You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > ffs Roy do something different ..
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ffs Roy do something different ..


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
kev64 Flag Cambs 09 Nov 19 6.09pm

Things have to change .. Roy says he's proud of today’s performance, one shot on goal in the 87 th min. The team are so defensively set up I doubt if we will ever score again.

CB and CW are given new contracts. We have Max and Victor no where to be seen, whilst Schulp continues to mascaraed as a footballer.

Wilf has fallen out of love with Roys tactics much like the fan base. We may get 40 points and stay up but this is like going back to the days of Trevor Francis .. ffs Roy do something positive....

 

AERO Flag 09 Nov 19 6.14pm

Totally agree with above

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 09 Nov 19 6.17pm

Have to agree, but not against Liverpool, next up.

 

PhuketEagle Flag Phuket 09 Nov 19 6.25pm

According to Roy we had a fully fit squad but none of Sakho, Meyer or Wickham were even on the bench. Not happy.

 

EddieMac Flag 09 Nov 19 6.28pm

I have always defended Roy but I have had enough myself. We have absolutely no creativity in midfield. I’d just be happy to see any sort of a change at this stage. Those last 2 games have been horrific.

The problem is we are all presuming that Meyer and Camarasa would be able to make that difference. I have see enough of Meyer to tell me that he is not good enough for this league so then it’s Camarasa and we have no idea what is going on with him. I think he was just bought in case of emergency as we signed no one else.

So if it’s not those 2 who start who do you put in ? I honestly think Roy’s hands are tied at the moment because our squad is threadbare.

When I get frustrated I scream for changes but we actually have no one to make a difference.

Edited by EddieMac (09 Nov 2019 6.28pm)

Edited by EddieMac (09 Nov 2019 6.29pm)

 

pax3908 Flag 09 Nov 19 6.33pm

Roy might like it, but the football is appalling, for goodness sake get a Centre forward or play one, no one wants to watch this rubbish, at least have a go!!!

 

eagleheath Flag Burgess Hill 09 Nov 19 7.03pm

Have to agree with everything kev64 has said. Spot on with the comments. Tactics under Roy just get worse .

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Nov 19 7.28pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

I have always defended Roy but I have had enough myself. We have absolutely no creativity in midfield. I’d just be happy to see any sort of a change at this stage. Those last 2 games have been horrific.

The problem is we are all presuming that Meyer and Camarasa would be able to make that difference. I have see enough of Meyer to tell me that he is not good enough for this league so then it’s Camarasa and we have no idea what is going on with him. I think he was just bought in case of emergency as we signed no one else.

So if it’s not those 2 who start who do you put in ? I honestly think Roy’s hands are tied at the moment because our squad is threadbare.

When I get frustrated I scream for changes but we actually have no one to make a difference.

Edited by EddieMac (09 Nov 2019 6.28pm)

Edited by EddieMac (09 Nov 2019 6.29pm)

A very good post.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 09 Nov 19 7.43pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

I have always defended Roy but I have had enough myself. We have absolutely no creativity in midfield. I’d just be happy to see any sort of a change at this stage. Those last 2 games have been horrific.

The problem is we are all presuming that Meyer and Camarasa would be able to make that difference. I have see enough of Meyer to tell me that he is not good enough for this league so then it’s Camarasa and we have no idea what is going on with him. I think he was just bought in case of emergency as we signed no one else.

So if it’s not those 2 who start who do you put in ? I honestly think Roy’s hands are tied at the moment because our squad is threadbare.

When I get frustrated I scream for changes but we actually have no one to make a difference.

--------------------------------------

Yes, not much Hodgson can do sadly against solid organised sides ..thankfully there are enough dodgy sides for us to survive this season but we desperately are in need of some luck in the recruiting world.


Edited by Tickled pink (09 Nov 2019 7.51pm)

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 09 Nov 19 7.44pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

I have always defended Roy but I have had enough myself. We have absolutely no creativity in midfield. I’d just be happy to see any sort of a change at this stage. Those last 2 games have been horrific.

The problem is we are all presum ing that Meyer and Camarasa would be able to make that difference. I have see enough of Meyer to tell me that he is not good enough for this league so then it’s Camarasa and we have no idea what is going on with him. I think he was just bought in case of emergency as we signed no one else.

So if it’s not those 2 who start who do you put in ? I honestly think Roy’s hands are tied at the moment because our squad is threadbare.

When I get frustrated I scream for changes but we actually have no one to make a difference.

Edited by EddieMac (09 Nov 2019 6.28pm)

Edited by EddieMac (09 Nov 2019 6.29pm)

True we don’t know if Max and Victor will make a difference, but we do know JS and JM2 don’t .. playing CK and Milo together kills the midfield.

Why the hell Roy didn’t have Wilf swap to the right today I’ve no idea. JA in a 451 he saw nothing of the ball .

Either go back to 442 or f it 352 with Tekkers and JA at least there may be a small chance of getting the ball in the box.

Edited by kev64 (09 Nov 2019 7.52pm)

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 09 Nov 19 7.53pm

We were very flat today. Certainly not a memorable away day.

 

PatrickA Flag London 09 Nov 19 7.58pm

Many make the assumption that players like Meyer and Camarasa are not good enough because, in the case of Meyer, he has not really impressed to date or because they maybe have not shown in training.
My problem with Roy is he tries to shoehorn players to his system and then jettisons them if he believes they don’t fit the mould.
I heard an interview with Pulis (boo,hiss!) where he said his policy was to look at the players available at Palace and then devise a way to play that would suit them.
This surely is a sensible and practical approach.
Roy’s methods means he sometimes uses square pegs in round holes e.g Mcarthur on right of midfield, Schlupp in central midfield or the immobile Benteke as a lone front man with no crosses to attack.
I know Roy is vastly more experienced than me, but as a football watcher of many years I can’t understand this

 

Aray Flag South London 09 Nov 19 8.01pm

If he continues with this midfield set up for much longer I’ll go spare. Thing is it’s so obvious that we lack any creative outlet. 3 cloggers in midfield. Even Jimmy Mac couldn’t pass today.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 09 Nov 19 8.15pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Many make the assumption that players like Meyer and Camarasa are not good enough because, in the case of Meyer, he has not really impressed to date or because they maybe have not shown in training.
My problem with Roy is he tries to shoehorn players to his system and then jettisons them if he believes they don’t fit the mould.
I heard an interview with Pulis (boo,hiss!) where he said his policy was to look at the players available at Palace and then devise a way to play that would suit them.
This surely is a sensible and practical approach.
Roy’s methods means he sometimes uses square pegs in round holes e.g Mcarthur on right of midfield, Schlupp in central midfield or the immobile Benteke as a lone front man with no crosses to attack.
I know Roy is vastly more experienced than me, but as a football watcher of many years I can’t understand this

Today Chelsea took us to the cleaners, it's going to happen a few more times this season, they simply made us play the way we looked today.

 

EddieMac Flag 09 Nov 19 8.20pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Many make the assumption that players like Meyer and Camarasa are not good enough because, in the case of Meyer, he has not really impressed to date or because they maybe have not shown in training.
My problem with Roy is he tries to shoehorn players to his system and then jettisons them if he believes they don’t fit the mould.
I heard an interview with Pulis (boo,hiss!) where he said his policy was to look at the players available at Palace and then devise a way to play that would suit them.
This surely is a sensible and practical approach.
Roy’s methods means he sometimes uses square pegs in round holes e.g Mcarthur on right of midfield, Schlupp in central midfield or the immobile Benteke as a lone front man with no crosses to attack.
I know Roy is vastly more experienced than me, but as a football watcher of many years I can’t understand this

I agree with you on this completely. Roy has a system and he doesn’t move from that no matter what. He is like a robot. It is painful for us fans but I honestly believe that if he wasn’t in charge right now we would be in the championship. I am willing to stick it out in the hope that we can get some more quality players in and progress.

We all have to remember that a couple of weeks ago we were delighted with our league position.
Every fan is different but I just want us to stay up in the hope that we can sort out the stadium and get some better players in and if that means suffering in the short term then I am willing to do it.

Edited by EddieMac (09 Nov 2019 8.20pm)

 

CharlesPaterson Flag 09 Nov 19 8.23pm

12 games in and we have scored 10 goals, even bottom club Norwich have more.

 

cpj Flag Kent 09 Nov 19 8.28pm

Originally posted by CharlesPaterson

12 games in and we have scored 10 goals, even bottom club Norwich have more.

3 were pens and 1 an OG - so we have scored 6 in open play in 12 games - 13 if you include the Cup against Colchester.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 09 Nov 19 8.35pm

Originally posted by CharlesPaterson

12 games in and we have scored 10 goals, even bottom club Norwich have more.

Defending is and always has been the deciding factor.

 

CharlesPaterson Flag 09 Nov 19 8.52pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Defending is and always has been the deciding factor.

Goals win games

 

Casual Flag Orpington 09 Nov 19 8.56pm

Originally posted by cpj

3 were pens and 1 an OG - so we have scored 6 in open play in 12 games - 13 if you include the Cup against Colchester.

Did we score against Colchester? I was at the game, can’t remember us scoring.

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > ffs Roy do something different ..