pretty weak players and this is what you get. The manager had to be seeing our running stats too. As others have said, most teams don't have a brilliant striker.
The guarantee is they work harder than us, and probably smarter.
This points to a failure in coaching and management.
I agree the squad is average, even quite poor, but better than how we've played for a few months now.

Agree with all of that.

Lots of factors to be considered in football however quality and work rate seem to be the two most influential. As it stands we should have enough quality but the work rate, beyond what we've all witnessed and our subjective opinions, is statistically the lowest in the league.

You throw in rumours of infighting and confidence at an all time low and it begins to paint a very bleak picture indeed.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 20 Mar 23 11.25am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Agree with all of that.

Lots of factors to be considered in football however quality and work rate seem to be the two most influential. As it stands we should have enough quality but the work rate, beyond what we've all witnessed and our subjective opinions, is statistically the lowest in the league.

You throw in rumours of infighting and confidence at an all time low and it begins to paint a very bleak picture indeed.

there doesnt seem tobe any infighting just lack of belief , 2 week break has come at the right time , regroup maybe new manager before the 1st game , problem may have been PV was to close to them , more like a friend than a manager .

I still believe we we will be ok , little bit of luck and we can get going , i played golf alot when i went through my bad spell didnt get any luck well tell a lie bad luck , then got a bounce my way a chip goes in and then 12 weeks of no idea , back to playing off single figures .

Bottom line is start up again and lose the first 2 were really in big trouble , start of with 4 points min and we will be ok COYP

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Mar 23 11.28am

Originally posted by fish mitten

Agree with just about everything you have stated.

The reality is that Patrick Vieira was not the entire problem. The lack of investment in the squad, leading to the lack of strength in depth has caused it. The last time it could be addressed was January and once again not enough was done. The Board must have believed we had enough to limp over the line. Sacking the manager and bringing in a new guy, is unlikely to bring in a massive upturn in our fortunes this season. I suspect the die has already been cast. Do we have enough quality to stay up, or are there 3 worse teams than us? Only time will tell.

That's why I want us to get a permanent manager now, not a stop gap. If we get a stand in manager, it is showing the Board are making the same mistakes and haven't learned anything. Introducing a new style takes investment, time and belief. If we have to go backwards to move forwards, so be it.

Relegation will be painful. But to try and plaster over the cracks with short term thinking means that the Board are far more interested in losing on their investment short term than they are the club moving forward in their playing style and philosophy.

The most annoying thing is at the end of last season we were in a great place. The failure to add three or four more quality players to the half a dozen we already had has lead to this.

Opting for relegation is just fvcking stupid. Sorry to interrupt

 


COYP

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 20 Mar 23 11.38am

previously, we had the oldest squad in the Premier League. Does anybody know the stats for currently ?

there are at least a 3 old men on our team who are really not fit enough for the rigours of the Prem. They were legends, but the Prem is very unforgiving.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

PJEagle Flag London 20 Mar 23 12.24pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Opting for relegation is just fvcking stupid. Sorry to interrupt

Agree entirely! I believe Parish stated that the summer transfer window is much better, as all matches are finished, so there's no need for panic buying? Hopefully we'll still be in PL and take our time to replace players like Ward who might be moving on, etc?

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 20 Mar 23 12.36pm

Didn't say we should opting for relegation. What I have tried to express is I don't think we are going to get a miracle cure now. The massive imbalances in the squad are what have primarily put us in this position, that can't be changed.

I don't believe in a Red Adair who can come in and firefight our way to guaranteed survival. Roy and Sam failed in their last jobs. Ahh, Watford were a basket case and didn't have good enough players. Have we? I'm not sure.

Be prepared for all options. To not be is fvcking stupid.

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Opting for relegation is just fvcking stupid. Sorry to interrupt

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 20 Mar 23 12.45pm

If the summer window is that much better why did he leave such gaping holes in the squad last summer?

I reckon this summer we need following

1. Replacement for Ward or Clyne (possibly both)
2. Replacement for Luka
3. Replacement for Riedeweld
4. Another left back
5. Another striker
6. Replace Mateta
7. Replace Zaha
8. Another loan/replacement for Lokonga
9. Replace McArthur

I haven't added Ayew or Tomkins to that and am realistic that we won't get all of them. It's going to be huge task.

I agree relegation will be a bad thing. I'm just starting to accept that it may well happen, because outside 6-7 players our squad is as weak as the others around us.

Originally posted by PJEagle

Agree entirely! I believe Parish stated that the summer transfer window is much better, as all matches are finished, so there's no need for panic buying? Hopefully we'll still be in PL and take our time to replace players like Ward who might be moving on, etc?

 

PatrickA Flag London 20 Mar 23 1.03pm

I read the average age has gone down down from something like 27.3 years to 26.9 years.
I thought this didn’t sound right as we had bought some younger players.
However, on closer analysis we have Guiata, Clyne/Ward, Schlupp, Ayew and Zaha often starting and then squad players such as Luka and Tomkins and then a few players in their mid twenties.
We’re still one of the older teams.

On a separate point is it ideal going into a relegation battle with so many players we will depend upon going out of contract? (Ward, Clyne, Zaha, McArthur, Luka, Tomkins and possibly Schlupp and Ayew).
It means they may have less ‘skin in the game’ so to speak although they would possibly have to forfeit a staying up bonus.

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

previously, we had the oldest squad in the Premier League. Does anybody know the stats for currently ?

there are at least a 3 old men on our team who are really not fit enough for the rigours of the Prem. They were legends, but the Prem is very unforgiving.

 

EddieMac Flag 20 Mar 23 5.54pm

I know we are in dire straits at the moment and this relegation carry on is very stressful but everyone has got to admit that they are excited for this Leicester game.

 

Jacey Flag 20 Mar 23 6.00pm

Facts are that yesterday's result was our second worst this season and surely underlines why we need an effective,motivated manager appointed quickly to arrest any slide to certain relegation.
Do not need SP,endless prevarication,dither and delay!!

 

Page 57 of 85 < 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Relegation 22/23