You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 6.12am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James McCarthy (SIGNED) (LOCKED)


Page 6 of 11 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
YT Flag Oxford 21 Jul 19 7.38am

Originally posted by s.rix@xtra.co.nz

After 3 successive pre-season defeats and no strong promise of goals from our strike force, we shall start the season without the benefits of early signings being blended into a coherent squad. I feel sorry for Roy and Ray who will have to work fast on ANY new signings (on the assumption we get some!)

I simply do not understand why SP has to do 'deadline/cliff-edge' deals at the last moment. This creates slow starts to a new season, poor self-confidence, relegation fears and fan disapproval. We then spend two-thirds of the season re-building and this is simply not fair on the coaching team. We are all very supportive of what SP has brought to the club but has to sort out the ownership, bring in new funds, re-build confidence, a new stand and make Palace GREAT again.

Remind me when we used to be GREAT.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

davehuggins Flag 21 Jul 19 9.14am

Let's just hope and pray these rumours are false, surely RH or SP wouldn't allow such a waste of money again!!

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 21 Jul 19 9.54am

Originally posted by samprior

I'd struggle to find any logic in this deal.

It's probably the one area of the squad which has comparable strength in depth. Considering we usually opt for a kind of central 3 with the left sided midfielder coming narrow. We already have 6 players who are somewhat interchangeable in those areas.

Meyer/Luka/MacArthur
Schlupp/Riedewald/Kouyate

Plus the two youngsters who seem closest to breaking into the first team squad Kirby and Dreher (though I don't think they're that close).

If for whatever reason we're in for McCarthy bearing in mind his injury record, lack of recent appearances and contract expiry I'd have started the bid at 2m going to a max of 3m on appearances, which still feels like we'd be doing them a favour.

Your head does start to wonder what the hell is going on when you read such random transfer targets like this. The best reason my wild imagination could come up with was it's to cover MacArthur who'll go to Rangers as part of a deal for Morelos! (but even then I wouldn't say we needed McCarthy). On the negative if it's a replacement for Luka then that's just about as depressing transfer that I can think of. I guess we'll just have to wait and see.

He’s been in the map for Palace for a couple of years so it hasn’t come out of the blue? Makes more sense as back up for either McArt(ur or Luke, but a lot of dosh to spend on a back up? Can’t see him starting ahead of Luke or McArthur but we would have a very good squad player for not a huge outlay?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jul 19 9.59am

We need more central midfielders. Ideally 10 of them. The fishmongers has some unsold crabs from yesterday. Roy would probably like them as well.

 


COYP

eag-les Flag Coulsdon 21 Jul 19 10.21am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

We need more central midfielders. Ideally 10 of them. The fishmongers has some unsold crabs from yesterday. Roy would probably like them as well.

Only if it's benefishell to the team-.-'

 


If I agreed with you we'd both be wrong

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jul 19 10.24am

Originally posted by eag-les

Only if it's benefishell to the team-.-'

I do t think there’s a Plaice to fill though.

 


COYP

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 21 Jul 19 10.43am

I don't think this is such a bad idea, we have five first team midfielders but only one you would hang your hat on: Luka. The others are a bit flaky one way or another, we need someone in mid who can convert defence into attack by carrying the ball effectively or releasing it quickly and creatively, that's McCarthy's role and he is a talented player, but the issue of flakiness is raised again due to his injury record, they don't all have to be marquee signings if they fit the particular gap we have in the team, you might not rave about players like Tom Cleverly but they can make a disproportionate difference if they're adding what's missing, that's why Serri from Fulham is interesting. We need both more solidity AND more creativity in midfield, McCarthy could potentially help to provide some of both, how much and how consistently is uncertain though

 

IMilburn Flag Chiang Rai / Rayong 21 Jul 19 10.44am

Has a long history of injuries to his mussels

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Jul 19 10.47am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

I don't think this is such a bad idea, we have five first team midfielders but only one you would hang your hat on: Luka. The others are a bit flaky one way or another, we need someone in mid who can convert defence into attack by carrying the ball effectively or releasing it quickly and creatively, that's McCarthy's role and he is a talented player, but the issue of flakiness is raised again due to his injury record, they don't all have to be marquee signings if they fit the particular gap we have in the team, you might not rave about players like Tom Cleverly but they can make a disproportionate difference if they're adding what's missing, that's why Serri from Fulham is interesting. We need both more solidity AND more creativity in midfield, McCarthy could potentially help to provide some of both, how much and how consistently is uncertain though

He would have been a very good signing, didn't Wilf comment along those lines after a tweet linking us? Unfortunately I believe he has now been signed by an Italian club

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 21 Jul 19 11.22am

Originally posted by IMilburn

Has a long history of injuries to his mussels

he haddock cruciate problem didn't he? Or is my memory 'erring? tell me please if this is either total pollocks or actually if this scampi a good addition to our midfield

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 Jul 19 11.39am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

I don't think this is such a bad idea, we have five first team midfielders but only one you would hang your hat on: Luka. The others are a bit flaky one way or another, we need someone in mid who can convert defence into attack by carrying the ball effectively or releasing it quickly and creatively, that's McCarthy's role and he is a talented player, but the issue of flakiness is raised again due to his injury record, they don't all have to be marquee signings if they fit the particular gap we have in the team, you might not rave about players like Tom Cleverly but they can make a disproportionate difference if they're adding what's missing, that's why Serri from Fulham is interesting. We need both more solidity AND more creativity in midfield, McCarthy could potentially help to provide some of both, how much and how consistently is uncertain though

How many assists does he make, or did he make before being injured for the last few years? He’s no attacking midfielder or number 10. He’s a bit of both midfielder. That isn’t a priority for us right now, for £10 mil and on no doubt a generous Prem wage.

I smell BS anyway.

 


COYP

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 21 Jul 19 12.07pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

he haddock cruciate problem didn't he? Or is my memory 'erring? tell me please if this is either total pollocks or actually if this scampi a good addition to our midfield

Prior to breaking his leg wiki states that he had a hamstring problem which was exacerbated when he played for Ireland against his club’s wishes. Between that and the leg break, it accounts for most of the last two seasons. I think many of the games he missed he was fit for, but not in the team.

Whether he is right for us I don’t know, but he is a decent player.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jul 19 12.24pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Between that and the leg break, it accounts for most of the last two seasons. I think many of the games he missed he was fit for, but not in the team.

Whether he is right for us I don’t know, but he is a decent player.

My Everton supporting mate told me that he has been fully fit since February but that has co-incided with Everton hitting form so he was unable to break into a settled midfield

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 21 Jul 19 12.55pm

McCarthy may be a bit of a risk because of his injuries but he also may be a bargain if these are behind him.

We already know he can play with Mcarthur as they have played together before. we know that he is a very talented and when fit consistent player.

He may not be a striker, right back or winger but providing his injuries are behind him then he will add squad depth at reasonable cost

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Jul 19 1.10pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

McCarthy may be a bit of a risk because of his injuries but he also may be a bargain if these are behind him.

We already know he can play with Mcarthur as they have played together before. we know that he is a very talented and when fit consistent player.

He may not be a striker, right back or winger but providing his injuries are behind him then he will add squad depth at reasonable cost

Someone posted about them playing together at Wigan, but they were at Hamilton at the same time so probably played together at this club.Roberto Martinez signed both of them from Hamilton when he was manager at Wigan.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 21 Jul 19 6.15pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

My Everton supporting mate told me that he has been fully fit since February but that has co-incided with Everton hitting form so he was unable to break into a settled midfield

That makes sense based on what is in the press too.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

The Beger Flag Croydon 28 Jul 19 4.31pm

NEWCASTLE EYE MOVE FOR PALACE TARGET MCCARTHY

[Link]

 


I am not a bot. No, seriously, I'm not.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Jul 19 6.55pm

Originally posted by The Beger

NEWCASTLE EYE MOVE FOR PALACE TARGET MCCARTHY

[Link]

Good

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Petereagle Flag Brockley 02 Aug 19 9.10am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Good

Not so good. Palace allegedly back in for him, possibly as a fallback option and time is running out?

[Link]

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 06 Aug 19 12.02pm

Being reported on Sky Sports transfer Center that we are back in for McCarthy.

`PALACE STILL IN FOR McCARTHY

Crystal Palace still want to sign James McCarthy from Everton, with talks back on according to Sky Sports News.

Having already had one bid rejected, Palace are understood to be trying to restructure a payment schedule.

We reported nine days ago that Everton had made a £55m bid for Zaha - and reported eight days ago they had made a second bid including McCarthy and Cenk Tosun.

Palace want McCarthy regardless of any potential swap deal involving Zaha.`

Suggests to me there is some doubt in us getting Camararsa over the line.

Edited by Mwncisee (06 Aug 2019 12.04pm)

 

Page 6 of 11 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic