This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
A poor person steals to put food on the table, that's not the problem, its that it then teaches their kids that stealing is ok, or that person ends up in prison and absent from that childs life. More realistically, poverty rather than being poor, creates selfishness, where people steal not to feed their kids, but to spend on themselves or fund drug habits, rather than spend that money on their family. That's the problem of poverty - not that you don't have money, but the way it erodes positive influences or opportunity. OK. So now we are getting closer on this. My problem is that these anti social attitudes already exist in some people who arrive here from other countries and that 'culture' is then on our streets.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
I understand why some people turn to crime - for example financial reasons, liking drugs etc. But where it gets interesting is why people choose certain types of crime, especially repeat crimes and anti-social crime. I think poverty impacts that, not causes it, but aggravates the appeal of certain types of crime that isn't 'rational'. Like thugs who just beat people up for fun. Poverty plays a role in making thrill crimes that deal with individual inadequacy fulfilment acceptable outcomes, because it creates alienation, lack of opportunities and achieving means of self worth. How many people who beat their wives just acting out their own inadequancies on other people. Poverty plays a role in enforcing those inadequancies and failings - because it reinforces the idea of being a failure in people - and their only means of sublimating those feelings, is in deviant behaviour.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
When does it become a problem then? At what level of 'poverty' does it become ok to steal? Are we allowed to take into account why the thief is in poverty in the first place? Its not a problem, because its a rational decision that's understandable. Of course its a problem but more because the end result is going to be a parent likely ending up in prison, and justifying immoral behaviour to your kids.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I understand why some people turn to crime - for example financial reasons, liking drugs etc. But where it gets interesting is why people choose certain types of crime, especially repeat crimes and anti-social crime. I think poverty impacts that, not causes it, but aggravates the appeal of certain types of crime that isn't 'rational'. Like thugs who just beat people up for fun. Poverty plays a role in making thrill crimes that deal with individual inadequacy fulfilment acceptable outcomes, because it creates alienation, lack of opportunities and achieving means of self worth. How many people who beat their wives just acting out their own inadequancies on other people. Poverty plays a role in enforcing those inadequancies and failings - because it reinforces the idea of being a failure in people - and their only means of sublimating those feelings, is in deviant behaviour. I've no doubt that all of that is true and yet many people from impoverished backgrounds commit little or no crime. Immigration is a factor in all this because we are allowing people to come here, some of whom are already indoctrinated with a different set of moral standards resulting from a more impoverished environment and it seems, no capacity to know right from wrong.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I've no doubt that all of that is true and yet many people from impoverished backgrounds commit little or no crime. Immigration is a factor in all this because we are allowing people to come here, some of whom are already indoctrinated with a different set of moral standards resulting from a more impoverished environment and it seems, no capacity to know right from wrong. You are funny.
|
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Its not a problem, because its a rational decision that's understandable. Of course its a problem but more because the end result is going to be a parent likely ending up in prison, and justifying immoral behaviour to your kids. Not a problem? A rational decision that is understandable? At what point is someone entitled to say they will not obey laws because they perceive themselves to be poor in some degree?
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
|
You are pathetic.
|
|
|
Originally posted by hedgehog50
Not a problem? A rational decision that is understandable? At what point is someone entitled to say they will not obey laws because they perceive themselves to be poor in some degree?
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Edited by 7mins (03 Aug 2017 10.31am) It's another great post but I think it's probably lost on our 'progressive' friends. I wonder if Kermit will read this and replace Irish with Scottish for his own situation.....probably not.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
The stats don't back you up, but I'm glad the people in your family see the sense in a good education... hopefully they will be the role models for the next generation. Young black boys are under-achieving in education. I'm a tad older than you, and we had free education, my parents knew education was vitally important and encouraged me to achieve as much as poss... no-one on the black side of my family did this, their idea was finish school, get a job as a postman/bus driver and that's pretty much where their ambitions stopped ... my dad has always taught me to have a free mind... I don't like rap music, I detest ghetto culture, I think BLM are a disgrace... these views alienate me from a lot of my black family... I encourage my views to be challenged, and I can back them up with rational arguments based on evidence and logic... but they're not interested... they see it as me not towing the racial line... like i'm a traitor.
You raise good points here. Young black boys do underachieve in school, however, many are driven to succeed and to go further than other black boys who have previously failed. However, the black community through the mistakes of older generations now know the importance of education and there are many mentoring and bursary schemes to help young black kids to push and stay in education. So I would not say that education is seen as a bad thing in our community as many kids are pushed to go into further education. Regarding your point on your views alienating you from your family, obviously I can't say because I have not met the members of your family but it seems as if these are opinions on culture rather than intelligence. I would say that in today's society black people commit crimes because of poverty. They see it as an easy way to escape poverty but then people get a taste for power, a taste for money and then carry on. Some believe there is no one to help them. People have different intentions with their crimes, for example, someone could mug someone because they want money for some new trainers, however someone else could mug someone because they need money to feed their family that has not eaten for the past two days. I have noticed that these days you do get a lot of Asians committing crimes as well as black people. However I would say the reason that Jews and Asians don't feel they have to commit crimes is because they are there for each other. Typically (from my experience anyway) if a Jew or an Asian has financial success, they share their success with their whole family and involve them in their businesses, whereas unfortunately, successful black people are not as keen to share. I really hope this will change. Regarding racism from black people, it is clear that black people have developed prejudices towards white people, for many it is due to receiving racism from white people, for others it is due to ignorance. However, in my experience, I have observed at witnessed more racism from white people, with actual derogatory remarks and mocking. I don't condone racism is any way shape or form but I would say that racism from white people is a lot worse. You say you have never been targeted by police or in a club or pub because of your colour of skin, well I wish I could say the same.
|
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
There is a problem with NH carnival... so much so 43 police were injured... and police are now dreading working at it. What is your source for saying other festivals are being reported differently? NH is the worst... so is reported more. I have seen various articles over time, will have a look when I have a bit more time. However I have witnessed such things, I have been in areas where police have been stabbed black people and it's made the news and have been in events where white people have stabbed police but this has not made the news. I have been at events where the spectators are mainly white where fights have broken out, serious injuries to spectators and police were caused but these events have not been reported. I have been to music festivals abroad which are heavily policed when there are young people around. There are more. I don't disagree that there are problems with events that are mainly attended by black people, but there are and have been problems at other events that are not reported in the same manner. There is a video about this type of thing as well, I'll see if I can find it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Shifty97
You raise good points here. Young black boys do underachieve in school, however, many are driven to succeed and to go further than other black boys who have previously failed. However, the black community through the mistakes of older generations now know the importance of education and there are many mentoring and bursary schemes to help young black kids to push and stay in education. So I would not say that education is seen as a bad thing in our community as many kids are pushed to go into further education. Regarding your point on your views alienating you from your family, obviously I can't say because I have not met the members of your family but it seems as if these are opinions on culture rather than intelligence. I would say that in today's society black people commit crimes because of poverty. They see it as an easy way to escape poverty but then people get a taste for power, a taste for money and then carry on. Some believe there is no one to help them. People have different intentions with their crimes, for example, someone could mug someone because they want money for some new trainers, however someone else could mug someone because they need money to feed their family that has not eaten for the past two days. I have noticed that these days you do get a lot of Asians committing crimes as well as black people. However I would say the reason that Jews and Asians don't feel they have to commit crimes is because they are there for each other. Typically (from my experience anyway) if a Jew or an Asian has financial success, they share their success with their whole family and involve them in their businesses, whereas unfortunately, successful black people are not as keen to share. I really hope this will change. Regarding racism from black people, it is clear that black people have developed prejudices towards white people, for many it is due to receiving racism from white people, for others it is due to ignorance. However, in my experience, I have observed at witnessed more racism from white people, with actual derogatory remarks and mocking. I don't condone racism is any way shape or form but I would say that racism from white people is a lot worse. You say you have never been targeted by police or in a club or pub because of your colour of skin, well I wish I could say the same.
How do you know you were targeted by colour... my nephew was stopped, they were looking for someone who matched his description... a lot of street crime in London is committed by young black males, the nature of the crime means there is often a good description of the perpetrator, that's why police sometimes stop young black males... they're just following up leads... this was explained by a black senior police officer on LBC. Someone phoned in, and genuinely said black crime should be investigated differently... that unless the crime was violent, a watered down approach was better. I started a thread on here about me moving my car a short distance and getting a ticket for not wearing sit belt... I thought to myself... I wonder if it's because I'm non white, in a 99% white Sussex town. Turns out... the copper is a jobsworth... he gets everyone. Sometimes people are arseholes... doesn't make em racist.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Shifty97
I have seen various articles over time, will have a look when I have a bit more time. However I have witnessed such things, I have been in areas where police have been stabbed black people and it's made the news and have been in events where white people have stabbed police but this has not made the news. I have been at events where the spectators are mainly white where fights have broken out, serious injuries to spectators and police were caused but these events have not been reported. I have been to music festivals abroad which are heavily policed when there are young people around. There are more. I don't disagree that there are problems with events that are mainly attended by black people, but there are and have been problems at other events that are not reported in the same manner. There is a video about this type of thing as well, I'll see if I can find it. Do you have an interest in actual statistics on these matters or is it all personal impressions and experiences that forms your point of view?
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
Bang on, but increasingly gangsta culture is young urban culture and is colour blind. Ww are producing a generation of promiscuous, poorly educated narcissists who only care about where their next bit of gratification is coming from. And that's just the graduates!
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune) |
|
|
let's be real...
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by 7mins
No one commits crime in London to feed their family. Play fair.... they commit crime because it's a easy option.
Pretty much, although I think for some in parts of the country finding work that will pay sufficient for a family to exist is pretty slim pickings - and some crimes I think are committed because the laws are pretty out of line with pragmatism (vice laws being the best example). Like yourself, I've always worked - except at University - it wasn't viable to work in Sheffield at the time, the wages were poor and unemployment was rife - but I worked over the summers to clear out my overdraft. I do know people who turned to drug dealing as a means of topping up their wages and in the south that seems to have become increasingly common place. Wages vs costs in the South are pretty poor, and that is a major problem (not a reason to commit crime - but its an incentive - why work two full time jobs when you could work one job and flog weed for a few hours a week).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
Bang on, but increasingly gangsta culture is young urban culture and is colour blind. Ww are producing a generation of promiscuous, poorly educated narcissists who only care about where their next bit of gratification is coming from. And that's just the graduates! There has always been a gangster allure, back in the 60s it was the Krays and the Richardsons, the difference between then and now, is that wages weren't s**t - Families of four could get by on a single adults wages. Working must always be a route out of poverty - not a means of subsistence. If they aren't, then the value of working is eroded as is the ethical imperative - and that leads to a greater allure of gangster culture - when you're spending 50 hours a week working a McDonalds to stand still, but some guy from the estate is earning 10k a week driving a nice car and has all the trapping of success, for what appears to be no real work - selling drugs - its an attractive prospect. Pretty much true of what every generation has said about the following generation.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.