This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Chelsea may be a good club for developing academy players but I am not sure they are good for those on the brink of the first team. It sounds like Roy made this point to him, stay at Palace and we will develop you. Olise has been great for us but there have been plenty of games where he disappeared I doubt Chelsea would be so patient with his off days so he might not play as regular as he would with us. Its a good point. They do develop some, but a lot also fall by the wayside. They also seam to have a few that break through, play a bit and then end up surplus (trevoh chalobah). It also feels like they never have 100% trust in anyone. e.g. Connor must have been excited about the new season this time last week, survived the chop and destined to play a bigger role. Then they spuff £170m+ 2 new CMs. And I guess that's the thing, if fit we can offer him 38 league games. If he has a bad game, he wont get dropped. And we are highly unlikely (!) to drop £100m on another left winger. As a core part of our scouting system we should be looking at all their kids and offering them a better path to first team football. With Ebs, Michael and Marc we have some great examples that this is a place where you can go from the reserves to the England squad in a season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
Its a good point. They do develop some, but a lot also fall by the wayside. They also seam to have a few that break through, play a bit and then end up surplus (trevoh chalobah). It also feels like they never have 100% trust in anyone. e.g. Connor must have been excited about the new season this time last week, survived the chop and destined to play a bigger role. Then they spuff £170m+ 2 new CMs. And I guess that's the thing, if fit we can offer him 38 league games. If he has a bad game, he wont get dropped. And we are highly unlikely (!) to drop £100m on another left winger. As a core part of our scouting system we should be looking at all their kids and offering them a better path to first team football. With Ebs, Michael and Marc we have some great examples that this is a place where you can go from the reserves to the England squad in a season.
One more point |
|
|
I think this has been lost in the euphoria around the Olise new contract. Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Of course, it’s fantastic news, but does anyone else think this deflects from the lack of activity in the market place? We have lost 4 senior players and bought 1 oven ready player and 1 injured kid. It’s hardly a wonder window so far.
|
|
|
Maybe we should be looking at the younger Olise. The one touted at Chelsea as being the next Reece James.
|
|
|
There's a video going round on Insta(?) Apparently made by the club to celebrate Olise's new deal, it's to the Fratellis 'Chelsea Dagger' . . . [Link]
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
When you have brothers at different clubs its not difficult to imagine that they talk to each other.
Originally posted by MabbsWasKing
Maybe we should be looking at the younger Olise. The one touted at Chelsea as being the next Reece James.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Of course, it’s fantastic news, but does anyone else think this deflects from the lack of activity in the market place? We have lost 4 senior players and bought 1 oven ready player and 1 injured kid. It’s hardly a wonder window so far. In my opinion we are in a new transition period in the transfer market that clubs are trying to adjust to. Prices have gone through the roof because of the Saudi League, Chelsea (part owned by Saudi’s) Newcastle (Owned by Saudi’s). Clubs have been getting massive prices for players so others are holding out for these fees also, but there will be panic stations when we get to the last week of the window and they haven’t sold which is where I believe we will do our business. Edited by EddieMac (18 Aug 2023 10.12am) Edited by EddieMac (18 Aug 2023 10.17am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Of course, it’s fantastic news, but does anyone else think this deflects from the lack of activity in the market place? We have lost 4 senior players and bought 1 oven ready player and 1 injured kid. It’s hardly a wonder window so far. I'm ok with it. The players we let go had slim to little impact on our season last year (except Wilf). So I can live with them not being replaced. Lerma will play every game and have a HUGE impact on the team. Lets hope Franca can too
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Of course, it’s fantastic news, but does anyone else think this deflects from the lack of activity in the market place? We have lost 4 senior players and bought 1 oven ready player and 1 injured kid. It’s hardly a wonder window so far.
Lerma's arrival isn't just about one good player coming in, it has, as Hodgson has said, allowed the attacking players more freedom and options in the knowledge we have a strong double pivot in front of our defense. Once Olise is fit again, he and Eze will have even more licence to do their stuff and I can see Edouard benefitting too and hitting the double figure mark in goals. If we get the two incomings Parish is hoping will arrive this month and keep our other stars then this will have been a good window IMO. And there's still the unknown quantity called Franca.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
I think this has been lost in the euphoria around the Olise new contract. We have 3! Johnstone, Matthews, Whitworth
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Lerma's arrival isn't just about one good player coming in, it has, as Hodgson has said, allowed the attacking players more freedom and options in the knowledge we have a strong double pivot in front of our defense. Once Olise is fit again, he and Eze will have even more licence to do their stuff and I can see Edouard benefitting too and hitting the double figure mark in goals. If we get the two incomings Parish is hoping will arrive this month and keep our other stars then this will have been a good window IMO. And there's still the unknown quantity called Franca. I think I would take Hodgson’s view that our squad is currently too thin over some of the opinions on this board. We are short at GK, CH, LB, RB, CF and wing. Apart from that everything is fine!
|
|
|
Originally posted by maddog
We have 3! Johnstone, Matthews, Whitworth Start of last season we had Guaita Johnstone and Butland before he disappeared on loan and then permanent deal. An injury to Johnstone this year and we will be looking to a big step up from Matthews and as good as Whitworth might become he didn’t look that great last time he played. I can see a goal keeper as being a priority if Guaita is out the door.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I think I would take Hodgson’s view that our squad is currently too thin over some of the opinions on this board. We are short at GK, CH, LB, RB, CF and wing. Apart from that everything is fine!
|
|
|
Originally posted by doombear
Hodgson said the squad was thin. Did I say he said more than that?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Start of last season we had Guaita Johnstone and Butland before he disappeared on loan and then permanent deal. An injury to Johnstone this year and we will be looking to a big step up from Matthews and as good as Whitworth might become he didn’t look that great last time he played. I can see a goal keeper as being a priority if Guaita is out the door. The Guaita situation makes all this difficult as nothing can be done whill he is still here refusing to play.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
I think I would take Hodgson’s view that our squad is currently too thin over some of the opinions on this board. We are short at GK, CH, LB, RB, CF and wing. Apart from that everything is fine! How many defenders to you want? We have 4 solid centre backs. We have 2 right backs and admittedly we could do with another left back. Clyne has played left back and Schlupp can cover in an emergency. It’s forwards the club is in need of…im sure we will sign a wide forward before the end of the window. And I’m sure we will sign a GK as well.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hudsoneagle
How many defenders to you want? We have 4 solid centre backs. We have 2 right backs and admittedly we could do with another left back. Clyne has played left back and Schlupp can cover in an emergency. It’s forwards the club is in need of…im sure we will sign a wide forward before the end of the window. And I’m sure we will sign a GK as well. Why is it that players like Tomkins, Ward and Clyne who more or less everyone thought were too old a year ago are now ok again for top class PL football? Clyne is not a left back, Mitchell has shown his fragility positionally as a defender, Richards is a good player but seems to pick up a lot of injuries as does Tomkins who is too old for this level. So when you ask how many do I want, I want a decent right back who can at leat keep up with a winger pace wise, a decent left back and a younger centre half. If you don’t think we need those players then that is your choice but I don’t agree with it.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.