You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs. Manchester United Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs. Manchester United Match Thread


Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Eaglecoops Flag CR3 16 Jul 20 10.24pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

So a player plays in a position because of injury and that makes them a left back ? If a cat barks is it a dog ?

Well if they played at left back then they were a left back at that point, not sure why you have such an issue with it. What are Reidewald’s and Schlupp’s positions then because we know Mitchell is a full back.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 16 Jul 20 10.28pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Schlupp, Riedewald and Mitchell have all played at left back for us so he is correct.

No,they can play at left back, but only one of them it's their chosen position.

 

Jaha Flag 16 Jul 20 10.28pm

Wish Patrick a speedy recovery. Played well tonight but again lack that final bit that actually results in us scoring. So many chances this evening due to a lazy and lacklustre man unt. So frustrating

 

deetee Flag 16 Jul 20 10.29pm

Good performance from the lads. If only VAR had done its job. would have been so different if we had got that pen.

 

hayling eagle Flag 16 Jul 20 10.29pm

Originally posted by Come to Daddy

Once you realise that, it invalidates your "facts are facts" line. The "same for everyone" is exactly the same as "these things even themselves out over a season".

I don't think that there is great conspiracy in the same way as many but VAR was a terrible idea in the first place and it's implementation has now brought in all this faux precision which infuriates even people who were previously advocates.

It does not invalidate my point. What I'm saying is the point about whether the cameras are accurate enough to be absolutely to the second has been brought up all season, but, if you are going to have the system, you can only use the best technology available. Everyone gets the same technology to decide offside. I am totally against VAR, always have been, but it seems that no one was happy with wrong or controversial decisions made by the onfield officials, so now we have wrong or controversial decisions made someone sitting in a studio. However, eho is going to listen to someone like me or you.

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 16 Jul 20 10.35pm

better performance today, let’s hope we have the same intensity against Wolves

 

CT Charlie Flag 16 Jul 20 10.38pm

In my opinion, McCarthy is entirely responsible for ManU's second goal. Watch the replay. Because McCarthy trots rather than sprints back on defense, Fernandes has the time and space for the easy pass to Rashford, who slips it neatly to Martial. When Roy says defense is almost entirely about concentration, this is exactly what he means. There is NO excuse for that goal.

As for VAR, I'd love to see how they determine: a) precisely when the ball is passed -- it's inexact to determine when the passer's foot may or may not be in contact with the ball, and b) where to place the computer line on the grass when a player's foot is in the air. This, too, seems to be guesswork by the VAR referee.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 16 Jul 20 10.40pm

Originally posted by hayling eagle

It does not invalidate my point. What I'm saying is the point about whether the cameras are accurate enough to be absolutely to the second has been brought up all season, but, if you are going to have the system, you can only use the best technology available. Everyone gets the same technology to decide offside. I am totally against VAR, always have been, but it seems that no one was happy with wrong or controversial decisions made by the onfield officials, so now we have wrong or controversial decisions made someone sitting in a studio. However, eho is going to listen to someone like me or you.


Correct

He was clearly offside people can keep moaning all they want the issue is as I saw a poster on twitter mention the var people are dumb they do not even know how do do lines correctly they keep doing them at angles when they should be done based on the pitch lines.

varwrong.png Attachment: varwrong.png (403.77Kb)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 16 Jul 20 10.43pm

Originally posted by Painter

No,they can play at left back, but only one of them it's their chosen position.[/

If you are going to throw in your tuppence answer your own question of what are the chosen positions of Schlupp and Riedewald?

 

EddieMac Flag 16 Jul 20 10.44pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Correct

He was clearly offside people can keep moaning all they want the issue is as I saw a poster on twitter mention the var people are dumb they do not even know how do do lines correctly they keep doing them at angles when they should be done based on the pitch lines.

He has taken that photo of his telly on a phone. Iv seen the lines on BT and believe me they are parallel with the 6 yard box.


Edited by EddieMac (16 Jul 2020 10.45pm)

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 16 Jul 20 10.46pm

Originally posted by Pete53

The outcome the same - another defeat, but at least we made a fist of it tonight and the players can hold their heads up.

Agreed, they were the classier team but we gave them a game.

Why couldn't we do the same v. Burnley, Leicester, Villa ?

 

EddieMac Flag 16 Jul 20 10.47pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Originally posted by Painter

No,they can play at left back, but only one of them it's their chosen position.[/

If you are going to throw in your tuppence answer your own question of what are the chosen positions of Schlupp and Riedewald?

Townsend could play left back as well. Doesn’t make him a left back

 

Jaha Flag 16 Jul 20 10.49pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Correct

He was clearly offside people can keep moaning all they want the issue is as I saw a poster on twitter mention the var people are dumb they do not even know how do do lines correctly they keep doing them at angles when they should be done based on the pitch lines.

Don’t understand how that photo supports your point. Your new lines all wonky. How you can say that obvious, I don’t understand

 

redshift Flag Toronto 16 Jul 20 10.51pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Correct

He was clearly offside people can keep moaning all they want the issue is as I saw a poster on twitter mention the var people are dumb they do not even know how do do lines correctly they keep doing them at angles when they should be done based on the pitch lines.

If the point of VAR was to eliminate confusion then it's been a dismal failure. The discussion has moved from the on field ref's decision to some faceless person off field, timing of a picture and pixel widths. This has not been an improvement in the game but it does waste a lot of time so there's that.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 16 Jul 20 11.01pm

This! And how much frames per second on the camera, we are not shown the moment the ball leaves the foot and the use of 3D lines is maddening as it depends on the camera angle what is perpendicular and parallel. Only used in the PL this "accuracy".
The standard of refereeing is atrocious, both on and off the pitch.

Originally posted by Cpfc1861

you are right but it cant be certain if the refs are choosing when to stop it. This makes it non factual.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 16 Jul 20 11.15pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Correct

He was clearly offside people can keep moaning all they want the issue is as I saw a poster on twitter mention the var people are dumb they do not even know how do do lines correctly they keep doing them at angles when they should be done based on the pitch lines.

Oh golly gosh! That one suckered you. Fcuk me that's funny.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 16 Jul 20 11.17pm

Thought Roy was very clever to play McArthur on the left against Wan Bissaka.

VAR was never going to work and the sport can't be calibrated to the level they are trying to achieve irrespective of frame rates.

The only thing in its favour is that its underlined how most premier league referees have been promoted beyond their level of competence.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 16 Jul 20 11.20pm

Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan

This! And how much frames per second on the camera, we are not shown the moment the ball leaves the foot and the use of 3D lines is maddening as it depends on the camera angle what is perpendicular and parallel. Only used in the PL this "accuracy".
The standard of refereeing is atrocious, both on and off the pitch.

That's always been the problem with VAR, that it's supposed to be objective, but there are still human elements of it that are as subjective as they ever were.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 16 Jul 20 11.21pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Correct

He was clearly offside people can keep moaning all they want the issue is as I saw a poster on twitter mention the var people are dumb they do not even know how do do lines correctly they keep doing them at angles when they should be done based on the pitch lines.

He wasn’t clearly offside,it took them over 2 minutes to decide it was!

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 16 Jul 20 11.25pm


It’s a good job for Kanu that he didn’t have to deal with this. His feet were so big he’d have been offside if he was standing behind the defender.

 

Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs. Manchester United Match Thread