|
Victor:
1. Not sure why IM not handling the media briefings on transfer dealings worries you. IM is a negotiations / player personnel guy not necessarily a 'media' guy. Is media even in his job description? To my knowledge he didn't do the media bit at Cardiff and nor do a lot of DoF's. Whether or not leaving SP to basically handle all media responsibilities is the right thing for the club is a different question (which I'm not gonna answer) but IM not doing the media is not an indicator of a disfunctional board room. I could similarly argue that them sitting next to each other at home games is an indicator of a functional relationship - either way would be reading too much into something that might not be there.
My preference is for football people to front up on football and business people to front up on business. I simply find big egos and limelight hogs unattractive. There are many people who, say, could afford a Ferrari but wouldn't choose to drive one because it's not their style (or lack thereof.) But your point that having an owner who is ostentatious not necessarily indicating disharmony within the club is a reasonable one. My conclusion is that the board's activities as noted in my earlier posts is far from a reason for panic -- I agree with you, but it's not a great portent for sound management either. I guess we meet halfway (ish) on this point.
2. You can.... you might not be. One transfer window aside (the most recent one) there aren't any real indicators of 'cock-up'. We've come from recent administration and Championship relegation battles to the PL in a short space of time so some of the football decisions (pre-IM) must have been good ones.
I have repeatedly said that CPFC2010 have got more right than wrong, whatever I think of their individual style and approach. It would be churlish to put things that have worked out well down more to luck than judgment, but I would say that promotion "happened to us" rather than being the outcome of a sound plan, and that while they have done a brilliant job with the club off the pitch, good fortune has tended to somewhat inflate their contribution on the playing side. That is NOT to say they have been a disaster...they've just been owners on a learning curve with some successes and some failures who really have been very, very lucky with outcomes. Few clubs with our form in the second half of last season will ever find themselves in the Premiership the following year. But I think a lot of our supporters simply want to believe they walk on water.
3. It doesn't 'completely' prove your point at all. It may 'partly' prove your point but think you're reading too much into it again. To suggest we haven't performed well at all in the transfer market is a bit of an overstatement - basically our whole team is signings post-adminstration so that can't be true. At best you can argue that the Summer was a bit of a catastrophe (which it was) but even the summer had some silver linings (Guediora, Bannan and I think Gayle / Campana may come good long term). Also, to your earlier point, you have NO IDEA about whether or not SP is a good negotiator (for example). All you know is that he ran a good marketing business - what underlines that (marketing nouse, negotiation skills, recruitment etc) is unknown to you. I know somebody who worked under SP at TAG who said that, whilst they thought he was a bit of an arse, he was an excellent negotiator and man motivator. Greg Dyke is currently the CEO of the FA. I doubt they employed him because the BBC (his former CEO role) used to show MotD weekly or because he could spot that Sherlock would be a winner on a Saturday night - its probably more to do with his all-round intangible skillset.
Well, I run a marketing agency so unfortunately the nous that requires is very well known to me. And Parish probably has more of it than I do, too (as his business was more successful than mine now is. That said, my car is cooler than his.) In light of that, though, I am very well positioned to know to what degree marketing nous qualifies you to run a football club. Answer: not very. As to your other points, I respect your opinion but I read things a different way. I'm not sure what else I can say, other than I have already explained why at some length. As a general rule, for some the cup is half empty. For some, it's half full. Neither party is wrong and on this we agree to disagree.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|