This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Dan89
There wasn't enough on the academy and further questions should of been asked, while is our scouting network so poor, and team like Southampton , stoke and wba find gems from abroad but we are unable, is a reastructure needed. Why isn't Gary issot job under threat, after nothing coming from the academy. Why doesn't the club announce transfer fee agreed on their official twitter and website like other sides like West Ham and Man Utd. First of all, there is a finite amount of time and I have to manage the topics we cover. To illustrate wh at I mean, we abandoned our 7pm pre-record after spending 45mins talking about ffp. Have we got no "gems" from abroad? I think SP addressed this and rightly pointed out that as palace fans, in general we will notice the successes at other clubs and not the failures. He mentioned Lamine of Southampton and make the point that we have signed Luka and Riedwald in that position. What else did you want? On the academy he has updated us on the training facilities and advised that the very recent appointment of DF is to address the failures to properly manage that academy. Then he pointed out the differences in managing it now vs in the past. What more did you want? Should I have told him off for neglecting it? I am not saying we couldn't have gone into detail but I think to satisfy some predispositions we would need 16 hours and some we would never satisfy. One thing no interviewer, professional or amateur, would do is attempt to start an argument to appease irate people. We have a responsibility to ask questions but also to allow a message to be communicated. We don't need to chase hyperbole or sensationalism content like talksport I think we get a lot more actual information because of that. Not seen one argument that has give any way to changing that view but I'm open to it. Edited by Hambo (18 Sep 2017 2.26pm)
HOL Radio Lead Presenter and sampler of processed meats HOL radio - Sunday nights [Link] [Tweet Link]My Twitter: [Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
I find it hilarious that Parish literally said in the same sentence that fans need to be more constructive and come up with solutions rather than just whingeing, then about 12 seconds later saying fans who say "I'd do this and that differently" are unhelpful. WTF? I think Parish needs to realise just as much as he claims "not all fans are against him, it's only about 50% who are unhappy", similarly not all fans who are now questioning his leadership are doing it regressively & blindly based on some longstanding agenda. There are many people who are genuinely concerned by the decisions and mistakes we keep making, and I've seen plenty of ideas of how things could've been done in a better way. It's been a culmination of f*** ups over a sustained period of time & decisions that can't rationally be understood that have led many to have serious questions of the leadership at the club. We're not all just abusive, defeatist idiots. Quite the opposite a lot of the time in fact. Edited by Mstrobez (17 Sep 2017 10.19pm)
Also a sidenote for Chris (Hambo)...good work with the questions bud but you may wish to re-visit your stock response to everything SP answered with "Fair point (or) That's a fair point" in almost every instance...just an observation...nothing more old bean On the whole, as usual, the show was excellent....oh and thanks for extending it to last for the entirety of my run...I'll buy you a beer for that
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Hambo, I think maybe rather than asking a question and just Parish answering it over 5 minutes, and some of it was waffling and contradicting himself, understandable with the pressure he must be under and feeling, perhaps you or jel or someone may ask him during or at the end of the answer, how or why he ...... (got it wrong if that's the case), and how he'd do it differently next time. Ordinarily you could say this is unnecessary but recently Parish is repeating errors. Btw, I think it'd be a big mistake if he wasn't the head man or one of them but my opinion is different over football matters. To be fair to you, I did have to drop a couple of such follow ups due to time constraints - but I do feel that the information is there in the responses we got. Particularly the references to hindsight.
HOL Radio Lead Presenter and sampler of processed meats HOL radio - Sunday nights [Link] [Tweet Link]My Twitter: [Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dan89
Here's some of the fans tweet him after the news of Zaha signed his 5 year deal I'm worried you think I was having a go at you because you're not letting it drop. I was just suggesting there was a semantic difference in what you thought he said and what I thought he said. Apologies if you've taken that personally, it wasn't intended in that way and if I am being fair to you, you probably have proved me/him wrong on that, to an extent, whichever way a person interprets what he said. I'm not sure if it's to the extent you think it is though. The screenshot you sent had a few people celebrating the news and a couple of people (I think I counted 3 actually) specifically praising him for the news.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
Also a sidenote for Chris (Hambo)...good work with the questions bud but you may wish to re-visit your stock response to everything SP answered with "Fair point (or) That's a fair point" in almost every instance...just an observation...nothing more old bean On the whole, as usual, the show was excellent....oh and thanks for extending it to last for the entirety of my run...I'll buy you a beer for that The fair point stuff is a verbal tick when I made a decision between commenting and moving on. I'll say it in my head next time!
HOL Radio Lead Presenter and sampler of processed meats HOL radio - Sunday nights [Link] [Tweet Link]My Twitter: [Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
Also a sidenote for Chris (Hambo)...good work with the questions bud but you may wish to re-visit your stock response to everything SP answered with "Fair point (or) That's a fair point" in almost every instance...just an observation...nothing more old bean On the whole, as usual, the show was excellent....oh and thanks for extending it to last for the entirety of my run...I'll buy you a beer for that 'A' beer???
HOL Radio Lead Presenter and sampler of processed meats HOL radio - Sunday nights [Link] [Tweet Link]My Twitter: [Tweet Link]
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pikester
Thanks chaps and quite a coup getting Steve on. I'll have a proper listen tomorrow but the bits I've heard so far make me feel a little more warm and fuzzy.... and that's just Jel's soothing tones. Who's that Patrick fellow? I thought it was Henning Wehn to start with!
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by Hambo
'A' beer???
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by Hambo
First of all, there is a finite amount of time and I have to manage the topics we cover. To illustrate wh at I mean, we abandoned our 7pm pre-record after spending 45mins talking about ffp. Have we got no "gems" from abroad? I think SP addressed this and rightly pointed out that as palace fans, in general we will notice the successes at other clubs and not the failures. He mentioned Lamine of Southampton and make the point that we have signed Luka and Riedwald in that position. What else did you want? On the academy he has updated us on the training facilities and advised that the very recent appointment of DF is to address the failures to properly manage that academy. Then he pointed out the differences in managing it now vs in the past. What more did you want? Should I have told him off for neglecting it? I am not saying we couldn't have gone into detail but I think to satisfy some predispositions we would need 16 hours and some we would never satisfy. One thing no interviewer, professional or amateur, would do is attempt to start an argument to appease irate people. We have a responsibility to ask questions but also to allow a message to be communicated. We don't need to chase hyperbole or sensationalism content like talksport I think we get a lot more actual information because of that. Not seen one argument that has give any way to changing that view but I'm open to it. Edited by Hambo (18 Sep 2017 2.26pm) I'm not critical of your job, but maybe some question could be expanded on. I've listened to the interview twice and no offence to you but I feel I haven't learnt much, that I didn't know already. Of course it depends on steve's time but maybe you should cover 2 topics throughly. Imo
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football |
|
|
Originally posted by Hambo
First of all, there is a finite amount of time and I have to manage the topics we cover. To illustrate wh at I mean, we abandoned our 7pm pre-record after spending 45mins talking about ffp. Have we got no "gems" from abroad? I think SP addressed this and rightly pointed out that as palace fans, in general we will notice the successes at other clubs and not the failures. He mentioned Lamine of Southampton and make the point that we have signed Luka and Riedwald in that position. What else did you want? On the academy he has updated us on the training facilities and advised that the very recent appointment of DF is to address the failures to properly manage that academy. Then he pointed out the differences in managing it now vs in the past. What more did you want? Should I have told him off for neglecting it? I am not saying we couldn't have gone into detail but I think to satisfy some predispositions we would need 16 hours and some we would never satisfy. One thing no interviewer, professional or amateur, would do is attempt to start an argument to appease irate people. We have a responsibility to ask questions but also to allow a message to be communicated. We don't need to chase hyperbole or sensationalism content like talksport I think we get a lot more actual information because of that. Not seen one argument that has give any way to changing that view but I'm open to it. Edited by Hambo (18 Sep 2017 2.26pm) I think this is quite common now with Parish. If there's a criticism or a big error, there's a mini success to give as an answer which is fine if the project or organisation is not much bigger than the success mentioned. But the problem is there's lots of these failings and answering that we signed Like and Riedewald doesn't solve our's. Similar with the 1 striker problem. Goes off about Frazier Campbell. I mean, where do you begin? 'Has problems scoring from time to time.' Sure it's not all of the time? I think it's got a bit too big and demanding for SP and I think a lot of this could be answered with looking for an experienced dof to either provide impartial and not Ex-CPFC advice that's taken. It's not as if we can't afford it. Might save fortunes too. Edited by Rudi Hedman (18 Sep 2017 2.38pm)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Part Time James
I'm worried you think I was having a go at you because you're not letting it drop. I was just suggesting there was a semantic difference in what you thought he said and what I thought he said. Apologies if you've taken that personally, it wasn't intended in that way and if I am being fair to you, you probably have proved me/him wrong on that, to an extent, whichever way a person interprets what he said. I'm not sure if it's to the extent you think it is though. The screenshot you sent had a few people celebrating the news and a couple of people (I think I counted 3 actually) specifically praising him for the news. All I saying is you can't take the praise, without the criticism. I'll leave it there. He gets both imo.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football |
|
|
Originally posted by Dan89
I'm not critical of your job, but maybe some question could be expanded on. I've listened to the interview twice and no offence to you but I feel I haven't learnt much, that I didn't know already. Of course it depends on steve's time but maybe you should cover 2 topics throughly. Imo Oh I appreciate that Dan, and I really do thank you for responding to me. Rarely do I get more than the initial critique! In an ideal world we'd do regular in depth interviews on limited topics but I gather the experience of being a PL chairman is a busy one so I am delighted with the time we do get I'm responding quite forcefully as I am really trying to understand what it is people want. Your answer (More detail) I get, but I don't equate that with giving someone a "grilling" to be honest.
HOL Radio Lead Presenter and sampler of processed meats HOL radio - Sunday nights [Link] [Tweet Link]My Twitter: [Tweet Link]
|
|
|
fair enough.
Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan |
|
|
Originally posted by Hambo
Oh I appreciate that Dan, and I really do thank you for responding to me. Rarely do I get more than the initial critique! In an ideal world we'd do regular in depth interviews on limited topics but I gather the experience of being a PL chairman is a busy one so I am delighted with the time we do get I'm responding quite forcefully as I am really trying to understand what it is people want. Your answer (More detail) I get, but I don't equate that with giving someone a "grilling" to be honest. It's definitely a fine balance...even with Diyar seemingly striking a note with some as to what they think it's not WHAT you ask but the WAY you ask it that gets the results. You all do a great job...even (begrudgingly) the Kiev muncher Jeremy It's just as much a sense of pride for me that we have people willing to spend their spare and precious time to actually produce a forum for the rest of us. Clearly as with SP you have to take the rough with the smooth and perhaps if more 'contributed' to the fundraiser you'd be able to afford Paxman...but not many did (even though you hit your target). Nevertheless, to have a fans show created and delivered by true fans and then to have dialogue with a Chairman, who whatever his minor faults, is happy to come on and at least discuss matters that we ordinarily wouldn't be party to is to be appreciated and 'treasured'.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by Dan89
All I saying is you can't take the praise, without the criticism. I'll leave it there. He gets both imo. I agree with you on both points sir, I never said otherwise. I'm not dragging this on further, just that I think he was claiming (rightly or wrongly) that he got more abuse for player signings than he got praise. As I say, I haven't be on Twitter, he could well be wrong. Hopefully no harm done, I wasn't having a go at you and although I don't always agree with stuff, I do enjoy reading your posts.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hambo
Oh I appreciate that Dan, and I really do thank you for responding to me. Rarely do I get more than the initial critique! In an ideal world we'd do regular in depth interviews on limited topics but I gather the experience of being a PL chairman is a busy one so I am delighted with the time we do get I'm responding quite forcefully as I am really trying to understand what it is people want. Your answer (More detail) I get, but I don't equate that with giving someone a "grilling" to be honest.
I am not sure anyone would expect you to give him a 'grilling' but they would expect him to get one if he went on Talksport and spoke to Adrian Durham. It is the choice of mouthpiece. You are a Palace related show and only an idiot would go out of their way to upset the owner of the entity they are following. Hol Radio is a platform for him to speak directly to the fans and get his point across without fear of an ambush. Some people would like him to be provoked into saying something unrehearsed or off message but I don't think that is your job. I don't think this thread is criticising you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by paperhat
fair enough. Yes, can't be easy when you know he may not return for further shows. It just felt like a lot of it had an aim of us to think, oh that's alright then' about it. I don't think the memory of this 1 striker situation and SP claiming we should've kept Fraizer Campbell on and that's the answer to that is going to fade very quickly. Couldn't believe my ears. And he wanted to overrule Frank on that one. Dear me.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Hambo
Oh I appreciate that Dan, and I really do thank you for responding to me. Rarely do I get more than the initial critique! In an ideal world we'd do regular in depth interviews on limited topics but I gather the experience of being a PL chairman is a busy one so I am delighted with the time we do get I'm responding quite forcefully as I am really trying to understand what it is people want. Your answer (More detail) I get, but I don't equate that with giving someone a "grilling" to be honest. Keep up the great work, maybe when dougie settled in he can give us more information on how the academy developing. Cheers Hambo.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.