Quote legaleagle at 12 Mar 2015 12.12pm
Quote The Sash at 12 Mar 2015 11.17am
Quote legaleagle at 12 Mar 2015 11.07am
Plenty of people thought Saville and Rolf Harris were,as entertainers,entertaining...
Edited by legaleagle (12 Mar 2015 11.08am)
Which to what we are discussing is irrelevant.
Unless we are now starting to equate that the systematic and covert enabling of child rape over decades at the BBC is the same as someone getting a right hander in the canteen in how the BBC should conduct is internal disciplinary procedure?
Edited by The Sash (12 Mar 2015 11.20am)
Sorry,I must have misunderstood you when you wrote this:
"The rest of us seem just to go meh...life is to short to worry about the flaws and virtues of the TV presenting classes personality traits...they only have one prerogative and that's to be entertaining - and there are precious few who do it well".
I had understood you to be suggesting that we ignore personality flaws in our TV entertainers and simply focus on their worth as entertainers.And,of course Clarkson isn't remotely in their league flaw-wise,but as a general principle it'd be interesting to know precisely where the line should be drawn in terms of people ignoring flaws so long as someone is a good "entertainer".
Edited by legaleagle (12 Mar 2015 12.19pm)
I guess you did or I patently wasn't clear enough, given it was in response to whether Clarkson is 'snidey' or not and wasn't related to the various criminal activities of the stars of the BBC.
He could be the snidiest barsteward this side of London or a human being full of warmth and generosity - neither that important - they aren't paid (by us) for their off screen personalities and theres a distinction between personality trait and criminal behaviour- Clarkson being snidey, smug and up his own arse isn't yet a criminal offence (although if it ever is Piers Morgan will be looking at 30 years to life)
Drawing the Line ????
Ainsley Harriot taking homes pens from the set of Ready, Steady Cook isn't as bad as Clarkson thumping someone which isn't as bad as Saville f***ing children on the set of Jim'll Fix it and I guess the line is 'flexible' accordingly. Trouble is people tend to be selective with their outrage and don't apply common sense - Collymore as raised by Danny a perfect case in point.
Edited by The Sash (12 Mar 2015 1.03pm)
Edited by The Sash (12 Mar 2015 1.06pm)
Edited by The Sash (12 Mar 2015 1.07pm)
As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014
|