This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote The White Horse at 09 Nov 2014 11.54pm
Quote serial thriller at 09 Nov 2014 10.31pm
Rarely heard someone hit the nail on the head as completely as this: [Link] Summarised, doesn't that basically boil down to "there's more to life than basic human desires, humanity should aspire to something better, be nice and chill out a bit". Hard to disagree with, but it's such a broad suggestion that it doesn't really inspire anything in particular. And most people wouldn't have both the patience and vocabulary to listen to him.
We live in a society where the ego is all. Individuality is celebrated, and collectivised activism is on a downward spiral. That is a general assertion, and there are counter-examples, but it's broadly true. Economically it has been called libertarianism, the liberation of capital from the monopoly of the state in to private hands, and it's summed up in the bullsh*t mantras of modern Capitalism: 'anyone can achieve anything if they work hard enough' and so on. To even suggest that unified progression is the only credible path for humankind is controversial. I recently read a list the Tory's put out of their successes since 2010 and it included a 20% reduction in union membership. A success!? The social antipathy towards any form of protest, demonstration or strike only emphasises that people working together to improve their lot is on the decrease. Brand is arguing, in a spiritual sense, that we must reject the sense of the ego, the individual, as key to particularly economic progress, and focus on working together for each other. Oh and just as an add on, for those claiming that there are no genuine left-wing alternatives given to Capitalism, I stumbled across this earlier. Not something I wholly agree with but nonetheless of interest... [Link]
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
|
Quote serial thriller at 10 Nov 2014 8.35pm
I actually disagree. We live in a society where the ego is all. Individuality is celebrated, and collectivised activism is on a downward spiral. That is a general assertion, and there are counter-examples, but it's broadly true. Economically it has been called libertarianism, the liberation of capital from the monopoly of the state in to private hands, and it's summed up in the bullsh*t mantras of modern Capitalism: 'anyone can achieve anything if they work hard enough' and so on. To even suggest that unified progression is the only credible path for humankind is controversial. I recently read a list the Tory's put out of their successes since 2010 and it included a 20% reduction in union membership. A success!? The social antipathy towards any form of protest, demonstration or strike only emphasises that people working together to improve their lot is on the decrease. Brand is arguing, in a spiritual sense, that we must reject the sense of the ego, the individual, as key to particularly economic progress, and focus on working together for each other. Ed Miliband used the word "together" 44 times in his conference speech. He leads a party which "believes that by the strength of our common endeavour we achieve more than we achieve alone". Even if Russell Brand was the only voice for collectivism, what has he actually suggested people do en masse? The main action I've heard him endorsing is abstention from voting, which achieves nothing. Quote serial thriller at 10 Nov 2014 8.35pm
Oh and just as an add on, for those claiming that there are no genuine left-wing alternatives given to Capitalism, I stumbled across this earlier. Not something I wholly agree with but nonetheless of interest... [Link] The problem with the far left is there's 50 different versions of it and none of them can even agree with each other. Ironic, given they purportedly support collectivism.
"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote The White Horse at 10 Nov 2014 10.44pm
Quote serial thriller at 10 Nov 2014 8.35pm
I actually disagree. We live in a society where the ego is all. Individuality is celebrated, and collectivised activism is on a downward spiral. That is a general assertion, and there are counter-examples, but it's broadly true. Economically it has been called libertarianism, the liberation of capital from the monopoly of the state in to private hands, and it's summed up in the bullsh*t mantras of modern Capitalism: 'anyone can achieve anything if they work hard enough' and so on. To even suggest that unified progression is the only credible path for humankind is controversial. I recently read a list the Tory's put out of their successes since 2010 and it included a 20% reduction in union membership. A success!? The social antipathy towards any form of protest, demonstration or strike only emphasises that people working together to improve their lot is on the decrease. Brand is arguing, in a spiritual sense, that we must reject the sense of the ego, the individual, as key to particularly economic progress, and focus on working together for each other. Ed Miliband used the word "together" 44 times in his conference speech. He leads a party which "believes that by the strength of our common endeavour we achieve more than we achieve alone". Even if Russell Brand was the only voice for collectivism, what has he actually suggested people do en masse? The main action I've heard him endorsing is abstention from voting, which achieves nothing. Quote serial thriller at 10 Nov 2014 8.35pm
Oh and just as an add on, for those claiming that there are no genuine left-wing alternatives given to Capitalism, I stumbled across this earlier. Not something I wholly agree with but nonetheless of interest... [Link] The problem with the far left is there's 50 different versions of it and none of them can even agree with each other. Ironic, given they purportedly support collectivism.
This conversation is not far from a real I've heard.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Nov 2014 11.14am
Quote TUX at 10 Nov 2014 8.14pm
Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 10 Nov 2014 5.44pm
Quote nickgusset at 08 Nov 2014 10.26am
It's the modern day socia economic practices that he is arguing against
Cowardice or reticence? All he can do is spread 'the truth' and hope that many follow. The bigger the following the brighter the future for many.
He looks like Jesus, but his choice of disciples (Wossy) leaves much to be desired. He a very naughty boy. Its ok, he'll be fixated on something else in a few years. The picture of him on the Anonymous demo showing his face says it all. A well meaning prick consumed by his own ego, who without making any real engagement in a subject has catapulted his ego to the forefront.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote TUX at 10 Nov 2014 8.14pm
Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 10 Nov 2014 5.44pm
Quote nickgusset at 08 Nov 2014 10.26am
It's the modern day socia economic practices that he is arguing against
Cowardice or reticence? All he can do is spread 'the truth' and hope that many follow. The bigger the following the brighter the future for many. Nothing is a cruel as the righteousness of innocence (Ignorance) with automatic weapons and a gospel of the truth. The problem is that people always think 'their answers' are the right answers. It'd be nice if humanity could move away from the idea of everyone having to follow the right truth, to letting people have their own life and own truth.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
As I said before he is Bell end in the first degree:
Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky. |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Part Time James at 11 Nov 2014 2.03pm
We seem to live in a society now where people who go round saying things like "let's redistribute all the wealth" and "let's write off personal debt" get a big round of applause. Everyone who goes "ok, now let's look at the logistics and economics of what you are suggesting" gets called a Nazi before they've even finished talking. It's very easy to say the things people want to hear. Coming up with working solutions is what should make someone a hero. Unfortunately, from what I can gather from Brand's babblings (admittedly I haven't read his book, just chatted to folk who have) is that he isn't really putting solutions out there. He's just putting his punchable face out there instead. Maybe I'm being harsh, but perhaps it was because his 'comedy' wasn't in demand any more and he needed another way to keep himself in the media. Basically its revolutionary politics, socialism and anarchism for people who don't read and want to identify emotionally with social justice, but not actually do anything about it really. Its a bit like someone releasing a charity single to help the starving, you're not really instigating change, ending poverty, you just posturing. If this was Mark Thomas or Mark Steele, I'd take it all more seriously, because the man, even if you hate him, has put the 'hours in', rather than turned up late to the party in his Prada Che Guervera T-Shirt. Its almost as if having gotten bored of being a drug addict Brand was all about being 'the dandy', then he was the sex symbol and now he's bored of that he's become the 'revolutionary', it'll be spiritual guru next. Read Peter Kropotkin or Emma Goldman instead.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote matt_himself at 11 Nov 2014 1.50pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 11 Nov 2014 12.51pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 11 Nov 2014 11.14am
Quote TUX at 10 Nov 2014 8.14pm
Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 10 Nov 2014 5.44pm
Quote nickgusset at 08 Nov 2014 10.26am
It's the modern day socia economic practices that he is arguing against
Cowardice or reticence? All he can do is spread 'the truth' and hope that many follow. The bigger the following the brighter the future for many.
He looks like Jesus, but his choice of disciples (Wossy) leaves much to be desired. He a very naughty boy. Its ok, he'll be fixated on something else in a few years. The picture of him on the Anonymous demo showing his face says it all. A well meaning prick consumed by his own ego, who without making any real engagement in a subject has catapulted his ego to the forefront. I agree except that I don't believe he is 'well meaning'. I believe he is selling a philosophy. He is packaging a vaguely leftish ideology in a nice coffee-table sized package for morons to think it is meaningful. You know its disturbing when I agree with you, and I think you're probably right, he's well meaning in his own head.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.