This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Mateta
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Crystal_Clear Belfast 28 May 23 8.57pm |
|
|
Looks like he could be on his way in the summer.
[Link]
|
Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 28 May 23 9.04pm |
|
|
I dont think Mateta can decide to leave if their is no decent offer on the table, i wish it was Edouard
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
|
Nicholas91 The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 May 23 10.10pm |
|
|
The spelling thus far has been shocking however with no animosity, I’d welcome any fee for JPM.
I think he’s an ok player but below what we need and that we should be striving for. I’ve said it before and will say again that I view both JPM and Edouard as sort of ‘half a striker’. They both have some strengths but an equal number of weaknesses. I’d quite happily get some cash for both, or just for one, and go for our 100%, first pick striker.
Either can play as a reserve/backup to that first choice striker but having two of them a bit pointless. It’s like they’ve taken turns in not being good enough to start to allow the other a run out. Buying two half effective strikers doesn’t equate to one effective centre forward, in fact it quite often equals none.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 28 May 23 10.29pm |
|
|
there is no honeymoon time in the Prem.....either you are amazing or you are expensive.
Mateta has not been amazing
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
sprites Auckland 29 May 23 1.32am |
|
|
Eduoard has the ability, but poor attitude. Mateta has a decent attitude, but little to no ability.
Doh.
|
Wilbraham413 29 May 23 2.47am |
|
Originally posted by sprites
Eduoard has the ability, but poor attitude. Mateta has a decent attitude, but little to no ability.
Doh.
Ability to do what? He can't make runs, can't score, can't hold the ball up, can't pass. He handed the ball to Forest today to give them their first goal. Then later, he missed an easy header for a goal. He was so bad that Roy subbed him out for Mateta after 60 minutes.
2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro 2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley 2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth 2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle
|
taylors lovechild 29 May 23 7.05am |
|
|
Mateta seems to have a loveable personality like a puppy (and the ball control of one), but he has not shown that he has the ability of a PL striker. The way we play right now we need a number 9 who can link up play the way Firminho did at Liverpool in his prime and who has the instinct to capitalise on the chances Olise and Eze create. Neither Edouard nor Mateta have shown they are capable of that. Personally I'd try and move them both on.
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 29 May 23 9.26am |
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
Mateta seems to have a loveable personality like a puppy (and the ball control of one), but he has not shown that he has the ability of a PL striker. The way we play right now we need a number 9 who can link up play the way Firminho did at Liverpool in his prime and who has the instinct to capitalise on the chances Olise and Eze create. Neither Edouard nor Mateta have shown they are capable of that. Personally I'd try and move them both on.
Frustrating is not the word and to think that I cried when Eduoard scored twice in his first appearance believing that we'd actually found someone with the ability of Murray ..but we are sadly a club that has to make a gamble in this league.
|
ambrose7 Croydon 29 May 23 10.03am |
|
|
I do think there's a player in Mateta. Unlikely to be here, but he could do a Sorloth and get a fair few goals elsewhere if he's left alone to get game time and find his rhythm. For every open goal miss against Liverpool, there's the well taken finishes against Brighton and Leicester.
Striker is the one position that pretty much 75% of the league can't get right. There's only 8 out and out strikers that got 12 goals or more in the league this year: Haaland, Kane, Toney, Wilson, Rashford, Watkins, Mitrovic, Rodrigo.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration 2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough 1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds 7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.
|
eritheagle Erith 29 May 23 10.40am |
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I dont think Mateta can decide to leave if their is no decent offer on the table, i wish it was Edouard
Me too!
I struggle to think of a lazier player to have worn a palace shirt! Doesn’t show any desire and is unable to manage two yard passes. Mateta may be limited but at least he puts in effort and looks like he wants to be here and do well.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 29 May 23 10.50am |
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
I dont think Mateta can decide to leave if their is no decent offer on the table, i wish it was Edouard
I am of the opinion that Mateta's contract extends to June 26.
|
Nubes London 29 May 23 10.57am |
|
|
JPM - He has little in game intelligence.
He doesn’t anticipate where the ball is going to be He doesn’t close players down quickly enough He is a slow thinker - on the back foot mentally He doesn’t create space or opportunities
Needs to go - overstayed his welcome
OE
Trots around (languid style) doesn’t do enough Life is both easy and comfortable for defenders Disappointed in his time here - expected better
Needs to go - proved he is not the answer
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 29 May 23 11.14am |
|
Originally posted by Nubes
JPM - He has little in game intelligence.
He doesn’t anticipate where the ball is going to be He doesn’t close players down quickly enough He is a slow thinker - on the back foot mentally He doesn’t create space or opportunities
Needs to go - overstayed his welcome
OE
Trots around (languid style) doesn’t do enough Life is both easy and comfortable for defenders Disappointed in his time here - expected better
Needs to go - proved he is not the answer
This season Eduoard and Mateta have scored the grand total of 9 goals in 69 appearances.
I do believe there is a player there inside Edouard but I am yet to be convinced we will see that in a Palace shirt.
|
Spiderman Horsham 29 May 23 12.02pm |
|
Originally posted by Willo
I am of the opinion that Mateta's contract extends to June 26.
It does indeed. Talk of him wanting to leave, for my game time and a loan May on the cards. Could be a good deal for all concerned
|
Canterbury Palace Whitstable 29 May 23 12.27pm |
|
|
Mateta and Edouard can both go in my opinion. If you wrote the names of every single striker in the Premier League, put them in a hat and pulled two out, you'd do well to pull out a worse pair.
Edouard I think has the ability but lacks the effort a lot of the time. Mateta simply isn't good enough.
We need new midfielders but up front is by far the biggest area in which we could radically improve, there has to be a couple of young options in the Championship.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...
|
Norbury Old Git London 29 May 23 3.03pm |
|
|
Over three years JPM has scored a goal every 263 minutes, beaten only by Wilf with a goal every 239 minutes. During this time he has been played an average of 37 minutes per match. Roy has only given him 63 minutes total in the last 10 matches. He dropped JPM after his Leicester goal, just as he did after the he scored in his debut against Brighton. After his treatment of Sorloth, who has now led his team into the Champions League, I suspect more egg on face for Roy and to some extent Vieira. We cannot afford a Firmino or top 6 striker so if we keep treating our forwards the way JPM has been treated we will never get into back into the top 10. If you still think JPM is bad, what about Ayew who has just ‘won’ the title of Most Dispossessed Player in the Premier League (Wilf was second) and has scored a goal every 853 minutes over the last three years!
|
Uphill Bedford 29 May 23 5.16pm |
|
|
Both he and Edouard have proved to be lacking at PL level.
OE has scored a couple of decent goals, Mateta is all energy and bustle with little end product.
Both may do a 'Sorloth' with other clubs but we need a Glenn Murray replacement and the most skilful I've seen is Gyorkes who has good hold-up play, can lay on passes and can score.
True, not yet proven in the PL but if we don't sign him I am certain he will be in the PL next season.
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 01 Jun 23 9.40pm |
|
Originally posted by Norbury Old Git
Over three years JPM has scored a goal every 263 minutes, beaten only by Wilf with a goal every 239 minutes. During this time he has been played an average of 37 minutes per match. Roy has only given him 63 minutes total in the last 10 matches. He dropped JPM after his Leicester goal, just as he did after the he scored in his debut against Brighton. After his treatment of Sorloth, who has now led his team into the Champions League, I suspect more egg on face for Roy and to some extent Vieira. We cannot afford a Firmino or top 6 striker so if we keep treating our forwards the way JPM has been treated we will never get into back into the top 10. If you still think JPM is bad, what about Ayew who has just ‘won’ the title of Most Dispossessed Player in the Premier League (Wilf was second) and has scored a goal every 853 minutes over the last three years!
Well said. I'm not for a moment suggesting that Mateta is the answer to our striking needs BUT he hasn't been given a decent run of games at any time during his time with us. I can well understand his frustration.
|
Charles Forest Hill 01 Jun 23 11.42pm |
|
|
JPM was signed as cover for Bentake when cash was short to put an end to an appalling saga of failed sttempts to do so on which none of us wish to dwell but which stretched back to signing Wickham at the same time as CB. It takes a lot to make Roy criticise his colleagues in public but the non recruitment of a reserve striker achieved just that; he had a point; CB was our most expensive player but we struggled to get the best from him because whenever he joined or left the side, a radical formation change was enforced. As a poor man's Benteke (term borrowed from another HOL user at the time JPM as signed) he's not too bad and if he was even half as good as CB in the air he'd be quite good. He's never really looked much more than a decent enough reserve for a budget squad; a lot of the time he looks a bit out of his depth but occasionally he pulls something pretty good out of the hat and you wonder if he couldn't be helped to do that more often. The harsh truth is that the fact so many of us - myself definitely included - wished we'd seen him start more often is mainly a comment on how useless Edouard is. He also looks out of his depth much of the time but the bits that stick in the memory are more like last Sunday's debacle than anything quality.
Edited by Charles (01 Jun 2023 11.43pm)
|
sprites Auckland 02 Jun 23 1.43am |
|
Originally posted by Wilbraham413
Ability to do what? He can't make runs, can't score, can't hold the ball up, can't pass. He handed the ball to Forest today to give them their first goal. Then later, he missed an easy header for a goal. He was so bad that Roy subbed him out for Mateta after 60 minutes.
To score goals - which is the primary function of a striker, no? His run for his most recent goal (Eze pass) was excellent - as was the finish. And his finish against Leeds was equally impressive. This is what I mean. He's got it in his locker...he just doesn't seem like he can be bothered half the time. Which is inexcusable.
|