You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle v Crystal Palace match thread
November 16 2026 4.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Newcastle v Crystal Palace match thread


Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 21 Apr 22 3.28am

It's a wake up call for sure, Newcastle just leapfrogged us, after the terrible form from the start and the odds of going down that they had.

It was never going to be an easy season.

What we have to do now, is prepare for next season.

Sorry to say it, CG needs to be a benched player - it's time for next years team to gel..

 


This was once a quality forum....

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 21 Apr 22 5.04am

Why are we playing in slow slow-motion most of the time? We improved when Macca and Mateta came on, unfortunately Schlupp with his strolling around and safe, sideways/backwards passing stayed on. And please, please stop that dicking around with defensive passing in defence. Even with three minutes remaining and we're 0-1 down, we aree doing it.

 

Jimmy Doyle Flag Butterworth 21 Apr 22 6.07am

Bejaysus, that was a shocking first half. We looked so much better when Mateta and McArthur came on in the second. Mitchell, Schlupp, Kouyate, Edouard and Zaha had performances best forgetten quickly. For me Guehi was our best player.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 21 Apr 22 6.36am

Originally posted by Willo

I would not be unhappy to see Ayew shown the door.He offers nothing at all.
McArthur has been a great servant but he is 34 and in the twilight of his career.
Most certainly, we need more creativity from our midfield next season and attacking full-backs would introduce a different dimension to our play.

Edited by Willo (20 Apr 2022 11.03pm)

Its not about full backs and midfield, its the decision making in the final third that lets us down. The only one, who has the coolness is Olise and he had a poor game, maybe injured.

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 21 Apr 22 6.44am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Why are we playing in slow slow-motion most of the time? We improved when Macca and Mateta came on, unfortunately Schlupp with his strolling around and safe, sideways/backwards passing stayed on. And please, please stop that dicking around with defensive passing in defence. Even with three minutes remaining and we're 0-1 down, we aree doing it.

That drove me nuts in the Leicester game as well. One goal in it, a couple of minutes of injury time to go and we're passing it from inside their half gradually backwards all the way to our keeper. There just doesn't seem to be that sense of urgency that other teams had in all those games in the first half of the season where we were trying to defend a one goal lead...and failing.

It's like we're prioritising goal difference above points...which would be nice as we'd be back in 9th.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 21 Apr 22 6.54am

I was thinking that we need two new midfield signings, but more likely we need three.

Luka, Jimmy Mac - done at this level
Schlupp - an athlete but not a footballer
Kouyate, Hughes - average at best
Gallagher - not our player
Eze - potential yet to be proven

The ball needs to move quicker from the back into midfield, less faffing about side to side. I don't think the current midfield (apart from Gallagher) have the savvy or natural ability to receive, carry, and release the ball in any offensive or creative sense other than our position in the league suggests. It's been like this for quite a few seasons and is unlikely to change whilst we employ run of the mill midfielders. It's ironic that our best player in the position is a loanee who can't get into his parent side.

To digress a little, I should add that in the grand heirarchy of things, and money and the best players concentrated in a limited number of clubs, since 2010 we have done exceptionally well to make up the numbers. Because that is what it is for clubs like us and those around us, we make up the numbers so there is some pretence that there is a competitive league and everything is equal.
Yes, we've done well with the resources at hand. Can we break into the top 10? We'll need better midfielders to do that.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (21 Apr 2022 7.57am)

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 21 Apr 22 7.51am

Originally posted by Willo

As someone mentioned to me tonight, in Hodgson's last 3 seasons, after 32 games, we had amassed 10 wins twice and 11 wins once, currently after 32 games we have only won 8 games.

Edited by Willo (20 Apr 2022 11.57pm)

We had 41 points after 35 games last season. After Leeds & Watford at home coming up we’ll probably be the same or better. And who can forget those thrilling cup runs under Hodgson….

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 21 Apr 22 8.21am

Not sure what to make of this result. After the Arsenal game (which was a great achievement), we seem to be suffering from a bout of ‘over confidence’. Perhaps too much tactical thinking by the management team…perhaps let other teams worry about our tactics and not the reverse.

Anyway, it’s not doom and gloom as others would highlight. The end of the season will soon be upon us, then we can properly reflect.

Form is a strange thing…Arsenal beat Chelsea…we beat Arsenal…Chelsea beat us…you know what I mean…

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 21 Apr 22 8.24am

Wish people would stop picking out players to blame, we've had a good solid season and our first where we've really got our teeth into trying to play in a different way. All clubs have moments that they wish they didn't.

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 21 Apr 22 8.33am

Did anybody else notice that Conor was not happy being taken off ans kind of slapped out at Patricks hand , and i watched the whole match and they did not once show any palace fans but then again i was watching it on Bien sports . Did the HOL have the banner there ?

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 21 Apr 22 8.44am

This passing the ball sideways in defence, especially when you're only one goal down. Is it to do with PV's upbringing in tippy tappy Arsenal, or is it a lack of confidence in the front player, or is there just a lack of movement ahead of them which gives the defenders no avenues to pass in.

The only alternative then is the big punt upfield.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Apr 22 8.58am

Originally posted by Davepalace707

We had 41 points after 35 games last season. After Leeds & Watford at home coming up we’ll probably be the same or better. And who can forget those thrilling cup runs under Hodgson….

I am not going to assume that we will beat a Leeds team who have won 3 and drawn 1 of their last 4 games under Jesse Marsch.

Apropos cup runs, with no disrepect to the teams, we beat Millwall,Hartlepool, Stoke and a struggling Everton on our way to Wembley with 3 of those games being at home.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 21 Apr 22 9.01am

If we had started the game with the increased urgency shown in the second half it could have been a different story.

But we deserved nothing from that first half performance.

Newcastle have been adept at protecting leads at home and proved it again last night.

The rotational fouling and theatrics from their players bear all the hallmarks of Bournemouth under Eddie Howe.

Ultimately it was another narrow but disappointing defeat. Too little, too late.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 21 Apr 22 9.09am

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

This passing the ball sideways in defence, especially when you're only one goal down. Is it to do with PV's upbringing in tippy tappy Arsenal, or is it a lack of confidence in the front player, or is there just a lack of movement ahead of them which gives the defenders no avenues to pass in.

The only alternative then is the big punt upfield.

It was because Newcastle had a good game where they scored a good goal and then allowed us only a couple of good scoring opportunities, we've done the same to other teams it's not against the rules.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Apr 22 9.10am

Originally posted by NEILLO

If we had started the game with the increased urgency shown in the second half it could have been a different story.

But we deserved nothing from that first half performance.

Newcastle have been adept at protecting leads at home and proved it again last night.

The rotational fouling and theatrics from their players bear all the hallmarks of Bournemouth under Eddie Howe.

Ultimately it was another narrow but disappointing defeat. Too little, too late.

Guehi said "When you start a game like that in their place, you get what you deserve,”.“We were second best to everything. They beat us to every duel, every challenge....."

Quite shocking and damning.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 21 Apr 22 9.20am

Originally posted by Willo

I am not going to assume that we will beat a Leeds team who have won 3 and drawn 1 of their last 4 games under Jesse Marsch.

Apropos cup runs, with no disrepect to the teams, we beat Millwall,Hartlepool, Stoke and a struggling Everton on our way to Wembley with 3 of those games being at home.

We don’t have to beat Leeds. Beat Watford and draw with Leeds or Southampton. Hodgson cup teams couldn’t beat Derby or Colchester.

 

PatrickA Flag London 21 Apr 22 9.23am

Similar to the Leicester game, we could have got a draw from the Newcastle game.
It’s a pattern that’s been repeated this season where we have not quite managed to eke out results when not at our best.
It took an excellent goal to beat us and I for one am quite happy that Mitchell did not bring Almiron down.
I’m fed up of this tolerance that has come into the game for bringing down players in threatening positions (‘he’s taken one for the team’ as opined by Sky).
We hate it if it happens to the like of Zaha or Olise and it seems to have even crept into amateur football.
We are at a stage of our development where inconsistency of results is not unexpected but as the club we are moving forward, and I’m hopeful for some good additions in the summer to address the areas that need to be improved.

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 21 Apr 22 9.25am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Similar to the Leicester game, we could have got a draw from the Newcastle game.
It’s a pattern that’s been repeated this season where we have not quite managed to eke out results when not at our best.
It took an excellent goal to beat us and I for one am quite happy that Mitchell did not bring Almiron down.
I’m fed up of this tolerance that has come into the game for bringing down players in threatening positions (‘he’s taken one for the team’ as opined by Sky).
We hate it if it happens to the like of Zaha or Olise and it seems to have even crept into amateur football.
We are at a stage of our development where inconsistency of results is not unexpected but as the club we are moving forward, and I’m hopeful for some good additions in the summer to address the areas that need to be improved.

Oh, I so agree. If you, rightly, condemn diving as on Sunday then why not the 'professional foul'?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Apr 22 9.29am

Originally posted by Davepalace707

We don’t have to beat Leeds. Beat Watford and draw with Leeds or Southampton. Hodgson cup teams couldn’t beat Derby or Colchester.

The lowest points total in a season under Hodgson was 43 pts, accordingly we need 6 pts from 6 games to match that total.Whether we actually achieve this total is a matter of conjecture.

Apropos the cup fixtures, Hodgson's sole focus was to secure PL safety and he achieved this feat over 4 seasons on a net spend of around £10 Mill.

Edited by Willo (21 Apr 2022 9.44am)

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Apr 22 9.48am

Originally posted by Croydon-Trucker

Did anybody else notice that Conor was not happy being taken off ans kind of slapped out at Patricks hand , and i watched the whole match and they did not once show any palace fans but then again i was watching it on Bien sports . Did the HOL have the banner there ?

You have to understand that at St James' Park the away fans are about half a mile away from the pitch! Had the TV bought their long range wildlife cameras perhaps they could have caught the Palace faithful doing their thing.

Was CG taken off as he had a yellow and was having one of those next-stop-red games? Fantastic player but discipline not his strong suit.

 

Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle v Crystal Palace match thread