You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs Everton match thread
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace vs Everton match thread


Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6
Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 23 Apr 23 11.05pm

Ha!

Good observation, I think you may well be right!

Originally posted by JRW2


A certain gentleman has been conspicuous by his absence from this thread. Perhaps there were too many bad refereeing decisions even for him to attempt to defend.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 23 Apr 23 11.15pm

Originally posted by antipodeagle

If Ayew had an end product (final pass, cross or shot) he'd be a m player. We paid about -3m for him. Arguably the best value for money we've had in the last 10 years.

That's like saying if only a tennis player had a forehand...

It's not like Guaita where you say 'if only he could play with his feet' and you can get round it. An end product is pretty important for a forward!

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 24 Apr 23 12.04am

Originally posted by ambrose7

That's like saying if only a tennis player had a forehand...

It's not like Guaita where you say 'if only he could play with his feet' and you can get round it. An end product is pretty important for a forward!

Would be my argument too.

A lot of people saying Ayew had a fantastic game however I really fail to see it.

His value is surely where we are outclassed in games and he provides a presence up the top some players just cannot offer and an outlet too with his unique traits, consistent performance and work rate. Despite low statistics, and therefore an easy target to pick at, he is also capable of providing the odd goal/assist too.

In games such as the Everton one however we needed someone to really unlock a stubborn team/produce that bit of composure/magic and he unfortunately was unable to provide the answer. It's almost as though his inclusion is dependant upon others providing the 'final piece' and actual goal threat sometimes. Equally, wasn't Edouard/Eze/Olise or anybody else's finest hour either for context.

To reiterate from an earlier post of mine, I think he is and has been a great player for us. Everton was not his game however as for all his effort it amounted, and never looked as though it would, to nothing.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 24 Apr 23 3.42am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Would be my argument too.

A lot of people saying Ayew had a fantastic game however I really fail to see it.

His value is surely where we are outclassed in games and he provides a presence up the top some players just cannot offer and an outlet too with his unique traits, consistent performance and work rate. Despite low statistics, and therefore an easy target to pick at, he is also capable of providing the odd goal/assist too.

In games such as the Everton one however we needed someone to really unlock a stubborn team/produce that bit of composure/magic and he unfortunately was unable to provide the answer. It's almost as though his inclusion is dependant upon others providing the 'final piece' and actual goal threat sometimes. Equally, wasn't Edouard/Eze/Olise or anybody else's finest hour either for context.

To reiterate from an earlier post of mine, I think he is and has been a great player for us. Everton was not his game however as for all his effort it amounted, and never looked as though it would, to nothing.

I think we're in violent agreement. I guess my point was that he is (or can be - like against Everton) excellent in other areas of the pitch but not where it really counts - but we've still got more value than what we paid for IMO. As compared with someone like Edouard who is ineffectual across every part of the pitch, but came with a significant (for us) price-tag.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 24 Apr 23 5.03am

Originally posted by Eaglehamster

A point will do. Awful game. Ruined to a large degree by all the illegal holding, shirt grabbing and general wrestling that referees ignore. Ruining the game IMV. Do the footballing authorities consider that the game should be entertaining?

It wasn’t an entertaining spectacle but certainly not helped by the shirt pulling and rolling around on the floor that went on largely unchallenged by the referee. At least we didn’t lose but we wasted opportunities to shoot on goal by playing one touch too many and trying to walk the ball in. -.-'

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 24 Apr 23 9.08am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Would be my argument too.

A lot of people saying Ayew had a fantastic game however I really fail to see it.

His value is surely where we are outclassed in games and he provides a presence up the top some players just cannot offer and an outlet too with his unique traits, consistent performance and work rate. Despite low statistics, and therefore an easy target to pick at, he is also capable of providing the odd goal/assist too.

In games such as the Everton one however we needed someone to really unlock a stubborn team/produce that bit of composure/magic and he unfortunately was unable to provide the answer. It's almost as though his inclusion is dependant upon others providing the 'final piece' and actual goal threat sometimes. Equally, wasn't Edouard/Eze/Olise or anybody else's finest hour either for context.

To reiterate from an earlier post of mine, I think he is and has been a great player for us. Everton was not his game however as for all his effort it amounted, and never looked as though it would, to nothing.

Yep, for me he plays in the tight games, but when we are going to have some ball and need to break a team down, he's not that guy.

But without Wilf, he's the guy at the moment.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 24 Apr 23 9.29am

All this Ayew bashing need to stop. Against Leicester instead of running down the line into a culdesac a la Zaha instead he cuts inside and plays a perfectly weighted through ball to Mateta, result being 3 points. Against Leeds he scores twice in a thumping victory. Against Southampton he plays a full part in his role resulting in another victory. Against Everton he once again played his part in an otherwise flat team performance.
These days he's better and more valuable to the side than Zaha, get over it.

 

PJEagle Flag London 24 Apr 23 9.52am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

All this Ayew bashing need to stop. Against Leicester instead of running down the line into a culdesac a la Zaha instead he cuts inside and plays a perfectly weighted through ball to Mateta, result being 3 points. Against Leeds he scores twice in a thumping victory. Against Southampton he plays a full part in his role resulting in another victory. Against Everton he once again played his part in an otherwise flat team performance.
These days he's better and more valuable to the side than Zaha, get over it.

Don't agree with that. Agreed that Ayew has been great, and has proved his worth to the team. Zaha is a great player who can create opportunities out of nothing. It will definitely give us a boost for the last few games.

 

PJEagle Flag London 24 Apr 23 9.59am

Originally posted by PJEagle

[Link]

Don't agree with that. Agreed that Ayew has been great, and has proved his worth to the team. Zaha is a great player who can create opportunities out of nothing. It will definitely give us a boost for the last few games.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 24 Apr 23 10.02am

Awesome (unrecognizable) performances against Saints and Leeds. Significantly less effective performances against Leicester and Everton.

Have we reverted to our old way of being great travelers? I guess we'll see tomorrow...

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 24 Apr 23 10.09am

Originally posted by silvertop

Awesome (unrecognizable) performances against Saints and Leeds. Significantly less effective performances against Leicester and Everton.

Have we reverted to our old way of being great travelers? I guess we'll see tomorrow...


Back to the Royball of his second season with just 5 home wins but 9 away wins (Incidentally including one at Wolves!).

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 24 Apr 23 10.13am

Originally posted by doombear


Back to the Royball of his second season with just 5 home wins but 9 away wins (Incidentally including one at Wolves!).

The way Everton set up to be so negative it stifled the life out of the game. No surprise we had more freedom away from home. Wolves will be interesting to see if we can produce a performance like the second halves against Leeds and Soton but against a better team

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 24 Apr 23 10.16am

Wilf, has always been an exceptional player, fading a bit now , but still possibly our best striking option. Ayew offers a much higher work rate, lower goals, but not that much lower than any of the so called forward players, the point being apart from the occasional strike the others don’t actually contribute more than Ayew. Ayew for two or three seasons now has been in the top three most fouled players in the Premier league, alongside Wilf, and Jack Grealish, this is not a statistic he would have if oppositions had any other answer to him. Any criticism should be the team don’t make more of his hard work.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Apr 23 10.53am

There has been some fustigation aimed in the direction of the referee but in the final analysis he was not responsible for a lacklustre performance by our team or the fact that we were unable to attain all the points.

I would humbly suggest that had we emerged victorious, John Brooks would not have featured significantly in this debate and the narrative would have gallivanted down a different path.

HOL will be a ‘Willo free zone’ for a few days as I entertain some visitors from abroad. I hear a cacophony of ‘Hooray’ !!

 

Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs Everton match thread