You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Bedroom tax
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bedroom tax


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 22 Feb 13 3.08pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 2.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 7.41pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 6.30pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 5.06pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 4.05pm

It is absolute bollocks that 25-30% of the children anywhere in the UK are in actual poverty, not the lack of PC/Broadband/Sky definition, the actual unclean, unclothed and unfed definition. Why do you swallow such nonsense, nick?

I got my info from here [Link]
a report from the child poverty action group. endchildpoverty.org

Child poverty has no hard and fast definition...

from [Link]

The European Union's working definition of poverty is:

'Persons, families and groups of persons whose resources (material, cultural and social) are so limited as to exclude them from the minimum acceptable way of life in the Member State to which they belong'.

The UK Government, following the consultation on "Measuring Child Poverty", set out three approaches to examining and measuring child poverty in the UK over time:

Absolute low income: this indicator measures whether the poorest families are seeing their income rise in real terms. The level is fixed as equal to the relative low-income threshold for the baseline year of 1998-99 expressed in today's prices;

Relative low income: this measures whether the poorest families are keeping pace with the growth of incomes in the economy as a whole. This indicator measures the number of children living in households below 60 % of contemporary median equivalised household income. It compares the incomes of the less well off in a society to that of the 'typical household' so threshold changes as wealth of society changes ('moving poverty line'.

Material deprivation and low income combined: this indicator provides a wider measure of people's living standards. This indicator measures the number of children living in households that are both materially deprived and have an income below 70% of contemporary median equivalised household income. Material deprivation looks at living standards such as:

A holiday away from home at least one week a year with family
Swimming at least once a month
Friends around for tea / snack once a fortnight
Celebrations on special occasions e.g. birthdays
Going on a school trip at least once a term


According to our definition, children are living in severe poverty if they live in a household with an income of below 50 per cent of the median (after housing costs), and where both adults and children lack at least one basic necessity, and either adults or children or both groups lack at least two basic necessities.

So no mention of Sky/Broadband etc, however if you think that everyone has Sky /cable or broadband then you are blinkered.

[Link]
has some facts about those with home internet access..

While the majority of people in the UK have access to the internet, there are still 10 million people who do not.

Of these people, 4 million are are the most socially and economically disadvantaged in the country.

49% of people without access are in the lowest socio-economic groups (DE)


70% of people who live in social housing aren't online

It has to be said that this research was carried out in 2009 so not entirely accurate, but I'm sure it's still a fairly reasonable representation.
The ons state that 80% of households had internet access [Link] however it doesn't break it down into socio-economic groups.

Edited by nickgusset (21 Feb 2013 5.10pm)


Like I said, not actual poverty. That online bit doesn't refer to broadband then, no?

All the bits in bold are just plucked out of thin air, none define poverty.


No that was a bit at the end that tried to define material deprivation. The website brought together different definitions of what poverty is.
Perhaps you should get onto the respected charity and add your definition of poor = dirty, scruffy and no sky or broadband (I'm paraphrasing you there)

Respective. Not respected.

This is the trouble with your Piper'esque cut and pastes. I've picked you up on something you've put up on the site and then you claim it's a side issue.

Which different definition are we supposed to be looking at? Point it out for me and i'll tear that apart as not actual poverty too.

1. I cut and paste the information from the child poverty action group to save you looking it up.

2. If you read it, you would have seen the part that said the Government have defined 3 levels of poverty:

Absolute low income, Relative low income and Material deprivation and low income combined.

3. The charity defined poverty as thus, 'children are living in severe poverty if they live in a household with an income of below 50 per cent of the median (after housing costs), and where both adults and children lack at least one basic necessity, and either adults or children or both groups lack at least two basic necessities.'
So for arguments sake, I'll pick the charities definition.

So if none of these are by your definition poverty, what is your actual definition of poverty?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 22 Feb 13 3.24pm

Quote nickgusset at 22 Feb 2013 3.08pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 2.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 7.41pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 6.30pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 5.06pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 4.05pm

It is absolute bollocks that 25-30% of the children anywhere in the UK are in actual poverty, not the lack of PC/Broadband/Sky definition, the actual unclean, unclothed and unfed definition. Why do you swallow such nonsense, nick?

I got my info from here [Link]
a report from the child poverty action group. endchildpoverty.org

Child poverty has no hard and fast definition...

from [Link]

The European Union's working definition of poverty is:

'Persons, families and groups of persons whose resources (material, cultural and social) are so limited as to exclude them from the minimum acceptable way of life in the Member State to which they belong'.

The UK Government, following the consultation on "Measuring Child Poverty", set out three approaches to examining and measuring child poverty in the UK over time:

Absolute low income: this indicator measures whether the poorest families are seeing their income rise in real terms. The level is fixed as equal to the relative low-income threshold for the baseline year of 1998-99 expressed in today's prices;

Relative low income: this measures whether the poorest families are keeping pace with the growth of incomes in the economy as a whole. This indicator measures the number of children living in households below 60 % of contemporary median equivalised household income. It compares the incomes of the less well off in a society to that of the 'typical household' so threshold changes as wealth of society changes ('moving poverty line'.

Material deprivation and low income combined: this indicator provides a wider measure of people's living standards. This indicator measures the number of children living in households that are both materially deprived and have an income below 70% of contemporary median equivalised household income. Material deprivation looks at living standards such as:

A holiday away from home at least one week a year with family
Swimming at least once a month
Friends around for tea / snack once a fortnight
Celebrations on special occasions e.g. birthdays
Going on a school trip at least once a term


According to our definition, children are living in severe poverty if they live in a household with an income of below 50 per cent of the median (after housing costs), and where both adults and children lack at least one basic necessity, and either adults or children or both groups lack at least two basic necessities.

So no mention of Sky/Broadband etc, however if you think that everyone has Sky /cable or broadband then you are blinkered.

[Link]
has some facts about those with home internet access..

While the majority of people in the UK have access to the internet, there are still 10 million people who do not.

Of these people, 4 million are are the most socially and economically disadvantaged in the country.

49% of people without access are in the lowest socio-economic groups (DE)


70% of people who live in social housing aren't online

It has to be said that this research was carried out in 2009 so not entirely accurate, but I'm sure it's still a fairly reasonable representation.
The ons state that 80% of households had internet access [Link] however it doesn't break it down into socio-economic groups.

Edited by nickgusset (21 Feb 2013 5.10pm)


Like I said, not actual poverty. That online bit doesn't refer to broadband then, no?

All the bits in bold are just plucked out of thin air, none define poverty.


No that was a bit at the end that tried to define material deprivation. The website brought together different definitions of what poverty is.
Perhaps you should get onto the respected charity and add your definition of poor = dirty, scruffy and no sky or broadband (I'm paraphrasing you there)

Respective. Not respected.

This is the trouble with your Piper'esque cut and pastes. I've picked you up on something you've put up on the site and then you claim it's a side issue.

Which different definition are we supposed to be looking at? Point it out for me and i'll tear that apart as not actual poverty too.

1. I cut and paste the information from the child poverty action group to save you looking it up.

2. If you read it, you would have seen the part that said the Government have defined 3 levels of poverty:

Absolute low income, Relative low income and Material deprivation and low income combined.

3. The charity defined poverty as thus, 'children are living in severe poverty if they live in a household with an income of below 50 per cent of the median (after housing costs), and where both adults and children lack at least one basic necessity, and either adults or children or both groups lack at least two basic necessities.'
So for arguments sake, I'll pick the charities definition.

So if none of these are by your definition poverty, what is your actual definition of poverty?

1. You haven't saved me looking it up, you've just swamped us with irrelevant information. According to yourself.

2. I've told you many times I don't read cut and paste s***e in full.

3. Please define these "basic necessities" you mention.

4. I made my definition in my first post (I think) on this thread.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 22 Feb 13 3.30pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 3.24pm

Quote nickgusset at 22 Feb 2013 3.08pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 2.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 7.41pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 6.30pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 5.06pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 4.05pm

It is absolute bollocks that 25-30% of the children anywhere in the UK are in actual poverty, not the lack of PC/Broadband/Sky definition, the actual unclean, unclothed and unfed definition. Why do you swallow such nonsense, nick?

I got my info from here [Link]
a report from the child poverty action group. endchildpoverty.org

Child poverty has no hard and fast definition...

from [Link]

The European Union's working definition of poverty is:

'Persons, families and groups of persons whose resources (material, cultural and social) are so limited as to exclude them from the minimum acceptable way of life in the Member State to which they belong'.

The UK Government, following the consultation on "Measuring Child Poverty", set out three approaches to examining and measuring child poverty in the UK over time:

Absolute low income: this indicator measures whether the poorest families are seeing their income rise in real terms. The level is fixed as equal to the relative low-income threshold for the baseline year of 1998-99 expressed in today's prices;

Relative low income: this measures whether the poorest families are keeping pace with the growth of incomes in the economy as a whole. This indicator measures the number of children living in households below 60 % of contemporary median equivalised household income. It compares the incomes of the less well off in a society to that of the 'typical household' so threshold changes as wealth of society changes ('moving poverty line'.

Material deprivation and low income combined: this indicator provides a wider measure of people's living standards. This indicator measures the number of children living in households that are both materially deprived and have an income below 70% of contemporary median equivalised household income. Material deprivation looks at living standards such as:

A holiday away from home at least one week a year with family
Swimming at least once a month
Friends around for tea / snack once a fortnight
Celebrations on special occasions e.g. birthdays
Going on a school trip at least once a term


According to our definition, children are living in severe poverty if they live in a household with an income of below 50 per cent of the median (after housing costs), and where both adults and children lack at least one basic necessity, and either adults or children or both groups lack at least two basic necessities.

So no mention of Sky/Broadband etc, however if you think that everyone has Sky /cable or broadband then you are blinkered.

[Link]
has some facts about those with home internet access..

While the majority of people in the UK have access to the internet, there are still 10 million people who do not.

Of these people, 4 million are are the most socially and economically disadvantaged in the country.

49% of people without access are in the lowest socio-economic groups (DE)


70% of people who live in social housing aren't online

It has to be said that this research was carried out in 2009 so not entirely accurate, but I'm sure it's still a fairly reasonable representation.
The ons state that 80% of households had internet access [Link] however it doesn't break it down into socio-economic groups.

Edited by nickgusset (21 Feb 2013 5.10pm)


Like I said, not actual poverty. That online bit doesn't refer to broadband then, no?

All the bits in bold are just plucked out of thin air, none define poverty.


No that was a bit at the end that tried to define material deprivation. The website brought together different definitions of what poverty is.
Perhaps you should get onto the respected charity and add your definition of poor = dirty, scruffy and no sky or broadband (I'm paraphrasing you there)

Respective. Not respected.

This is the trouble with your Piper'esque cut and pastes. I've picked you up on something you've put up on the site and then you claim it's a side issue.

Which different definition are we supposed to be looking at? Point it out for me and i'll tear that apart as not actual poverty too.

1. I cut and paste the information from the child poverty action group to save you looking it up.

2. If you read it, you would have seen the part that said the Government have defined 3 levels of poverty:

Absolute low income, Relative low income and Material deprivation and low income combined.

3. The charity defined poverty as thus, 'children are living in severe poverty if they live in a household with an income of below 50 per cent of the median (after housing costs), and where both adults and children lack at least one basic necessity, and either adults or children or both groups lack at least two basic necessities.'
So for arguments sake, I'll pick the charities definition.

So if none of these are by your definition poverty, what is your actual definition of poverty?

1. You haven't saved me looking it up, you've just swamped us with irrelevant information. According to yourself.

2. I've told you many times I don't read cut and paste s***e in full.

3. Please define these "basic necessities" you mention.

4. I made my definition in my first post (I think) on this thread.


The information isn't irrelevent. You asked what poverty is, I looked up some definitions and posted them.

My own definition: Basic necessities: House, Food, Heat, Clothing, Hot Water, electricity/power.

Anyone who is lacking in any one of these could be defined as being in poverty.
You're just arguing for wind ups sake.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 22 Feb 13 3.44pm

Quote nickgusset at 22 Feb 2013 3.30pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 3.24pm

Quote nickgusset at 22 Feb 2013 3.08pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 2.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 7.41pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 6.30pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 5.06pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 4.05pm

It is absolute bollocks that 25-30% of the children anywhere in the UK are in actual poverty, not the lack of PC/Broadband/Sky definition, the actual unclean, unclothed and unfed definition. Why do you swallow such nonsense, nick?

I got my info from here [Link]
a report from the child poverty action group. endchildpoverty.org

Child poverty has no hard and fast definition...

from [Link]

The European Union's working definition of poverty is:

'Persons, families and groups of persons whose resources (material, cultural and social) are so limited as to exclude them from the minimum acceptable way of life in the Member State to which they belong'.

The UK Government, following the consultation on "Measuring Child Poverty", set out three approaches to examining and measuring child poverty in the UK over time:

Absolute low income: this indicator measures whether the poorest families are seeing their income rise in real terms. The level is fixed as equal to the relative low-income threshold for the baseline year of 1998-99 expressed in today's prices;

Relative low income: this measures whether the poorest families are keeping pace with the growth of incomes in the economy as a whole. This indicator measures the number of children living in households below 60 % of contemporary median equivalised household income. It compares the incomes of the less well off in a society to that of the 'typical household' so threshold changes as wealth of society changes ('moving poverty line'.

Material deprivation and low income combined: this indicator provides a wider measure of people's living standards. This indicator measures the number of children living in households that are both materially deprived and have an income below 70% of contemporary median equivalised household income. Material deprivation looks at living standards such as:

A holiday away from home at least one week a year with family
Swimming at least once a month
Friends around for tea / snack once a fortnight
Celebrations on special occasions e.g. birthdays
Going on a school trip at least once a term


According to our definition, children are living in severe poverty if they live in a household with an income of below 50 per cent of the median (after housing costs), and where both adults and children lack at least one basic necessity, and either adults or children or both groups lack at least two basic necessities.

So no mention of Sky/Broadband etc, however if you think that everyone has Sky /cable or broadband then you are blinkered.

[Link]
has some facts about those with home internet access..

While the majority of people in the UK have access to the internet, there are still 10 million people who do not.

Of these people, 4 million are are the most socially and economically disadvantaged in the country.

49% of people without access are in the lowest socio-economic groups (DE)


70% of people who live in social housing aren't online

It has to be said that this research was carried out in 2009 so not entirely accurate, but I'm sure it's still a fairly reasonable representation.
The ons state that 80% of households had internet access [Link] however it doesn't break it down into socio-economic groups.

Edited by nickgusset (21 Feb 2013 5.10pm)


Like I said, not actual poverty. That online bit doesn't refer to broadband then, no?

All the bits in bold are just plucked out of thin air, none define poverty.


No that was a bit at the end that tried to define material deprivation. The website brought together different definitions of what poverty is.
Perhaps you should get onto the respected charity and add your definition of poor = dirty, scruffy and no sky or broadband (I'm paraphrasing you there)

Respective. Not respected.

This is the trouble with your Piper'esque cut and pastes. I've picked you up on something you've put up on the site and then you claim it's a side issue.

Which different definition are we supposed to be looking at? Point it out for me and i'll tear that apart as not actual poverty too.

1. I cut and paste the information from the child poverty action group to save you looking it up.

2. If you read it, you would have seen the part that said the Government have defined 3 levels of poverty:

Absolute low income, Relative low income and Material deprivation and low income combined.

3. The charity defined poverty as thus, 'children are living in severe poverty if they live in a household with an income of below 50 per cent of the median (after housing costs), and where both adults and children lack at least one basic necessity, and either adults or children or both groups lack at least two basic necessities.'
So for arguments sake, I'll pick the charities definition.

So if none of these are by your definition poverty, what is your actual definition of poverty?

1. You haven't saved me looking it up, you've just swamped us with irrelevant information. According to yourself.

2. I've told you many times I don't read cut and paste s***e in full.

3. Please define these "basic necessities" you mention.

4. I made my definition in my first post (I think) on this thread.


The information isn't irrelevent. You asked what poverty is, I looked up some definitions and posted them.

My own definition: Basic necessities: House, Food, Heat, Clothing, Hot Water, electricity/power.

Anyone who is lacking in any one of these could be defined as being in poverty.
You're just arguing for wind ups sake.


Along with a load of other irrelevant crap, which you stated, when I addressed some of it.

Those I agree with, actual poverty. The figures will be nowhere near the percentages you quoted. (Again, all of this is in my first couple of posts on this)

You don't read people's replies, that's the problem. I'm not even arguing with you, I just don't believe the nonsense that you swallow with relish.

Edited by Stuk (22 Feb 2013 3.45pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 22 Feb 13 5.29pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 3.44pm

Quote nickgusset at 22 Feb 2013 3.30pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 3.24pm

Quote nickgusset at 22 Feb 2013 3.08pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 2.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 7.41pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 6.30pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Feb 2013 5.06pm

Quote Stuk at 21 Feb 2013 4.05pm

It is absolute bollocks that 25-30% of the children anywhere in the UK are in actual poverty, not the lack of PC/Broadband/Sky definition, the actual unclean, unclothed and unfed definition. Why do you swallow such nonsense, nick?

I got my info from here [Link]
a report from the child poverty action group. endchildpoverty.org

Child poverty has no hard and fast definition...

from [Link]

The European Union's working definition of poverty is:

'Persons, families and groups of persons whose resources (material, cultural and social) are so limited as to exclude them from the minimum acceptable way of life in the Member State to which they belong'.

The UK Government, following the consultation on "Measuring Child Poverty", set out three approaches to examining and measuring child poverty in the UK over time:

Absolute low income: this indicator measures whether the poorest families are seeing their income rise in real terms. The level is fixed as equal to the relative low-income threshold for the baseline year of 1998-99 expressed in today's prices;

Relative low income: this measures whether the poorest families are keeping pace with the growth of incomes in the economy as a whole. This indicator measures the number of children living in households below 60 % of contemporary median equivalised household income. It compares the incomes of the less well off in a society to that of the 'typical household' so threshold changes as wealth of society changes ('moving poverty line'.

Material deprivation and low income combined: this indicator provides a wider measure of people's living standards. This indicator measures the number of children living in households that are both materially deprived and have an income below 70% of contemporary median equivalised household income. Material deprivation looks at living standards such as:

A holiday away from home at least one week a year with family
Swimming at least once a month
Friends around for tea / snack once a fortnight
Celebrations on special occasions e.g. birthdays
Going on a school trip at least once a term


According to our definition, children are living in severe poverty if they live in a household with an income of below 50 per cent of the median (after housing costs), and where both adults and children lack at least one basic necessity, and either adults or children or both groups lack at least two basic necessities.

So no mention of Sky/Broadband etc, however if you think that everyone has Sky /cable or broadband then you are blinkered.

[Link]
has some facts about those with home internet access..

While the majority of people in the UK have access to the internet, there are still 10 million people who do not.

Of these people, 4 million are are the most socially and economically disadvantaged in the country.

49% of people without access are in the lowest socio-economic groups (DE)


70% of people who live in social housing aren't online

It has to be said that this research was carried out in 2009 so not entirely accurate, but I'm sure it's still a fairly reasonable representation.
The ons state that 80% of households had internet access [Link] however it doesn't break it down into socio-economic groups.

Edited by nickgusset (21 Feb 2013 5.10pm)


Like I said, not actual poverty. That online bit doesn't refer to broadband then, no?

All the bits in bold are just plucked out of thin air, none define poverty.


No that was a bit at the end that tried to define material deprivation. The website brought together different definitions of what poverty is.
Perhaps you should get onto the respected charity and add your definition of poor = dirty, scruffy and no sky or broadband (I'm paraphrasing you there)

Respective. Not respected.

This is the trouble with your Piper'esque cut and pastes. I've picked you up on something you've put up on the site and then you claim it's a side issue.

Which different definition are we supposed to be looking at? Point it out for me and i'll tear that apart as not actual poverty too.

1. I cut and paste the information from the child poverty action group to save you looking it up.

2. If you read it, you would have seen the part that said the Government have defined 3 levels of poverty:

Absolute low income, Relative low income and Material deprivation and low income combined.

3. The charity defined poverty as thus, 'children are living in severe poverty if they live in a household with an income of below 50 per cent of the median (after housing costs), and where both adults and children lack at least one basic necessity, and either adults or children or both groups lack at least two basic necessities.'
So for arguments sake, I'll pick the charities definition.

So if none of these are by your definition poverty, what is your actual definition of poverty?

1. You haven't saved me looking it up, you've just swamped us with irrelevant information. According to yourself.

2. I've told you many times I don't read cut and paste s***e in full.

3. Please define these "basic necessities" you mention.

4. I made my definition in my first post (I think) on this thread.


The information isn't irrelevent. You asked what poverty is, I looked up some definitions and posted them.

My own definition: Basic necessities: House, Food, Heat, Clothing, Hot Water, electricity/power.

Anyone who is lacking in any one of these could be defined as being in poverty.
You're just arguing for wind ups sake.


Along with a load of other irrelevant crap, which you stated, when I addressed some of it.

Those I agree with, actual poverty. The figures will be nowhere near the percentages you quoted. (Again, all of this is in my first couple of posts on this)

You don't read people's replies, that's the problem. I'm not even arguing with you, I just don't believe the nonsense that you swallow with relish.

Edited by Stuk (22 Feb 2013 3.45pm)


I'm pretty sure that a charity would not publicly release figures without getting them verified. The report I linked yesterday goes through child poverty figures region by region. Did you read it? Or have you just dismissed it out of hand?

 

Stuk Flag Top half 22 Feb 13 5.37pm

Quote nickgusset at 22 Feb 2013 5.29pm

I'm pretty sure that a charity would not publicly release figures without getting them verified. The report I linked yesterday goes through child poverty figures region by region. Did you read it? Or have you just dismissed it out of hand?


Firstly, they're not verified. They aren't even accurate, they're estimates.

Secondly it's a campaign, they're hardly going to shoot themselves in the foot by saying - you know what, we're way above poverty in actual terms the rest of the world uses.

Thirdly it's bollocks.

It is only based on the DWP figures on Households Below Average Income.

Below average income doesn't mean poverty, you could have zero income and still not technically be in poverty.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 22 Feb 13 6.04pm

Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 5.37pm

Quote nickgusset at 22 Feb 2013 5.29pm

I'm pretty sure that a charity would not publicly release figures without getting them verified. The report I linked yesterday goes through child poverty figures region by region. Did you read it? Or have you just dismissed it out of hand?


Firstly, they're not verified. They aren't even accurate, they're estimates.

Secondly it's a campaign, they're hardly going to shoot themselves in the foot by saying - you know what, we're way above poverty in actual terms the rest of the world uses.

Thirdly it's bollocks.

It is only based on the DWP figures on Households Below Average Income.

Below average income doesn't mean poverty, you could have zero income and still not technically be in poverty.

The Joseph Beds Rowntree foundation's research on child poverty comes up with similar figures. They have a very good reputation. Tis worth having a look through some of the reports on their website.
[Link]


Edited by nickgusset (22 Feb 2013 6.05pm)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 22 Feb 13 6.23pm

Just a thought, if someone who lives on their own in a two bedroom house and is on benefit is persuaded / coerced (delete as per political persuasion,) to move into a one bedroom house surely we are doing them a favour. Cheaper running costs and all that?

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 22 Feb 13 6.40pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 22 Feb 2013 6.23pm

Just a thought, if someone who lives on their own in a two bedroom house and is on benefit is persuaded / coerced (delete as per political persuasion,) to move into a one bedroom house surely we are doing them a favour. Cheaper running costs and all that?


Yep, it makes sense. But not every case will be that simple... which is where IDS's original plan fell down. it will be interesting to see what his department change to allow for the complicated cases.

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 23 Feb 13 7.06am

Quote Kermit8 at 22 Feb 2013 12.15pm

It was unregulated banks, greed and aggressive capitalism that has brought us to this pathetic point.

It wasn't just that. They p*ssed the north sea oil money up the wall. And they flogged off everything from british airways to the gas and water and blew the proceeds on a massive house price boom (which then bust). Before that they let most of British industry go to the wall in the 1979-81 recession, in the name of monetarism. Before that there was the civil war between the government and the unions which meant we needed an IMF bailout while the likes of Germany and Italy overtook us.

We've been in decline for donkeys years, mate, the bankers were just the latest muppets in a long line.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 23 Feb 13 8.17am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 23 Feb 2013 7.06am

Quote Kermit8 at 22 Feb 2013 12.15pm

It was unregulated banks, greed and aggressive capitalism that has brought us to this pathetic point.

It wasn't just that. They p*ssed the north sea oil money up the wall. And they flogged off everything from british airways to the gas and water and blew the proceeds on a massive house price boom (which then bust). Before that they let most of British industry go to the wall in the 1979-81 recession, in the name of monetarism. Before that there was the civil war between the government and the unions which meant we needed an IMF bailout while the likes of Germany and Italy overtook us.

We've been in decline for donkeys years, mate, the bankers were just the latest muppets in a long line.


Yep. Shocking really.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Stuk Flag Top half 25 Feb 13 6.17pm

I noted in a report over the weekend that will affect approx. 600,000 people. No chance 420,000 of those will be disabled as was intimated.

They also specifically exclude those that have an overnight carer from these changes.

Edited by Stuk (25 Feb 2013 6.17pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

johnfirewall Flag 02 Mar 13 10.28pm

Suppose the tennant should just be able to rent the spare room out privately?

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Mar 13 12.53am

Quote Stuk at 25 Feb 2013 6.17pm

I noted in a report over the weekend that will affect approx. 600,000 people. No chance 420,000 of those will be disabled as was intimated.

They also specifically exclude those that have an overnight carer from these changes.

Edited by Stuk (25 Feb 2013 6.17pm)


I think you may be wrong...
[Link]

Edited by nickgusset (10 Mar 2013 12.54am)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Mar 13 12.54am

Quote johnfirewall at 02 Mar 2013 10.28pm

Suppose the tennant should just be able to rent the spare room out privately?


I don't think that there are many housing associations or councils that allow this.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Mar 13 1.09am

It'll cost more to administer than it will save and be a PR nightmare waiting to happen (when the inevitable lawsuits occur over 'fostered occupants'.

Unrealistic, and unpractical, it looks like a 'tough on benefits' gesture to get the panties of the right wing wet.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 Mar 13 11.24pm

[Link]

worth reading the comments under IDS's article.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 06 Sep 14 8.10am

Good to see the commons scrap the spare room subsidy for those disabled or with children. Twas a nasty law from a nasty party.
Methinks the liberal party are aligning themselves with labour because they don't think the Tory cunds have a chance in the next election.

 

legaleagle Flag 06 Sep 14 9.53am

...and desperately trying to regain some voter credibility as not being simply minor bedfellows of the tories to try to avoid their vote getting decimated at the next election...

Edited by legaleagle (06 Sep 2014 9.55am)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Sep 14 10.06am

Quote legaleagle at 06 Sep 2014 9.53am

...and desperately trying to regain some voter credibility as not being simply minor bedfellows of the tories to try to avoid their vote getting decimated at the next election...

Edited by legaleagle (06 Sep 2014 9.55am)

Indeed !

 

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Bedroom tax