You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 58 of 71 < 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 >
Mapletree Flag Croydon 02 Dec 18 4.47pm

After the match yesterday we decided to take matters into our own hands and went to talk with the HF

We met an absolutely delightful couple of lads. They were genuinely deeply upset that the recent process has gone so wrong and were clear they never wanted to do anything to upset anyone.

They were also highly inclusive. We explained that we are in two of the seats they would particularly want, middle of Row 19, but we are not moving. They weren’t at all concerned and just wanted to welcome us into the fold.

They told us that they have no input into who joins the singing section. They have requested a pattern of seats for the existing HF members but don’t know if they will get it. They also said that CPFC2010 has to apply for a licence and that process isn’t clear to them.

We asked about their stated intention to meet with current Block E people and how they intended to do that. They didn’t really have an answer, they just said they would really like to meet anyone that wishes to talk with them and would take any opportunity.

If anyone wants us to pass contact details onto them we are happy to do so, PM me.

We take away from this that if you are Block E and want to stay and sing the HF will welcome all-comers but you will have to convince Paul McGowan you really are a keen singer and will stay the pace. Sign up to the singing section and make sure he knows you are keen.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 02 Dec 18 5.21pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

After the match yesterday we decided to take matters into our own hands and went to talk with the HF

We met an absolutely delightful couple of lads. They were genuinely deeply upset that the recent process has gone so wrong and were clear they never wanted to do anything to upset anyone.

They were also highly inclusive. We explained that we are in two of the seats they would particularly want, middle of Row 19, but we are not moving. They weren’t at all concerned and just wanted to welcome us into the fold.

They told us that they have no input into who joins the singing section. They have requested a pattern of seats for the existing HF members but don’t know if they will get it. They also said that CPFC2010 has to apply for a licence and that process isn’t clear to them.

We asked about their stated intention to meet with current Block E people and how they intended to do that. They didn’t really have an answer, they just said they would really like to meet anyone that wishes to talk with them and would take any opportunity.

If anyone wants us to pass contact details onto them we are happy to do so, PM me.

We take away from this that if you are Block E and want to stay and sing the HF will welcome all-comers but you will have to convince Paul McGowan you really are a keen singer and will stay the pace. Sign up to the singing section and make sure he knows you are keen.

Well played, cant help but thinking that the actual people at the pointy end of this having a proper discussion is a good call.

Meanwhile the atmosphere seemed enhanced yesterday and once again the yank TV coverage was showing the HF ad nauseum.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Aray Flag South London 02 Dec 18 6.31pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Well played, cant help but thinking that the actual people at the pointy end of this having a proper discussion is a good call.

Meanwhile the atmosphere seemed enhanced yesterday and once again the yank TV coverage was showing the HF ad nauseum.

I think this is what it is all about from the club's perspective. How do we stand a chance of building an international fan base? Without the HF I suspect the marketing of our club would be harder.

 

.TUX. Flag 02 Dec 18 8.55pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

They don’t ‘belong’ anywhere.

The singers have moved around for my fifty plus years

I thought about it today and realised they aren’t in the best position, nor in the historic position for the singers.

The noise gets lost a bit. I see the logic in wanting a move

This.

 


Buy Litecoin.

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 02 Dec 18 8.58pm

Highlights on MOTD showed the HF at least 3 times, once ironically when the crowd wasnt singing very loud, Its obvious that the HF give the club a marketing front when it comes to TV which is surprising as at Anfield for example they got more flags and scarved waved than weve ever had in the club shops in total ( well a lot anyway)

COYP

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 02 Dec 18 9.53pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Dream on. This is Palace and Parish. There’s as much chance of the new stand being finished soon so that it coincides with safe standing as there was of the Holmesdale originally being built with a roof more than 25 years ago with a terrace still allowed. Probably partly why the HF actions.

The only reason it was built was because we received a sports grant. (Noades never would’ve paid for the whole thing when there were bank accounts to be kept topped up and things in Oxted and elsewhere to buy)

Not a ‘dream on’ scenario. It’s fairly realistic that the new stand will be built and safe standing will be passed in about 5 years time. The rest is natural progression. The fact safe standing isn’t already in place in the Premier League is just farcical.

In my opinion the danger to the new stand is relegation, as attendance will drop to around 18,000 - 20,000 and the new extra seats will be pointless.


Edited by Goal Machine (02 Dec 2018 9.54pm)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 02 Dec 18 10.04pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Not a ‘dream on’ scenario. It’s fairly realistic that the new stand will be built and safe standing will be passed in about 5 years time. The rest is natural progression. The fact safe standing isn’t already in place in the Premier League is just farcical.

In my opinion the danger to the new stand is relegation, as attendance will drop to around 18,000 - 20,000 and the new extra seats will be pointless.


Edited by Goal Machine (02 Dec 2018 9.54pm)

5 years isn’t soon.

 


COYP

turbohorsebox Flag Coulsdon 03 Dec 18 12.32pm

Originally posted by Medway Eagle

Welcome back HF. I would think 85% of people who actually go to games are pleased your back, look forward to you moving in to block E next season

good luck

Personally couldn't give a f*ck, but there you go.

Happy to be one of the 15%. Which I suspect is an underestimate.

 


All good. Nothing bad.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 03 Dec 18 12.33pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Well played, cant help but thinking that the actual people at the pointy end of this having a proper discussion is a good call.

Meanwhile the atmosphere seemed enhanced yesterday and once again the yank TV coverage was showing the HF ad nauseum.

Whatever next bleddy organ music blaring out every ten minutes, cheerleaaders dancing and waving their pom poms the whole game. This is England not the USA!!!

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Painter Flag Croydon 03 Dec 18 12.36pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Well played, cant help but thinking that the actual people at the pointy end of this having a proper discussion is a good call.

Meanwhile the atmosphere seemed enhanced yesterday and once again the yank TV coverage was showing the HF ad nauseum.

It’s the same coverage regardless which country is showing it. The Premier League film it and sell on to TV companies around the world.

 

bicycle repair man 03 Dec 18 1.52pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Well played, cant help but thinking that the actual people at the pointy end of this having a proper discussion is a good call.

Meanwhile the atmosphere seemed enhanced yesterday and once again the yank TV coverage was showing the HF ad nauseum.


The enhanced atmosphere was caused by a terrific display by the team,and a vital victory.
Nothing to do with the part-time "fanatics",turning up.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 03 Dec 18 1.58pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


The enhanced atmosphere was caused by a terrific display by the team,and a vital victory.
Nothing to do with the part-time "fanatics",turning up.

Watching MOTD the noise and atmosphere at both Leicester and Newcastle was way ahead of ours.
e

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 03 Dec 18 2.17pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Watching MOTD the noise and atmosphere at both Leicester and Newcastle was way ahead of ours.
e

I'd agree on this. Which is good that a proper section next year should put the Palace back on top.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 03 Dec 18 2.58pm

Well I'm watching the game again now and not on a particularly high volume and we sound superb, constant noise for 90 mins and everyone in sync. No one can say with a straight face that the HF aren't a massive boost to a) our atmosphere and b) the positivity in Selhurst. I respect that it's hard on the 400 Block E fans but I think we really would go to another level there with the roof amplifying the HF's noise and it spreading accordingly, maybe even to Blocks F onwards. Surely that has to be a positive for us when weighed up

Sorry but I cannot take seriously anyone who downplays the HF, especially when comparing the games without them to Saturday. When in SP in my seat in Block B found myself beaming when watching the Arthur all singing and bouncing along again and the lads giving their all for the team in front of me. Felt like Palace at our best again

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 03 Dec 18 4.02pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Watching MOTD the noise and atmosphere at both Leicester and Newcastle was way ahead of ours.
e

With respect, its not really possible to judge watching TV due to microphone positioning. The same can be said of Selhurst Park of course. Leicester generally do have good home support but can't be taken seriously with the clappers they're given every week. I'm expecting to see those again at Brighton tomorrow.

It seems that the likes of you and BRM would rather sit in a silent stadium. Do you actually believe the HF make no difference? Is your anger aimed more at the HF or the club for way it's been handled?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 03 Dec 18 4.32pm

Originally posted by Painter

It’s the same coverage regardless which country is showing it. The Premier League film it and sell on to TV companies around the world.

Yep, outside of the UK broadcasters they get what they're given by the Premier League.

 


Optimistic as ever

Dman Palace Flag Brixton 03 Dec 18 5.27pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man


The enhanced atmosphere was caused by a terrific display by the team,and a vital victory.
Nothing to do with the part-time "fanatics",turning up.

"Another top performance and finally 3 points to go with it nice to add another tap in to the collection and to hear Selhurst rocking again #CPFC" pic.twitter.com/jQ4YqlPH7z

— Andros Townsend (@andros_townsend) December 1, 2018

"SELHURST PARK… finally!!!!"

— Patrick van Aanholt (@pvanaanholt) December 1, 2018


Seems rather important to these fellas!


Edited by Dman Palace (03 Dec 2018 5.39pm)

Edited by Dman Palace (03 Dec 2018 5.39pm)

 

Palace Loyal Flag New Addington 03 Dec 18 5.31pm

To bicycle repair man!
My God, not to sure if you have learning difficulties or mental problems? Not to admit the atmosphere was a lot better with the HF back in town.
You have some warped hatred of the HF, sure there not perfect but the atmosphere was 10 times better on Saturday
You spout the same old rubbish old the time!
The HF are back! The atmosphere is back!
So get on your bicycle & get riding!
Cos your boring tires are flat!

 

The_postman Flag Forest Row 03 Dec 18 6.11pm

The singing without the HF was sporadic and died out fairly quickly. What you get from the HF is constant singing from the first to last minute regardless of what is happening on the pitch. Constant singing needs to be orchestrated and they do that very well. The HF do not create a great atomosphere by themselves (alone they are not loud enough) but they are a vital catalyst. It is much easier for the rest of us to join in and turn up the volume to create a great atmosphere.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 03 Dec 18 6.13pm

Originally posted by Palace Loyal

To bicycle repair man!
My God, not to sure if you have learning difficulties or mental problems? Not to admit the atmosphere was a lot better with the HF back in town.
You have some warped hatred of the HF, sure there not perfect but the atmosphere was 10 times better on Saturday
You spout the same old rubbish old the time!
The HF are back! The atmosphere is back!
So get on your bicycle & get riding!
Cos your boring tires are flat!

Chill mate

He is cycling against the tide in any case. The move is happening, there is no turning back

From where I sat the HF worked very hard but weren't as good as they used to be, I think there were fewer of them. But importantly, they aren't in the best position to hit us with a wall of sound.

Not great to accuse someone of mental health problems. Just leave him be and enjoy what in the end should be a better atmosphere. And also be respectful for the 398 people that seem like they have to move. It's an awful lot and they are long standing loyal fans.

I am aware that many aren't too steady on their pins as well, so I really hope a good solution can be found for each and every one. I shall miss the friendship built up over 23 years.

 

Page 58 of 71 < 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic