You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Clattenburg in disguise?
November 16 2026 10.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Clattenburg in disguise?


Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 26 Feb 17 2.29pm

Originally posted by Willo

No it wasn't 'Kammy' but was someone whom you have heard of !

Yeah of course it was! Another one of your invisible friends???
I was actually referring to you suggestion that the ref blinked every time we should have been given a penalty....I woud suggest that is you who is blinkered Willo....does it ever make you wonder why you are the ONLY one defending the absolute clown we had yesterday????

 

chateauferret Flag 26 Feb 17 2.30pm

Originally posted by Willo

As someone once said to me "You can blink at the wrong time".

If he saw nothing WTF did he book McArthur for? To book him he'd need to have been cerain of what he'd seen. So: bollocks.

(Actually someone said this earlier but you elected to ingnore this point).

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 2.54pm

Originally posted by cpfc1976

I rest my case you're clearly on the wind up.

Absolutely NOT.
I can assure you I was told this and in my opinion it is totally feasible in it's context.Maybe it was said to me in jest but I can relate to it.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 3.05pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

If he saw nothing WTF did he book McArthur for? To book him he'd need to have been cerain of what he'd seen. So: bollocks.

(Actually someone said this earlier but you elected to ingnore this point).

The referee from his angle saw it differently.Split-second decision in a fast moving scenario.I haven't seen it on 'Slow-Mo' from a number of different angles so I cannot pass comment on the specifics of the incident.

Edited by Willo (26 Feb 2017 3.05pm)

 

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 26 Feb 17 3.12pm

Originally posted by Willo

The referee from his angle saw it differently.Split-second decision in a fast moving scenario.I haven't seen it on 'Slow-Mo' from a number of different angles so I cannot pass comment on the specifics of the incident.

Edited by Willo (26 Feb 2017 3.05pm)

You cant say what the ref did see or didnt see. If you havent seen the slow - mos then you shouldnt be making a comment about the situation.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 3.12pm

Originally posted by the silurian

Yeah of course it was! Another one of your invisible friends???
I was actually referring to you suggestion that the ref blinked every time we should have been given a penalty....I woud suggest that is you who is blinkered Willo....does it ever make you wonder why you are the ONLY one defending the absolute clown we had yesterday????

He is far from invisible I can assure you.

As for my "Defending", I am NOT a 'defence lawyer' for Madley or any other referee and try to see decisions from the perspective of the man in the middle.

At least I accept that referees make mistakes - seemingly to the majority on here they are expected to be right 100% of the time. Of course I have witnessed many 'Faux Pas' over the years but can understand why mistakes were made.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 3.13pm

Originally posted by the silurian

Yeah of course it was! Another one of your invisible friends???
I was actually referring to you suggestion that the ref blinked every time we should have been given a penalty....I woud suggest that is you who is blinkered Willo....does it ever make you wonder why you are the ONLY one defending the absolute clown we had yesterday????

He is far from invisible I can assure you.

As for my "Defending", I am NOT a 'defence lawyer' for Madley or any other referee and try to see decisions from the perspective of the man in the middle.

At least I accept that referees make mistakes - seemingly to the majority on here they are expected to be right 100% of the time. Of course I have witnessed many 'Faux Pas' over the years but can understand why mistakes were made.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 3.16pm

Originally posted by eagle@ tn34

You cant say what the ref did see or didnt see. If you havent seen the slow - mos then you shouldnt be making a comment about the situation.

The referee obviously saw something hence the 'Yellow' card.He didn't have the benefit of 'Slow-Mo' of course and as I haven't availed of this I cannot comment about the specifics of the incident.

I look at the 'Bigger picture' and I can only re-iterate that a referee can only give what he sees from his angle or vantage point or what he is informed by his assistants.And yes there will be variances with what he/assistant sees and what others see, including the pundits.

Edited by Willo (26 Feb 2017 3.18pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 3.24pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

It took Attwell four years of being consistently s***e before this happened. Mike Dean of course was demoted in a blaze of publicity, took a Championship match the following week which he f***ed up with another bollocks decision, and was then quietly put back in the Premiership. Can't find a ny other examples at all. And Clattenburg, notoriously dreadful, gets away with all sorts. So do most of the others.

If youbseriously think that this system is maintaining the standards of officials then you are delusional.

"Notoriously dreadful" - only it appears on HOL and possibly BBS.

NO such referee is awarded 3 major finals in a year and is seen as one of the best in the world by those who know far more about these things than you and I.

But let's not turn this into a WILLO or Clattenburg thread and de-rail the debate.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 3.31pm

Anyway Ladies and Gentleman.

This really IS my last post on this thread.

I appreciate I posted this before but this was after midnight after celebrating our win and I forgot about it this morning - my memory isn't what it used to be !

 

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 26 Feb 17 3.32pm

Originally posted by Willo

Absolutely NOT.
I can assure you I was told this and in my opinion it is totally feasible in it's context.Maybe it was said to me in jest but I can relate to it.

It was said to you as a joke for good reason. Only a moron would think it's a valid argument in defence of that refs numerous errors yesterday.

If blinking affected your sight so much, why are we all safe to drive? Because you don't really miss anything blinking it's so fast.

I don't believe you were told anything by anyone. All these contacts that you think you know, eh trolley.

I am also still waiting to hear back from you on my post earlier as to how if according to you the ref didn't see what happened he booked Jimmy Mac for diving? If you don't see it you give nothing. You replied to everything else but that, I expect you were busy washing your hog again.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 26 Feb 17 3.59pm

Originally posted by cpfc1976

It was said to you as a joke for good reason. Only a moron would think it's a valid argument in defence of that refs numerous errors yesterday.

If blinking affected your sight so much, why are we all safe to drive? Because you don't really miss anything blinking it's so fast.

I don't believe you were told anything by anyone. All these contacts that you think you know, eh trolley.

I am also still waiting to hear back from you on my post earlier as to how if according to you the ref didn't see what happened he booked Jimmy Mac for diving? If you don't see it you give nothing. You replied to everything else but that, I expect you were busy washing your hog again.

Even shearer couldn't believe the ref didn't see it was a foul , or even the linesman who was even closer than the ref. Can't believe the standard of refereeing this season. I've seen better in Sunday league football.

 

bicycle repair man 26 Feb 17 4.06pm

A lot of the refs are wannabe Clattenburgs.
Make a few controversial decisions,get a bit of publicity,before you know it you get called a top ref and earn a fortune.

 

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 26 Feb 17 4.29pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Even shearer couldn't believe the ref didn't see it was a foul , or even the linesman who was even closer than the ref. Can't believe the standard of refereeing this season. I've seen better in Sunday league football.

Yeah it's been beyond bad. We've been on the wrong end of so many terrible decisions. The protection or lack of it Wilf gets almost every game is a disgrace. Refs give players free reign to foul him. The moment we do anything it's a yellow card.

Yesterday was a new low in refs decisions going against us, to win despite that says how good our performance was.

 

chateauferret Flag 26 Feb 17 5.26pm

Willo, I don't know what you've been drinking but you really need to give it up. Today you've been posting stuff that even by your remarkable standards qualifies as some of the most fantastic bollocks imaginable. The ref mistook a foul for a dive because he blinked? When he then booked the player? Seriously? Is that really your position? Incredible.

Do you spout s***e like this in the pub as well?

 


============
The Ferret
============

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 26 Feb 17 5.38pm

Originally posted by Willo

He is far from invisible I can assure you.

As for my "Defending", I am NOT a 'defence lawyer' for Madley or any other referee and try to see decisions from the perspective of the man in the

middle.

At least I accept that referees make mistakes - seemingly to the majority on here they are expected to be right 100% of the time. Of course I have witnessed many 'Faux Pas' over the years but can understand why mistakes were made.


what do you call it then? You defend EVERY referee against anyone who dares to comment negatively concerning referees performance. No body expects 100% correct decisions, no one here has ever said that, BUT they would like fair unbiased refereeing, and thats NOT what they are getting.. why can there be no appeal against a very obvious wrongly issued yellow card? Even a blind fool like Madely, sorry Bobby, should be able to look at replays and have the card rescinded. I guess they dont allow it because it would make the referee seem fallible and the FA wouldnt like that would they? maybe you could ask one of your friends in high places, Marky maybe, and see what he thinks, if indeed he does think anything other than "screw Palace"
Oops just seen you've made your last post on this thread so we will wait till the next refereeing debacle and start all over

or maybe Trolley could answer!
Edited by the silurian (26 Feb 2017 5.39pm)

Edited by the silurian (26 Feb 2017 5.47pm)

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 26 Feb 17 6.24pm

Originally posted by Willo

As someone once said to me "You can blink at the wrong time".

That's obviously is true. Problem is he saw it clear as day. We know this because he booked Macca for a dive, so clearly he didn't blink at the wrong time on this occasion. Lino needs to take big stick for it also.

Edited by Dangermouse (26 Feb 2017 6.27pm)

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 26 Feb 17 6.28pm

Seems to me he thought the Boro played the ball and Macca made contact and took a dive. Replays showed otherwise. Not a great moment in the history of officiating but I've seen much worse. There also seems to be an emphasis on calling dives whether they are or not.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

bicycle repair man 26 Feb 17 6.33pm

So we conclude ref Madely is no blinking good.

 

chateauferret Flag 26 Feb 17 6.36pm

Perhaps he assumed it was Zaha, took out his card because, after all, the Laws do say that nothing done to Zaha counts as a foul, and then found himself face to face with McArthur whom, in all the years he has been playing for Palace, I have never, ever seen dive.


Edited by chateauferret (26 Feb 2017 6.38pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Clattenburg in disguise?