You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Man City Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Man City Match Thread


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Oct 19 7.58pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

Wilf was missing for large parts of the game, is this why the really big clubs don't rate him?

It helps if he can be supplied with the ball in good areas. Playing overtly defensive tactics means he won't get much supply.

 

herefordeagle Flag Hereford 19 Oct 19 7.58pm

I thought Wilf was only missing for the parts of the game that he was played down the right. He looked dangerous when switched to the left as did the team once Townsend was down the right. Can't help but think Roy is that desperate to get his favourite player Sclupp in the starting line up that he's willing to play Wilf in a postion that he's less effective and drop Townsend completely. We're blunt up front anyway with our attacking options, why make things even worse by playing players that will create less or players out of position that will create even less chances for them?

 


"It's ok postman , he'll lick you to death" "That isn't really that comforting , I still end up dead !!"

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 19 Oct 19 8.01pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

Wilf was missing for large parts of the game, is this why the really big clubs don't rate him?

he wasnt involved because citeh had 80% possession and whenever he got the ball he has sterling back asap to cover off the full back.

i dont see tonight as the time to be digging out players, losing 2 zip to that mob is fine in my eyes...especially when they play like that.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 19 Oct 19 8.04pm

Agreed. Thought we gave them a run. The chap from Bloomfield should go and support Liverpool, we don’t need his kind here.

Thought we all played well, undone by two moments of quality.

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

he wasnt involved because citeh had 80% possession and whenever he got the ball he has sterling back asap to cover off the full back.

i dont see tonight as the time to be digging out players, losing 2 zip to that mob is fine in my eyes...especially when they play like that.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 19 Oct 19 8.08pm

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

Why cant we just give the teamsroy respects 3 points and skip the game. was the same with the spuds.
horrible.


Because then we'd miss out on the great memories we've had against Arsenal and City last season and United this one. If you expect us to turnover the top 6 teams every time we play them then you might have a lot of disappointment in the coming years.

 

merganser Flag 19 Oct 19 8.20pm

Well played Wayne Hennessy - he made some great saves.

Impressed too by Ayew and Ward.


Reassuring that Christian B can still outjump opponents.

Edited by merganser (19 Oct 2019 8.23pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 19 Oct 19 8.50pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

It helps if he can be supplied with the ball in good areas. Playing overtly defensive tactics means he won't get much supply.


Not at all he gets the ball and top players will try to get involved

his problems are

1. poor movement at times you see him only walking around
2. he keeps slowing play up
3. needs to stop with tricks every time
4. does he not know how to cross or pass quickly
5. you can tell he doesn't like coming back
6. needs to stop playing as striker
7. really needs to grow up drop the attitude
8. waits for the ball doesn't attack it or offer much movement for better passes.

the guy is not top level with the experience and age he is at he should be a much better all round player.

now some will say maybe it's due to the level of players he is playing with but i dont buy that because he should be looking like a superstar then every game the guy was out paced by 33 year old and sterling had him in pocket

I do think better coaching would improve his game but he strikes me as having the wrong attitude look at the world class players and how much effort and attitude they have he is not in their league.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 19 Oct 19 9.11pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Not at all he gets the ball and top players will try to get involved

his problems are

1. poor movement at times you see him only walking around
2. he keeps slowing play up
3. needs to stop with tricks every time
4. does he not know how to cross or pass quickly
5. you can tell he doesn't like coming back
6. needs to stop playing as striker
7. really needs to grow up drop the attitude
8. waits for the ball doesn't attack it or offer much movement for better passes.

the guy is not top level with the experience and age he is at he should be a much better all round player.

now some will say maybe it's due to the level of players he is playing with but i dont buy that because he should be looking like a superstar then every game the guy was out paced by 33 year old and sterling had him in pocket

I do think better coaching would improve his game but he strikes me as having the wrong attitude look at the world class players and how much effort and attitude they have he is not in their league.

1) its called conserving energy, explosive players need to do that
2) nothing in front of him so whats the point in getting to the byline with potentially only ayew in the box
3) over the last 18 months he has done this
4) see point 2
5) no attacker does, he still does it tho as its part of his job
6) roys choice
7) agreed, thats my only criticism of him.
he has more dribbles than any player in the PL this season, hardly strikes me as a player who doesnt show for the ball.

is wilf a world class player, probably not...is he the best player outside the top 6...yes.

and he plays for our club, we should embrace this not just picking everything apart after a 2 zip loss against the champions.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 19 Oct 19 9.21pm

Better team won, no complaints about the result...

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 19 Oct 19 9.26pm

Spot on Braunston, grumpymort gets grumpier.
Tonight we lost to the best footballing team in the country so why to so called supporters have to slag off individual players is beyond me.
Wayne made some great saves as did Ederson from Tekkers and Wilf.You cannot go all out at City they will take you apart, ask Watford.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Oct 19 9.46pm

Originally posted by Daddyorc

Agreed. Thought we gave them a run. The chap from Bloomfield should go and support Liverpool, we don’t need his kind here.

Thought we all played well, undone by two moments of quality.

Sorry but we didn’t give them a run at all. I’m not complaining at the result or score but when you’re behind you may as well give it a go. If they go 3 up they may not bust a gut for 4 or 5 anyway. They didn’t bust a gut for a 3rd as proof. We didn’t close them down in pairs and 3’s or 4’s and didn’t get tight to them at any time. Wish I stayed at home tbh but there’s going to be some games I may not make so I’m going when I know I can.

 


COYP

merganser Flag 19 Oct 19 9.50pm

I’m leaning towards grumpymort.

What’s the port of a forum that just heaps adulation on its own players?

I love the player, but one of Wilf’s biggest personal challenges is to overcome his own petulance.

Sometimes his tantrums must really frustrate his team mates.

With all his experience, Roy should have got this sorted long ago.

Edited by merganser (19 Oct 2019 9.53pm)

 

Alex1991 Flag Ashford 19 Oct 19 10.01pm

Disappointing result but they are a superb team, can't see any of our players getting into their squad to be honest. Understand why people are saying we should have gone for it more but had Wilf scored to make it 2-1 we would have had a chance. 2-0 is a respectable result against the champions, and I'd much rather that than to ship 4 or 5.

Wayne was decent, Luka needs to sharpen up, Wilf was poor and Dann looked shaky.

 


"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 19 Oct 19 10.03pm

Originally posted by merganser

I’m leaning towards grumpymort.

What’s the port of a forum that just heaps adulation on its own players?

I love the player, but one of Wilf’s biggest personal challenges is to overcome his own petulance.

Sometimes his tantrums must really frustrate his team mates.

With all his experience, Roy should have got this sorted long ago.


Edited by merganser (19 Oct 2019 9.53pm)

i agree he needs to curb his tantrums, however really...in our eyes thats his only downpoint, and if thats the case then its really not that bad.

i am sure some team mates get annoyed by his tantrums, im pretty sure its overcome by the fact he produces a lot, and i mean a lot for the team on the whole so i am sure all is forgiven.

a lot of this over critical analysis of wilf IMO comes from his desire to play at a bigger club, we cant let that desire cloud the quality he brings to the team...as i promise, 100% that whatever money we get for him when he eventually leaves, we will not be able to properly replace him, so all this bollocks about his attitude does not wash with me.

we need to embrace & admire what we have before we dont have it anymore...hes not perfect, but he is our not perfect player...and i will defend him to the hilt because of that.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 19 Oct 19 10.13pm

Wilf has lost a yard off his pace. That was not just evident today (when being outpaced for the loose ball by an ageing defender) but has been evident all season.
Yes, he’s still very skilful and still relatively quick but the blistering difference in pace has gone.

He has been totally average this year and mostly ineffective...no goals and two assists? Meh!

 

cp forever Flag south london 19 Oct 19 10.24pm

Never good to see a better side at our ground but they were very good and I thought we worked very hard and often well, yes we can't match them but we did resist them and 0-2 is not so bad against the champions. A lot of players had good games and not many attracted the sudden flurry of players that Wilf did as usual when he was near the ball...he was outplayed but he kept going. I appreciate Braunston's defence of Wilf, it was inevitable that there would be a lot of griping...actually not as much as I expected. I clapped them off quite proudly I thought they gave all they could.

 

The Dolphin Flag 19 Oct 19 10.42pm

City were on form and we didn't give it a go until Townsend came on.
If we had then we might have done okay orlost by more - who knows?
0-2 is acceptable but we should have had more ambition earlier in the game really.
Hennessey was good as was Kouyate - Schlupp was abysmal.
Most teams would have got done by City today so we can't complain - Sterling missed a bundle!
Move on to the next game!

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 19 Oct 19 10.45pm

The same best team that lost 2-0 to the wolves, and was beaten by Norwich? Wait, was also beaten by us last season

Originally posted by gerry theagle

Spot on Braunston, grumpymort gets grumpier.
Tonight we lost to the best footballing team in the country so why to so called supporters have to slag off individual players is beyond me.
Wayne made some great saves as did Ederson from Tekkers and Wilf.You cannot go all out at City they will take you apart, ask Watford.

 

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 19 Oct 19 10.51pm

Living where you do, you should well understand what liberty means. Not even my dad or God can tell me what team to or not support. Wanting our team to have a result that’s equal or more than the sum of its parts is very very healthy my palace friend.

Originally posted by Daddyorc

Agreed. Thought we gave them a run. The chap from Bloomfield should go and support Liverpool, we don’t need his kind here.

Thought we all played well, undone by two moments of quality.

 

EddieMac Flag 19 Oct 19 11.38pm

Ah we were beaten by the much better side and it could have been 6 or 7 , but in the same breath if Benteke’s header goes in with 15 to go then we would have been chasing a point. Football is a funny all game.

We lost and we all expected to lose but the big plus is that we were not completely battered so no long lasting damage done.

Edited by EddieMac (19 Oct 2019 11.39pm)

 

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Man City Match Thread