This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by kuge
The population density argument as regards deaths is not supported by the data. There are many countries with a higher density of population with far lower numbers of fatalities. This chart shows us that the UK as of October 6, 2021, has a death rate of 2,018.76 per million and a population density of 272.9 people per Km2. Compared to: The UK looks to have performed very badly. That is even before we consider the levels of health care available in these different countries. Looking at a comparable nation in Europe I'm not going to claim we've covered ourselves in glory. Buy there a are far more factors at play than just population density. Our free at the point of care health care system might not be as effective as other private systems in the world. Reporting on testing within 28 days of a positive test might be a bit sharper here than other places. Existing obesity rates and poor fitness levels in the population. Having an larger elderly population. Different weather conditions, etc etc Some externalities of being a more prosperous nation might hit us harder than poorer nations. In other ways we might be better protected. Given all the variables. It's going to be years until we can objectively assess this and come up with a standard measurement to qualitify what country performed best. On top of that you'd have to assess the long term implications of lock down on the population. Impacts of Covid belly inactivity. Adverse affects of the development of the young. Chuck enough metrics at it and the data will all be totally worthless - except to those who'd like a good debate. No one really knows the truth yet.
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
I agree with him our MPs are hard working and selfless because they are paid so badly nobody wants to do the job just look at the next general election there wont be any candidates , oh wait.... Wait indeed Badger, wait indeed!
|
|
|
Originally posted by kuge
Yes, the UK has a death rate nearly double that of Germany which has a very similar population density and a comparable level of health care. Your argument would put the difference in deaths purely down to compliance? I think if you had asked someone pre pandemic what they though death rates would be comparing Bangladesh to the UK they would have likely said that the UK would perform better. There are obviously other factors to consider, however, what is very clear the UK has performed badly. Exactly why this is might take some time to fully understand. The government will not be partially interested in having the evidence examined as it’s unlikely to let them off lightly. Mr Johnson will just say something like, “time to move on, or people are tired of hearing about that”. Yes, compliance, density and methods of recording statistics, probably other factors but I'm no expert. You may think the UK has performed badly but personally I'm more inclined to the view that there is an inflated opinion more contagious than the virus over how much a government can affect these statistics once density and compliance factors are taken in. Of course they can destroy their economies finding out.....which is basically what has happened. Save some boomers while you place future generations into ever more heavier chains. It's always easier to have concern for the tragedy you see while it's far easier to ignore the far larger one being created. Forgive my cynicism. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Oct 2021 7.46pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
The private sector pulled out all the stops during the pandemic:- Privatisation is a clapped-out model.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The private sector pulled out all the stops during the pandemic:- Privatisation is a clapped-out model. Interesting I saw an article recently that said NHS staff were refusing (political reasons) to refer patients to private hospitals even though they had the capacity and the treatment had been paid for. I don't know what the truth is but somebody needs to get their act together.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
The private sector pulled out all the stops during the pandemic:- Privatisation is a clapped-out model. If the figures are there to show vfm and quality through renationalising all these private (former state) businesses I'm up for a read. Until then it's really just a political wet dream!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Interesting I saw an article recently that said NHS staff were refusing (political reasons) to refer patients to private hospitals even though they had the capacity and the treatment had been paid for. I don't know what the truth is but somebody needs to get their act together. Haha - no Daily Mail link there, then. I am sorry Mr. S, but I can't refer you. But Doctor, why not? I am afraid to say that, from our records, it appears you are not a liberal democrat.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Haha - no Daily Mail link there, then. I am sorry Mr. S, but I can't refer you. But Doctor, why not? I am afraid to say that, from our records, it appears you are not a liberal democrat.
Or it could just be a cynical move from the BMA to try to show the old we need more money,higher wages,more managers on the NHS.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Or it could just be a cynical move from the BMA to try to show the old we need more money,higher wages,more managers on the NHS. I cannot imagine that this was the NHS, more likely the Private places being tricky. Private hospitals aren’t there to get their hands dirty. They are there to take £000’s from the Insurer for doing a bit of work on your knee or some other specific body part. In and out. “We’ve replaced your knee, your insurer has paid us, now f**k off.” They’re not there for emergencies - it’s why you get an amount per day back from your private health insurer, if you spend time in an NHS Hospital. Last thing your average private hospital wants to do is have long term sick patients or emergency stuff. It buggers the model up - too costly with too small returns, too risky for staff and too tricky to price. So many companies now offer private health care as part of the employment package as it gets their staff looked at quickly and back to work. It’s lucrative for everyone. If you clog it up with emergencies or general treatment then waiting lists there will go up and employers may think twice about that cost if it doesn’t make as much difference. Private hospitals won’t want to damage the model as health insurance work has to be their major cash cow. That there are so many consultants doing half a day NHS and four and a half private also hasn’t helped the NHS. (A sort of ‘I’m spending most of my time treating those that can afford to pay me to be treated rather than those who deserve, need or can’t afford it’). When they’re on the TV slagging off NHS funding or pay you never hear them mention how much they earn, on the side, from the private sector. (NOT nurses - Doctors and Consultants - to qualify that point). The model remains broken. It’s only a matter of time (with this bloody Govt) before we see a “Thorpe Park” style fast track system coming into it one day - a sort of NHS/Private hybrid where you can pay more for quicker NHS care - just to really ram it home to the poor and increase the divide. Just my opinion.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Or it could just be a cynical move from the BMA to try to show the old we need more money,higher wages,more managers on the NHS. Exactly the article was written by a doctor as I said I don't know if it is true but if it is it is shameful that people waiting for scans to see if they had cancer were denied this. If it is not true and the reason was that the private sector didn't have staff so couldn't do the job then whoever agreed that contract should be investigated. Either way someone screwed up. Edited by Badger11 (08 Oct 2021 7.42am)
One more point |
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Helmet46
I cannot imagine that this was the NHS, more likely the Private places being tricky. Private hospitals aren’t there to get their hands dirty. They are there to take £000’s from the Insurer for doing a bit of work on your knee or some other specific body part. In and out. “We’ve replaced your knee, your insurer has paid us, now f**k off.” They’re not there for emergencies - it’s why you get an amount per day back from your private health insurer, if you spend time in an NHS Hospital. Last thing your average private hospital wants to do is have long term sick patients or emergency stuff. It buggers the model up - too costly with too small returns, too risky for staff and too tricky to price. So many companies now offer private health care as part of the employment package as it gets their staff looked at quickly and back to work. It’s lucrative for everyone. If you clog it up with emergencies or general treatment then waiting lists there will go up and employers may think twice about that cost if it doesn’t make as much difference. Private hospitals won’t want to damage the model as health insurance work has to be their major cash cow. That there are so many consultants doing half a day NHS and four and a half private also hasn’t helped the NHS. (A sort of ‘I’m spending most of my time treating those that can afford to pay me to be treated rather than those who deserve, need or can’t afford it’). When they’re on the TV slagging off NHS funding or pay you never hear them mention how much they earn, on the side, from the private sector. (NOT nurses - Doctors and Consultants - to qualify that point). The model remains broken. It’s only a matter of time (with this bloody Govt) before we see a “Thorpe Park” style fast track system coming into it one day - a sort of NHS/Private hybrid where you can pay more for quicker NHS care - just to really ram it home to the poor and increase the divide. Just my opinion.
|
|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
Funny thing is, most of these private hospitals have the same doctor and consultants that are working in your local nhs hospital, they work private on their days off, private hospitals aren"t usually equipped for a full scale operation melt down, thats why its best to get the nhs. Only thing is, you could wait years for your nhs appointment under this government, but could wait days to go private! Decisions decisions. Why shouldn't a doctor or consultant do both. As long as they do their contracted NHS hours then it's fine. If the NHS management aren't strong enough to tie them down to more hours whose fault is that; not the quacks!
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Why shouldn't a doctor or consultant do both. As long as they do their contracted NHS hours then it's fine. If the NHS management aren't strong enough to tie them down to more hours whose fault is that; not the quacks! Why not indeed?-although tell that to the person at the back of the 5 million queue needing an urgent operation -without the plumbers wad in his/her pocket to go private! As for the nhs should pay them enough- you better ask bungle mate , he promised them a big pay rise after their heroic covid effort, only to deliver a pay cut after inflation! Mind you, they were stupid to believe bunble, he is a CON, who knew?
|
|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
Why not indeed?-although tell that to the person at the back of the 5 million queue needing an urgent operation -without the plumbers wad in his/her pocket to go private! As for the nhs should pay them enough- you better ask bungle mate , he promised them a big pay rise after their heroic covid effort, only to deliver a pay cut after inflation! Mind you, they were stupid to believe bunble, he is a CON, who knew? Well said plumber doesn't have a wad like yourself but has got a JOB which has a perk of private health care. Why do nurses deserve a huge pay rise? They were doing their JOB that they accepted on certain Ts and Cs. Should've gone private!
|
|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
Why not indeed?-although tell that to the person at the back of the 5 million queue needing an urgent operation -without the plumbers wad in his/her pocket to go private! As for the nhs should pay them enough- you better ask bungle mate , he promised them a big pay rise after their heroic covid effort, only to deliver a pay cut after inflation! Mind you, they were stupid to believe bunble, he is a CON, who knew? Excuse me…Please do show us where Boris ‘promised them a big pay rise’ ?!
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Well said plumber doesn't have a wad like yourself but has got a JOB which has a perk of private health care. Why do nurses deserve a huge pay rise? They were doing their JOB that they accepted on certain Ts and Cs. Should've gone private! They took a risk mate, above and beyond the call of duty-and some took a bullet- lest we forget!
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
Excuse me…Please do show us where Boris ‘promised them a big pay rise’ ?! You are correct phil, they had mooted a 2,1% payrise , but that was only mooted! I must have got distracted by Boris giving his chief of staff a 40%, yes, 40% pay rise! Who"s more important, Domonic cummings or an NHS nurse?, you decide!
|
|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
They took a risk mate, above and beyond the call of duty-and some took a bullet- lest we forget! They could have just been unlucky as most didn't.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.