You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sheffield United vs. Crystal Palace match thread
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sheffield United vs. Crystal Palace match thread


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Den1923 Flag 13 Aug 23 11.33am

It was of course great to win the first game of a new season away from home and very welcome. However, it is also important not to forget we were probably playing at best a very average championship team who have just been promoted and are already looking dead certs for the drop. Sheffield United conceded the midfield, thereby handing control of the game to us. our defence looked good because it had very little to do although it was exposed at times when they got the ball forward quickly taking advantage of JW lack of pace and Mitchell poor reading of the game. The reality is we need a striker who can score, 24 attempts with one conversion is not going to keep us out of the relegation battle.

We still need players to come in to bolster both defence and attack and we certainly cannot afford to lose anymore players in the T/F window. The real test of where we are will come against the Gunners in a weeks time on Monday evening.

 

Aray Flag South London 13 Aug 23 11.34am

Who would you drop from the 1st team Palace Chick? Seems like Schlupp is the weakest link up front. But the rest of the attack are playing quite well?

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 13 Aug 23 1.20pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Let’s not go overboard with our win. We had our strongest team possible on the pitch and could only score once against a team that would have been beaten by all the prem teams yesterday. Other than those promoted in my opinion? Corners we conceded yesterday May have resulted in goals scored with much better quality players attacking them against us. Really pleased we won but our squad is weaker than last season at the moment and we were fortunate to have drawn a poor team (presently) as our first match. Plus for me was Lerma and the work ethic of the other 10 but I’m not going overboard until we have some more incomings before the end of the window. And those incomings need to be first teamers dropping some of yesterday’s team to the bench. Still loved getting 3 points away but it was only Sheffield Utd :-)

A shrewd analysis, I feel pretty much the same about it.

 

YT Flag Oxford 13 Aug 23 1.43pm

I'm not going overboard, but I repeat that it shouldn't be assumed that we are certs to lose to Arsenal. They were far from convincing yesterday.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 13 Aug 23 2.13pm

Originally posted by silvertop

A year ago we were outplayed for 30 minutes and conceded 2.

We then outplayed them for 60 minutes but couldn't convert.

It will be the same save our defence is better and I think Eze will bag a brace.

2-1.

I know this thread is about now, but my memory of last year is slightly different from yours. I remember that we were outplayed for a big chunk of the game, leaving Arsenal 1 up at HT. We then really got into it and it seemed only a matter of time before we equalised. Then against the run of play Saka came in from the right (in front of the Arsenal fans), sent in a low cross and Andersen put it into the net. The reaction of their fans was of great joy but also, I think, of relief.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 13 Aug 23 2.18pm

Originally posted by JRW2

I know this thread is about now, but my memory of last year is slightly different from yours. I remember that we were outplayed for a big chunk of the game, leaving Arsenal 1 up at HT. We then really got into it and it seemed only a matter of time before we equalised. Then against the run of play Saka came in from the right (in front of the Arsenal fans), sent in a low cross and Andersen put it into the net. The reaction of their fans was of great joy but also, I think, of relief.


That's the game I witnessed as well. I would add that Saliba played an absolute blinder for them if my memory is correct.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 13 Aug 23 2.20pm

If we back off Arsenal and look like the proverbial lambs we will be slaughtered.

If we’re to stand up to them a bit and have confidence in ourselves we could well rattle them enough to cause an upset.

I post that only as I’m sure Roy with all his experience and expertise consults this forum in hopes to catch my tactical insight

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Teddy Eagle Flag 13 Aug 23 2.55pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

If we back off Arsenal and look like the proverbial lambs we will be slaughtered.

If we’re to stand up to them a bit and have confidence in ourselves we could well rattle them enough to cause an upset.

I post that only as I’m sure Roy with all his experience and expertise consults this forum in hopes to catch my tactical insight

He's smarter than the government anyway. They'd be fizzing with competence if they came to the HOL for advice.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 Aug 23 2.59pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I post that only as I’m sure Roy with all his experience and expertise consults this forum in hopes to catch my tactical insight

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 13 Aug 23 5.33pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

If we back off Arsenal and look like the proverbial lambs we will be slaughtered.

If we’re to stand up to them a bit and have confidence in ourselves we could well rattle them enough to cause an upset.

I post that only as I’m sure Roy with all his experience and expertise consults this forum in hopes to catch my tactical insight

I hate it when we do that, I’d sooner get beaten having a go and getting stuck in than standing off a team watching them tippy tapping the ball around before they eventually open us up and score anyway. We did it a lot in Roy’s last season and we took a few good hidings.

You’re spot on as well, Arsenal are still a bit flakey, Forest proved that second half, let’s rattle them by getting stuck in and attack THEM.

 

YT Flag Oxford 13 Aug 23 5.56pm

Brentford and Spurs both dropped 2 points today. Chelsea and Liverpool are drawing so hopefully will do the same. The table is shaping up nicely!!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 13 Aug 23 6.01pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Let’s not go overboard with our win. We had our strongest team possible on the pitch and could only score once against a team that would have been beaten by all the prem teams yesterday. Other than those promoted in my opinion? Corners we conceded yesterday May have resulted in goals scored with much better quality players attacking them against us. Really pleased we won but our squad is weaker than last season at the moment and we were fortunate to have drawn a poor team (presently) as our first match. Plus for me was Lerma and the work ethic of the other 10 but I’m not going overboard until we have some more incomings before the end of the window. And those incomings need to be first teamers dropping some of yesterday’s team to the bench. Still loved getting 3 points away but it was only Sheffield Utd :-)


Exactly this. If we want to be playing PL football next6 season we have to beat the Sheff Us and Lutons both home and away. They are both strong favourites for relegation and we usually do the double over relegation fodder (both Leeds and Southampton last year and 4 points off Leicester).

Yes it was good that we controlled the game well.

We'll get some idea of where we are in the pecking order once we've played Forest in our 8th game. I would want to see us with 14 points by then.

Edited by doombear (13 Aug 2023 6.02pm)

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 14 Aug 23 6.04am

One of the telling takeaways from the game was that once we took the lead Sheffield United never looked like scoring whereas we were still creating chances. Our ball retention and concentration were very good.
Lerma and Doucoure look formidable as a midfield block and meant our defense and goalkeeper were not really worked.
With this sort of line up it does give space for the full backs to get forward and if the rumours are true and we get Lewis Hall on loan he will be perfect for this system.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 14 Aug 23 6.07am

On the Eduard performance i would say he took his goal well but he has got to learn how to stay on side. He often only seems to be aware of the player on the ball and then makes a run to receive the pass only to have strayed into an offside position as the defence stepped up.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 14 Aug 23 8.45am

A good solid win but what concerned me was that Eze seemed to be trying to do too much at times and gave the ball away a fair few times. It was similar to the Lyon friendly. Last season he seemed to know when to pass and when to take it on himself. With Olise injured and Wilf gone I worry that he he now sees himself as needing to always make things happen and that's affecting him. He still played ok and had a couple of nice moments, but Sheffield Utd were poor.

.

 

Fatherken Flag 14 Aug 23 9.08am

There is a lot o talk about Eduard being off side , what about Ayew's off side goal . A footballer of his experience should know better

 

Den1923 Flag 14 Aug 23 9.21am

Originally posted by Fatherken

There is a lot o talk about Eduard being off side , what about Ayew's off side goal . A footballer of his experience should know better

I think to absolutely fair to all players experienced or not, offside is measured in microns these days and is decided by technology and therefore it is impossible for players to be sure they always time their moves to ensure that are always going to be on side!

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 14 Aug 23 10.08am

Good win and performance for first game of season as a possible banana skin. Lerma looked good. Great bit of business like Docoure last season. If we take our chances, a large if, and we don't make silly errors like Forest feel we could well get something against Arsenal. COYP !!

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 14 Aug 23 10.41am

When Olise returns, the Brazilian kid is injury-free and Lewis Hall take over from Schlupp on our left side, we will be a very good PL side.

 

YT Flag Oxford 14 Aug 23 11.40am

Originally posted by Den1923

I think to absolutely fair to all players experienced or not, offside is measured in microns these days and is decided by technology and therefore it is impossible for players to be sure they always time their moves to ensure that are always going to be on side!

Fair point, but Edouard was about a yard and a half offside. Ayew about half a yard.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sheffield United vs. Crystal Palace match thread