You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manure v crystal palace match thread
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Manure v crystal palace match thread


Page 6 of 9 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 19 Sep 20 8.36pm

Immense, every single one of them.

The effort and work rate was fantastic, game plan executed perfectly and although Man U did look very rusty, we totally deserved that.

I absolutely hate VAR and that should never have been a penalty but with the awful modern interpretation of ‘Handball’ I can see why it might have been given. As for the retake, well again...VAR is ruining the game. We may have benefitted but it’s just farcical and we will see so many inconsistencies with that aspect of VAR use during the season.

McCarthy was terrific tackling back and got so many good blocks and important challenges in. Schlupp also worthy of a special mention. Wilf took his goals very well and could’ve maybe had a hat-trick.

Sloppy defending from Kouyate and Sakho for their goal and on another day that could’ve been very costly.

Mitchell has done well but I’m still not convinced he is quite the answer at LB, he does seem to get taken on and beaten far too easily.

Seeing Wilf play up front with some renewed verve has been very promising and with the arrival of Eze (and potentially Benrahma) I’d actually now be interested to see him stay and play in that position this season. I don’t think he will though but I hope I’m wrong.

Overall we played very well and probably created more chances in that game than I saw in all of our Home games combined last Season!

Well done Palace...terrific start!

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 19 Sep 20 8.38pm

Quite unbelievable result. Penalty decision was diabolical but I expect it won’t be long before we suffer something similar. I keep criticising Roy but every time we get a result like that I’m proved wrong. Will we lose Zaha? 50/50 after that I reckon but let’s hope not.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 19 Sep 20 8.40pm

Originally posted by Wilesy01

Congrats to the team on a very solid performance.

Had our luck but then again we got none when we last played them back in July

Tyrick developing rapidly. Still room for improvement but I think he can make it at this level.

Only managed to watch the second half and thought we should've scored at least five.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 19 Sep 20 8.47pm

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

Quite unbelievable result. Penalty decision was diabolical but I expect it won’t be long before we suffer something similar. I keep criticising Roy but every time we get a result like that I’m proved wrong. Will we lose Zaha? 50/50 after that I reckon but let’s hope not.

If we keep defending like that and keep creating opportunities like that he won't want to go lol

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 19 Sep 20 8.47pm

I know it's early days.... but I think Roy has got it right.

I was convinced we'd struggle without some fresh players, he sorted that.

He ensured we played some friendlies and the first team all had a run out.

With the Saints win under our belt we were ready! Man U were not.

So delighted with a perfect start to the season.

The morale in the team must be great.

Wonder how it'll affect Wilf?

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

becky Flag over the moon 19 Sep 20 8.52pm

Let's just sit back and enjoy this whilst it lasts......


119961978_10157358417956875_361943966716778460_n.jpg Attachment: 119961978_10157358417956875_361943966716778460_n.jpg (28.90Kb)

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

taylors lovechild Flag 19 Sep 20 8.53pm

The new rule around handball in the box is that if the ball hits your arm and it's away from your body it's a penalty. Harsh, but that is the new rule. Again, if the GK has a foot off the line it has to be retaken. Harsh, but that's the rules. We've fallen foul of VAR on numerous occasions, but in terms of the new rules the penalty and the retake is B&W. Nice for these things to go in our favour though

 

The Dolphin Flag 19 Sep 20 8.55pm

A great result.
We were on it all match bar a few minutes and everyone did his bit.
I love Palace!!!!!!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 19 Sep 20 8.57pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

Immense, every single one of them.

The effort and work rate was fantastic, game plan executed perfectly and although Man U did look very rusty, we totally deserved that.

I absolutely hate VAR and that should never have been a penalty but with the awful modern interpretation of ‘Handball’ I can see why it might have been given. As for the retake, well again...VAR is ruining the game. We may have benefitted but it’s just farcical and we will see so many inconsistencies with that aspect of VAR use during the season.

McCarthy was terrific tackling back and got so many good blocks and important challenges in. Schlupp also worthy of a special mention. Wilf took his goals very well and could’ve maybe had a hat-trick.

Sloppy defending from Kouyate and Sakho for their goal and on another day that could’ve been very costly.

Mitchell has done well but I’m still not convinced he is quite the answer at LB, he does seem to get taken on and beaten far too easily.

Seeing Wilf play up front with some renewed verve has been very promising and with the arrival of Eze (and potentially Benrahma) I’d actually now be interested to see him stay and play in that position this season. I don’t think he will though but I hope I’m wrong.

Overall we played very well and probably created more chances in that game than I saw in all of our Home games combined last Season!

Well done Palace...terrific start!

Many players stumble their run up to make the keeper commit their intentions also if the pen had gone in would the officials still notice the movements of the keeper?

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 19 Sep 20 8.57pm

great result love the money 17/2 happy days. but why is Wilf pulling out of 50/50s could have scored at least another de gea was for the taking great penalty, Ayew kick with both feet and never take another penalty, it could have been a bigger score line, but still smiling lowest rating 9 for all players COYP oh forgot Roy went for the juggler Eze and Bats please keep doing it Roy

Edited by michaelpearce (19 Sep 2020 9.01pm)

 

The Dolphin Flag 19 Sep 20 9.05pm

All of my pre match worries were dispelled by an excellent performance full of pace, tackling and positive controlled aggression!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 19 Sep 20 9.16pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Only 34 points to safety!
One of our best team performances since returning to the Premier League as we controlled the match and the whole team played well.
Don’t think Mcarthy lost a tackle all game and when he plays like that he’s a huge asset to the team.
Schlupp also played with real drive and purpose.
Kouyate looks so comfortable at centre back Roy will have a tough decision to make when the injured players return.

Natural if ever a word, needs to be cemented there in our starting 11.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 19 Sep 20 9.17pm

More sh1t tactics from Roy. Sat back too far, picks his favourites like McArthur and Schlupp. No subs and doesn’t give youth a chance.

Even Guaita is getting worse. He’s too old and negative and no players have improved under his tenure. Complete fluke today.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 19 Sep 20 9.19pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

More sh1t tactics from Roy. Sat back too far, picks his favourites like McArthur and Schlupp. No subs and doesn’t give youth a chance.

Even Guaita is getting worse. He’s too old and negative and no players have improved under his tenure. Complete fluke today.

Tbh I think Hennessy is to blame.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 19 Sep 20 9.21pm

How gratifying - a public apology by Graham Souness to all Palace fans !

At the match preview he said Palace play survival football, at the end he said that was wrong - Palace play good football and thoroughly deserved the win.

I hope that cynical gasbag Shearer is similarly complimentary on MOD.

One point, the away kit is smart but the numbers are hard to read. As our main kit is predominantly blue
why don't we use it against the other 'red' teams: Liverpool, Arsenal, Sheff Utd, Villa, Burnley & west Ham ?

 

kegart Flag London 19 Sep 20 9.21pm

Enjoy......just enjoy.

 

Deleagle Flag "Bubba's bar 'n' grill" 19 Sep 20 9.23pm

Originally posted by Ecopalace

Will PVA get back in the team?

I hope not, nor Luka!

They aren't good enough and it's shown for a while last season when they were playing and now they aren't playing it can clearly be seen what we haven't missed.

Luka only gets the nod as he's captain and skilled at free kicks and penalties, well Wilf made sure of his penalty today as well as the captaincy.

A very very good win spoiled again by VAR but it's nice to get something out of Atkinson for once, even though he had to be told by VAR control

 


What can this strange device be?
When I touch it it gives forth a sound.



Eagles fit fans squad number 21, group 2

- =

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 19 Sep 20 9.28pm

Originally posted by kegart

Enjoy......just enjoy.

Thank you so much!

 

derby eagle Flag Derby 19 Sep 20 9.29pm

Originally posted by kegart

Enjoy......just enjoy.

Jam on toast...swivel on it!

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 19 Sep 20 9.51pm

Originally posted by kegart

Enjoy......just enjoy.

What a class A cock this bloke is!

 

Page 6 of 9 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manure v crystal palace match thread