You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Southampton vs Palace Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southampton vs Palace Match Thread


Page 6 of 11 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Dec 19 5.04pm

Originally posted by horrible.man

Im afraid no matter how good a point is away we gave that to them,
they were doing nothing till we give them a goal from nothing which woke them up

Yes, precisely ...we seem to do this passing along and around the back with opponents chasing like it's some celebratory tea party, I will never understand it

 

Melbourne Eagle Flag Melbourne 28 Dec 19 5.10pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

Roy seems to never use our subs very much.

Unfortunately Palace almost never have a game won (or lost) by several goals with 20-25 to go and we always seems to be hanging onto a point or a one goal lead.

There never seems to be a good time to use the subs. Problem is Roy flogs his starting 11 almost without change and I reckon fatigue is not helping the injury run we are having.

Players without much match time then come into the starting 11 rusty and not match fit and we wonder why injuries are happening - e.g Riedelwald.

 

YoDougie Flag London 28 Dec 19 5.14pm

Disappointing error from Kelly but overall a point I can respect away from home against an in-form Southampton side. We can continue our good form into the new year against Norwich.

Well done to the players who don't start often but have shown they can come in and do a job when needed - Jairo (glad you could run off that injury) and McCarthy both very good today.

Meyer was okay but it seems, our tactics/mentality are to play it to Zaha, so the ball rarely made it onto his side. But took his strike well (even though is was ruled out) and is a good passer. Hope he gets more opportunities.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Dec 19 5.19pm

Originally posted by Melbourne Eagle

Unfortunately Palace almost never have a game won (or lost) by several goals with 20-25 to go and we always seems to be hanging onto a point or a one goal lead.

There never seems to be a good time to use the subs. Problem is Roy flogs his starting 11 almost without change and I reckon fatigue is not helping the injury run we are having.

Players without much match time then come into the starting 11 rusty and not match fit and we wonder why injuries are happening - e.g Riedelwald.

We scored two goals today, one though apparently 1mm offside because of Zaha's stupid fingernail!

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 28 Dec 19 5.21pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Indeed though unless we know the exact point the ball was played we don't know its at that point they were level


The Mail on Sunday article a couple of moths back highlighted that VAR could only be accurate to a margin of error ranging anything from 13cm minimum up to potential 38.8cm!!! (due to freeze technology and judging when the ball was played). This is just a farce when they are examining it to such a microscopic degree.

Also working out where to draw the lines is done by a human and not technology so yet further room for error!

How you can decide when the ball was played, where wilf’s shoulder ends and arm begins EXACTLY and where that is in relation to a boot with a margin of error of up to almost 39cm is a flippin joke and VAR is ruining the game in its current form and interpretation.

 

merganser Flag 28 Dec 19 5.24pm

Re Kelly, it was perhaps a lapse in concentration caused by fatigue.
He’s been such a fantastic servant for Palace - brave and determined - that I would never call him out. Considering all the times he has saved us with heroic last-ditch defending, let’s not be in too much of a hurry to put the boot in with unkind words. For 99.9999 per the cent of the time, he’s Mr Reliable.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 28 Dec 19 5.28pm

Riedewald, Guaita, Tomkins excellent today. Most of the others good solid performances. Yes it was a waste of 2 points but harsh on Kelly as it was a rare error for him this year.

Big decision on the VAR went against us but, having said all that, we got a draw at a venue we normally feck it right up so can’t be too unhappy.

Three points against Norwich or even a point and we will say we had a decent Xmas programme.

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 28 Dec 19 5.33pm

Originally posted by merganser

Re Kelly, it was perhaps a lapse in concentration caused by fatigue.
He’s been such a fantastic servant for Palace - brave and determined - that I would never call him out. Considering all the times he has saved us with heroic last-ditch defending, let’s not be in too much of a hurry to put the boot in with unkind words. For 99.9999 per the cent of the time, he’s Mr Reliable.

You beat me to it. Kelly has stepped up on many occasions and always gives 100% for Palace. Costly mistake, but it was bound to happen to someone due to the high volume of games and concentration required.

Hey, a draw against a team that beat Chelsea a few days ago is no shame.

 

cp forever Flag south london 28 Dec 19 5.33pm

Excellent comment..one or two people on here could learn from this attitude, but lets not hold our breath.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 28 Dec 19 5.34pm

Originally posted by merganser

Re Kelly, it was perhaps a lapse in concentration caused by fatigue.
let’s not be in too much of a hurry to put the boot in with unkind words. For 99.9999 per the cent of the time, he’s Mr Reliable.

To be fair to our posters, I don't think we're putting the boot in. We're disappointed, perhaps even a bit angry, and he's bound to be criticised. But I think we all accept that these things happen, and that on this occasion he just happened to be the poor sap responsible for the loss of 2 points. He'll play brilliantly on Wednesday.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 28 Dec 19 5.40pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber


The Mail on Sunday article a couple of moths back highlighted that VAR could only be accurate to a margin of error ranging anything from 13cm minimum up to potential 38.8cm!!! (due to freeze technology and judging when the ball was played). This is just a farce when they are examining it to such a microscopic degree.

Also working out where to draw the lines is done by a human and not technology so yet further room for error!

How you can decide when the ball was played, where wilf’s shoulder ends and arm begins EXACTLY and where that is in relation to a boot with a margin of error of up to almost 39cm is a flippin joke and VAR is ruining the game in its current form and interpretation.

Im agreeing with all of that .

Still happy with a point in the end . Could have been worse after gifting them a lifeline back into the match .Really felt for Kelly ,s*** happens .

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Dec 19 5.42pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber


The Mail on Sunday article a couple of moths back highlighted that VAR could only be accurate to a margin of error ranging anything from 13cm minimum up to potential 38.8cm!!! (due to freeze technology and judging when the ball was played). This is just a farce when they are examining it to such a microscopic degree.

Also working out where to draw the lines is done by a human and not technology so yet further room for error!

How you can decide when the ball was played, where wilf’s shoulder ends and arm begins EXACTLY and where that is in relation to a boot with a margin of error of up to almost 39cm is a flippin joke and VAR is ruining the game in its current form and interpretation.

They should use feet nothing else and give priority to the attacking team, we need goals in football.

 

55 years a fan Flag 28 Dec 19 5.44pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


What a dumb excuse how are they suppose to get experience if never getting any minutes in Prem game.

Like I said whats the point even including them on the bench.

With so many injuries and games close together he should be trying out other players just look how well Ried has done coming in yet Roy lost interest in him as well a pattern here. (I bet he gets dropped straight away when PVA or Schlupp comes back)

Edited by grumpymort (28 Dec 2019 4.57pm)

Yes no matter what Roy does you are never happy. You have to be
the most negative poster on this forum.

You got your name right as Grumpy sums you up to a tee.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Dec 19 5.51pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Im agreeing with all of that .

Still happy with a point in the end . Could have been worse after gifting them a lifeline back into the match .Really felt for Kelly ,s*** happens .

We seem intent on passing the ball around at the back needlessly until someone is forced into an error, we did it in the first half with Sakho almost gifting them! ...this s*** should not happen.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 28 Dec 19 6.10pm

Good point but the board needs to back Roy in the market

 

ger20 Flag London 28 Dec 19 6.14pm

Am I missing something here. Palace have lost only one of their last 7 games, that was against Newcastle in a match they should have won. Still there are people out there slagging Roy and individual players who are fatigued having to play several games because of injuries to a squad that is paper thin.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Dec 19 6.18pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

They should use feet nothing else and give priority to the attacking team, we need goals in football.

Thank you, thank you.

I’ve been saying that for ages. 2 if not 3 perfectly good goals been ruled out today. Beyond the idiotic and ridiculous.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

bicycle repair man 28 Dec 19 6.27pm

You can't please some of the dopes on here,talking all their cobblers about Roy.
Since he's been with us we've had our most successful spell ever in the Premier League.The guy has spent hardly any money,and more than half the team are out injured,and we are still picking up plenty of points, and they are still having a go at him.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 28 Dec 19 6.35pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

They should use feet nothing else and give priority to the attacking team, we need goals in football.

If you use feet you stil have the variance of 13cm to 38cm in the system to deal with.
The better way would be to have it as offside only if there is daylight between the players.
Easier to spot and would stretch the game more.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Dec 19 6.43pm

Originally posted by ger20

Am I missing something here. Palace have lost only one of their last 7 games, that was against Newcastle in a match they should have won. Still there are people out there slagging Roy and individual players who are fatigued having to play several games because of injuries to a squad that is paper thin.

Kelly is not fatigued, he's just a Very Naughty Boy.

 

Page 6 of 11 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Southampton vs Palace Match Thread