You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Victorian poverty
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Victorian poverty


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
johnfirewall Flag 05 Apr 15 2.19pm

"Children in 2015 should not be hungry and coming to school with no socks on and no coats - some children are living in Victorian conditions - in the inner cities," said one unnamed teacher.

[Link]

Nick?

To be fair a teacher at my Mum's school sorted new clothes for a kid, who then came in the next day with the same old ones. The father was a scumbag by all accounts and had likely sold them, and not to put food on the table. (Pre-coalition BTW)

Edited by johnfirewall (05 Apr 2015 2.23pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Apr 15 2.53pm

Wrong union. But what the report says is about right.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 05 Apr 15 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Apr 15 4.20pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


Go on...

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 05 Apr 15 4.33pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 4.20pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


Go on...

I will qualify the "s***ty" bit. Poor would have been better. The reality is that too many families (both poor and wealthy) don't have the skills to raise a family if it doesn't involve spending money. So when the money stops, people cannot/will not adapt.

Cooking skills, haberdashery etc have almost vanished in a single generation. By today's measure, I grew up in poverty for a large part of my childhood. having meat with a meal would besides a Sunday chicken usually be offal or pigs trotters until I was 12 and got a job on a farm.

Instead of throwing money at the problem improve life skills.
Also bearing in mind the survey was for a teaching Union, the result is Hadley surprising.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

matt_himself Flag Matataland 05 Apr 15 5.10pm

A union issues the findings of a survey of its members denouncing the state of 'Cameron's Britain' during an election. What could their motives be?

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

chris123 Flag hove actually 05 Apr 15 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Apr 15 7.06pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.


Really? Do you think people do this deliberately?
As such, teachers are required to report this sort of thing and they do. However, are you expecting children to be taken away from their families because the family have to choose between food or clothes.
Next you'll be proposing we bring back workhouses.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 05 Apr 15 7.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.06pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.


Really? Do you think people do this deliberately?
As such, teachers are required to report this sort of thing and they do. However, are you expecting children to be taken away from their families because the family have to choose between food or clothes.
Next you'll be proposing we bring back workhouses.


Well not meeting a child's basic needs is neglect - and a responsible adult, who is passive and does nothing, is complicit in my view. I can't believe you don't agree.

 

Ibanez 05 Apr 15 7.25pm

Lets be honest here, if a child doesn't have a pair of socks then the responsibility lies with the parents.

 

elgrande Flag bedford 05 Apr 15 7.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.06pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.


Really? Do you think people do this deliberately?
As such, teachers are required to report this sort of thing and they do. However, are you expecting children to be taken away from their families because the family have to choose between food or clothes.
Next you'll be proposing we bring back workhouses.


Or clothes for their children,or fags for themselves.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Apr 15 7.39pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.06pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.


Really? Do you think people do this deliberately?
As such, teachers are required to report this sort of thing and they do. However, are you expecting children to be taken away from their families because the family have to choose between food or clothes.
Next you'll be proposing we bring back workhouses.


Well not meeting a child's basic needs is neglect - and a responsible adult, who is passive and does nothing, is complicit in my view. I can't believe you don't agree.


I do agree. However if you cannot afford to is it still neglect?
People are too quick to judge.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 05 Apr 15 7.51pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.39pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.06pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.


Really? Do you think people do this deliberately?
As such, teachers are required to report this sort of thing and they do. However, are you expecting children to be taken away from their families because the family have to choose between food or clothes.
Next you'll be proposing we bring back workhouses.


Well not meeting a child's basic needs is neglect - and a responsible adult, who is passive and does nothing, is complicit in my view. I can't believe you don't agree.


I do agree. However if you cannot afford to is it still neglect?
People are too quick to judge.

I doubt you can price the cost of neglecting a child's basic needs, so of course it's neglect, people are too quick to adopt a slopey shoulder.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Apr 15 8.20pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.51pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.39pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.06pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.


Really? Do you think people do this deliberately?
As such, teachers are required to report this sort of thing and they do. However, are you expecting children to be taken away from their families because the family have to choose between food or clothes.
Next you'll be proposing we bring back workhouses.


Well not meeting a child's basic needs is neglect - and a responsible adult, who is passive and does nothing, is complicit in my view. I can't believe you don't agree.


I do agree. However if you cannot afford to is it still neglect?
People are too quick to judge.

I doubt you can price the cost of neglecting a child's basic needs, so of course it's neglect, people are too quick to adopt a slopey shoulder.


And some people genuinely struggle to get by financially. Do you dispute this? Or do you think it's made up?

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 05 Apr 15 8.29pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 8.20pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.51pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.39pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.06pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.


Really? Do you think people do this deliberately?
As such, teachers are required to report this sort of thing and they do. However, are you expecting children to be taken away from their families because the family have to choose between food or clothes.
Next you'll be proposing we bring back workhouses.


Well not meeting a child's basic needs is neglect - and a responsible adult, who is passive and does nothing, is complicit in my view. I can't believe you don't agree.


I do agree. However if you cannot afford to is it still neglect?
People are too quick to judge.

I doubt you can price the cost of neglecting a child's basic needs, so of course it's neglect, people are too quick to adopt a slopey shoulder.


And some people genuinely struggle to get by financially. Do you dispute this? Or do you think it's made up?

Some people do struggle yes. In a way it should be so I.e. Anyone on long term benefits should struggle. That doesn't mean people shouldn't be able to afford food but equally it doesn't mean that they should have the life of Reilly.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

chris123 Flag hove actually 05 Apr 15 8.53pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 8.20pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.51pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.39pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.06pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.


Really? Do you think people do this deliberately?
As such, teachers are required to report this sort of thing and they do. However, are you expecting children to be taken away from their families because the family have to choose between food or clothes.
Next you'll be proposing we bring back workhouses.


Well not meeting a child's basic needs is neglect - and a responsible adult, who is passive and does nothing, is complicit in my view. I can't believe you don't agree.


I do agree. However if you cannot afford to is it still neglect?
People are too quick to judge.

I doubt you can price the cost of neglecting a child's basic needs, so of course it's neglect, people are too quick to adopt a slopey shoulder.


And some people genuinely struggle to get by financially. Do you dispute this? Or do you think it's made up?


You seem to think if someone is hard up, not providing for a child's basic needs might not be neglect - I cannot adequately express how much I disagree with you.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Apr 15 9.01pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 8.53pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 8.20pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.51pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.39pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.06pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.


Really? Do you think people do this deliberately?
As such, teachers are required to report this sort of thing and they do. However, are you expecting children to be taken away from their families because the family have to choose between food or clothes.
Next you'll be proposing we bring back workhouses.


Well not meeting a child's basic needs is neglect - and a responsible adult, who is passive and does nothing, is complicit in my view. I can't believe you don't agree.


I do agree. However if you cannot afford to is it still neglect?
People are too quick to judge.

I doubt you can price the cost of neglecting a child's basic needs, so of course it's neglect, people are too quick to adopt a slopey shoulder.


And some people genuinely struggle to get by financially. Do you dispute this? Or do you think it's made up?


You seem to think if someone is hard up, not providing for a child's basic needs might not be neglect - I cannot adequately express how much I disagree with you.

The child would be neglected, but not deliberately. Seriously, people on tight budgets face stark choices. Rather than tarring parents, why not focus on the cause of the poverty.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 05 Apr 15 9.11pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 9.01pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 8.53pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 8.20pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.51pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.39pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.06pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.


Really? Do you think people do this deliberately?
As such, teachers are required to report this sort of thing and they do. However, are you expecting children to be taken away from their families because the family have to choose between food or clothes.
Next you'll be proposing we bring back workhouses.


Well not meeting a child's basic needs is neglect - and a responsible adult, who is passive and does nothing, is complicit in my view. I can't believe you don't agree.


I do agree. However if you cannot afford to is it still neglect?
People are too quick to judge.

I doubt you can price the cost of neglecting a child's basic needs, so of course it's neglect, people are too quick to adopt a slopey shoulder.


And some people genuinely struggle to get by financially. Do you dispute this? Or do you think it's made up?


You seem to think if someone is hard up, not providing for a child's basic needs might not be neglect - I cannot adequately express how much I disagree with you.

The child would be neglected, but not deliberately. Seriously, people on tight budgets face stark choices. Rather than tarring parents, why not focus on the cause of the poverty.

A neglected child is an abused child, there should be no other focus.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Apr 15 9.18pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 9.11pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 9.01pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 8.53pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 8.20pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.51pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.39pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.06pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.


Really? Do you think people do this deliberately?
As such, teachers are required to report this sort of thing and they do. However, are you expecting children to be taken away from their families because the family have to choose between food or clothes.
Next you'll be proposing we bring back workhouses.


Well not meeting a child's basic needs is neglect - and a responsible adult, who is passive and does nothing, is complicit in my view. I can't believe you don't agree.


I do agree. However if you cannot afford to is it still neglect?
People are too quick to judge.

I doubt you can price the cost of neglecting a child's basic needs, so of course it's neglect, people are too quick to adopt a slopey shoulder.


And some people genuinely struggle to get by financially. Do you dispute this? Or do you think it's made up?


You seem to think if someone is hard up, not providing for a child's basic needs might not be neglect - I cannot adequately express how much I disagree with you.

The child would be neglected, but not deliberately. Seriously, people on tight budgets face stark choices. Rather than tarring parents, why not focus on the cause of the poverty.

A neglected child is an abused child, there should be no other focus.


So what do you propose to do then? Make conditions in which some people are too poor to feed and clothe their families, then punish them for this.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 05 Apr 15 9.31pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 9.18pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 9.11pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 9.01pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 8.53pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 8.20pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.51pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.39pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 7.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Apr 2015 7.06pm

Quote chris123 at 05 Apr 2015 6.01pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 05 Apr 2015 4.16pm

Sorry but that's not to do with poverty, that's s***ty parenting.

Times are tough for some people, no doubt and whilst you can argue the pros and cons of the current benefit system there's enough to stop this from happening.


This is clearly neglect, and any teacher not reporting it immediately is complicit to that neglect.


Really? Do you think people do this deliberately?
As such, teachers are required to report this sort of thing and they do. However, are you expecting children to be taken away from their families because the family have to choose between food or clothes.
Next you'll be proposing we bring back workhouses.


Well not meeting a child's basic needs is neglect - and a responsible adult, who is passive and does nothing, is complicit in my view. I can't believe you don't agree.


I do agree. However if you cannot afford to is it still neglect?
People are too quick to judge.

I doubt you can price the cost of neglecting a child's basic needs, so of course it's neglect, people are too quick to adopt a slopey shoulder.


And some people genuinely struggle to get by financially. Do you dispute this? Or do you think it's made up?


You seem to think if someone is hard up, not providing for a child's basic needs might not be neglect - I cannot adequately express how much I disagree with you.

The child would be neglected, but not deliberately. Seriously, people on tight budgets face stark choices. Rather than tarring parents, why not focus on the cause of the poverty.

A neglected child is an abused child, there should be no other focus.


So what do you propose to do then? Make conditions in which some people are too poor to feed and clothe their families, then punish them for this.


How much tolerance would you provide to a child abuser? I would punish any form of neglect and not providing for a child's basic needs is neglect.

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Victorian poverty