You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Just a bit of perspective.... Please?
November 16 2026 5.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Just a bit of perspective.... Please?


Page 6 of 9 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 30 Nov 20 12.13pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Not really. We need a holistic view to tactical gameplay, a balance between attack and defence, game management during the ebb and flow of the game.
One very obvious example is the over reliance on Zaha, rather then spreading the load in what is a team game. Over over-emphasis on defence means the game is played more in our half, as statistically the opposition have more of the ball. This limits the time when we create genuine goal scoring opportunities.

Some very interesting points. I've noticed we often drop too deep, particularly when defending a lead. We should strike more of a balance and go for two when we score one. The difficulty of how deep we are makes the opposition look great as they have loads of space to run onto us. I was thinking we need an attacking unit of perhaps Zaha, Eze and Ayew who stick together up front and always press. If they have to track back as much as they do it's no real surprise that we can't score. The obvious times are when there is no one in the area. At least two people should be up front at all times. Otherwise opposition defenders can take their time and pick a pass, whilst midfielders and strikers can run to the edge of our area and then shoot. Think how many times we see this - several times a game. We haven't learnt anything, we haven't grown or evolved. We are the living definition of a team that stood still. Trouble is the rest of the world is moving on.

Edited by ASCPFC (30 Nov 2020 12.14pm)

 


Red and Blue Army!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Nov 20 12.21pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

You are seeing abuse where none exists. Of course you are entitled to your opinion, just as I am to mine that simple solutions don't exist and that those who expect instant answers are glory hunters. If that's the way you come over to me then, that's the way you come over to me.

Dear me.

Is there a Latin motto for ‘accept and shut up’?

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 20 12.24pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Some very interesting points. I've noticed we often drop too deep, particularly when defending a lead. We should strike more of a balance and go for two when we score one. The difficulty of how deep we are makes the opposition look great as they have loads of space to run onto us. I was thinking we need an attacking unit of perhaps Zaha, Eze and Ayew who stick together up front and always press. If they have to track back as much as they do it's no real surprise that we can't score. The obvious times are when there is no one in the area. At least two people should be up front at all times. Otherwise opposition defenders can take their time and pick a pass, whilst midfielders and strikers can run to the edge of our area and then shoot. Think how many times we see this - several times a game. We haven't learnt anything, we haven't grown or evolved. We are the living definition of a team that stood still. Trouble is the rest of the world is moving on.

Edited by ASCPFC (30 Nov 2020 12.14pm)

We generally defend deep as we simply do not have the pace in defence.

I refer back to my previous comments apropos the age of the squad, with 15 players either 30 next year or in their 30s.
In general we don't possess the pace or mobility to play football on the front-foot 'Pressing' teams as others do, so Hodgson has to devise a system with all these contraints.

Most of our players are in the 'Twilight' of their careers and whilst outsiders might highlight certain 'Name' players, I suspect many of our supporters know they are not the players they were and have been on the wane for some time.This is the harsh reality of our situation.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 30 Nov 20 12.34pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Some very interesting points. I've noticed we often drop too deep, particularly when defending a lead. We should strike more of a balance and go for two when we score one. The difficulty of how deep we are makes the opposition look great as they have loads of space to run onto us. I was thinking we need an attacking unit of perhaps Zaha, Eze and Ayew who stick together up front and always press. If they have to track back as much as they do it's no real surprise that we can't score. The obvious times are when there is no one in the area. At least two people should be up front at all times. Otherwise opposition defenders can take their time and pick a pass, whilst midfielders and strikers can run to the edge of our area and then shoot. Think how many times we see this - several times a game. We haven't learnt anything, we haven't grown or evolved. We are the living definition of a team that stood still. Trouble is the rest of the world is moving on.

Edited by ASCPFC (30 Nov 2020 12.14pm)

I'm in total agreement. IMO the reason we sit so deep, apart from this being Hodgson's preferred tactical game plan, is the fact that our centre backs are ageing and really slow and have to sit deep because they can't recover against a quick striker. This has an effect throughout the side whereby our forwards are further away, and so we decide to convince ourselves that we are a counter attacking side due to circumstance, as we let the opposition have the ball, creating pressure on ourselves. Just to add I don't see the level of physical exertion required at this level, particularly by players who should be playing for renewed contracts. That said, on recent performances it would appear that a few of them are in the twilight of their Premiership careers and the Championship beckons.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (30 Nov 2020 1.32pm)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 30 Nov 20 12.37pm

Originally posted by Willo

We generally defend deep as we simply do not have the pace in defence.

I refer back to my previous comments apropos the age of the squad, with 15 players either 30 next year or in their 30s.
In general we don't possess the pace or mobility to play football on the front-foot 'Pressing' teams as others do, so Hodgson has to devise a system with all these contraints.

Most of our players are in the 'Twilight' of their careers and whilst outsiders might highlight certain 'Name' players, I suspect many of our supporters know they are not the players they were and have been on the wane for some time.This is the harsh reality of our situation.

We have plenty of youngsters in the U23s, Banks, Dreher, Kirby, who can run around all day. We have Mitchell, Zaha, Schlupp and Eze and PVA is also quick. Clyne is not slow either, nor Ayew!

I think it’s more the point that Roy doesn’t want to play that way. He is happy to play narrow and deep and then utilise the pace we have on the break. I don’t see why the older midfielders can’t run their socks off for 45 minutes and then get substituted at HT. it’s not like we don’t have enough defensive midfielders to choose from. Start with Milivojevic and McArthur, finish with Riedewald and MacCarthy or Kouyate.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Nov 20 12.40pm

Originally posted by Willo

We generally defend deep as we simply do not have the pace in defence.

I refer back to my previous comments apropos the age of the squad, with 15 players either 30 next year or in their 30s.
In general we don't possess the pace or mobility to play football on the front-foot 'Pressing' teams as others do, so Hodgson has to devise a system with all these contraints.

Most of our players are in the 'Twilight' of their careers and whilst outsiders might highlight certain 'Name' players, I suspect many of our supporters know they are not the players they were and have been on the wane for some time.This is the harsh reality of our situation.

I agree with this to a point, and I think it’s been a bit more obvious this season. The issue is when you look at the set up and players on the bench vs those on the pitch. Some there’s no logical explanation for.

One thing I’d agree with you know who is Eze is the only thing worth watching right now. It feels like there’s no point bothering apart from that, which is easy to say if you’re not going or watching from a remote place in England or a croydon postcode I’ve found.

Why we’ve never really played 4-2-3-1 is a mystery. The same thing over and over is just not worth the time atm.


Edited by Rudi Hedman (30 Nov 2020 12.50pm)

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 20 1.04pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

We have plenty of youngsters in the U23s, Banks, Dreher, Kirby, who can run around all day. We have Mitchell, Zaha, Schlupp and Eze and PVA is also quick. Clyne is not slow either, nor Ayew!

I think it’s more the point that Roy doesn’t want to play that way. He is happy to play narrow and deep and then utilise the pace we have on the break. I don’t see why the older midfielders can’t run their socks off for 45 minutes and then get substituted at HT. it’s not like we don’t have enough defensive midfielders to choose from. Start with Milivojevic and McArthur, finish with Riedewald and MacCarthy or Kouyate.

Clyne appears to have lost pace,perhaps understandably due to the advancement of years and his injuries.I would not assert that Ayew is particularly fleet of foot but wouldn't file him under "Lacks pace".

I consider our defenders, Ward,Clyne,Cahill,Dann,Tomkins,Sakho all of whom are no longer the quickest.
The midfielders, Milivojevic,McArthur,McCarthy,Kouyate,are hardly players known for their pace nor creativity.
Out wide, I believe Townsend is not as quick as he was.
A dearth of pace and creativity in key areas and of course we have Benteke and Wickham in our squad as strikers.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 30 Nov 20 1.13pm

Originally posted by Willo

Clyne appears to have lost pace,perhaps understandably due to the advancement of years and his injuries.I would not assert that Ayew is particularly fleet of foot but wouldn't file him under "Lacks pace".

I consider our defenders, Ward,Clyne,Cahill,Dann,Tomkins,Sakho all of whom are no longer the quickest.
The midfielders, Milivojevic,McArthur,McCarthy,Kouyate,are hardly players known for their pace nor creativity.
Out wide, I believe Townsend is not as quick as he was.
A dearth of pace and creativity in key areas and of course we have Benteke and Wickham in our squad as strikers.

The team unsurprisingly reflects the attributes of the manager: dull, uninspiring, and predictable.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (30 Nov 2020 1.29pm)

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 30 Nov 20 3.40pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

If that isn’t the very definition of arrogance then I don’t know what is. It is perhaps not a coincidence that the two biggest know it alls on here are both in Cornwall. Enjoy your locals favourite game of eye spy with my middle eye.

That post reeks of arrogance in that you chose to insult
the indigenous people of Cornwall. In any case I did not abuse you in any way I merely referred to those people who have deliberately (and it is well documented) flouted the Covid regulations.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 30 Nov 20 3.55pm

It would be a fitting acknowledgement of an out-of-date manager who should have retired a few years ago, if Roy were to take us down in his last season in management. We'd be the martyr for all of football to look at and learn from. Taking one for the 'team'. Rid the game of dinosaurs. Crystal Palace helping to evolve the game of football by showing you how not to do it.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 30 Nov 20 3.56pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

That post reeks of arrogance in that you chose to insult
the indigenous people of Cornwall. In any case I did not abuse you in any way I merely referred to those people who have deliberately (and it is well documented) flouted the Covid regulations.

I apologise unreservedly to all two eyed people of Cornwall and those who may have lost one, or both come to think of it.

But, I do not buy into the reason for your self righteous indignation. As I said, you and WE, are like peas in a pod, you both like to dig out anyone who has an alternative opinion.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 30 Nov 20 4.04pm

we got away with it last season - not investing the AWB money, Roy did brilliantly to add McCarthy and Ayew to the squad and with a bit of rotation and competition for places, + very defensive tactics and discipline we managed enough narrow wins and results to finish mid table. But they were short term fixes - we've taken our eye off the ball with the midfield - they're mainly past their best, not the quickest and not very creative - in fact by prem standards we have a cloggers midfield - I think Wolves best showed our limitedness possession-wise, they pinged it about and moved in ways we can only dream about. Roy did brilliantly last year (till lockdown), but those methods can't continue, we need more finesse and energy in our midfield, we've just got tenacity and discipline atm, although it's funny recently our play through the pitch has been better, but we've failed more with the final pass, but a more creative midfield would enable us to make more and better chances, not the half chances we currently snatch at. It's not just Roy who is liable for our recent failings, he has never been backed in the market and he needs to be, he would get the team to play better with the right resources, he oversaw us beat Leicester 5-0 with Cabaye and Loftus Cheek in the side, we don't have that quality in midfield this season - we need to add to the squad or things will get worse I feel, Zaha's return will paper over the cracks no doubt, but I'm not sure refreshing our squad can wait till the end of the season when so many contracts are up.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 20 4.09pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

It would be a fitting acknowledgement of an out-of-date manager who should have retired a few years ago, if Roy were to take us down in his last season in management. We'd be the martyr for all of football to look at and learn from. Taking one for the 'team'. Rid the game of dinosaurs. Crystal Palace helping to evolve the game of football by showing you how not to do it.

Maybe if Hodgson had retired years ago we would not now by plying our trade in the PL.

Apropos "Dinosaurs", one person's "Dinosaur" is another persons highly experienced manager who has managed renowned clubs, won titles and has also managed at International level.

Should we win at WBA,the acrimony against Hodgson will be greatly reduced.A defeat and he will face a barrage of ordure and visceral vituperation.
One day he is cock of the walk, the next a feather duster.

 

PatrickA Flag London 30 Nov 20 4.45pm

I don’t understand why anybody who criticises Roy is depicted as a knee jerk reactionary to the most recent defeat.
If we beat WBA at the weekend it doesn’t negate the criticisms of him which are based on the form over most of this year.
I have reviewed Roy’s post match quotes after Brighton, Chelsea , Wolves, Burnley and Newcastle and even he has acknowledged shortcomings in performance.
If he’s prepared to accept there’s room for improvement I cannot understand the sensitivity of some on here if others dare to call into question some of his selections, decision making and tactics.
I’ve been encouraged by some of our play this season and hope we can continue to improve with players returning.
But even though I’m a realistic fan of many years including the years in the old division 3, and know it’s beyond us to consistently compete at the top level, I still expect us to strive to be the best we can and not accept mediocrity as high attainment.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 20 5.07pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

I don’t understand why anybody who criticises Roy is depicted as a knee jerk reactionary to the most recent defeat.
If we beat WBA at the weekend it doesn’t negate the criticisms of him which are based on the form over most of this year.

I have reviewed Roy’s post match quotes after Brighton, Chelsea , Wolves, Burnley and Newcastle and even he has acknowledged shortcomings in performance.
If he’s prepared to accept there’s room for improvement I cannot understand the sensitivity of some on here if others dare to call into question some of his selections, decision making and tactics.
I’ve been encouraged by some of our play this season and hope we can continue to improve with players returning.
But even though I’m a realistic fan of many years including the years in the old division 3, and know it’s beyond us to consistently compete at the top level, I still expect us to strive to be the best we can and not accept mediocrity as high attainment.

I accept that some supporters have a critical view based on recent seasons, however what I was advocating is that a defeat tends to stir up emotions of acrimony against Roy Hodgson, perhaps amongst those who perhaps have taken a longer view, but a victory has the proclivity NOT to cause such hyperventilation due to the fact that we have gained all the points.

There can be those who are still critical of form,style of play etc over a period of time but are not motivated to vent their spleens on websites after a win.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 30 Nov 20 5.16pm

Originally posted by Willo

I accept that some supporters have a critical view based on recent seasons, however what I was advocating is that a defeat tends to stir up emotions of acrimony against Roy Hodgson, perhaps amongst those who perhaps have taken a longer view, but a victory has the proclivity NOT to cause such hyperventilation due to the fact that we have gained all the points.

There can be those who are still critical of form,style of play etc over a period of time but are not motivated to vent their spleens on websites after a win.

Willo, you live in the same Weed catchment area as me. Just 2 weeks ago, having not won in 7 games, there was a group of Brighton fans calling for Potter to be replaced with someone with a more pragmatic approach.

A win and a draw later, and all is now well apparently.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Plaistow Eagle Flag 30 Nov 20 6.06pm

Originally posted by Willo

Maybe if Hodgson had retired years ago we would not now by plying our trade in the PL.

Apropos "Dinosaurs", one person's "Dinosaur" is another persons highly experienced manager who has managed renowned clubs, won titles and has also managed at International level.

Should we win at WBA,the acrimony against Hodgson will be greatly reduced.A defeat and he will face a barrage of ordure and visceral vituperation.
One day he is cock of the walk, the next a feather duster.

I like that analogy Willo..!!

COYP

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 20 6.28pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Willo, you live in the same Weed catchment area as me. Just 2 weeks ago, having not won in 7 games, there was a group of Brighton fans calling for Potter to be replaced with someone with a more pragmatic approach.

A win and a draw later, and all is now well apparently.

Neillo,I am further west than you.
I have not encountered a prevalence of Brighton supporters in my area, in actual fact I know and am aware of a number of our supporters!

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 30 Nov 20 7.30pm

Having just watched the Leicester Fulham game, which for the neutral was a decent game. I thought Fulham played very well. They certainly didn’t look like a nailed on relegation candidate. It makes the WBA game a massive game for us.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 30 Nov 20 10.54pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

We have plenty of youngsters in the U23s, Banks, Dreher, Kirby, who can run around all day. We have Mitchell, Zaha, Schlupp and Eze and PVA is also quick. Clyne is not slow either, nor Ayew!

I think it’s more the point that Roy doesn’t want to play that way. He is happy to play narrow and deep and then utilise the pace we have on the break. I don’t see why the older midfielders can’t run their socks off for 45 minutes and then get substituted at HT. it’s not like we don’t have enough defensive midfielders to choose from. Start with Milivojevic and McArthur, finish with Riedewald and MacCarthy or Kouyate.

So am I getting this right ? You're slaughtering the manager but advocating making pre-conceived substitutions as per a Sunday League or kids game with no allowance for injuries or what turn the game takes in the first half ? Ridiculous.

Playing less time isn't going to give the players speed or intensity either.

 

Page 6 of 9 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Just a bit of perspective.... Please?