This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Good news, 1 done 2 to go.
I am not a bot. No, seriously, I'm not. |
|
|
Originally posted by The Beger
Good news, 1 done 2 to go. I think it's just 1 to go as all the reports are saying that Townsend won't be having his contract renewed
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Give one of the youngsters a chance and I'm pretty sure they'd be just as effective as Townsend. I'm not that bothered if he goes, as long as we have cover. Let's face it, he'd lost most of his pace and nearly always lost the ball. He had flashes of good play each season but looked off the pace plenty of times too. I wish him every luck for the future, he served us well, but time to move on. I would have really liked Townsend to stay, he clearly likes his time here and the players I seem to like the most, are those who want to be here the most. However reading your post has kind of changed my mind a bit. I think your right about his performances and what he does can be replaced. It would make sense to go with youth as an understudy to whoever gets a regular place. Having said that, he still offers something in terms of being a fairly good backup option and just plain old team togethernes. Is that enough? Probably not but I would offer him a smaller contract, while making it clear that his game time would be limited. If he goes for that then great or he could try and get a first team place with another team. I hate to see players that like the club leaving but, nowards and upwards first. If Townsend doesn't get a new deal, then I would like to say, thanks for your good service, really wish you well and good luck for the future.
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead" Stan Laurel |
|
|
Originally posted by Mr Palaceman
I would have really liked Townsend to stay, he clearly likes his time here and the players I seem to like the most, are those who want to be here the most. However reading your post has kind of changed my mind a bit. I think your right about his performances and what he does can be replaced. It would make sense to go with youth as an understudy to whoever gets a regular place. Having said that, he still offers something in terms of being a fairly good backup option and just plain old team togethernes. Is that enough? Probably not but I would offer him a smaller contract, while making it clear that his game time would be limited. If he goes for that then great or he could try and get a first team place with another team. I hate to see players that like the club leaving but, nowards and upwards first. If Townsend doesn't get a new deal, then I would like to say, thanks for your good service, really wish you well and good luck for the future. I think you'll find it's yes Wards! He got a new deal
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
I think you'll find it's yes Wards! He got a new deal Very good..
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead" Stan Laurel |
|
|
Fascinating insight You could be onto something here in that we have players to develop there and - dare I say it - buy. I wonder if it's a bit simpler than that and Andros fancied a move away more than the other two. They got the offers partly because they were sold on Palace as their immediate home. He's still notionally in his prime and can become a main man at somewhere like Norwich say and get more or less guaranteed first teems footie. It's been a while since he's been a real regular on the teamsheet with us. Greener pastures? He has after all moved about a fair amount whereas the other two have barely had a transfer between them. Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I wouldn't have thought Cahill, Ward and Clyne out-performed Townsend last year, or offered noticeable better value to wages. Here's a thought... I remember years ago Peterborough (under the ownership and guidance of Barry Fry) believed that they always needed to employ attack-minded managers who played open, skilful football. This was not because it was the most likely way of achieving promotion (any style of play can be effective), but because the club needed to sell the players it produced, and Fry reasoned that a promising young attacker would always fetch a far higher price than a promising young defender. If he employed a defensive-minded manager then his attacking players would not shine as much, and the business plan would not work. Now, obviously promising young defenders can go for big money too (see AWB), but I think there's still some logic to Fry's theory. I wonder if perhaps -in part at least- Cahill, Ward and Clyne are being offered new terms but not Townsend because the potential value of an exciting young attacker is greater than that of a young defender. If Olise, Rak-Sakyi or Omilabu prove to be good top flight players very quickly, they are far more likely to be worth a fortune than a young defender would be. It might be as simple as Townsend having the misfortune to play in a position where we would benefit most from developing a young player, financially speaking. Personally, I'd still keep him. If he was available on a free transfer from another club we'd all say he was a sensible signing. However, perhaps Parish and Freedman want to remove as many obstacles as they can from the paths of Olise, Rak-Sakyi etc so as to maximise the chances of increasing the squad value to its greatest extent. Edited by TheBigToePunt (15 Jul 2021 4.31pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I wouldn't have thought Cahill, Ward and Clyne out-performed Townsend last year, or offered noticeable better value to wages. Here's a thought... I remember years ago Peterborough (under the ownership and guidance of Barry Fry) believed that they always needed to employ attack-minded managers who played open, skilful football. This was not because it was the most likely way of achieving promotion (any style of play can be effective), but because the club needed to sell the players it produced, and Fry reasoned that a promising young attacker would always fetch a far higher price than a promising young defender. If he employed a defensive-minded manager then his attacking players would not shine as much, and the business plan would not work. Now, obviously promising young defenders can go for big money too (see AWB), but I think there's still some logic to Fry's theory. I wonder if perhaps -in part at least- Cahill, Ward and Clyne are being offered new terms but not Townsend because the potential value of an exciting young attacker is greater than that of a young defender. If Olise, Rak-Sakyi or Omilabu prove to be good top flight players very quickly, they are far more likely to be worth a fortune than a young defender would be. It might be as simple as Townsend having the misfortune to play in a position where we would benefit most from developing a young player, financially speaking. Personally, I'd still keep him. If he was available on a free transfer from another club we'd all say he was a sensible signing. However, perhaps Parish and Freedman want to remove as many obstacles as they can from the paths of Olise, Rak-Sakyi etc so as to maximise the chances of increasing the squad value to its greatest extent. Edited by TheBigToePunt (15 Jul 2021 4.31pm) I think the simpler answer is probably that Andros is a vocal Spurs fan and Vieira is having none of that.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Omph
Fascinating insight You could be onto something here in that we have players to develop there and - dare I say it - buy. I wonder if it's a bit simpler than that and Andros fancied a move away more than the other two. They got the offers partly because they were sold on Palace as their immediate home. He's still notionally in his prime and can become a main man at somewhere like Norwich say and get more or less guaranteed first teems footie. It's been a while since he's been a real regular on the teamsheet with us. Greener pastures? He has after all moved about a fair amount whereas the other two have barely had a transfer between them. All possible of course, but Townsends tone whenever he is asked about his future on Talksport very much suggests a man who wants to remain at Palace and is waiting in the hope of a contract offer.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
All possible of course, but Townsends tone whenever he is asked about his future on Talksport very much suggests a man who wants to remain at Palace and is waiting in the hope of a contract offer.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
All possible of course, but Townsends tone whenever he is asked about his future on Talksport very much suggests a man who wants to remain at Palace and is waiting in the hope of a contract offer. My understanding was that he had been offered a contract on reduced terms and has decided to seek a better offer elsewhere. I don't know if the offer has an expiry date though so I guess we'll see if he goes somewhere else.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Putitout
Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978 |
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I wouldn't have thought Cahill, Ward and Clyne out-performed Townsend last year, or offered noticeable better value to wages. Here's a thought... I remember years ago Peterborough (under the ownership and guidance of Barry Fry) believed that they always needed to employ attack-minded managers who played open, skilful football. This was not because it was the most likely way of achieving promotion (any style of play can be effective), but because the club needed to sell the players it produced, and Fry reasoned that a promising young attacker would always fetch a far higher price than a promising young defender. If he employed a defensive-minded manager then his attacking players would not shine as much, and the business plan would not work. Now, obviously promising young defenders can go for big money too (see AWB), but I think there's still some logic to Fry's theory. I wonder if perhaps -in part at least- Cahill, Ward and Clyne are being offered new terms but not Townsend because the potential value of an exciting young attacker is greater than that of a young defender. If Olise, Rak-Sakyi or Omilabu prove to be good top flight players very quickly, they are far more likely to be worth a fortune than a young defender would be. It might be as simple as Townsend having the misfortune to play in a position where we would benefit most from developing a young player, financially speaking. Personally, I'd still keep him. If he was available on a free transfer from another club we'd all say he was a sensible signing. However, perhaps Parish and Freedman want to remove as many obstacles as they can from the paths of Olise, Rak-Sakyi etc so as to maximise the chances of increasing the squad value to its greatest extent. Edited by TheBigToePunt (15 Jul 2021 4.31pm) This is a really sensible post. I can see why Barry Fry took this approach however I agree with you that with Palace it is more the fact we want to create a pathway for our youth. We do have some exciting talent coming through our Academy.
True Blue Red 'n' Blue !!! |
|
|
Thought this was to do with a contract extension but appears to be that Palace didn’t wish Andros a happy birthday on their Twitter account until late in the day. [Tweet Link]
Edited by Bubbs (17 Jul 2021 5.47am)
'Better stop dreaming of the quiet life 'cos it's the one we'll never know' |
|
|
I hear that Clyne has signed a new contract, not announced yet, however he is playing in the Walsall friendly.
I am not a bot. No, seriously, I'm not. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.