You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The FA Cup Semi Final match thread
November 16 2026 4.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The FA Cup Semi Final match thread


Page 6 of 10 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
samprior Flag Hamburg 17 Apr 22 7.07pm

A shame that we never really made a game of it. Tactics kind of surprised Chelsea first half and it was a stalemate but we couldn't find any answers in the second half. Annoying that it just drifted by but it'll be a good bit of experience for the young team. Tough on Mitchell that his mistake cost us.

But anyway if you'd told me at the start of this season we'd be safe with 10 games or more to go and an FA Cup semi final I'd have snapped your hand off.

Hopefully a few more decent performances to come before the end of the season and then "transition part 2" in the summer.

Disappointing today but I still feel positive about our direction. Fans sounded great today.

COYP

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 17 Apr 22 7.08pm

Disappointed but not too surprised with the result.

All credit to our supporters who were majestic today, even after the final whistle.

Feel for Mitchell who had a strong game, but made one mistake.

Gallagher would have made a difference, how much we will never know and not worth trying to evaluate. Nothing to be gained.

Butland did OK and wasn't at fault for their goals.

Ayew tries to go it alone too much. Clearly desperate to score and lacks vision to see better opportunities for others.

Olise should have started and can only assume he wasn't fully fit.

Biggest let down was Eze. I used to be his biggest fan, but he didn't impress today. Far too negative I thought.

We did well to get to the semi with a young, inexperienced and inexpensive team. I expect more from them next year, but in the meantime, well done lads.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 17 Apr 22 7.09pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

PV did his best. The Chelscum chequebook got us. Show me the weak chink in their squad ?

did they cost 4 times or 8 times the Palace squad ? for money ?


Why are PSG not winning everything then.

Nothing to do with cost if it was Palace should have been relegated years ago.

We beat Man City this season and the other game only a few weeks ago was a draw this is the team who are top of the league look how much they are worth more then Chelsea.


Originally posted by Robk

Wilf never really does it against the top teams...certainly not Chelsea.....

He is not a top player that is why it is very clear to see the best players turn up in these games he never has this is what the scouts see as well which is why no big team is interested in him.


Originally posted by Steveoxon

You boys turn against the manager and team in a thrice. This has been the best season for years and you still moan. Don't believe it. You to*sers think you can come up with a better match plan than one of the best premier league players of all time! Palace don't deserve tw ats like you wingers. Unbelievable.

Edited by Steveoxon (17 Apr 2022 6.50pm)


Best season how so? its not over yet we are currently in 13th in the league with other teams very close behind us if we mess up a few more we could be down to 16th.

We reached a cup final with AP with mostly championship level players and finished in the league 15th.

Best league place has been 11th with very little investment those years.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Den1923 Flag 17 Apr 22 7.12pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

That's because he is a completely different player.

Edited by Slimey Toad (17 Apr 2022 6.58pm)

That obvious and clearly not as good!

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 17 Apr 22 7.12pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Disappointed but not too surprised with the result.

All credit to our supporters who were majestic today, even after the final whistle.

Feel for Mitchell who had a strong game, but made one mistake.

Gallagher would have made a difference, how much we will never know and not worth trying to evaluate. Nothing to be gained.

Butland did OK and wasn't at fault for their goals.

Ayew tries to go it alone too much. Clearly desperate to score and lacks vision to see better opportunities for others.

Olise should have started and can only assume he wasn't fully fit.

Biggest let down was Eze. I used to be his biggest fan, but he didn't impress today. Far too negative I thought.

We did well to get to the semi with a young, inexperienced and inexpensive team. I expect more from them next year, but in the meantime, well done lads.

Agree.

We didn't really show up today, said it before but will say it again we looked as though we were playing for penalties which may have actually worked on another day but is disappointing.

Butland not to blame but I think Guaita would have been the better choice, c'est la vie! Mitchell made a mistake, easy to read too much in to, he's already earned his forgiveness and we move on.

Would liked to have seen a bit more attacking intent, a bit of Wilf's magic, a few more chances created, etc. etc. We have a new look, young and promising squad but a few way past their best still hanging on: Jmac, Luka, Ward, Ayew, Benteke etc etc. All have more than had their day of course but not quite up for it, at all, anymore.

It looked to me as though Chelsea were there for the taking first half, but they probably thought the same about us. One team took the initiative second half and the other didn't.

Frustrating, disappointing and in the end a poor showing from us but, again, c'est la vie. I wouldn't have held much hope for the final if we did go through, admittedly, and in the grand scheme of things a trip to Wembley is never too shabby for a first season manager. Let's hope for a few more wins and points for a decent finish as the season closes.

COYP!!!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

PatrickA Flag London 17 Apr 22 7.14pm

The first hour the tactics worked well in terms of stifling Chelsea and there was not much between the teams.
When Mateta went off it seemed to unbalance us and we seemed to play 10 yards further back and invited pressure.
There was only going to be one winner after that.
Good performances from the centre backs and Kouyate.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 17 Apr 22 7.16pm

We really missed Gallagher today. No great surprise that when your best player and pretty much ever-present all season ISNT playing - that you struggle to adapt and other players don’t step up, especially at a pressure occasion like Wembley. We either try and replace him or we move on with the players we have. Still a good season.

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 17 Apr 22 7.17pm

Anti climax or missed opportunity?! Not sure what is applicable

However, I agree with others…it’s one game…second half just attack and enjoy it. Only when the changes were made did we start to look a little more threatening.

Personally, should have stuck with our usual system…Ward playing as a wing back did not work.

Anyway, it was a good day out…did see Mitchell limping off at the end…hopefully just fatigue

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 17 Apr 22 7.19pm

We lost today lads , youd think we would be used to it by now . I didnt expect to win , i congratulated my brother who is a Chelski fan before we kicked a ball . IMO that was not our strongest team and when i saw Ward on the starting 11 no Ayew or Olise no cline or Vincente i was miffed and Eze didnt exactly set the field ablaze with his dribbling skills like he used to . But it is what it is . our fans were great , hopefully Chelski will beat the scummy Scousers . On to the next game and COYP .

 

Elwissthebest Flag Marlborough 17 Apr 22 7.21pm

The bottom line is that we didn't have to beat anyone decent to get to the Semi final. If you chose a joint Chelsea/Palace XI, it would feature eleven Chelsea players. A player who Chelsea sent out on loan has made an appearance for England which is credit to Palace but puts the thing in perspective.
We play better football than last season and we have become harder to beat. It is a fact, however, that we have won seven league games in thirty one outings.

 

adelaar Flag Edgware 17 Apr 22 7.21pm

We are all disappointed and that's good. We want and think there is more to come from this team.
For me we have to let Luka and Benteke go, they are well past their sell by date. Ward also just isn't up to this level.
Sort that and somehow work out how to do without Gallagher, things will be rosy next season!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 Apr 22 7.22pm

Just to reiterate the point I made earlier: without Gallagher's industry we just cannot compete at the level required to win this type of game. I wouldn't cite Eze as Gallagher's replacement, a completely different type of player; that said I think Eze is the most overated player currently on the books.
Without Gallagher Vieira gambled, mixed it up, and ultimately came up short. Quite evident that we need a right back, a decent box to box midfielder, and another striker at the very least.
Next season should be interesting.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 17 Apr 22 7.22pm

We either need Gallagher to stay or an identical replacement.

Chelsea were never under his type of pressure.

A good performance just lacking that extra oomph.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 17 Apr 22 7.52pm

To beat the top teams the game plan has to be right or lucky and your best players have to perform

Didnt happen , it was a fun ride though . COYP

 

Wilesy01 Flag Bristol 17 Apr 22 7.56pm

Chelsea fans giving it the big one on the tube despite the fact they've left the game at the full time whistle and not bothered to stay and celebrate in the stadium.

What a sad little club.

 

Zaha127 Flag 17 Apr 22 8.02pm

Shows Palace need to invest again this summer. Gallagher will probably back he can get ahead of Werner for Chelsea's first team.

Finding a replacement for him is very difficult. Striking wise there are options: Mateda and hopefully Edouard plays more next season and does well. Midfield is where the main investment is needed.

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 17 Apr 22 8.12pm

I can't really look past us playing 5 at the back for 70 minutes. We changed our whole philosophy to suit Chelsea's and it just looked disjointed going forwards for the whole game. Not saying it would've changed the result but would've liked us to be a bit braver and stick to the 433 the players know.

 

CT Charlie Flag 17 Apr 22 8.20pm

I thought we did well actually, and I'll defend PV's game plan.

1) We were never going to dominate play. We needed to take our chances, and we missed 3 good ones: Andersen's header, Kouyate's header, and Kouyate's drive off the post.

2) Defensively, our formation and team play was fine. Only two individual errors led to the goals. Chelsea seldom threatened.

3) Up front, I suspect PV hoped Wilf would have a greater chance of earning a penalty if he played nearer the center.

4) Our lack of pressure seemed more of a tactical choice than a matter of Gallagher's absence. I think PV feared that Chelsea would burn us if we tried to apply pressure high.

5) As for man selection, I believe PV wanted to spread the wealth, share the load, reward the veterans. I can't argue.


It took a superb shot in the 66th minute for the game to turn against us and even then, we had a chance if Andersen had executed a routine header from point-blank range. For a side with exactly 0 players who would see much, if any, playing time for Chelsea, we played well enough to pull off a massive upset.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 Apr 22 8.24pm

Originally posted by steven_t92

I can't really look past us playing 5 at the back for 70 minutes. We changed our whole philosophy to suit Chelsea's and it just looked disjointed going forwards for the whole game. Not saying it would've changed the result but would've liked us to be a bit braver and stick to the 433 the players know.

Most certainly, and a sure indication of psychological capitulation by Vieira. I was right about one thing, I thought Vieira would start cautiously, and when I saw that line-up and the mode they were laid out I thought Hodgson had returned and we were playing for a draw...

 

NE14T Flag 17 Apr 22 8.30pm

Oh well. We didn’t deserve that. If Anderson had buried the sitter header we may have been lifted and gone on to win but you reap what you sow. Very poor last 25 mins.

 


The beatings will stop when morale improves.

Page 6 of 10 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The FA Cup Semi Final match thread