You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy's comments
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy's comments


Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Painter Flag Croydon 31 Oct 23 3.48pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

My only caveat to this is, you can’t realistically expect inexperienced players to come on and change the entire way we were playing (which is what we had to do against Spurs) and then take the game by the scruff of the neck. Lerma, Doucoure are supposed to provide the solidity to the team. Provided they are fit they should play full games every week, so if you are going to change the game it has to come from the players in front of those two and then JRS, Franca, Ahamada must get the support from behind to allow them to do that.

Hughes should be our back up player for one of the Doucoure/Lerma spots and nothing else. He does not have the pace to influence the game anywhere else.

To be honest I couldn’t work out what we were trying to do in the last 20 mins, so to blame the subs is harsh unless of course they didn’t do what they were instructed to do, which is quite possible.

The notion that JRS and Franca should start is unrealistic currently. It doesn’t matter what support they have behind them, the problem is the experienced pro in front of them of the opposition. They aren’t ready for the first team yet, Roy knows that and appears to be giving them some game time at the end of games.
Premier football is tough, they have done well to get this far, as many talented young players fall by the wayside. They have to prove they are good enough and not just their egos massaged.

 

Brinscalleagle2 Flag Brinscall 31 Oct 23 4.44pm

Last night I watched West Brom v Coventry whilst watching Pal@ce U21 v West Brom u21. The difference in physical presence, work rates and game awareness between the West Brom U21 team and their first team players was stark. It is exactly the same at Palace even the best of the youngsters fail to exhibit the physical presence, work rate and game awareness. We cannot afford to have youngsters in our side that show promise but contribute little more than one at a time if we want to survive. These lads will come through under Roy’s tutoring but to play three in the side at the same time against the Premier League leaders will very definitely weaken our side compared to playing our experienced professionals. Roy can only work with what he has been given and to me he is doing a pretty good job. He introduced the youngsters and it confirmed they are not yet ready to influence games.COYP

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 31 Oct 23 4.53pm

Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2

Last night I watched West Brom v Coventry whilst watching Pal@ce U21 v West Brom u21. The difference in physical presence, work rates and game awareness between the West Brom U21 team and their first team players was stark. It is exactly the same at Palace even the best of the youngsters fail to exhibit the physical presence, work rate and game awareness. We cannot afford to have youngsters in our side that show promise but contribute little more than one at a time if we want to survive. These lads will come through under Roy’s tutoring but to play three in the side at the same time against the Premier League leaders will very definitely weaken our side compared to playing our experienced professionals. Roy can only work with what he has been given and to me he is doing a pretty good job. He introduced the youngsters and it confirmed they are not yet ready to influence games.COYP

The situation explained .

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 31 Oct 23 7.41pm

IMHO - Roy’s comments were unnecessarily negative - especially in a media environment..!!

What he should have said is something like “the premier league is tough, especially when you are playing a team at the top the of table and our younger players will learn from today’s experience” - same connotation - but without the negativity..!!

I get he may be frustrated with injuries and lack of investment - but there’s a time and a place to make those feelings known - and the full glare of the media wasn’t either the time or the place..!!

Conversely - this is the same Roy that has consistently ignored/discounted younger talent over his “favourite” under performing elder “more experienced” players - prime example - why was Riedewald in Fridays squad over Ozoh..??

Beyond that he has now got to pick these players up and motivate them…!!

In summary inappropriate comments at the wrong time to the wrong audience - not something you would expect from a Manager of Roy’s experience..!!

COYP

 

PatrickA Flag London 01 Nov 23 1.28pm

There seems to be split opinion on this (no bad thing - it is a discussion forum).
Some think the negativity to young players is unhelpful, others believe they need criticism to fire them up.
I’ve just watched an interview with John Terry, and one of the questions asked was why Salah and DeBruyne failed at Chelsea given their obvious brilliance.
He said they lost confidence because of the criticism from the management which they couldn’t take as young players.
Terry said he regrets not doing more to help them.
It’s a difficult balance to achieve as criticism can be justified and helpful to players, but that’s two weeks in a row that Roy has criticised them, and I hope in training he’s encouraging them and offering the carrot as well as the stick.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 01 Nov 23 3.14pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

There seems to be split opinion on this (no bad thing - it is a discussion forum).
Some think the negativity to young players is unhelpful, others believe they need criticism to fire them up.
I’ve just watched an interview with John Terry, and one of the questions asked was why Salah and DeBruyne failed at Chelsea given their obvious brilliance.
He said they lost confidence because of the criticism from the management which they couldn’t take as young players.
Terry said he regrets not doing more to help them.
It’s a difficult balance to achieve as criticism can be justified and helpful to players, but that’s two weeks in a row that Roy has criticised them, and I hope in training he’s encouraging them and offering the carrot as well as the stick.

The debate is not so much should he criticise the young players ,as should it be public.
Not sure Sala, or DeBruyne, were criticised in public.but as with all young players criticism would have been part of their day to day. The fact is managers are not going to hang their future on being nice to players that don’t satisfy., no matter their age, yes there are ways to do it, and one might not be to do it in public.
I think Roy has crossed a line of sorts, but this has the appearance of something already being played out in house, if not it is now.
This situation has been sacking territory so why not now? Well indeed, why not? because Roy is an intelligent man fully aware of the sacking factors , it looks like a please your self to me, due to the provocation of the club not forming a more experienced squad for him to work with, .It’s just a case of Will the club bite?
If they did what sort of football genius is lurking out there to pick up the reigns?

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Nov 23 4.09pm

Originally posted by Putitout

The debate is not so much should he criticise the young players ,as should it be public.
Not sure Sala, or DeBruyne, were criticised in public.but as with all young players criticism would have been part of their day to day. The fact is managers are not going to hang their future on being nice to players that don’t satisfy., no matter their age, yes there are ways to do it, and one might not be to do it in public.
I think Roy has crossed a line of sorts, but this has the appearance of something already being played out in house, if not it is now.
This situation has been sacking territory so why not now? Well indeed, why not? because Roy is an intelligent man fully aware of the sacking factors , it looks like a please your self to me, due to the provocation of the club not forming a more experienced squad for him to work with, .It’s just a case of Will the club bite?
If they did what sort of football genius is lurking out there to pick up the reigns?

I'm not sure I fully understand what you are hinting at here. Why would Hodgson act in this manner? What is he trying to say? Does he feel slighted in some way? I repeat, he worked with Parish for four seasons previously, and he must have been aware of what was happening with Vieira, so much so he was approached behind Vieira's back long before Vieira was actually sacked. What was Hodgson expecting from Parish, other than a one year contract? Let's not delude ourselves, Hodgson has been in the game a long time and knows the score.
The only thing I would ask him is "Why Roy? Why take the role on and then complain about what you already know?"

Edited by southnorwoodhill (01 Nov 2023 4.11pm)

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 01 Nov 23 5.34pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I'm not sure I fully understand what you are hinting at here. Why would Hodgson act in this manner? What is he trying to say? Does he feel slighted in some way? I repeat, he worked with Parish for four seasons previously, and he must have been aware of what was happening with Vieira, so much so he was approached behind Vieira's back long before Vieira was actually sacked. What was Hodgson expecting from Parish, other than a one year contract? Let's not delude ourselves, Hodgson has been in the game a long time and knows the score.
The only thing I would ask him is "Why Roy? Why take the role on and then complain about what you already know?"

Edited by southnorwoodhill (01 Nov 2023 4.11pm)

The one thing Hodgson definitely is, is intelligent , which would indicate he doesn’t get bitten twice without a reaction. He has made it very clear on a number of occasions what he needed, what he wanted, because of that it’s hardly likely he wasn’t given to believe he would get what he wanted, needed. There is a thread elsewhere bemoaning the lack of the very numbers Hodgson said he wanted , once again ,more than once, and totally in line with the obvious.
Yes he knows this season is it for him, so break the habit of a lifetime not much to lose, go public just enough to let it be known thie situation he in is not his idea. We have to disagree.on what he already knew , you could say he should have known that’s all . Most people work on trust Hodgson , probably does.

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 01 Nov 23 6.04pm

I think Roy could have worded it slightly better so not to directly implicate the subs.

However, at present we can't expect much from them.

JRS - should go.out on loan in Jan. The step from Div 1 to PL is too much.

Ahamada - I thought he might be a surprise bonus this season but the injury has probably put him back.

Franca - he is going to need time to adjust. A different country, language and league. Plus he has only come back from injury.

Unfortunately more is expected of them because we wasted money on an injury keeper and dodgy centre back, as well as lack of loans.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Nov 23 6.50pm

Originally posted by Putitout

The one thing Hodgson definitely is, is intelligent , which would indicate he doesn’t get bitten twice without a reaction. He has made it very clear on a number of occasions what he needed, what he wanted, because of that it’s hardly likely he wasn’t given to believe he would get what he wanted, needed. There is a thread elsewhere bemoaning the lack of the very numbers Hodgson said he wanted , once again ,more than once, and totally in line with the obvious.
Yes he knows this season is it for him, so break the habit of a lifetime not much to lose, go public just enough to let it be known thie situation he in is not his idea. We have to disagree.on what he already knew , you could say he should have known that’s all . Most people work on trust Hodgson , probably does.

Roy's tenure first time round, finishes of 11th, 12th, 14th , 14th. Diminishing returns for a thin, ageing squad. Signings and finances out Roy's hands, then as now. Roy did what he had to do, and it wasn't pretty.
Wouldn't it be something if Parish pulled Roy in for a friendly chat, speaking to him in the manner Roy spoke of the youngsters:
"Well Roy, I gave you another year, you've inherited Patrick's side minus Wilf, it's a decent side albeit at the moment a bit thin due to injuries, but what are you doing with it Roy? Nothing Roy. 0-0 at home to Forest and Fulham Roy, it's not good enough."

 

glazedallover Flag Allier 01 Nov 23 6.58pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Roy's tenure first time round, finishes of 11th, 12th, 14th , 14th. Diminishing returns for a thin, ageing squad. Signings and finances out Roy's hands, then as now. Roy did what he had to do, and it wasn't pretty.
Wouldn't it be something if Parish pulled Roy in for a friendly chat, speaking to him in the manner Roy spoke of the youngsters:
"Well Roy, I gave you another year, you've inherited Patrick's side minus Wilf, it's a decent side albeit at the moment a bit thin due to injuries, but what are you doing with it Roy? Nothing Roy. 0-0 at home to Forest and Fulham Roy, it's not good enough."

and Roy replies "So sack me " . Then what ?

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 Nov 23 7.13pm

Originally posted by glazedallover

and Roy replies "So sack me " . Then what ?

Then they've reached that impasse. Parish will ask Hodgson to think about it over the weekend, and offer his resignation in writing if he still feels the same way. Roy is the employee, Parish would be right to ask Roy why the brinkmanship? i have no doubts about Parish sacking Roy if it came to it, he's proved he can be ruthless if need be, and if it were to happen Paddy would become interim manager with Ray departing.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (01 Nov 2023 7.15pm)

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 01 Nov 23 7.14pm

Lopetegui takes over, hopefully before Gareth fails to win the Euros due to his appalling negative tactics. Lopetegui recognises that Joel Ward is past his sell by date, and we recruit a half decent full back. We sell Edouard and Mateta and use the money to buy 1 better striker who actually scores goals, presses and puts in a shift. Simples...

 

TheGreatGorbo Flag sunbury 01 Nov 23 7.41pm

No Roy you made the subs, three youngsters thrown into the deepend against the league leaders what did you expect, hell Mary I call it, it didn’t work why blame them shame on you,

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 01 Nov 23 8.01pm

Originally posted by glazedallover

and Roy replies "So sack me " . Then what ?

That’s more like it. And then what indeed? Who is this top man that would want to take on this league with a squad as thin as Hodgson,s?

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 01 Nov 23 8.32pm

I would normally stand up for Roy but those comments were out of order. They are not comments that should have been aired publicly, and the management and development of these younger players has to be a large part of any Palace managers remit. This season is a free hit given the dross that came up from the championship. So if the right candidate can be identified I would make the change. I don’t buy that we are an unattractive proposition for a prospective manager. Our first team when all fit is a match for most teams in the league.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 01 Nov 23 8.34pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Roy's tenure first time round, finishes of 11th, 12th, 14th , 14th. Diminishing returns for a thin, ageing squad. Signings and finances out Roy's hands, then as now. Roy did what he had to do, and it wasn't pretty.
Wouldn't it be something if Parish pulled Roy in for a friendly chat, speaking to him in the manner Roy spoke of the youngsters:
"Well Roy, I gave you another year, you've inherited Patrick's side minus Wilf, it's a decent side albeit at the moment a bit thin due to injuries, but what are you doing with it Roy? Nothing Roy. 0-0 at home to Forest and Fulham Roy, it's not good enough."

Much more likely is. Roy mate I know you said you have had enough, but look Pats f—-ed up ain’t won a game for weeks, they ain’t a bad bunch ,please.
End of season fantastic job Roy , you could get us in the top ten with this lot, I’m sure Wilf will stay , and we will replace Macca, and the Serb, Lerma is decent ,and that counts the loaner out might even get you a little bit more really keen on this Brazilian kid, he is mustard, we can do it Roy mate. The young lads love you, Eze thinks the sun shine out of your A—e. We need you Roy.
Parish, gave Hodgson nothing, that wasn’t going down hill , and then failed to even keep that squad up to the previous seasons levels, injury to Eze, and Olize, and three or four others produced the 0-0s you moan about. Fulham and Forest were at virtual full strength , we could barely put a viable side out. No wonder Hodgson is pissed off, and Parish is going to think long and hard before he moves Hodgson on. Because he is out of viable options.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Nov 23 7.18am

Originally posted by Putitout

Much more likely is. Roy mate I know you said you have had enough, but look Pats f—-ed up ain’t won a game for weeks, they ain’t a bad bunch ,please.
End of season fantastic job Roy , you could get us in the top ten with this lot, I’m sure Wilf will stay , and we will replace Macca, and the Serb, Lerma is decent ,and that counts the loaner out might even get you a little bit more really keen on this Brazilian kid, he is mustard, we can do it Roy mate. The young lads love you, Eze thinks the sun shine out of your A—e. We need you Roy.
Parish, gave Hodgson nothing, that wasn’t going down hill , and then failed to even keep that squad up to the previous seasons levels, injury to Eze, and Olize, and three or four others produced the 0-0s you moan about. Fulham and Forest were at virtual full strength , we could barely put a viable side out. No wonder Hodgson is pissed off, and Parish is going to think long and hard before he moves Hodgson on. Because he is out of viable options.

Aww boo hoo, poor Croydon Roy, naïve enough not to have thought through the variables that have made this scenario possible, and took on the job anyhow. All that glitters is not gold.
He's upset, and has used the youngsters to express his frustration at Parish. This is what you're saying? And he's right to call them out because they've got to man up, yeah?
I'd say to Roy, get on with it, these things happen and it's your role to do your best and get the best out of the players at your disposal. Three winnable games coming up in succession, go and win them.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (02 Nov 2023 9.05am)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Nov 23 7.32am

Originally posted by Painter

The notion that JRS and Franca should start is unrealistic currently. It doesn’t matter what support they have behind them, the problem is the experienced pro in front of them of the opposition. They aren’t ready for the first team yet, Roy knows that and appears to be giving them some game time at the end of games.
Premier football is tough, they have done well to get this far, as many talented young players fall by the wayside. They have to prove they are good enough and not just their egos massaged.

The big conundrum. They are not good enough as they lack experience and they can’t gain experience because we can’t risk playing them. In my opinion this is why you should only introduce one youngster at a time. Putting all three on was asking for trouble, but as others have mentioned, perhaps that’s Roy saying that these are his only alternatives for fresh legs.

For this reason I would have started with either JRS or Franca and if they were struggling, take them off.

This becomes moot shortly as hopefully Eze and Olise will be back but it does beg the question then where the youngsters will gain their experience. Personally I think JRS should be on loan as should Ebiowei.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 02 Nov 23 10.09am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Aww boo hoo, poor Croydon Roy, naïve enough not to have thought through the variables that have made this scenario possible, and took on the job anyhow. All that glitters is not gold.
He's upset, and has used the youngsters to express his frustration at Parish. This is what you're saying? And he's right to call them out because they've got to man up, yeah?
I'd say to Roy, get on with it, these things happen and it's your role to do your best and get the best out of the players at your disposal. Three winnable games coming up in succession, go and win them.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (02 Nov 2023 9.05am)


In most respects that is what I have said. It’s not a tear jerker, but an appreciation of what’s actually happening . You don’t have to like it, or respond to it.
We know what you would say to Roy, you publicise your attitude to him constantly..
Your reasoning is rarely better than just a personal dislike , for him.
You might give him your orders to win the next three games, no matter how depleted his squad is. Because you don’t respect him. No other reason. That’s by the by , what’s relevant is you wouldn’t know what to do if he lost those games, that could possibly mend the situation. That’s if you had to, which you don’t, some sort of safety net wouldn’t you say.

 

Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy's comments