You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Red Nose Day
November 22 2026 2.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Red Nose Day


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
legaleagle Flag 16 Mar 15 10.32pm

Yes, good post IMO by Mr Palaceman. And if anyone wants to see some of those grand buildings built on blood money,go no further than Bristol or Liverpool as just two examples.

And re China, yes not all good reasons indeed,me thinks they are in it in large part for the raw materials..same old story,new player.

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 10.33pm)

 

imbored Flag UK 16 Mar 15 11.10pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 Mar 2015 10.32pm

Quote imbored at 16 Mar 2015 10.25pm

Quote sitdownstandup at 16 Mar 2015 8.12pm

Quote Mr Palaceman at 16 Mar 2015 1.03am

The thing is that IMO you will never be shown anything positive in the media when it comes to Africa. They are too used to showing hungry children with European doctors doing there best to help.

Africa is a huge and diverse continent, even on world maps it is made too look smaller than it really is even though it is the second biggest continent in the world, it is always shown as just slightly bigger than South America despite being twice the size.

It is made up of many, many different countries, with many different cultures and people of many different races and languages and shades of skin colour but it is all just lumped together.

As a continent, many of it's countries are some of the best places in the world to invest. With growth rates for some, three times that of any European country, and many with growth rates higher than China but you would never know it. The reason why China invests so heavily in many African countries is that it is a good investment for them for many reasons, although not all good IMO.

When you think of the benefits that many European countries have gained from the slave trade, echos of which can still be felt today in Africa and here, it is no wonder that we are able to call ourselves a developed country. All those pretty buildings you see when you go to Brugge were built on African blood and rubber, in an absolutely horrific manner.

I remember reading a report a few years ago where a top London accountancy firm were asked to calculate the financial benefits of the slave trade. That figure came back as around 700 trillion dollars, more than ten times greater than global GDP.

That is what African blood, sweat and tears has given to us and on this thread people moan about aid and debate why some and I say some Africa countries are poor.

It's like beating someone and stealing their clothes and then arguing over whether to give them back a shoe.

Edited by Mr Palaceman (16 Mar 2015 1.09am)


A well written, thoughtful and insightful post. Well done palaceman.


Agreed.


Na.....It reads like he's just watched, 'Soulman' on Blu-ray.

If the slave trade had never existed the situation would still be the same.....People conveniently forget all the black slavers as well.

Also the slave trade is a long long time ago. In the modern world it doesn't excuse the underlying problems within Africa societies.

Africa is coming....It's developing but it's still held back by core cultural problems related to institutional weakness, corruption and exploitation....Both internal and external.

Just like the famous shag scene in Soulman, referring back to historical wrongs as a cause for the present is just an illusion.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Mar 2015 10.41pm)

I don't think it's all or nothing really. Everything plays a part. People are good at keeping and hoarding wealth, families are good at it, nations are good at it. Just look at the class system. We are very often significantly defined by all that came many decades before us. Results of events we have no direct involvement with. That doesn't mean we can't do our best to elevate ourselves of course.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 16 Mar 15 11.26pm

Quote imbored at 16 Mar 2015 11.10pm

I don't think it's all or nothing really. Everything plays a part. People are good at keeping and hoarding wealth, families are good at it, nations are good at it. Just look at the class system. We are very often significantly defined by all that came many decades before us. Results of events we have no direct involvement with. That doesn't mean we can't do our best to elevate ourselves of course.


There's a certain truth to that. Though money is defined by what it obtains for the owner...It can't hold a continent back once it's in control of its own affairs.....And we are talking about wealth that in GB's case ended 181 years ago.

The point is slave trade or no, Africa would still be in the same mess it is now.....It's problems are deep rooted.

It's far too easy to point fingers at history and say 'there be the cause'. Frankly the thing that has held Africa back more than anything else is war and its corrupt leaders.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Mr Palaceman Flag 17 Mar 15 6.43am

Quote Stirlingsays at 16 Mar 2015 10.32pm

Quote imbored at 16 Mar 2015 10.25pm

Quote sitdownstandup at 16 Mar 2015 8.12pm

Quote Mr Palaceman at 16 Mar 2015 1.03am

The thing is that IMO you will never be shown anything positive in the media when it comes to Africa. They are too used to showing hungry children with European doctors doing there best to help.

Africa is a huge and diverse continent, even on world maps it is made too look smaller than it really is even though it is the second biggest continent in the world, it is always shown as just slightly bigger than South America despite being twice the size.

It is made up of many, many different countries, with many different cultures and people of many different races and languages and shades of skin colour but it is all just lumped together.

As a continent, many of it's countries are some of the best places in the world to invest. With growth rates for some, three times that of any European country, and many with growth rates higher than China but you would never know it. The reason why China invests so heavily in many African countries is that it is a good investment for them for many reasons, although not all good IMO.

When you think of the benefits that many European countries have gained from the slave trade, echos of which can still be felt today in Africa and here, it is no wonder that we are able to call ourselves a developed country. All those pretty buildings you see when you go to Brugge were built on African blood and rubber, in an absolutely horrific manner.

I remember reading a report a few years ago where a top London accountancy firm were asked to calculate the financial benefits of the slave trade. That figure came back as around 700 trillion dollars, more than ten times greater than global GDP.

That is what African blood, sweat and tears has given to us and on this thread people moan about aid and debate why some and I say some Africa countries are poor.

It's like beating someone and stealing their clothes and then arguing over whether to give them back a shoe.

Edited by Mr Palaceman (16 Mar 2015 1.09am)


A well written, thoughtful and insightful post. Well done palaceman.


Agreed.


Na.....It reads like he's just watched, 'Soulman' on Blu-ray.

If the slave trade had never existed the situation would still be the same.....People conveniently forget all the black slavers as well.

Also the slave trade is a long long time ago. In the modern world it doesn't excuse the underlying problems within Africa societies.

Africa is coming....It's developing but it's still held back by core cultural problems related to institutional weakness, corruption and exploitation....Both internal and external.

Just like the famous shag scene in Soulman, referring back to historical wrongs as a cause for the present is just an illusion.

Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Mar 2015 10.41pm)


Soulman is not my style stirlingsays, however I do agree that history should not be given as an excuse for a person or a people for a lack of progression but to say that the history of African slavery has no effect today is just blinkered IMO.

Many in this country can look back and trace their history. I am fortunate in that I can trace my family history back more than a thousand years through my family name, written and oral history and knowledge of self is key, if you are to develop a strong future. It is important to know where you have come from and who you are.

The effects of this knowledge can clearly be seen even the recent history of this country. We have a collective sense of who we are and this comes from the knowledge of our past and a shared historical experience.

The “Stiff upper lip”, “The spirit of the Blitz”. “Britain’s, never, never, never shall be slaves” etc. These are ideas that some today would say are what it is to be British and there is a thought that we alone have given these values as a gift to the world. I have no real problem with that, as these perceived values rub off on the people and sometimes a sense of justice will develop from this type of collective thought. However, this way of thinking can also lead to feelings of superiority.

The perception we have of ourselves today comes from the knowledge, true or perceived, of our understanding of past history. This leads to a collective “self-esteem”.

In order for a person, nation or people to become truly great, discipline is required, discipline leads to self-respect and self-respect leads to courage. Courage is what is required to be great.

In contrast, for slavery to be viable you must first destroy the slave’s self-esteem and history. The link that the slave has to their common thought and historic past must first be eradicated. Even their names must be taken and replaced with a name of the ”masters” choosing and all self-worth must be eroded. If a slave has any link to a better past they can never be truly enslaved as they would always draw on that past as an example and blueprint of what they can be as opposed to what their enslavers want them to be in order to exploit them.

Acts of violence against slaves are used in order to placate, humiliate and subdue. The men were often beaten and killed in front of their women to imprint on the minds of those women that their men could not help them and were worthless.

This process was systematic and carried out for more than four hundred years in colonial Africa. Once implemented, it is almost impossible to undo.

The modern day consequence of this is a low, historical self-esteem and when you look back at your history as one of control and subjugation, it is all the harder to break free of the mental chains that often bind tighter and longer than the physical chains of bondship.

Obviously, this not the case of all Africans but as I said in my earlier post, Africa is often referred to as one big lump that is all the same, hence comments like “Blacks always f”ck it up”.

This is not to say that this should be used as an excuse for not striving for better a future, or that nothing can be done, or even believing that a better future is not possible because of a historical disadvantage, no matter how great.

However, when you look at the history of Africans, wherever they may be in the world, there is a theme and that is, whenever someone shows the courage to be great, they are stopped by those who have the most to lose from their awareness of self, as an awareness of self, leads to the desire for self-determination and self-determination leads to a loss of control for those that would seek to exploit, control and humiliate in order to benefit selfishly.

Very obvious examples of Africans who have struggled against those who wish to exploit, are, of course, the likes of Martin Luther King (assassinated), Malcolm X (assassinated), Marcus Garvey, (Imprisoned). Paul Bogle (Hung by the then British Governor of Jamaica, who was later disgraced), Steve Biko (tortured for twenty two hours and beaten to death) and of course Nelson Mandela (imprisoned for 27 years). I could go on.

Those mentioned above, whether you agree with the way they went about it or not, have something in common. An overwhelming desire to decide their own future and the courage to see out that dream, no matter what the personal cost was to themselves.

And those who wish they were never born make comments like, S.P.A.D.E. and Black people always f@ck up etc.

The effects of colonial slavery in the modern era are IMO, evident even on this forum, in the attitudes of the posters on both sides of the debate. The minute there is a story about black people, good or bad; there are those who are the first to post. It may be “Racism Train Bloke Annoying Me”, or The African Cup of Nations, Jamaican independence, a black football federation, acts of racism by fans of other clubs, “Red Nose Day” and personally I was always switch off Red Nose Day programing. I don’t like the format or portrayal of Africa on those shows. I do not donate and chose other means to make a difference.

But for me, I don’t think this thread was ever about Red Nose Day as such. It was an excuse to try and reinforce the old colonial stereotypes of old, by those who are fearful that everything is changing and we shouldn’t allow those we once ruled and in some cases still have power over to be free think or do things for themselves, in case they make mistakes or even God forbid get it right.

The effects of slavery do still exist, in the minds of the decendants, of both the enslavers and the once enslaved.

 


"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead"

Stan Laurel

Stuk Flag Top half 17 Mar 15 2.38pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 9.26pm

Quote Stuk at 16 Mar 2015 4.02pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 9.45am

The Aussie map of the world can also be interesting in terms of a different perspective from the traditional Euro-centric way of seeing the world,with Europe is a central position..

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (16 Mar 2015 9.46am)


It's not Europe that's central, it's Britain, and the reason is the Prime meridian.


Yes,and that was because at the time we were the dominant world power and took the view the centre of things was here as the natural order of things...ie all time based around variations of GMT,GMT being the standard reference point,and not because scientifically it had to be...


But it does work out well scientifically too. If it wasn't, it would've changed by now.

 


Optimistic as ever

reborn 17 Mar 15 2.42pm

Quote legaleagle at 16 Mar 2015 9.30pm

Quote imbored at 16 Mar 2015 1.21pm

Quote reborn at 16 Mar 2015 12.49pm

At least they are doing something, more than 99% of people on this board, including the OP?

I'd gladly be disproved of that by the way.

Exactly. I've worked with charities and it's never those doing charity work that slag off people raising money for other causes. So you wind up with those not helping their neighbour or anyone elses for that matter, moaning about amazing and often life saving efforts.

I've worked for a charity as a full time employee and some people seem to think that should also involve working full-time for nothing.The reality is,yes admin and staff costs eat up part of donations but most charity workers work for less than equivalent jobs in the private sector or even in the state sector.

Exactly.

Much easier to sit on your ass doing nothing, and moaning.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 17 Mar 15 3.12pm

Quote nickgusset at 16 Mar 2015 3.43pm

Jamie... [Link]

This sums up a large part of what charity is to me, a means by which social band aids are applied to problems that are the responsibility of the state to address directly. Instead its fobbed off onto charity, peoples guilt is esurred by giving a few quid now and then, and everyone pats themselves on the back - whilst directors of those charities earn very large salaries.

I don't care if 'they take less' than they would in another field, the reality is at the top the wages are staggering, and well beyond what could be said to be sufficient for 'a luxurious life'. Self justification. If you'd 'far more' as a CEO elsewhere, why not take that CEO job, and give half the difference (or the difference) to charity?

The audacity of Comic Relief and Live Aid, where you have people earning fortunes asking people to give, whilst those people attempt to boost their profile on the back of some 's**t entertainment skit' or 'knock off crappy single' represents one of the lowest forms of exploitation in history.

And I hate the attitude of the once a year f**king Charity 'shennigans' where someone will 'do something crazy' like wear a dress and harras people into giving them money (they themselves rarely actually give, same as the c**ts on Comic Relief - giving their 'precious time'.

F**k comic relief and all of those 'high profile' charities full of c-list scum looking to become b-list scum, and the s**ts who just 'give their time' and demand we give the money: f**k ALS Ice Bucket Challenges - We know you just want to feel special.

F**k them all.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 17 Mar 15 3.17pm

You forgot to mention their needless choice to all have expensive central London offices. Which they fit out with, generally, the most expensive specification they can rather than the most practical and cost effective.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 17 Mar 15 3.25pm

After all its the 'charity workers' who make the difference right, not the people that they're paid to extract the money from.

Lets hear it for the Charity workers, giving their time so heroically when they could be working for Arse.com on 5-10% more for 50 hour weeks, and no job security.

Heaven forbid if the little people who actually give the money complain, tsk tsk.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 17 Mar 15 4.58pm

Soulman has a famous scene???!!?!?!?!

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

legaleagle Flag 17 Mar 15 8.50pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 17 Mar 2015 3.25pm

After all its the 'charity workers' who make the difference right, not the people that they're paid to extract the money from.

Lets hear it for the Charity workers, giving their time so heroically when they could be working for Arse.com on 5-10% more for 50 hour weeks, and no job security.

Heaven forbid if the little people who actually give the money complain, tsk tsk.

Always good to read a stream of invective from someone who hasn't actually got a clue about average reality on the ground and is so uncharitably consumed by bile.Nobody minds "little people" complaining.Its narrow minded people rather...

I'm against Comic Relief etc for many of the reasons given by others.I also agree that charities play a negative role in that they are an excuse for the state not to fund and to cut provision.I also get sick of people accosting me daily trying to get me to sign up to a direct debit for well-known charities.But do note those people are not employees of the charities in question.

But, the average charity is one you never will have heard of.It's small and runs and survives on a shoestring with help from dedicated staff flogging their guts out because they believe in what they are doing and being paid a relatively low salary (I earned about £10k a year for a highly skilled job) including most of those in senior positions at such charities.That doesn't mean they should be particularly praised.Rather,just not slagged off needlessly.

So,by all means slag off Red Nose Day (I hate it personally and the celebs and avoid it like the plague ) and a few high profile examples of charities where people earn a lot at the top but try not to let blind prejudice cloud you to quite such an extent.


Edited by legaleagle (17 Mar 2015 11.04pm)

 

reborn 18 Mar 15 8.41am

And.....at least they are doing SOMETHING

Which is more than 99% of this board.

#justsaying

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 9.41am

Quote reborn at 18 Mar 2015 8.41am

And.....at least they are doing SOMETHING

Which is more than 99% of this board.

#justsaying

I'm going out on a limb, but I'd say that more than 1% of people have given money to charity or make donations, or give money in some way.

I bought a 1000 wheelchair for a friend recently, because the NHS wouldn't pay for it (she needs a special wheelchair, because she has a disease that leaves her physically incapable of wheeling herself). I also used to volunteer teaching convicts basic IT skills, and support a number of charitable causes.

We can all make a difference without someone shoving buckets under our noses, boosting their flagging pop careers or doing something 'zany' or running a marathon they'd have run anyhow. You're not doing anything special.

I'm not against charity per se, but the sanctimonious righteousness that seems to come with certain causes and the persistant need to shove them in peoples faces when they don't support 'their annual zany stunts'.

Things like Comic Relief, Live Aid etc are a parasite that debases us, as a society. Pictures of Staving Children Sell Records and all that (because f**k knows charity singles are almost certainly s**t records).

I don't have a problem with people who directly work for a charity either. Its the idea that somehow working in 'Charity' as a company, has any special value.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 9.45am

Quote legaleagle at 17 Mar 2015 8.50pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 17 Mar 2015 3.25pm

After all its the 'charity workers' who make the difference right, not the people that they're paid to extract the money from.

Lets hear it for the Charity workers, giving their time so heroically when they could be working for Arse.com on 5-10% more for 50 hour weeks, and no job security.

Heaven forbid if the little people who actually give the money complain, tsk tsk.

Always good to read a stream of invective from someone who hasn't actually got a clue about average reality on the ground and is so uncharitably consumed by bile.Nobody minds "little people" complaining.Its narrow minded people rather...

I'm against Comic Relief etc for many of the reasons given by others.I also agree that charities play a negative role in that they are an excuse for the state not to fund and to cut provision.I also get sick of people accosting me daily trying to get me to sign up to a direct debit for well-known charities.But do note those people are not employees of the charities in question.

But, the average charity is one you never will have heard of.It's small and runs and survives on a shoestring with help from dedicated staff flogging their guts out because they believe in what they are doing and being paid a relatively low salary (I earned about £10k a year for a highly skilled job) including most of those in senior positions at such charities.That doesn't mean they should be particularly praised.Rather,just not slagged off needlessly.

So,by all means slag off Red Nose Day (I hate it personally and the celebs and avoid it like the plague ) and a few high profile examples of charities where people earn a lot at the top but try not to let blind prejudice cloud you to quite such an extent.

Edited by legaleagle (17 Mar 2015 11.04pm)

By Charity Workers I mean those who work for the 'Company' of charity, the executives, project managers, directors, marketers or the fund raising executives, not the people in the front line actually doing the work, such as a Macmillian Nurse.

If your job, is paid, to raise money for charity, you're nothing special. Just a mook in a job, pretending that somehow you're making a difference - Unless of course you're giving a percentage of your wages to that charity. But I doubt it.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

legaleagle Flag 18 Mar 15 10.04am

Many of what you think of as charity workers are not "employed" by charities,but are people "employed" on a casual basis for low remuneration by companies used by big charities (a small minority of actual overall charities) raising very large scale funds,to raise money,a million miles away from the "average" charity.Hence the difference between the people trying to get you to sign up for a direct debit with a major charity and the person (often a volunteer) standing with a tin in your high street.

In my experience,the bulk of people actually employed by charities are not primarily involved in fund raising but rather in administering and/or directly providing the "service/help" that the charity in question gives,be it veterinary treatment/refuges for abandoned animals,free legal advice for people who couldn't otherwise afford it, small local social services/mental heath support charities, and a million other things.If you are going to have the service,its not possible without individuals administering and providing it.It often requires more than just a group of untrained volunteers going "out there" including,heaven forbid, small scale "executives" and"project managers" and,to make it possible in the first place small scale "fund raisers".

There are those who might think working for perhaps a third of the going rate they could get elsewhere raising funds or working generally in an average charity might not be a lot different to "giving some of your wages to charity", rather than being a "mook" "pretending"

Edited by legaleagle (18 Mar 2015 10.32am)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 10.32am

Quote legaleagle at 18 Mar 2015 10.04am

Many of what you think of as charity workers are not "employed" by charities,but are people "employed" on a casual basis for low remuneration by companies used by big charities (a small minority of actual overall charities) raising very large scale funds,to raise money,a million miles away from the "average" charity.Hence the difference between the people trying to get you to sign up for a direct debit with a major charity and the person (often a volunteer) standing with a tin in your high street.

No problem with the volunteer, but those who are paid, and hang around on the streets trying to 'push' direct debits are just working stiffs, doing nothing special other than just doing a s**ty job like most of us. They're nothing special just because its a 'charity'.

I work in Defense, earning less than I would in the private market, but that doesn't have any other value other than me doing a well paid job. There is no extra nobility, I'm not keeping the country safe, or protecting our citizens, I'm just doing my job.

Quote legaleagle at 18 Mar 2015 10.04am

The bulk of people actually employed by charities are not primarily involved in fund raising but rather in administering and/or directly providing the "service/help" that the charity in question gives,be it a refuge for abandoned animals,free legal advice for people who couldn't otherwise afford it, St John's Ambulance,meals for old people, charities like MIND, NSPCC and a million other things.If you are going to have the service,its not possible without individuals administering and providing it.

They're good people in my book, doing work, that I generally believe should shame the state. A respite care nurse is a nurse, irrespective who pays them though, doesn't really matter if your a NHS or McMillian Nurse.

Quote legaleagle at 18 Mar 2015 10.04am

There are those who might think working for perhaps a third of the going rate they could get elsewhere raising funds in an average small charity might not be a lot different to "giving some of your wages to charity", rather than being a "mook" pretending".

Edited by legaleagle (18 Mar 2015 10.18am)

This last part applies very much to me. I could work in charity and do good, but by way of what I can command elsewhere, I'm much better off working elsewhere and contributing money to charitable causes (as are the charities), and I think that's a significant fact. For example, if your the CEO of Oxfam, why not work for three times as much in the private sector and then donate a third of that directly to Oxfam.

Similarly, how much administration and employees does a charity directly need, does it really need to spend 70% of its income on maintaining its existence, so that only 30% of donations are channeled out? Why are people working for some charities drawing very large salaries, far in excess of the cost of a very nice lifestyle?

A lot of these organisations I'd hazard have become overly focused on their own internal structure at the cost of causes they support.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

legaleagle Flag 18 Mar 15 10.42am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Mar 2015 10.32am

Quote legaleagle at 18 Mar 2015 10.04am

Many of what you think of as charity workers are not "employed" by charities,but are people "employed" on a casual basis for low remuneration by companies used by big charities (a small minority of actual overall charities) raising very large scale funds,to raise money,a million miles away from the "average" charity.Hence the difference between the people trying to get you to sign up for a direct debit with a major charity and the person (often a volunteer) standing with a tin in your high street.

No problem with the volunteer, but those who are paid, and hang around on the streets trying to 'push' direct debits are just working stiffs, doing nothing special other than just doing a s**ty job like most of us. They're nothing special just because its a 'charity'.

I work in Defense, earning less than I would in the private market, but that doesn't have any other value other than me doing a well paid job. There is no extra nobility, I'm not keeping the country safe, or protecting our citizens, I'm just doing my job.

Quote legaleagle at 18 Mar 2015 10.04am

The bulk of people actually employed by charities are not primarily involved in fund raising but rather in administering and/or directly providing the "service/help" that the charity in question gives,be it a refuge for abandoned animals,free legal advice for people who couldn't otherwise afford it, St John's Ambulance,meals for old people, charities like MIND, NSPCC and a million other things.If you are going to have the service,its not possible without individuals administering and providing it.

They're good people in my book, doing work, that I generally believe should shame the state. A respite care nurse is a nurse, irrespective who pays them though, doesn't really matter if your a NHS or McMillian Nurse.

Quote legaleagle at 18 Mar 2015 10.04am

There are those who might think working for perhaps a third of the going rate they could get elsewhere raising funds in an average small charity might not be a lot different to "giving some of your wages to charity", rather than being a "mook" pretending".

Edited by legaleagle (18 Mar 2015 10.18am)

This last part applies very much to me. I could work in charity and do good, but by way of what I can command elsewhere, I'm much better off working elsewhere and contributing money to charitable causes (as are the charities), and I think that's a significant fact. For example, if your the CEO of Oxfam, why not work for three times as much in the private sector and then donate a third of that directly to Oxfam.

Similarly, how much administration and employees does a charity directly need, does it really need to spend 70% of its income on maintaining its existence, so that only 30% of donations are channeled out? Why are people working for some charities drawing very large salaries, far in excess of the cost of a very nice lifestyle?

A lot of these organisations I'd hazard have become overly focused on their own internal structure at the cost of causes they support.



You make a choice.But,that doesn't mean its right to slag off those that decide to spend time working for a charity,rather than your model.This discussion didn't arise from charity workers seeking praise for being altruistic,but rather from them being inappropriately generically slagged as a group

If everyone works in the private sector and donates large sums,who will be left with the requisite skills to opt for instead working necessarily full time for a third of the going rate to actually enable service provision to take place?..its a necessary thing...which doesn't mean a whole rang of choices including your suggested one are not valid as well as alternatives.

In some instances,ie disaster relief,its very hard not to have very large overheads,ie getting relief supplies to somewhere like Vanuatu.So not all large overheads equate to "fat cat" charity workers creaming off donations to enjoy a very comfortable lifestyle.

You also generalise too much about charities, most of which are very small,your (not necessarily invalid) prejudices against the some of the "big boys".Most charities are far too small,being able to afford to employ full-time only a small number of people,to have anything like the issues your posts might suggest are the general situation.

Edited by legaleagle (18 Mar 2015 10.48am)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Mar 15 10.54am

Quote legaleagle at 18 Mar 2015 10.42am

You make a choice.But,that doesn't mean its right to slag off those that decide to spend time working for a charity,rather than your model.This discussion didn't arise from charity workers seeking praise for being altruistic,but rather from them being inappropriately generically slagged as a group

If everyone works in the private sector and donates large sums,who will be left with the requisite skills to opt for instead working necessarily full time for a third of the going rate to actually enable service provision to take place?..its a necessary thing...which doesn't mean a whole rang of choices including your suggested one are not valid as well as alternatives.

You also generalise to charities, most of which are very small,your (not necessarily invalid) prejudices against the some of the "big boys".Most charities are far too small,being able to afford to employ full-time only a small number of people,to have anything like the issues your posts might suggest are the general situation.

Edited by legaleagle (18 Mar 2015 10.43am)

Please, if you're working raising funds for charity, you're coercing people to give you money they otherwise didn't want to.

Big charities use their financial capacity to corner the market in 'donations', by flooding areas with 'paid fund raisers'.

As I said before, there is working for charity, and working in charity. And my problem is those people who work in charity, and profess somekind of almost special status like they're doing anything other than just a job.

But generally when I talk about Charities, I'm talking about the 'Big Business Charities' who's aim generally seems to be earning as much revenue as possible, cornering the 'donations' market.

Which tend to also be the ones spending lots of money on executives, advertising, professional fund raising executives, event planners and co-ordinators.

If only 30p in every pound is going to the actual cause, you'd be better off giving that quid to the afflicted directly.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 18 Mar 15 11.44am

I always loved the Sean Lock comment.

We all know the charity collecters who accost you with a clipboard to get money as Charity Muggers- or chuggers.

He suggests chunts is a much better term hahaha

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 18 Mar 15 11.44am

And Lenny Henry is still NOT Funny.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Red Nose Day