You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Manchester City Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.03am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace v Manchester City Match Thread


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 01 May 21 4.50pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

An ageing team with little investment versus a team built with hundreds of millions. We worked hard but today we just lost to the better team. I thought Ward was motm and Mitchell had a reasonable game, and Eze was more involved, although his set-pieces were not great. Zaha was really poor today though. Poor decisions, poor touch and couldn't beat his man. Had he been at his best there were a few times when he could have done more. Not sure if he was carrying a knock, or just off his game.


Both Ward and Mitchell were good today. I thought Mitchell just shaded Wardy for MOTM, but just my opinion.
I agree with all your other comments and would add:
1) Once again Wilf failed to show any quality against one of the top teams.
2) Our 2 DMs did a reasonable job with Jairo for once (in recent games) getting one or two good tackles and interceptions in.
3) Mateta looked lost in those last 25 mins
4) Townsend showed he was the better option to start over Ayew.
5) Overall a reasonable performance from the team against the best club team in the land (and possibly in Europe/the World). But when you can afford to fork out £40m plus on every player in your squad (Foden excepted) your B team should beat the likes of us. This was Citeh's 19th consecutive away win in all competitions.

No disgrace today (unlike at the Etihad)

Edited by doombear (01 May 2021 4.52pm)

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 May 21 4.53pm

Originally posted by doombear

You presumably didn't see Kelly in the recent U23 game against Stoke. He was poor. Dann was in the same game and was the better of the two on that occasion IMO. Neither looked PL standard, though..

Not many of the squad do - Championship material at best. We've gone full circle: Holloway's Championship team that Pulis did well with to Hodgson's jaded and ageing side.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 01 May 21 5.04pm

Originally posted by doombear

Both Ward and Mitchell were good today. I thought Mitchell just shaded Wardy for MOTM, but just my opinion.
I agree with all your other comments and would add:
1) Once again Wilf failed to show any quality against one of the top teams.
2) Our 2 DMs did a reasonable job with Jairo for once (in recent games) getting one or two good tackles and interceptions in.
3) Mateta looked lost in those last 25 mins
4) Townsend showed he was the better option to start over Ayew.
5) Overall a reasonable performance from the team against the best club team in the land (and possibly in Europe/the World). But when you can afford to fork out £40m plus on every player in your squad (Foden excepted) your B team should beat the likes of us. This was Citeh's 19th consecutive away win in all competitions.

No disgrace today (unlike at the Etihad)

Edited by doombear (01 May 2021 4.52pm)

Yep. Unlike at Leicester where I think Roy got his subs wrong, today it was all about whether we could stop them scoring. Once they did they had complete control, just as they did when they took the lead against PSG midweek. We now have four games where we can be more competitive and hopefully get some points.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 May 21 5.14pm

Seen enough of Mateta now to understand why Benteke's being picked. Looks absolutely hopeless.

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 01 May 21 5.29pm

So why bring Mateta in?
Not the first suggestion that Parish and Freedman think one thing and Hodgson thinks another. The manager must be involved in transfer and loan policy if he picks the team.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 May 21 5.36pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Seen enough of Mateta now to understand why Benteke's being picked. Looks absolutely hopeless.

So he has 20 minutes against the best team in the country, when we are already losing 2-0 and he is hopeless! Did you say this after Brighton game? He has hardly had any game time, give the bloke a chance before writing him off

 

manoftaste Flag Hastings 01 May 21 5.48pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

So he has 20 minutes against the best team in the country, when we are already losing 2-0 and he is hopeless! Did you say this after Brighton game? He has hardly had any game time, give the bloke a chance before writing him off

Absolutely agree with this. Mateta is being treated the way Meyer was treated (and Reidewald until injuries forced Roy to pick him). He is being made marginal.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 01 May 21 6.17pm

The manager has looked at Mateta and doesn't rate him above the other options, simple as that.

Why did the club sign him? Because they judged it a risk worth taking given price vs potential value vs need. Same as any signing, some come off and some don't.

The real issue here is the wider one of which Mateta is but one example - however underwhelming our usual players might be, replacing them is extremely difficult. There are very few players in the world who are guaranteed to be a noticeable upgrade on a mid table Premier league player and that we can afford. All this 'Get rid of the deadwood' is all very good, but we need to be able to replace them with something better. Otherwise, and this is the bit I feel people miss too easily, we will be a worse team.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 May 21 6.19pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

So he has 20 minutes against the best team in the country, when we are already losing 2-0 and he is hopeless! Did you say this after Brighton game? He has hardly had any game time, give the bloke a chance before writing him off

He did absolutely nothing. I thought he was poor against Brighton (goal aside) and Leeds as well and should be doing more to affect the game. Can't hang onto the ball, has a poor touch, movement not great etc.

Obviously I stand to be proven wrong and will eat humble if that's the case.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 May 21 6.24pm

Originally posted by manoftaste

Absolutely agree with this. Mateta is being treated the way Meyer was treated (and Reidewald until injuries forced Roy to pick him). He is being made marginal.

Meyer wasn't good enough IMO. I'd watched Riedewald with interest in cup games and thought he looked heavy / leggy although he played well against City at home at the end of 2017. He looks lighter now but still not convinced he can play with the intensity to be a regular centre mid starter.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 01 May 21 6.25pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

He did absolutely nothing. I thought he was poor against Brighton (goal aside) and Leeds as well and should be doing more to affect the game. Can't hang onto the ball, has a poor touch, movement not great etc.

Obviously I stand to be proven wrong and will eat humble if that's the case.

He seems over qualified to play up front for us!

I didn’t see the game today but there must be a reason why he’s not played much. Either they’re working with him on the training pitch to get him ready for next season or he’s not as good as they thought he’d be.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 May 21 6.27pm

Originally posted by Elwissthebest

So why bring Mateta in?
Not the first suggestion that Parish and Freedman think one thing and Hodgson thinks another. The manager must be involved in transfer and loan policy if he picks the team.

I'm not sure that's a given to be honest but Eze aside we've been shopping in the bargain basement haven't we ?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 May 21 7.17pm

Originally posted by eritheagle

He seems over qualified to play up front for us!

I didn’t see the game today but there must be a reason why he’s not played much. Either they’re working with him on the training pitch to get him ready for next season or he’s not as good as they thought he’d be.

Because Roy says Benteke is a better defender

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 May 21 7.19pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

He did absolutely nothing. I thought he was poor against Brighton (goal aside) and Leeds as well and should be doing more to affect the game. Can't hang onto the ball, has a poor touch, movement not great etc.

Obviously I stand to be proven wrong and will eat humble if that's the case.

Soa few long balls up to him, with his back to goal and not one pass to his feet. What is he meant to do? IMO you will be proved wrong about him, as long as he gets sufficient chances

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 01 May 21 7.32pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

He did absolutely nothing. I thought he was poor against Brighton (goal aside) and Leeds as well and should be doing more to affect the game. Can't hang onto the ball, has a poor touch, movement not great etc.

Obviously I stand to be proven wrong and will eat humble if that's the case.

You and I are seeing exactly the same thing then. I'll gladly join you for a slice of that humble pie if he comes good next year (seemingly under different management) but I don't think we need to set the table just yet.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 01 May 21 7.44pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Because Roy says Benteke is a better defender

Er ummm ... maybe a silly idea, but why don't we play our forwards up field and give them the football in front of goal?

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

cryrst Flag The garden of England 01 May 21 8.01pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Er ummm ... maybe a silly idea, but why don't we play our forwards up field and give them the football in front of goal?

0-0 is success 38 times a season.
In some managers opinions I guess.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 May 21 8.04pm

Originally posted by manoftaste

Absolutely agree with this. Mateta is being treated the way Meyer was treated (and Reidewald until injuries forced Roy to pick him). He is being made marginal.

From what I've seen of Mateta so far, I think we were wise to try before we buy. And at the moment I can't see us going through with the full fee.

Aside from a slick finish against Brighton, he looks like a player that's been promoted from the youth team to the first team too soon.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 01 May 21 8.25pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

From what I've seen of Mateta so far, I think we were wise to try before we buy. And at the moment I can't see us going through with the full fee.

Aside from a slick finish against Brighton, he looks like a player that's been promoted from the youth team to the first team too soon.

We create so few chances that a striker needs to be able to convert at the Harry Kane level to make an impact on the result. How many chances has Mateta had in the last 3 months? A hell of a lot less than Benteke. Who has started pretty much every game. And how many goals has Benteke scored in that time.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 May 21 8.32pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

We create so few chances that a striker needs to be able to convert at the Harry Kane level to make an impact on the result. How many chances has Mateta had in the last 3 months? A hell of a lot less than Benteke. Who has started pretty much every game. And how many goals has Benteke scored in that time.

I'm not passing judgement solely on goals. His overall play needs to improve.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Manchester City Match Thread