You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Saints Match Thread
November 16 2026 3.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Saints Match Thread


Page 6 of 9 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 07 Jan 23 3.11pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

Yep it’s time. Last 3 home games have been absolute toilet.

Here is a manager who couldn't do it in a No relegation MLS with the likes of Pirlo, Lampard, Villa in the team. Unfortunately it appears that great players don't always make great coaches & I'm not sure what Roberts brings to the table either.

 


Pro USA & Israel

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 07 Jan 23 3.11pm

By all accounts Southampton were awful, we played well for the most part but currently we couldn’t score in a brothel and our goalkeeper chucked a couple of goals in the net. We need a decent goal scorer. Ayew was his usual busy ineffective self. PV clearly doesn’t rate Mateta or Richards for some reason.

Wilf is having his normal January slump and will be off in the summer. Time to take anything we can get for him and Mateta, buy a striker and hope that Ayew picks up an injury so that PV is forced to play him and give Edouard a run on the left. Stick Johnstone in goal.

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 07 Jan 23 3.14pm

Well you get what you deserve.
Butland, despite being rated by Man Utd, never given a chance.
Continued perseverance with a flawed, unpredictable 36 year old in goal another example of a stupid Viera selection.
The owners continued complacency and lack of investment, thank God Mr Textor bailed us in Summer 2021 with that freak spending when all those players were out of contract, a situation which the club will find itself in again this summer.
The situation with Wilfried, not the player he was & clearly will leave on a free.
Losing at home over and over again to lesser sides, Fulham were made to look like Man City for God sake.
Lack of ambition and always electing to compete at the top table on the cheap is going to slide back into the Championship.

 

hcjbrooks Flag 07 Jan 23 3.14pm

The club is lurching towards relegation Palace need a complete overhaul from top to bottom Parish Viera Roberts and some of the players are failing the club badly - personnel replacements are essential if we are to stay in the premier league

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 07 Jan 23 3.15pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Sadly PV has to go. I’ve no idea who can we bring in but a stop gap of Freedman and Derry may just be good enough to organise this team into picking up enough points to keep us up. Stay with PV and we are definitely going down. Team is all over the place and completely disorganised under him I’m afraid :-(

Derry yes, Freedman no. He's half of our problem. Director of Football? Surely an in joke.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 07 Jan 23 3.16pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


PV has been backed.

He is not using players correctly and keeps selecting people when they don't deserve it.

We have had previous managers who had far less quality players and money yet did better.

He may have been 'backed', but those signings weren't a gift to him personally. They were needed because the squad was desperately short. Bare in mind the bulk of these were two summers ago, since then we have lost more than we have gained. Meanwhile those around us will invest and evolve, invest and evolve, with succession planning mapped out.

Ward has been a stop-gap for about 5 years. Our midfield engine room is a choice from Shlupp, Doucourè, Milivojevic, Hughes, MacArthur, Ayew. Only one of them is currently good enough for a first 11 in my opinion.

Part of our issue is that we so rarely recoup a transfer fee. Bar Wan-Bissaka, you're going back to Zaha to Man Utd for anything substantial. All the players signed in PL era have basically left for nothing at the end of their contract, or ar best some kind of nominal fee. Benteke, Cabaye, PVA, Milivojevic, MacArthur, Sakho.... and probably many others i can't recall... there's just no resale value, so we have to break the bank to replace them.

It's partly why we always seem to need to seek investment to buy players. We used to spend all the income on wages and nothing else.

We are investing in youth these days, but we are yet to reap any reward, through ability or finances. Everything takes time, and I am confident we aren't going to get relegated. But my God, we do need a couple of additions of a higher calibre to those already there. And Chuba Akpom doesn't strike me as any better than the two strikers we already have.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 07 Jan 23 3.21pm

Personally I'm not panicking. I think to say we were awful today is a push. Saints fans were booing their team in the first half because we were so dominant. Second half they had two chances, one of which was a gift from Guiata. We played some good football in patches and if we'd won this 2 or 3-0 I don't think many people would have said it was undeserved. Our final ball and finishing is still off though, which I don't really see a new manager fixing. I do think we need more leadership on the pitch though as everyone seems too passive aside from Wilf.

I feel for the fans who attended the game in horrible conditions and can understand the frustration, but I do think Vieira has earned some patience. Unfortunately for him and us it is a tough run of games ahead of us which I struggle to see us getting much from.

 

Jacey Flag 07 Jan 23 3.23pm

Yet another home defeat to continue our downward slide.
Better out of the Cup at this stage,so that we can harness maximum effort to avoid relegation without this distraction.

 

beak Flag croydon 07 Jan 23 3.23pm

Originally posted by PalaceDevon

pv must go

now

That has been obvious for sometime.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 07 Jan 23 3.27pm

It was our 'first team' out there and they couldn't beat Southampton! After a six week break they have returned as losers. Obviously, this is relegation form so alarm bells should be ringing LOUDLY at the club. ACTION PLEASE!!!!

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Jacey Flag 07 Jan 23 3.28pm

Originally posted by beak

That has been obvious for sometime.

Anyone for Dyche??
We have just lost to the bottom club and P.V. appears clueless to address the slide.

 

New Forest Eagle Flag Darlington 07 Jan 23 3.32pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

It's time this place was updated it's unusable at times.

Edited by grumpymort (07 Jan 2023 2.51pm)

I agree. Always seems to crash when you need it most. Before l, During and after the game

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 07 Jan 23 3.34pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Personally I'm not panicking. I think to say we were awful today is a push. Saints fans were booing their team in the first half because we were so dominant. Second half they had two chances, one of which was a gift from Guiata. We played some good football in patches and if we'd won this 2 or 3-0 I don't think many people would have said it was undeserved. Our final ball and finishing is still off though, which I don't really see a new manager fixing. I do think we need more leadership on the pitch though as everyone seems too passive aside from Wilf.

I feel for the fans who attended the game in horrible conditions and can understand the frustration, but I do think Vieira has earned some patience. Unfortunately for him and us it is a tough run of games ahead of us which I struggle to see us getting much from.

Wow, you really did see a different match to me. You sure it was Palace you were watching ;-) Doesn’t matter that Saints fans were booing them, we were just as bad and eventually worse than them. Two awful teams that will go down unless drastic changes are made by each club :-(

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 07 Jan 23 3.35pm

Originally posted by Jacey

Anyone for Dyche??
We have just lost to the bottom club and P.V. appears clueless to address the slide.

I’m in :-)

 

taylors lovechild Flag 07 Jan 23 3.45pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Wow, you really did see a different match to me. You sure it was Palace you were watching ;-) Doesn’t matter that Saints fans were booing them, we were just as bad and eventually worse than them. Two awful teams that will go down unless drastic changes are made by each club :-(

At one-nil up Ayew conspired to hit the bar from five-yards after a beautiful passage of play and the commentator was eulogising about how well we were playing. Up until the freaky JWP goal we'd completely contained Saints and it looked like we'd win comfortably. Second half we weren't as good and struggled to create much and then Guiata gifted them the win. I didn't say we played well, I just said we weren't awful, in my opinion. Ward and Ayew were really bad today though, pointing again at the need for investment.

 

johnny the eagle Flag wivenhoe 07 Jan 23 3.47pm

Something seriously ain't right, alarm bells are ringing, very loudly.

 


South London born and bred
red and blue till im dead.

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 07 Jan 23 3.48pm

Originally posted by palace chick

I’m in :-)

We've got some tough games coming up so there's no point in hanging about. Get the man a train ticket to Selhurst as soon as the strike is over.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

CT Charlie Flag 07 Jan 23 3.49pm

It's easy to blame Vieira because he's an obvious target. And yet, every one of his critics acknowledges that we have:

* only ONE at-least-average Prem quality midfielder
* only TWO healthy at-least-average Prem quality defenders (Mitchell's fitness being a ?), and
* ZERO at-least-average Prem quality strikers

Zaha, Eze, and Olise can be included in the pile of plus-talented players, but the lack of quality attackers forces Zaha to do everything solo. And, as lovely as the two young players are on the ball, at this stage of their careers they are defensive liabilities in a team which is woefully lacking.

This is why a player like Gallagher or even Gallagher Light (McArthur) would make such a huge difference, turning every 2nd or 3rd one-goal loss into a draw, or draw into a win.

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 07 Jan 23 3.59pm

It's apparent that something has to change and soon. I suspect Vieira will eventually get the push, but the reality is however we bring in is going to struggle with this lot.
We had years of an ageing squad and though we had a good summer window in 2021, we have had two since which have been inadequate and it seems we will have another one which will be the same. Probably 5 out of McArthur, Luka, Riedeweld, Ayew, Tomkins, Ward and Clyne should have been replaced by now.
No point buying promising youngsters if they aren't going to get any game time. We needed players for now.
We have only one premier league quality midfielder (Hughes is a decent standby), both right backs are only back-ups at best, and we have ONE left back. Two forwards who are probably amongst the weakest in the league.
Yes we have Zaha, Eze and Olise but they are flair players and we lack leaders and hard workers.
The squad has more holes than a sieve.
Perhaps time to go down and start again.
The board doesn't want to back the manager and I can't think of any manager (Dyche included) who will get a tune out of the current squad without significant incomings.
Even if we stay up, it is going to need a £100million plus spent in the summer window to make us competitive.
We have been on a up for a decade. I suspect the Palace rollercoaster is about to descend.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 07 Jan 23 3.59pm

As fans of Palace, we are kept very much in the dark re the structure of the club, its shareholders positions individually and their plans for Palace. It must go without saying they want us to succeed, but despite my constant probing of their financial positions and desires to move us forwards and upwards, it remains unknown.
From what Ive read, there is currently little inclination or any willing to inject a necessary fund from existing shareholders to advance the club.
We are in a position now to grow the club but it desperately needs funding.
I fear without a decent injection of cash right now and some serious re evaluation of our overall management, our team management and our game management plans, this afternoon we are looking pretty rudderless.
I really hope Im wrong, but I haven't read, seen or heard anything to allay my concerns.

 

Page 6 of 9 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Saints Match Thread