You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thank you, Roy…
November 16 2026 2.46am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Thank you, Roy…


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Jacey Flag 07 Dec 23 6.09pm

Originally posted by monkey

Love Roy, but he’s looking tired and uninterested now and that is definitely rubbing off on the team. There’s obviously hints of frustration at the strength of the squad and with SP announcing only loans in January, I think Roy’s had enough.
I wouldn’t sack or let him leave by ‘mutual consent’ just yet though, we don’t want any new manager to have such a tough first few games.

His apprentice Paddy is not up to the job,either.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 07 Dec 23 6.11pm

Originally posted by Jacey

His apprentice Paddy is not up to the job,either.

No I can’t see what all the fuss is about with Paddy either, maybe if we were a division or two lower, but he’ll be out of his depth imho

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 07 Dec 23 6.30pm

Originally posted by redpalace91

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Hodgson out' by Guntrisoft

In my opinion Roy is doing the best with the limited resources he has. Parish should have brought in some more players in the summer - the team is only half decent when both Olise and Eze play and both have had injury problems this season. The squad is too thin and we don't have a decent goal scorer.

When he's not beating Forest, Fulham, Luton, Everton how is he doing the best he can?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 07 Dec 23 7.13pm

Not condoning whoever threw that bottle at Roy, but given that it missed him I’d start by questioning our forwards.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 07 Dec 23 7.16pm

If we lose a few more before the Christmas fixtures are over , and it would be no surprise if we did ,then Roy should be begging Parish to release him. By then it will not be easily turned around. Wilf, probably waited to see what was being done for the coming season realised very little , and knew that this was inevitable,

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 07 Dec 23 7.24pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

Not condoning whoever threw that bottle at Roy, but given that it missed him I’d start by questioning our forwards.

I didn’t know about this, but I hope it didn’t just miss him ,but that it was an empty plastic thing. Younger men than Roy have died by a glass bottle thrown in fury.

 

pssguy Flag 07 Dec 23 7.57pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Pity SP didn’t feel the need to look at loans in the summer

Well, we did have Lewis Hall from Chelsea lined up who would have been of great benefit playing down the left-hand side. Of course, Roy would probably not have picked him as he just turned 19

In any event, Newcastle came in for him and it suited all parties for him to move. Having said that, he has played less than 60 minutes in the league so I guess there is a faint chance Newcastle would loan him to us come January


 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 07 Dec 23 8.23pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

I cant understand why he didnt play Olise in the free role behind Edouard, Ayew on the right, where all 3 assists have come from, Schlupp on the left, its his only position, and to not bring Franca or Ebowei on just smacks of stubbornness.

Is exactly right Lanzo..!!

Why because he is Roy - and obdurate beyond belief - this is my formation I'm sticking to it irrespective of available resources and whether it means playing square pegs in round holes..!!

Roy will just not change, it's his way or the highway..!!

He's comments after the game that we as fans have been "spoilt" are both typical Roy i that he will never accept responsibility and then bordering on derisible - how have we been spoilt - we have lost to Luton and Bournemouth - how does Roy see that given the resources we have available we as fans should not expect to be beating teams like this..??

As I said previously Roy will always play experienced mediocrity over youth and potential.

Last nights comments and those after the Spurs game - "youngsters just not good enough" - tells you all you need to know..!!

I'm not discounting that we have injuries to key players - but we have been beaten twice Luton and Bournemouth by teams not better than us but just showed more desire - that starts with the Manager and Roy can dance around it all he likes - but we just ain't showing basic desire - and that Roy is down to you..!!

For me - he's time is done and it's time for someone that will give youth and potential a chance..!!

I for one am fed up with Roy stubbornness - blaming everything/everyone rather than looking at himself and his own turgid team selections and tactics..!!

COYP

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 07 Dec 23 8.35pm

'AERO',
'Give Paddy the rest of the season' Really ?? and Why ??
He is currently part of this mess with no managerial experience of note. At the end of this month we are likely to be in a proper relegation fight - everyone has banged on this season about how Burnley, Sheffield United and Luton are awful and will go straight back down blah blah blah. However on current form probably only the first 2 of those are currently worse and there is often a team that drops like a stone.
I don't know if you went last night but in my nearly 50 years of going I don't think I have seen a Palace crowd turn so quickly and so hostilely and RH will have torn it even more with his post-match comments. If McCarthy were appointed it would, I think it would be a decision similarly received, though it is probably possible given that Parish likes to surround himself with cheap, yes men.
Knowing how completely clueless Parish is in transfer windows, we will probably be further weakened by the sale of a Guehi or an Olise etc to raise funds and he also doesn't do replacements or positions where we are lacking.
Any new manager needs to be the proven article (not Cooper, why ??) and though it hurts to say it Potter is possibly the best choice even though he is ex-Seaweed scum, though would he come ??
Complacent and arrogant Parish with all the owners of a similar ilk need to get some very big decisions right and quickly or we will be in the Championship next year where Parish can call on his much-vaunted Academy which is all he seems to be bothered about.

 

AERO Flag 07 Dec 23 8.59pm

Agree with some of your points but seriously who will come to us with our transfer budget and up and coming fixtures? Potter certainly won't. Paddy temporary would hopefully keep us up and at least hopefully play a few of the youngsters. Yes a parish yes man but beggars can't be choosers and we are in a bad place at the moment.

 

andy p Flag Warrington cheshire 07 Dec 23 9.22pm

did we not interview Dyche?

 


stuck up here with a load of northern monkeys!

southnorwoodhill Flag 07 Dec 23 9.27pm

Parish has exhausted other managerial avenues, it explains how we ended up with Roy again. What other mug would want to take on the role without a guarantee of funding to improve a paper thin side?
The only option left to Parish is to recruit internally, and this is where Paddy steps in.
Future scholars of the game will see by CPFC's example the average lifespan of a side in the PL, and how easy it is to exit it without regular funding.

 

AERO Flag 07 Dec 23 9.29pm

We interview everyone Lol Like I say we our not a good proposition at the moment especially for good proven managers.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 07 Dec 23 9.38pm

I think if we offer Roy another year he will turn it down. He doesn't seem to be enjoying the job at all

 

AERO Flag 07 Dec 23 9.46pm

If we offer him another year Parrish needs to be sectioned !!!!

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 07 Dec 23 10.14pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Is exactly right Lanzo..!!

Why because he is Roy - and obdurate beyond belief - this is my formation I'm sticking to it irrespective of available resources and whether it means playing square pegs in round holes..!!

Roy will just not change, it's his way or the highway..!!

He's comments after the game that we as fans have been "spoilt" are both typical Roy i that he will never accept responsibility and then bordering on derisible - how have we been spoilt - we have lost to Luton and Bournemouth - how does Roy see that given the resources we have available we as fans should not expect to be beating teams like this..??

As I said previously Roy will always play experienced mediocrity over youth and potential.

Last nights comments and those after the Spurs game - "youngsters just not good enough" - tells you all you need to know..!!

I'm not discounting that we have injuries to key players - but we have been beaten twice Luton and Bournemouth by teams not better than us but just showed more desire - that starts with the Manager and Roy can dance around it all he likes - but we just ain't showing basic desire - and that Roy is down to you..!!

For me - he's time is done and it's time for someone that will give youth and potential a chance..!!

I for one am fed up with Roy stubbornness - blaming everything/everyone rather than looking at himself and his own turgid team selections and tactics..!!

COYP

Franca not performing in the u23 is probably because he hasn’t joined for reserve football. Like an apprentice plumber being given plastic stillsons. What’s the use and why bother. The 15 minutes I saw at the toon showed me he has something. What Roy is missing is I cannot remember fans immediately loosing on any player who tries their hardest even if they don’t produce what is expected. We always give them time from what I remember in 46 years. Protecting a professional player by not playing them is what destroys them.

 

mart.denman Flag In a cave 07 Dec 23 10.19pm

Totally agree.
He looks dazed & confused.
Never have I seen him 'manage'from' the touchline,just stares blankly.
I've never been a Roy fan & be glad to out him.
OK he's old & does that automatically give him forget?
The board are pathetic too with no respect for the fans
Mugging us off with an second rate squad.
We look like we've only just been promoted

 

mart.denman Flag In a cave 07 Dec 23 10.21pm

Sorry phone issues if last post don't flow correctly

 

BelfastEagle Flag 07 Dec 23 10.33pm

'Give Paddy the rest of the season‘

Certainly not that’s a one way ticket to the championship. If Roy goes we need somebody experienced to have a chance of steadying the ship.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 08 Dec 23 10.25pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

I think if we offer Roy another year he will turn it down. He doesn't seem to be enjoying the job at all

Listen to today’s press conference he basically said this was a 1 year arrangement. Possibly have a replacement in mind already?

 

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Thank you, Roy…