You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The MOBO Awards
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The MOBO Awards


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Nov 15 3.09pm

Quote Seth at 07 Nov 2015 2.45pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 07 Nov 2015 2.17pm

Your original point was nonsense. That was the problem.

To say all human made things are of black origin because all people were once black is simplt flawed logic and secondly, you can't even prove the seemingly obvious assertion that all humans were once black. Nobody knows for sure, and in any case, that has nothing to do with who invented what. Your logic is barmy.

Nobody knows for sure? Don't take my word for it:

Dark skin

All modern humans share a common ancestor who lived around 200,000 years ago in Africa.[20] Comparisons between known skin pigmentation genes in chimpanzees and modern Africans show that dark skin evolved along with the loss of body hair about 1.2 million years ago and is the ancestral state of all humans.[21] Investigations into dark skinned populations in South Asia and Melanesia indicate that skin pigmentation in these populations is due to the preservation of this ancestral state and not due to new variations on a previously lightened population.[8][22]

Hence the leading hypothesis for the evolution of human skin color proposes that:

From about 1.2 million years ago to less than 100,000 years ago, archaic humans, including archaic Homo sapiens, were dark-skinned.
As Homo sapiens populations began to migrate, the evolutionary constraint keeping skin dark decreased proportionally to the distance north a population migrated, resulting in a range of skin tones within northern populations.
At some point, some northern populations experienced positive selection for lighter skin due to the increased production of vitamin D from sunlight and the genes for darker skin disappeared from these populations.
Subsequent migrations into different UV environments and admixture between populations have resulted in the varied range of skin pigmentations we see today.

[Link]

I'm sure we were all black once. My point was about proving it conclusively. Science has a track record of being wrong on a lot of things archaeological.
A few years back they were telling us that modern humans and Neanderthals did not share genes. I knew they were wrong about that and it has now been confirmed.
Now getting back to music. There is no way to confirm that black people invented modern music. In fact, since music evolves from older forms all the time, no one can be sure about where the current form started.
It might well have been in Africa but good luck proving that.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Nov 15 3.17pm

Quote bilbo at 07 Nov 2015 10.33pm

The MOBOs was a who's who of about every famous black person in Britain. According to some here that means they're all incredible racists. It makes me laugh. Simple explanations please simple minds.

Edited by bilbo (07 Nov 2015 10.39pm)


Yes but those rules are not applied equally.

If we had a celebration of all things white, it would be accused of racism. Simple mindedness comes in many forms.

Celebrating blackness is outdated by the same measure unless of course you would prefer us to return to a 70's mentality toward ethnic minorities.

One can't have one's cake and eat it.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Nov 15 3.24pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Nov 2015 3.54pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 07 Nov 2015 12.43pm

Quote Seth at 07 Nov 2015 11.50am

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 05 Nov 2015 9.04pm

Quote Seth at 05 Nov 2015 6.11pm

Everything made by humans is of black origin, seeing as we descend from people who came out of Africa and were most definitely black.

Which makes you all self-hating racists


Er no.

You could equally credit one celled sea creatures.

Today's music might have evolved from any number of places. Just because Africans have music and we all descended from Africans does not mean that contemporary music originated wholly or partly from Black people. That is presumption without any proof.
Just because black people sung the blues for example, doesn't mean they didn't learn it from the Romans. (I'm not sayng they actually did BTW)

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 Nov 2015 9.10pm)

Er no. I was talking about humans, not amoeba. That's why I said "Everything made by humans..."

That humans originated in Africa is not a presumption. It is very well researched and evidenced in many studies. Therefore my assertion stands.

EDIT: There were black Romans too anyway, but I'm not sure if they invented the Blues.

Edited by Seth (07 Nov 2015 11.51am)

You miss my point.

You could argue that black people invented the telephone or discovered radium by the same logic. It doesn't wash.

Prove that black people invented modern music. I dare you.

Just the good stuff. I think its kind of hard to doubt that genres such as Jazz, Rock, Rock N Roll, Blues, Soul and Disco were pioneered and pushed forwards by black artists into a white audience that then embraced them. Genres such as Funk, Hip Hop, Rap, Detroit House music and also revolutionised music again throughout a more modern period.

When I think Jazz and Blues (arguably the two most influential of genres) I think Billie Holiday, Miles Davis, Robert Johnson, Lead Belly, Muddy Waters, Blind Lemon, John Coltraine, rather than... Eric Clapton and Glenn Miller.

Elvis might have been the king of rock and roll, but he was really just playing black music to white kids, as were the Stones and Beatles when they both started out. That's not to say white music was entirely non-contributory (Country music for example), but that modern music really stems from the influence of the 50s and 60s adaptation of black influences.

Of course the real pioneer was Patti Page and Frankie Laine.

Absolutely no doubt that most forms of current music were in large part derived and stolen from black musicians in the modern era.
That was not really the argument.I was talking about much further back in time.

The one exception is classical music which still influences music more than people realise.


 

bilbo Flag 08 Nov 15 6.43pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 08 Nov 2015 3.17pm

Quote bilbo at 07 Nov 2015 10.33pm

The MOBOs was a who's who of about every famous black person in Britain. According to some here that means they're all incredible racists. It makes me laugh. Simple explanations please simple minds.

Edited by bilbo (07 Nov 2015 10.39pm)


Yes but those rules are not applied equally.

If we had a celebration of all things white, it would be accused of racism. Simple mindedness comes in many forms.

Celebrating blackness is outdated by the same measure unless of course you would prefer us to return to a 70's mentality toward ethnic minorities.

One can't have one's cake and eat it.


Where the vast majority of people fall within one demographic it's already the focus and the dominating voice. Others are to varying degrees less likely to be treated fairly, are identifiable by their difference and more likely to hold other cultural ties. That is balanced out by them developing an identity that is mainstream but very often includes a bond with those sharing these same experiences and challenges.

There is a specific niche audience for say the Asian Network whereas there is little need for 'White TV' in a society that is vasty white. By nature of that fact the motivation for it would come from a different place. This is my logic behind the belief that all British black celebs, most of whom were at the MOBOS, aren't incredible racists which is essentially what some people here are saying.

By the same token if the country was vastly black instead of white I would understand the relevance of niche shows catering to that audience.


Edited by bilbo (08 Nov 2015 7.04pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Nov 15 7.12pm

Quote bilbo at 08 Nov 2015 6.43pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 08 Nov 2015 3.17pm

Quote bilbo at 07 Nov 2015 10.33pm

The MOBOs was a who's who of about every famous black person in Britain. According to some here that means they're all incredible racists. It makes me laugh. Simple explanations please simple minds.

Edited by bilbo (07 Nov 2015 10.39pm)


Yes but those rules are not applied equally.

If we had a celebration of all things white, it would be accused of racism. Simple mindedness comes in many forms.

Celebrating blackness is outdated by the same measure unless of course you would prefer us to return to a 70's mentality toward ethnic minorities.

One can't have one's cake and eat it.


Where the vast majority of people are within a demographic it is already the focus and the dominating voice. Others are to varying degrees less likely to be treated fairly, are certainly identifiable by their difference and more likely to hold other cultural ties. That is balanced out by them developing an identity that is mainstream but also often including a bond with those sharing their experiences and challenges.

There is a specific niche audience for say the Asian Network whereas there is little need for 'White TV' in a society that is vasty white. By nature of that fact the motivation for it would come from a different place. This is my logic behind the belief that all British black celebs, most of whom were at the MOBOS, aren't incredible racists which is essentially what some people here are saying.

By the same token if the country was vastly black instead of white I would understand the relevance of niche shows catering to the culture and hisory of that audience.

Edited by bilbo (08 Nov 2015 6.50pm)

A argument very well expressed. I don't agree because there is more than enough black representation in media.
There are may more black faces on TV than the 3% in the population warrants. News readers, actors, footballers, musicians, athletes, politicians etc etc.

I don't think any one should reasonably be feeling left out.

 

bilbo Flag 08 Nov 15 7.27pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 08 Nov 2015 7.12pm

Quote bilbo at 08 Nov 2015 6.43pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 08 Nov 2015 3.17pm

Quote bilbo at 07 Nov 2015 10.33pm

The MOBOs was a who's who of about every famous black person in Britain. According to some here that means they're all incredible racists. It makes me laugh. Simple explanations please simple minds.

Edited by bilbo (07 Nov 2015 10.39pm)


Yes but those rules are not applied equally.

If we had a celebration of all things white, it would be accused of racism. Simple mindedness comes in many forms.

Celebrating blackness is outdated by the same measure unless of course you would prefer us to return to a 70's mentality toward ethnic minorities.

One can't have one's cake and eat it.


Where the vast majority of people are within a demographic it is already the focus and the dominating voice. Others are to varying degrees less likely to be treated fairly, are certainly identifiable by their difference and more likely to hold other cultural ties. That is balanced out by them developing an identity that is mainstream but also often including a bond with those sharing their experiences and challenges.

There is a specific niche audience for say the Asian Network whereas there is little need for 'White TV' in a society that is vasty white. By nature of that fact the motivation for it would come from a different place. This is my logic behind the belief that all British black celebs, most of whom were at the MOBOS, aren't incredible racists which is essentially what some people here are saying.

By the same token if the country was vastly black instead of white I would understand the relevance of niche shows catering to the culture and hisory of that audience.

Edited by bilbo (08 Nov 2015 6.50pm)

A argument very well expressed. I don't agree because there is more than enough black representation in media.
There are may more black faces on TV than the 3% in the population warrants. News readers, actors, footballers, musicians, athletes, politicians etc etc.

I don't think any one should reasonably be feeling left out.

Thanks!

Black people are certainly and thankfully much better represented than was once the case but these things take a while to fully filter through into peoples thinking.

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Nov 15 1.02am

Quote bilbo at 08 Nov 2015 6.43pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 08 Nov 2015 3.17pm

Quote bilbo at 07 Nov 2015 10.33pm

The MOBOs was a who's who of about every famous black person in Britain. According to some here that means they're all incredible racists. It makes me laugh. Simple explanations please simple minds.

Edited by bilbo (07 Nov 2015 10.39pm)


Yes but those rules are not applied equally.

If we had a celebration of all things white, it would be accused of racism. Simple mindedness comes in many forms.

Celebrating blackness is outdated by the same measure unless of course you would prefer us to return to a 70's mentality toward ethnic minorities.

One can't have one's cake and eat it.


Where the vast majority of people fall within one demographic it's already the focus and the dominating voice. Others are to varying degrees less likely to be treated fairly, are identifiable by their difference and more likely to hold other cultural ties. That is balanced out by them developing an identity that is mainstream but very often includes a bond with those sharing these same experiences and challenges.

There is a specific niche audience for say the Asian Network whereas there is little need for 'White TV' in a society that is vasty white. By nature of that fact the motivation for it would come from a different place. This is my logic behind the belief that all British black celebs, most of whom were at the MOBOS, aren't incredible racists which is essentially what some people here are saying.

By the same token if the country was vastly black instead of white I would understand the relevance of niche shows catering to that audience.


Edited by bilbo (08 Nov 2015 7.04pm)

Excellent explanation of the situation mr baggins

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Nov 15 1.04am

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 08 Nov 2015 7.12pm

Quote bilbo at 08 Nov 2015 6.43pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 08 Nov 2015 3.17pm

Quote bilbo at 07 Nov 2015 10.33pm

The MOBOs was a who's who of about every famous black person in Britain. According to some here that means they're all incredible racists. It makes me laugh. Simple explanations please simple minds.

Edited by bilbo (07 Nov 2015 10.39pm)


Yes but those rules are not applied equally.

If we had a celebration of all things white, it would be accused of racism. Simple mindedness comes in many forms.

Celebrating blackness is outdated by the same measure unless of course you would prefer us to return to a 70's mentality toward ethnic minorities.

One can't have one's cake and eat it.


Where the vast majority of people are within a demographic it is already the focus and the dominating voice. Others are to varying degrees less likely to be treated fairly, are certainly identifiable by their difference and more likely to hold other cultural ties. That is balanced out by them developing an identity that is mainstream but also often including a bond with those sharing their experiences and challenges.

There is a specific niche audience for say the Asian Network whereas there is little need for 'White TV' in a society that is vasty white. By nature of that fact the motivation for it would come from a different place. This is my logic behind the belief that all British black celebs, most of whom were at the MOBOS, aren't incredible racists which is essentially what some people here are saying.

By the same token if the country was vastly black instead of white I would understand the relevance of niche shows catering to the culture and hisory of that audience.

Edited by bilbo (08 Nov 2015 6.50pm)

A argument very well expressed. I don't agree because there is more than enough black representation in media.
There are may more black faces on TV than the 3% in the population warrants. News readers, actors, footballers, musicians, athletes, politicians etc etc.

I don't think any one should reasonably be feeling left out.


What makes you think you are qualified to speak on behalf of black people's experience in this country?

Just like I wouldn't claim to speak for 9th century Norse pirates, I don't think you have any right to say who should feel represented or not, apart from yourself.

Edited by Seth (09 Nov 2015 1.15am)

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Nov 15 1.14am

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 08 Nov 2015 3.24pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Nov 2015 3.54pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 07 Nov 2015 12.43pm

Quote Seth at 07 Nov 2015 11.50am

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 05 Nov 2015 9.04pm

Quote Seth at 05 Nov 2015 6.11pm

Everything made by humans is of black origin, seeing as we descend from people who came out of Africa and were most definitely black.

Which makes you all self-hating racists


Er no.

You could equally credit one celled sea creatures.

Today's music might have evolved from any number of places. Just because Africans have music and we all descended from Africans does not mean that contemporary music originated wholly or partly from Black people. That is presumption without any proof.
Just because black people sung the blues for example, doesn't mean they didn't learn it from the Romans. (I'm not sayng they actually did BTW)

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 Nov 2015 9.10pm)

Er no. I was talking about humans, not amoeba. That's why I said "Everything made by humans..."

That humans originated in Africa is not a presumption. It is very well researched and evidenced in many studies. Therefore my assertion stands.

EDIT: There were black Romans too anyway, but I'm not sure if they invented the Blues.

Edited by Seth (07 Nov 2015 11.51am)

You miss my point.

You could argue that black people invented the telephone or discovered radium by the same logic. It doesn't wash.

Prove that black people invented modern music. I dare you.

Just the good stuff. I think its kind of hard to doubt that genres such as Jazz, Rock, Rock N Roll, Blues, Soul and Disco were pioneered and pushed forwards by black artists into a white audience that then embraced them. Genres such as Funk, Hip Hop, Rap, Detroit House music and also revolutionised music again throughout a more modern period.

When I think Jazz and Blues (arguably the two most influential of genres) I think Billie Holiday, Miles Davis, Robert Johnson, Lead Belly, Muddy Waters, Blind Lemon, John Coltraine, rather than... Eric Clapton and Glenn Miller.

Elvis might have been the king of rock and roll, but he was really just playing black music to white kids, as were the Stones and Beatles when they both started out. That's not to say white music was entirely non-contributory (Country music for example), but that modern music really stems from the influence of the 50s and 60s adaptation of black influences.

Of course the real pioneer was Patti Page and Frankie Laine.

Absolutely no doubt that most forms of current music were in large part derived and stolen from black musicians in the modern era.
That was not really the argument.I was talking about much further back in time.

The one exception is classical music which still influences music more than people realise.

It's not that difficult to understand. All human societies, even the most "primitive" ones, create music, so the first music would very likely have emerged amongst our dark-skinned ancestors in Africa.

It probably began with voices and a form of drumming, which created rhythm and beat. Modern music has rhythm and a beat, which is still made mostly by drums. The connection is not hard to comprehend.


 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 Nov 15 12.49pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 1.14am

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 08 Nov 2015 3.24pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Nov 2015 3.54pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 07 Nov 2015 12.43pm

Quote Seth at 07 Nov 2015 11.50am

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 05 Nov 2015 9.04pm

Quote Seth at 05 Nov 2015 6.11pm

Everything made by humans is of black origin, seeing as we descend from people who came out of Africa and were most definitely black.

Which makes you all self-hating racists


Er no.

You could equally credit one celled sea creatures.

Today's music might have evolved from any number of places. Just because Africans have music and we all descended from Africans does not mean that contemporary music originated wholly or partly from Black people. That is presumption without any proof.
Just because black people sung the blues for example, doesn't mean they didn't learn it from the Romans. (I'm not sayng they actually did BTW)

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 Nov 2015 9.10pm)

Er no. I was talking about humans, not amoeba. That's why I said "Everything made by humans..."

That humans originated in Africa is not a presumption. It is very well researched and evidenced in many studies. Therefore my assertion stands.

EDIT: There were black Romans too anyway, but I'm not sure if they invented the Blues.

Edited by Seth (07 Nov 2015 11.51am)

You miss my point.

You could argue that black people invented the telephone or discovered radium by the same logic. It doesn't wash.

Prove that black people invented modern music. I dare you.

Just the good stuff. I think its kind of hard to doubt that genres such as Jazz, Rock, Rock N Roll, Blues, Soul and Disco were pioneered and pushed forwards by black artists into a white audience that then embraced them. Genres such as Funk, Hip Hop, Rap, Detroit House music and also revolutionised music again throughout a more modern period.

When I think Jazz and Blues (arguably the two most influential of genres) I think Billie Holiday, Miles Davis, Robert Johnson, Lead Belly, Muddy Waters, Blind Lemon, John Coltraine, rather than... Eric Clapton and Glenn Miller.

Elvis might have been the king of rock and roll, but he was really just playing black music to white kids, as were the Stones and Beatles when they both started out. That's not to say white music was entirely non-contributory (Country music for example), but that modern music really stems from the influence of the 50s and 60s adaptation of black influences.

Of course the real pioneer was Patti Page and Frankie Laine.

Absolutely no doubt that most forms of current music were in large part derived and stolen from black musicians in the modern era.
That was not really the argument.I was talking about much further back in time.

The one exception is classical music which still influences music more than people realise.

It's not that difficult to understand. All human societies, even the most "primitive" ones, create music, so the first music would very likely have emerged amongst our dark-skinned ancestors in Africa.

It probably began with voices and a form of drumming, which created rhythm and beat. Modern music has rhythm and a beat, which is still made mostly by drums. The connection is not hard to comprehend.


Lol

You presume that there was an unbroken chain between primitive music and modern music. That is not necessarily the case. It might be way more complicated than that. You can't know for sure. You just presume to know.

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Nov 15 2.07pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 12.49pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 1.14am


It's not that difficult to understand. All human societies, even the most "primitive" ones, create music, so the first music would very likely have emerged amongst our dark-skinned ancestors in Africa.

It probably began with voices and a form of drumming, which created rhythm and beat. Modern music has rhythm and a beat, which is still made mostly by drums. The connection is not hard to comprehend.


Lol

You presume that there was an unbroken chain between primitive music and modern music. That is not necessarily the case. It might be way more complicated than that. You can't know for sure. You just presume to know.


I presume nothing. If you actually read what I posted you'd notice I used the words "very likely" and "probably". Does that suggest I "presume to know" the answer? Of course not. I am making a judgement based on the balance of probabilities, whereas you are making a judgement based on nothing in particular, except perhaps your own prejudices.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 Nov 15 3.21pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 2.07pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 12.49pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 1.14am


It's not that difficult to understand. All human societies, even the most "primitive" ones, create music, so the first music would very likely have emerged amongst our dark-skinned ancestors in Africa.

It probably began with voices and a form of drumming, which created rhythm and beat. Modern music has rhythm and a beat, which is still made mostly by drums. The connection is not hard to comprehend.


Lol

You presume that there was an unbroken chain between primitive music and modern music. That is not necessarily the case. It might be way more complicated than that. You can't know for sure. You just presume to know.


I presume nothing. If you actually read what I posted you'd notice I used the words "very likely" and "probably". Does that suggest I "presume to know" the answer? Of course not. I am making a judgement based on the balance of probabilities, whereas you are making a judgement based on nothing in particular, except perhaps your own prejudices.

So in other words, you know nothing.

What are my prejudices exactly ? Other than toward people who twist and turn their arguments before admitting that they actually have no real knowledge of the subject beyond Wiki.

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Nov 15 4.28pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 3.21pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 2.07pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 12.49pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 1.14am


It's not that difficult to understand. All human societies, even the most "primitive" ones, create music, so the first music would very likely have emerged amongst our dark-skinned ancestors in Africa.

It probably began with voices and a form of drumming, which created rhythm and beat. Modern music has rhythm and a beat, which is still made mostly by drums. The connection is not hard to comprehend.


Lol

You presume that there was an unbroken chain between primitive music and modern music. That is not necessarily the case. It might be way more complicated than that. You can't know for sure. You just presume to know.


I presume nothing. If you actually read what I posted you'd notice I used the words "very likely" and "probably". Does that suggest I "presume to know" the answer? Of course not. I am making a judgement based on the balance of probabilities, whereas you are making a judgement based on nothing in particular, except perhaps your own prejudices.

So in other words, you know nothing.

What are my prejudices exactly ? Other than toward people who twist and turn their arguments before admitting that they actually have no real knowledge of the subject beyond Wiki.


*Sigh* This is getting tiresome.

I said I was making a judgement based on the balance of probabilities. That is all. If you don't like it then come up with some kind of alternative theory. Or not, more likely.

Your prejudices are your own concern, I can only guess at them based on what you post. But I'll leave that because debating sensibly with you is like herding cats.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 Nov 15 4.37pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 4.28pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 3.21pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 2.07pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 12.49pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 1.14am


It's not that difficult to understand. All human societies, even the most "primitive" ones, create music, so the first music would very likely have emerged amongst our dark-skinned ancestors in Africa.

It probably began with voices and a form of drumming, which created rhythm and beat. Modern music has rhythm and a beat, which is still made mostly by drums. The connection is not hard to comprehend.


Lol

You presume that there was an unbroken chain between primitive music and modern music. That is not necessarily the case. It might be way more complicated than that. You can't know for sure. You just presume to know.


I presume nothing. If you actually read what I posted you'd notice I used the words "very likely" and "probably". Does that suggest I "presume to know" the answer? Of course not. I am making a judgement based on the balance of probabilities, whereas you are making a judgement based on nothing in particular, except perhaps your own prejudices.

So in other words, you know nothing.

What are my prejudices exactly ? Other than toward people who twist and turn their arguments before admitting that they actually have no real knowledge of the subject beyond Wiki.


*Sigh* This is getting tiresome.

I said I was making a judgement based on the balance of probabilities. That is all. If you don't like it then come up with some kind of alternative theory. Or not, more likely.

Your prejudices are your own concern, I can only guess at them based on what you post. But I'll leave that because debating sensibly with you is like herding cats.


You're welcome.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (09 Nov 2015 4.37pm)

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Nov 15 5.39pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 4.37pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 4.28pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 3.21pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 2.07pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 12.49pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 1.14am


It's not that difficult to understand. All human societies, even the most "primitive" ones, create music, so the first music would very likely have emerged amongst our dark-skinned ancestors in Africa.

It probably began with voices and a form of drumming, which created rhythm and beat. Modern music has rhythm and a beat, which is still made mostly by drums. The connection is not hard to comprehend.


Lol

You presume that there was an unbroken chain between primitive music and modern music. That is not necessarily the case. It might be way more complicated than that. You can't know for sure. You just presume to know.


I presume nothing. If you actually read what I posted you'd notice I used the words "very likely" and "probably". Does that suggest I "presume to know" the answer? Of course not. I am making a judgement based on the balance of probabilities, whereas you are making a judgement based on nothing in particular, except perhaps your own prejudices.

So in other words, you know nothing.

What are my prejudices exactly ? Other than toward people who twist and turn their arguments before admitting that they actually have no real knowledge of the subject beyond Wiki.


*Sigh* This is getting tiresome.

I said I was making a judgement based on the balance of probabilities. That is all. If you don't like it then come up with some kind of alternative theory. Or not, more likely.

Your prejudices are your own concern, I can only guess at them based on what you post. But I'll leave that because debating sensibly with you is like herding cats.


You're welcome.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (09 Nov 2015 4.37pm)


It wasn't intended as a thank you.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 09 Nov 15 6.06pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 5.39pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 4.37pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 4.28pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 3.21pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 2.07pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 12.49pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 1.14am


It's not that difficult to understand. All human societies, even the most "primitive" ones, create music, so the first music would very likely have emerged amongst our dark-skinned ancestors in Africa.

It probably began with voices and a form of drumming, which created rhythm and beat. Modern music has rhythm and a beat, which is still made mostly by drums. The connection is not hard to comprehend.


Lol

You presume that there was an unbroken chain between primitive music and modern music. That is not necessarily the case. It might be way more complicated than that. You can't know for sure. You just presume to know.


I presume nothing. If you actually read what I posted you'd notice I used the words "very likely" and "probably". Does that suggest I "presume to know" the answer? Of course not. I am making a judgement based on the balance of probabilities, whereas you are making a judgement based on nothing in particular, except perhaps your own prejudices.

So in other words, you know nothing.

What are my prejudices exactly ? Other than toward people who twist and turn their arguments before admitting that they actually have no real knowledge of the subject beyond Wiki.


*Sigh* This is getting tiresome.

I said I was making a judgement based on the balance of probabilities. That is all. If you don't like it then come up with some kind of alternative theory. Or not, more likely.

Your prejudices are your own concern, I can only guess at them based on what you post. But I'll leave that because debating sensibly with you is like herding cats.


You're welcome.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (09 Nov 2015 4.37pm)


It wasn't intended as a thank you.

No s***.

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 09 Nov 15 9.21pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 6.06pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 5.39pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 4.37pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 4.28pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 3.21pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 2.07pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 09 Nov 2015 12.49pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 1.14am


It's not that difficult to understand. All human societies, even the most "primitive" ones, create music, so the first music would very likely have emerged amongst our dark-skinned ancestors in Africa.

It probably began with voices and a form of drumming, which created rhythm and beat. Modern music has rhythm and a beat, which is still made mostly by drums. The connection is not hard to comprehend.


Lol

You presume that there was an unbroken chain between primitive music and modern music. That is not necessarily the case. It might be way more complicated than that. You can't know for sure. You just presume to know.


I presume nothing. If you actually read what I posted you'd notice I used the words "very likely" and "probably". Does that suggest I "presume to know" the answer? Of course not. I am making a judgement based on the balance of probabilities, whereas you are making a judgement based on nothing in particular, except perhaps your own prejudices.

So in other words, you know nothing.

What are my prejudices exactly ? Other than toward people who twist and turn their arguments before admitting that they actually have no real knowledge of the subject beyond Wiki.


*Sigh* This is getting tiresome.

I said I was making a judgement based on the balance of probabilities. That is all. If you don't like it then come up with some kind of alternative theory. Or not, more likely.

Your prejudices are your own concern, I can only guess at them based on what you post. But I'll leave that because debating sensibly with you is like herding cats.


You're welcome.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (09 Nov 2015 4.37pm)


It wasn't intended as a thank you.

No s***.

Bye

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

dannyb1 Flag Chichester 10 Nov 15 1.58pm

[Link]

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 10 Nov 15 2.19pm

Quote dannyb1 at 10 Nov 2015 1.58pm

[Link]


Interesting!

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 11 Nov 15 3.18pm

Quote Seth at 09 Nov 2015 1.14am

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 08 Nov 2015 3.24pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Nov 2015 3.54pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 07 Nov 2015 12.43pm

Quote Seth at 07 Nov 2015 11.50am

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 05 Nov 2015 9.04pm

Quote Seth at 05 Nov 2015 6.11pm

Everything made by humans is of black origin, seeing as we descend from people who came out of Africa and were most definitely black.

Which makes you all self-hating racists


Er no.

You could equally credit one celled sea creatures.

Today's music might have evolved from any number of places. Just because Africans have music and we all descended from Africans does not mean that contemporary music originated wholly or partly from Black people. That is presumption without any proof.
Just because black people sung the blues for example, doesn't mean they didn't learn it from the Romans. (I'm not sayng they actually did BTW)

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (05 Nov 2015 9.10pm)

Er no. I was talking about humans, not amoeba. That's why I said "Everything made by humans..."

That humans originated in Africa is not a presumption. It is very well researched and evidenced in many studies. Therefore my assertion stands.

EDIT: There were black Romans too anyway, but I'm not sure if they invented the Blues.

Edited by Seth (07 Nov 2015 11.51am)

You miss my point.

You could argue that black people invented the telephone or discovered radium by the same logic. It doesn't wash.

Prove that black people invented modern music. I dare you.

Just the good stuff. I think its kind of hard to doubt that genres such as Jazz, Rock, Rock N Roll, Blues, Soul and Disco were pioneered and pushed forwards by black artists into a white audience that then embraced them. Genres such as Funk, Hip Hop, Rap, Detroit House music and also revolutionised music again throughout a more modern period.

When I think Jazz and Blues (arguably the two most influential of genres) I think Billie Holiday, Miles Davis, Robert Johnson, Lead Belly, Muddy Waters, Blind Lemon, John Coltraine, rather than... Eric Clapton and Glenn Miller.

Elvis might have been the king of rock and roll, but he was really just playing black music to white kids, as were the Stones and Beatles when they both started out. That's not to say white music was entirely non-contributory (Country music for example), but that modern music really stems from the influence of the 50s and 60s adaptation of black influences.

Of course the real pioneer was Patti Page and Frankie Laine.

Absolutely no doubt that most forms of current music were in large part derived and stolen from black musicians in the modern era.
That was not really the argument.I was talking about much further back in time.

The one exception is classical music which still influences music more than people realise.

It's not that difficult to understand. All human societies, even the most "primitive" ones, create music, so the first music would very likely have emerged amongst our dark-skinned ancestors in Africa.

It probably began with voices and a form of drumming, which created rhythm and beat. Modern music has rhythm and a beat, which is still made mostly by drums. The connection is not hard to comprehend.


Actually this is slightly more complicated than it seems to be. Whilst there is a reasonable grounds to believe that Homo Sapians evolved from homo erectus, and that Africa was a likely point, its far from certain, because a number of hominds classed individually, should have been classed under Homo Erectus.

Also the presumption that because those initial evolutionary steps were in Africa, that the first homo sapiens were black, and that as the species spread new skin colours evolved, there is no evidence of that first 'men' were black. They might well have been of any racial type - what we do know is that at some point the racial groups settled into areas suited to, or evolved towards racial groups, that suited environmental factors in various different climate regions.

Its actually a bit racist to assume that because homo sapiens originated in Africa they must have been black.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (11 Nov 2015 3.18pm)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The MOBO Awards