You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Budget 2016
November 22 2026 1.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Budget 2016


Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Mar 16 2.24pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Para 1 - that's how politics used to run jamie. Have a successful career make a bit of money then give a bit back to society by becoming an MP then Lord in the 2nd house. MP's these days are political clones churned out to short circuit the system and get to the House of Lords a lot quicker.

I think that might be a bit idealised view, and its somewhat undemocratic, but certainly we need more politicians who don't see it as a career, but a calling, in which issues outweigh party allegiance and getting re-elected is the same as being right.

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
Para 2 - Highlighted in red - NO jamie you mean many left wingers that THINK they can present a better knowledge and they talk a good game, based on Keynesian theories they have read about. Ask them for practical solutions with actual details of what they would do tends to shut them up. Ed Balls was a prime example of this type of Lefty Mouthpiece.

Practical solutions, are only valid, if you're talking in maintaining the status quo, which contradicts the notion of social change. Wealth redistribution cannot occur without upsetting the status quo, and causing change, economic and social impacts, unless its interested in maintaining the existing imbalance. This has been the failure of the Labour Party continually, its belief that you can have a fair distribution of wealth, without impact or changing society.

But that's not what I meant. I was talking about the theories of social justice and the critical theories around the difference between wealth, status, power and empowerment, and how these interact. For example, Rawls focus on Wealth distribution has a flawed basis, because it fails to understand that equality isn't purely established by payment of say a disability allowance, it also requires addressing the status, power and self empowerment of the disabled to participate freely in society.

This also has been a continual failure of the labour party, the idea that throwing money at a social problem is a resolution. Poverty, for example, isn't resolved just by giving the poor money, you also have to give them the capacity to escape from the social, political and self-identity problems created by poverty. In fact these are far more important, as they are what allow people to escape from poverty without the states intervention.

The problem of disability isn't about money, its also about how society incorporates the disabled, values them and how they view themselves in society.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Mar 16 2.37pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!


Para 2 is only really relevant if you believe that wealth distribution is important. Most capitalists argue (with merit) that inequality should come second to the actual living standards of the working poor. When left-wingers argue against this it comes across as the "politics of envy" to me.

Living standards for the poor are (on the whole) better in countries with less wealth distribution.

I disagree to an extent, but I also agree that wealth distribution is a symptom of problem. In the first world, wealth is very deterministic of how your life will work out, especially at the lower end of the scale.

Making the poor rich won't solve all their problems. I think even Marx saw that it was about empowering the working classes to become capable of determining their own destiny, rather than it being determined by the ownership of production by another who's interests are divergent from those of the workers (ie Status, Power and Self Empowerment).

Some people, giving them 'money' will just make their suffering greater, because they lack a capacity of functionality to prosper and use wealth as a means to self empowerment (the classic 'money doesn't buy you class'.

However the issue is poverty, and poverty is not just about money, but the way poverty inhibits chance and opportunity, as well as spawning and creating social problems that blight those around them.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Mar 16 2.37pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I disagree to an extent, but I also agree that wealth distribution is a symptom of problem. In the first world, wealth is very deterministic of how your life will work out, especially at the lower end of the scale.

Making the poor rich won't solve all their problems. I think even Marx saw that it was about empowering the working classes to become capable of determining their own destiny, rather than it being determined by the ownership of production by another who's interests are divergent from those of the workers (ie Status, Power and Self Empowerment).

Some people, giving them 'money' will just make their suffering greater, because they lack a capacity of functionality to prosper and use wealth as a means to self empowerment (the classic 'money doesn't buy you class'.

However the issue is poverty, and poverty is not just about money, but the way poverty inhibits chance and opportunity, as well as spawning and creating social problems that blight those around them.

Actually the bits about Marx, probably better describe Webber.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Mar 16 3.29pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!


Para 2 is only really relevant if you believe that wealth distribution is important. Most capitalists argue (with merit) that inequality should come second to the actual living standards of the working poor. When left-wingers argue against this it comes across as the "politics of envy" to me.

Living standards for the poor are (on the whole) better in countries with less wealth distribution.

Yeah Mes Thatcher in parliament talking about lefties wanting the gap closed rather than both rich and poor better off than they both would be with the gap closing.

I'm not so sure. Having divides in society widening isn't healthy and at some point the positives of this drop off and I'd imagine it's hard to reverse having put the rich in such a strong position.

But having said that the middle have been shafted quite a lot as well. Being moderately successful got you a lot further than it does now.

 


COYP

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Mar 16 3.33pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yeah Mes Thatcher in parliament talking about lefties wanting the gap closed rather than both rich and poor better off than they both would be with the gap closing.

I'm not so sure. Having divides in society widening isn't healthy and at some point the positives of this drop off and I'd imagine it's hard to reverse having put the rich in such a strong position.

But having said that the middle have been shafted quite a lot as well. Being moderately successful got you a lot further than it does now.

Its the disparity that's the problem. The vast difference between the bottom 80% and the top 5% is quite staggering, even actually he disparity between the 15% and the top 5%).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Budget 2016