You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace team v Newcastle.
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace team v Newcastle.


Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 21 Oct 23 5.21pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Only 7pts between us and the team in 18th, that's a worry!

Only if we had to play Newcastle, Man.City, Liverpool, Arsenal etc every week, but thankfully we don’t have too and we’ll win and draw plenty of games to keep ourselves out of trouble as we have consistently done over the last ten years, let’s not be stressing too much over one result

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 21 Oct 23 5.22pm

Awful performance and it's not going to get any easier with Spurs visiting on Friday.

We simply cannot afford to put out a team that negative again.

Today we had four defenders, two defensive midfielders, a central midfielder in Will Hughes who offers little attacking threat and a forward, in Jordan Ayew, whose defining characteristics can be said to be working hard, tracking back and holding the ball up. It's no wonder that our two strikers didn't get any service.

Rak-Sakyi simply has to start and Ahamada deserves a chance in the Eze role, both in place of Hughes and Mateta who are average. Also if you play Ayew on the left for the moment, it will help protect Mitchell.

Whilst there's no need to overreact after one bad result, Hodgson has to show that he has learnt his lesson rather than sticking with the same old formula time and time again.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

southnorwoodhill Flag 21 Oct 23 5.22pm

This was a result waiting to happen - a lacklustre team depleted by injury up against a side who play with intensity and get players forward in waves for every attack. Don't blame Mitchell, what the f*** is he supposed to do when he's outmanned and team mates aren't covering? Mastermind defensive maestro Roy should have seen it coming, but ultimately what options did he have given the circumstances?

 

taylors lovechild Flag 21 Oct 23 5.27pm

JRS showed more effort, desire and more threat in a cameo than JPM or OE showed all game between them. He has to start against spuds and drop one of the two feet draggers. The youngsters (Rak-Sakyi, Franca and Ozoh) added a bit of life but aside from that there were no positives. On the Franca note he strode out and made his debut at Tooncastle Arabia when his team were 4-0 down and didn't look phased at all. A couple more sub appearances and I think he'll be starting. His corners were great.

Johnstone 5 - made one easy save but hard to give him higher
Ward 4 - looked slow again and got caught out because of it
Andersen 4 - like Ward got caught out for pace
Guehi 5 - slipped for one goal but otherwise was ok
Mitchell 3 - didn't get much support in the first half but repeatedly lost Murphy
Doucoure 4 not much went through the middle, but can't remember him doing much good or bad
Lerma 4 like Doucoure didn't seem to do much good or bad
Hughes 3 - a lot of heart but repeatedly switched off and lost the runner and looked off the pace and failed to support Mitchell
Ayew 6 - I actually thought he was ok and helped shut down the left side in the second half.
JPM 3 - misplaced header on goal, failed repeatedly to hold the ball up looked knackered after 5 minutes. Did clear one ball from our box though!
Edouard 4 - had our best shot on goal but other than that offered nothing. Marginally better than JPM.

JRS & Franca 6 - added a bit of life and energy
Ozoh n/a - not on the pitch long enough

 

Den1923 Flag 21 Oct 23 5.34pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Only 4 points between us and Europe ...COYP

18th is more likely than europe, but its nice to dream

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 21 Oct 23 5.34pm

We were never getting anything from this game.
No creativity in the midfield and blunt up front.

Spurs will be another tough one, but we need to be upbeat.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 21 Oct 23 5.35pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

JRS showed more effort, desire and more threat in a cameo than JPM or OE showed all game between them. He has to start against spuds and drop one of the two feet draggers. The youngsters (Rak-Sakyi, Franca and Ozoh) added a bit of life but aside from that there were no positives. On the Franca note he strode out and made his debut at Tooncastle Arabia when his team were 4-0 down and didn't look phased at all. A couple more sub appearances and I think he'll be starting. His corners were great.

Johnstone 5 - made one easy save but hard to give him higher
Ward 4 - looked slow again and got caught out because of it
Andersen 4 - like Ward got caught out for pace
Guehi 5 - slipped for one goal but otherwise was ok
Mitchell 3 - didn't get much support in the first half but repeatedly lost Murphy
Doucoure 4 not much went through the middle, but can't remember him doing much good or bad
Lerma 4 like Doucoure didn't seem to do much good or bad
Hughes 3 - a lot of heart but repeatedly switched off and lost the runner and looked off the pace and failed to support Mitchell
Ayew 6 - I actually thought he was ok and helped shut down the left side in the second half.
JPM 3 - misplaced header on goal, failed repeatedly to hold the ball up looked knackered after 5 minutes. Did clear one ball from our box though!
Edouard 4 - had our best shot on goal but other than that offered nothing. Marginally better than JPM.

JRS & Franca 6 - added a bit of life and energy
Ozoh n/a - not on the pitch long enough


I was shouting at the TV halfway through the second half when Edoaurd had the ball on the edge of the box and lackadaisically tried to stroke it past the keeper despite being about 15 yards out.

It was utter laziness and neither he or Mateta are who you want in a fight when the chips are down. Neither mind ability, compare that attitude to Wilf who would go berserk when people didn't put effort in and would always fight until the end.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Den1923 Flag 21 Oct 23 5.36pm

Originally posted by monkey

Only if we had to play Newcastle, Man.City, Liverpool, Arsenal etc every week, but thankfully we don’t have too and we’ll win and draw plenty of games to keep ourselves out of trouble as we have consistently done over the last ten years, let’s not be stressing too much over one result

Hope so, but our inability to score goals is the biggest concern because you have to score to win games!

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 21 Oct 23 5.37pm

If you are getting stuffed down one side you cannot just let it continue.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 21 Oct 23 5.40pm

On the positive side if Roy gives Franca and JRS more time on Friday hopefully they'll be ready to step up in the games that follow (Burnley, Everton and Luton). Plus Olise might be ready for the bench by then. Another positive is Newcastle might be put off poaching any of our players after that!!

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 21 Oct 23 5.53pm

Tyrick Mitchell v Newcastle United

Edited by steeleye20 (21 Oct 2023 5.54pm)

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 21 Oct 23 5.58pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

If you are getting stuffed down one side you cannot just let it continue.

It was obvious from the start, and Ayew should have been switched over within 20 minutes of said start. Perhaps we would then have gone in just the one down. We shall never know :-( Didn’t help that Lerma and Doucoure weren’t ready to start today. And other than Ward and Ayew in the second half everyone else had an off day. Not including those that came on but in truth they aren’t yet premiership standard. Newcastle were just too good and that’s no wonder with their monies and squad.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 21 Oct 23 5.58pm

Originally posted by monkey

Easy, 0-7 against the scousers

0-4 against Fulham and Sunderland at home, at least Liverpool were in the top 2.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 21 Oct 23 6.11pm

Outplayed today and we couldn’t cope with Newcastles intensity over the 90 minutes. Interesting to see we had 17 attempts at goal.

 

Aray Flag South London 21 Oct 23 6.49pm

We paid the price for Rig being so negative. I almost don’t blame him rushing players back into the team but today shows the downside. We still got tonked.

Only upside was seeing the younger players get on the pitch. Poor performance from most of the players. The 2 central defenders/midfielders and forwards (esp JPM) were appalling.

 

esox lucius Flag Deal 21 Oct 23 6.52pm

Unfortunately the result I thought we would get up there. Hopefully the toon saw a below performance from Andersen and think they don’t need him.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 21 Oct 23 7.05pm

I'm trying to recall Roy's response when we got tonked in succession by Villa and Livarpool a few seasons ago? I'm expecting a doubling down against Spurs and more rear guard action. let's face the fact that Mateta and Edouard are useless at defending from the front.

 

Aray Flag South London 21 Oct 23 7.12pm

So maybe we try to play to our strengths. I was more worried about their inability to receive and keep the ball.

 

PatrickA Flag London 21 Oct 23 7.24pm

Roy has 50 more years’ management experience than me so I feel a bit sheepish in offering a mild criticism.
However, here I go…
It’s obvious to any football watcher that Newcastle attack down the sides and Mitchell was left criminally exposed having to contend with both the winger and a marauding Trippier.
I’m reluctant to criticise Edouard here because he’s not a natural tracker and I think we could all foresee before the game that gaps would be left and Mitchell left defending 2 on 1.
There’s no shame in being beaten by moneybags Newcastle who have enough players to field two teams ( plus having a greedy interest in Anderson and Eze if rumours are to be believed).
However, it was a poor performance and from Roy’s comments post match he seems to agree.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 21 Oct 23 7.32pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Some protect him like he’s their kid. He gets caught out of position more often than any left back we’ve had and I thought PVA was poor in that respect. We need competition in the left back spot for no other reason than lifting his performances.

I agree with some that it’s not all his fault today but he was at fault for two of the goals. If he is getting overloaded on his side he has to be screaming at the left mid and left attacker to help out. He’s not a junior player, he needs to be more vocal on the pitch.

At least PVA was good at going forward. Mitchell has been awful today, both in defence and attacking play. Can’t pass for toffee, gave the hall away so many times, ripped apart all game, booked because his poor touch got him in trouble and responsible for another two goals. That fourth one he was just so poor, nothing whatsoever to do with being overloaded or two players to mark, just simply not good enough.

 

Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace team v Newcastle.